On November 6, 1989, in St. Louis, Missouri, Zein Isa and his wife killed their youngest daughter. In the months before that night, the FBI had been listening in on the household under a federal intelligence order, on the belief that Zein Isa was working for a foreign power. The microphones were there to catch espionage. They recorded the argument that ended with the girl's death, the conversations before it and the telephone calls the parents made afterward.
The recordings turned the case from the parents' word into a matter of evidence. Federal judges first had to decide whether intelligence tapes could be handed to a local prosecutor at all. They decided that they could. In 1991 the Circuit Court for the City of St. Louis tried husband and wife together for first-degree murder, and on December 20, 1991, both were sentenced to death. The killing came to be called an "honor" killing, a label that rests on the parents' own grievances and offers no justification for it.
Zein Hassan Isa was born in Palestine. He settled in the United States and became a naturalized citizen in 1980, which meant that under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act he counted as a "United States person," entitled to the act's added protections.
He came under federal suspicion of espionage. With the approval of the special federal court that hears intelligence applications, FBI agents placed microphones to cover the household and tapped its telephone lines. The government's case for the order was that Isa was an agent of a foreign power. He later swore in an affidavit that he was not a member of the Palestine Liberation Organization, had no sympathy for it, and that his calls to Palestine were personal. The federal judges who read the classified application found probable cause despite his denial.
The Supreme Court of Missouri later set out the conflict the recordings captured. The girl's parents feared they were losing control of her, refused her permission for one activity after another and objected bitterly to a relationship she kept up anyway. Late in October 1989 she took a job without telling them. She let them know on November 5, in a note.
The argument that night was about the job and the relationship, and both parents took part in it. It turned physical, and the girl died in the early hours of November 6.
Afterward his wife called for police and an ambulance. To the officers who arrived, the parents gave a version of events in which their daughter was the aggressor, and Zein Isa told police that he alone was responsible for the death and that his wife had played no part in it. The State's case was that the parents had acted together and that their story was part of an effort to conceal what they had done; the Supreme Court of Missouri later treated his wife's statement to police as untrue in part and as part of that concealment.
The State of Missouri charged both parents with first-degree murder, and the two cases were joined for a single trial in the Circuit Court for the City of St. Louis. But the recordings belonged to a federal intelligence investigation, and the St. Louis Circuit Attorney could not use them without federal approval. The Attorney General of the United States authorized their use, and the federal government asked the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri to rule that the surveillance had been lawful.
Zein Isa fought the tapes. He argued, among other things, that the original application lacked probable cause, that the FBI had broken the act's rules on minimizing what it kept, and that the tapes could not be shared without his consent. The district judge reviewed the classified application alone, in chambers, held the surveillance lawful and denied the motion to suppress.
On January 10, 1991, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed. It held that the act allows the government to keep and pass on evidence of a crime picked up during intelligence surveillance, even when the crime has nothing to do with foreign intelligence, and that a private review of the classified file did not violate his right to confront the evidence against him. The tapes themselves, the court noted, would confront him in open court at his state trial.
Husband and wife sat as co-defendants before a single jury. The recordings, transcribed and translated from the languages spoken in the household, were the heart of the State's case. Zein Isa took the stand and kept to the line he had given police: he alone was responsible, and his wife had no part in the death. The jury rejected that account as to his wife and convicted her of first-degree murder. On December 20, 1991, the court sentenced both parents to death.
On March 23, 1993, the Supreme Court of Missouri affirmed his wife's conviction but reversed her death sentence. The penalty instruction, it held, had let the jury fix her punishment by what her husband had done, and it sent her case back for a new penalty hearing. The ruling concerned her sentence alone. Zein Isa's own sentence of death was not before the court.
The parents' account that their daughter was the aggressor was rejected by the jury and treated by the Supreme Court of Missouri as part of an effort at concealment. Zein Isa's insistence that his wife had no part in the death was likewise rejected by the verdict against her. His denial that he was a foreign agent was never tested at a trial; the federal courts found only that probable cause supported the surveillance order.
1980: Zein Hassan Isa becomes a naturalized U.S. citizen.
Before November 1989: The FBI places the Isa household in St. Louis under surveillance under a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act order.
November 5, 1989: The girl tells her parents in a note that she has taken a job.
November 6, 1989: She is killed in St. Louis.
Before January 1991: A federal district judge in St. Louis rules the surveillance lawful and denies Zein Isa's motion to suppress the tapes.
January 10, 1991: The Eighth Circuit affirms in United States v. Isa.
1991: Joint trial in the Circuit Court for the City of St. Louis; his wife is convicted of first-degree murder.
December 20, 1991: Zein Isa and his wife are sentenced to death.
March 23, 1993: The Supreme Court of Missouri affirms his wife's conviction, reverses her death sentence and orders a new penalty hearing.