Zdravko Mucić ran a detention camp for five or six months in 1992, and in that time nine men held there died at the hands of the guards who answered to him. He was not found to have harmed anyone himself. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia convicted him anyway, as the commander who knew what his subordinates were doing and did nothing to stop or punish it. The Čelebići camp near Konjic, in central Bosnia and Herzegovina, held Bosnian Serbs detained by Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat forces, and the case against its staff was the first indictment the Tribunal issued that dealt with Bosnian Serb victims.
On November 16, 1998, a Trial Chamber in The Hague found Mucić guilty as a superior, under Article 7(3) of the Tribunal's Statute, of the wilful killings of nine detainees, of torture, of wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health, and of inhuman treatment, all as grave breaches of Geneva Convention IV, and of the unlawful confinement of civilians. It sentenced him to seven years. The Appeals Chamber found that term inadequate. A second Trial Chamber raised it to nine years in October 2001, and the Appeals Chamber confirmed it in April 2003. Three months later the Tribunal's President granted him early release. He died in July 2020, near the town where the camp had stood.
The Trial Chamber placed the case in the municipality of Konjic, 59 kilometers southwest of Sarajevo and 71 kilometers north of Mostar. In the spring of 1992 the old order there fell apart. The Serb members left the municipal assembly and executive council, Muslim and Croat officials formed a crisis staff to run the municipality, and a War Presidency was put in place on April 8. By mid-April the town was effectively surrounded by Bosnian Serb forces and cut off from Sarajevo and Mostar, and from May 4 it was shelled daily for more than three years.
The military operations that followed led to the detention of many Serb residents of the municipality, and a place was needed to hold them. Under an agreement with the Yugoslav People's Army, the barracks and warehouses at the village of Čelebići had been handed over without a fight, and by the end of April 1992 they were under the control of the Territorial Defense and the interior ministry police.
Most of the people held at Čelebići between April and December 1992 were men captured during and after operations in the villages of Bradina and Donje Selo and the area around them. A group from Cerići was brought in on May 23, and a larger group arrested in the center of Bradina on May 27. Others came from Bjelovčina, Brđani, Vinište, Ljuta, Kralupi and Homolje, some arrested alone, some on surrender.
The judges found that the detainees were deprived of adequate food, access to water, medical care, and sleeping and toilet facilities, and that an atmosphere of fear and intimidation prevailed throughout the camp. Water was not scarce; the camp authorities rationed it as a matter of policy. The specific crimes the prosecution proved, the judges added, by no means represented the whole of what was done to the detainees.
A military investigation commission worked at the camp for about a month that summer, classifying prisoners and identifying those who had been wrongly arrested. Its members then resigned together in protest at what they had seen there. The International Committee of the Red Cross visited twice in the first half of August 1992. Detainees left the camp in groups and alone from May onward, some for exchange, some for further detention at the Musala sports hall in Konjic, some under the Red Cross. The last group, about 30 people, was moved to Musala on December 9, 1992.
Mucić was born on August 31, 1955, in Spiljani, Bosnia and Herzegovina. He was a Bosnian Croat, and the court record gives his nickname as Pavo.
There was never a written order making him commander, and his defense made much of that. The Trial Chamber held that a formal appointment was not needed: the actual exercise of authority was enough. By his own account to investigators he went to the camp every day from May 20, 1992, and he admitted holding authority over it at least from July 27. The judges found that he was present and exercising authority before the end of May.
The evidence of his power was practical. He signed documents releasing detainees. Visits to the camp required his permission. He chose the guards and picked Hazim Delić as his deputy. He could confine guards to barracks and report serious offenses, and in October 1992 he removed one guard, Esad Landžo, from the camp. Witnesses described guards taking care when he was present. The judges concluded that he had overall authority over the officers, the guards and the detainees.
That authority had a gap in it, and the gap mattered. Mucić was usually not in the camp at night. The Trial Chamber found his absences frequent, regular and deliberate, and found that he knew his subordinates would commit crimes while he was away. He admitted to investigators that he had known crimes were committed in June and July 1992 and that he had seen detainees mistreated. He set up no system to monitor or report abuse, though he knew of his deputy's record. He left the camp in November 1992, and Delić commanded it until it closed.
The Trial Chamber found Mucić responsible as a superior for the deaths of nine detainees: Željko Ćećez, Petko Gligorević, Gojko Miljanić, Miroslav Vujičić, Pero Mrkajić, Šćepo Gotovac, Željko Milošević, Simo Jovanović and Boško Samouković, a man from Bradina, the village that supplied so many of the camp's prisoners. All were Bosnian Serbs held in the camp in 1992, and the court's case summary attributes their deaths to guards under his command. What is known of them comes mostly from the men who were held beside them and later gave evidence in The Hague.
Two of Mucić's co-defendants were convicted of taking part in some of these killings themselves: Landžo of three and Delić of one. Mucić's conviction for the nine deaths rested on his position, not on any act of his own.
The same judgment held him responsible as a superior for the torture of six detainees, for causing great suffering or serious injury to three more, for the inhuman treatment of seven others, and, with the other two convicted men, for the inhumane conditions in the camp from May to October 1992. Four further deaths had been charged against him. On those the court acquitted him.
The Tribunal's prosecutors opened the investigation into crimes in the Konjic municipality in late October or November 1994. They chose Čelebići because a base of witnesses existed, but finding them was slow. The detainees had told their stories to aid organizations and then scattered, and most of the first group was interviewed in the United States, with a few in Canada. From late 1994 into 1996 the authorities of Republika Srpska and the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, where many other witnesses had gone, refused to cooperate, and investigators had to meet witnesses in neighboring countries. The paperwork was thin; the commission members' resignation was one of the few documents that spoke directly to conditions inside.
Before the indictment went for confirmation, the prosecution learned that Mucić was in Vienna. At its urgent request Austrian police detained him there on March 18, 1996. A judge confirmed the indictment three days later, and the Tribunal announced it as its first dealing with Bosnian Serb victims. It accused Mucić, as a superior, of responsibility for crimes his subordinates committed while he commanded the camp from about May to November 1992: the murder of at least 14 detainees, at least seven acts of torture, at least five cases of causing great suffering or serious injury, at least three inhumane acts, and the unlawful confinement of detainees in inhumane conditions. It also charged him personally with the plunder of detainees' property.
Austria handed him to the Tribunal on April 9, 1996, and two days later he pleaded not guilty to all charges. Delić and Landžo were arrested by the Bosnian authorities and transferred in June. Mucić had agreed to be interviewed by the prosecution's investigators after his arrest, without a lawyer. Those interviews, in which he acknowledged his authority over the camp from late July and his knowledge of crimes there, became part of the case against him.
The trial of the four accused opened on March 10, 1997, and ran for some 19 months. It was the Tribunal's first trial involving more than one accused, and many of the witnesses had been held in the camp. Mucić did not testify. Several witnesses, prosecution witnesses among them, spoke of occasions on which he had stepped in for a prisoner. One former detainee said Mucić had moved him from a tunnel to the camp infirmary, brought him food and released him on July 17, 1992.
On November 16, 1998, the court found that the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina had been an international armed conflict throughout 1992, and that the camp's detainees were persons protected by the Fourth Geneva Convention. It found Mucić to have been the de facto commander of the camp and criminally responsible, as a superior, for the acts of its staff.
In respect of the nine named detainees it found him GUILTY of a Grave Breach of Geneva Convention IV (wilful killings) and a Violation of the Laws or Customs of War (murders). In respect of four further detainees named in Counts 13 and 14 it found him NOT GUILTY of wilful killing and murder; for one of those four it found him GUILTY instead of wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health and of cruel treatment. On the torture counts, the great-suffering counts, the inhuman-treatment counts and the counts covering the camp's conditions it convicted him as charged, with acquittals in respect of a few named detainees. It found him GUILTY of a Grave Breach of Geneva Convention IV (unlawful confinement of civilians). One count of cruel treatment and the count of plunder were dismissed. For each conviction it imposed seven years, all to run concurrently, with credit for the time already in custody.
The Chamber found that Mucić had allowed those under him to commit grave crimes without taking any disciplinary action. It weighed against him his conduct during the trial and evidence that he had tried to influence witnesses. In his favor it counted the circumstances in Konjic at the time, evidence that he had helped some detainees, and the absence of any credible evidence that he had personally committed violence. The fourth accused, the regional coordinator of the area's defense forces, was acquitted on every count and released the same day.
The Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment on February 20, 2001. It rejected his central argument, that command responsibility reached only commanders appointed in law. A position of de facto command could be enough, it held, so long as the superior had effective control over the people committing the crimes, meaning the material ability to prevent or punish them, and a reasonable court could find that he held that control. It upheld his conviction for unlawful confinement, holding that he had some authority to release prisoners and had failed to free civilians he knew were held without the review the Geneva Convention required. It found no error in admitting his interviews.
On one point he won. Where the same acts supported convictions both as grave breaches and as violations of the laws or customs of war, the Appeals Chamber held, only the grave-breach convictions could stand, and it dismissed Counts 14, 34, 39, 45 and 47 against him. The sentence fared worse. The seven-year term, the Appeals Chamber found, had failed to take adequate account of the gravity of his offenses and of several aggravating matters, including the effect of a commander's continuing failure to supervise on the lawlessness inside a camp. It also accepted his complaint that the trial judges had erred in referring, when sentencing him, to his decision not to give evidence. It sent the question of a new sentence to a reconstituted Trial Chamber, indicating that it would itself have imposed around ten years but for the adjustment the dismissed counts might require.
The new Trial Chamber gave judgment on October 9, 2001. It treated the finding that seven years was inadequate as binding and took the ten-year indication into account. It could not say what effect, if any, the original reference to his silence had had on the sentence, so it allowed a small reduction. It made no adjustment for the dismissed counts, finding that the totality of his criminal conduct had not changed, and it imposed a single sentence of nine years, with credit for time in custody.
Mucić appealed again, arguing that an error as basic as the one the trial judges had made deserved a reduction to match it. On April 8, 2003, the Appeals Chamber dismissed every appeal against sentence. An appellate court, it held, removes an error's effect rather than compensating the appellant for it, and nine years fitted the gravity of his conduct and the form and degree of his participation. It confirmed his credit from March 18, 1996.
He applied for early release on the day of that judgment. Unlike Delić and Landžo, who were sent to Finland that July to serve their terms, Mucić had spent his entire custody at the Tribunal's detention unit in the Netherlands, and the President of the Tribunal held that the eligibility rule of the states that enforced its sentences should apply to him too: release could be considered after two-thirds of a term. Mucić had served two-thirds. His sentence would otherwise have ended on March 18, 2005.
The file before the President showed good behavior in detention, a 2001 psychological evaluation finding him not prone to loss of control, and prosecution memoranda on his cooperation. In an interview on June 24, 2003, Mucić acknowledged that conditions in the camp had been appalling. The President weighed the gravity of his crimes against his resolve to return to society, his health, his conduct in custody, his family ties and his prospects of work. On July 9, 2003, he granted the request, effective July 18, and Mucić left custody that day.
Regional news outlets reported that he died in July 2020 near Konjic.
Mucić never accepted that he had commanded the camp from the start. He conceded authority only from July 27, 1992, and argued on appeal that no document named him commander. Both chambers held that his de facto authority began before the end of May and covered the whole period charged.
The indictment accused him of responsibility for at least 14 killings. The trial court convicted him of nine and acquitted him on four others. No court found that he personally harmed any detainee. The testimony that he had protected and released individual prisoners was accepted in mitigation, but both chambers treated it as proof that he had the power to protect others and did not use it.
Landžo testified that Mucić and Delić had asked him to kill a detainee; the trial judges found him an unreliable witness and rejected the claim. Mucić's argument that he had not freely waived his right to a lawyer before his interviews was rejected at trial and on appeal. The Tribunal's records also differ on when the camp closed: its case summary gives December 1992, with the last detainees moved on December 9, while its successor mechanism gives November 9, 1992.
August 31, 1955: Zdravko Mucić is born in Spiljani, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
April 8, 1992: A War Presidency is formed in Konjic after the Serb members leave the municipal assembly.
Late April 1992: The Čelebići barracks pass to the Territorial Defense and interior ministry police; detainees begin to arrive.
May 20, 1992: By his own account, Mucić begins going to the camp daily; the court finds him exercising authority before the end of May.
May 1992 to October 1992: The period of inhumane conditions for which Mucić and two subordinates are convicted.
July 27, 1992: The date from which Mucić admitted authority over the camp.
August 1992: The International Committee of the Red Cross visits the camp twice.
November 1992: Mucić leaves the camp; Hazim Delić takes command.
December 9, 1992: The last detainees are moved from Čelebići to Musala.
Late October or November 1994: ICTY prosecutors open the Konjic investigation.
March 18, 1996: Austrian police arrest Mucić in Vienna.
March 21, 1996: The indictment is confirmed.
April 9, 1996: Mucić is transferred to the ICTY.
April 11, 1996: He pleads not guilty to all charges.
March 10, 1997: The trial opens.
November 16, 1998: The Trial Chamber convicts him and imposes seven years.
February 20, 2001: The Appeals Chamber upholds his convictions, dismisses the duplicate counts and sends his sentence back for review.
October 9, 2001: A new Trial Chamber sentences him to nine years.
April 8, 2003: The Appeals Chamber confirms the nine-year sentence.
July 9, 2003: The Tribunal's President grants early release.
July 18, 2003: Mucić is released.
July 2020: Mucić dies near Konjic.