Utah Officials Close the 1974 Murder of Melissa Ann Smith, 17, and Name Ted Bundy as Her Killer
Summit County cleared the 52-year-old case after the state crime lab found male-line DNA from her case consistent with evidence in the Laura Ann Aime case, tied to Bundy in April.
Published
Fifty-two years to the day after hunters found Melissa Ann Smith's body in the woods near Toll Canyon, Summit County, Utah, closed her murder case on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, and named Ted Bundy as the man who killed her. "Today, I am announcing the closure of the 1974 homicide investigation into the death of Melissa Ann Smith," Sheriff Kacey Bates said at the Summit County Justice Center, TownLift reported. County Attorney Margaret Olson, whose office reviewed the findings before the case was closed, also spoke.
Melissa was 17, from Midvale, and the daughter of the town's police chief, Louis Smith, according to Cowboy State Daily. She disappeared on October 18, 1974, after leaving a pizza restaurant where she had been visiting a friend. Nine days later hunters found her in a wooded area near the line between Summit and Salt Lake counties, in Summit Park. For most of the half century since, the state's cold-case listing has carried her as a homicide victim believed to have been killed by Bundy, and on the day of the announcement it still showed the case as active.
The path back to her case ran through Utah County. The renewed review began in May 2025, when Utah County investigators contacted Summit County about similarities between Melissa's killing and that of Laura Ann Aime, 17, who disappeared on Halloween 1974. Earlier this year the Utah State Crime Lab developed a DNA profile from evidence on Aime's body that matched Bundy's known profile on file in Florida, and Utah County closed her case on April 1.
The link to Melissa rests on a different kind of test. From the remaining Aime evidence the lab developed a Y-STR profile, DNA that passes down the father's line, and compared it with a Y-STR profile from evidence recovered from Melissa's body. The lab found the two consistent. Because male relatives share Y-STR DNA, crime lab officials said, the result does not identify one man on its own; investigators said it established Bundy's responsibility when taken together with "pattern, motive, means, and opportunity."
Lt. Alan Siddoway began the review and died earlier this month. Bates closed with a line Siddoway liked to quote, which he attributed to Voltaire: "To the living we owe respect, but to the dead we owe only the truth." Salt Lake County, which had kept the 1974 evidence, worked the case alongside Summit County. "This case demonstrates the importance of preserving evidence even when decades have passed," Salt Lake County Sheriff Rosie Rivera said. "It does not close the book on Ted Bundy." Investigators are still working the disappearance of Nancy Wilcox, which Rivera said is also linked to him. A member of Melissa's family was "very, very gratified" by the result, the Sheriff's Office said, but chose not to take part publicly.
Bundy was never charged with her death. He was executed in Florida on January 24, 1989.