Youssouf Fofana

Victims
1 young man kidnapped and murdered, Paris area, 2006. Convicted July 10, 2009 of premeditated murder (antisemitic aggravating circumstance) and kidnapping for ransom
Years active
January 20 to February 13, 2006
Location
Sceaux and Bagneux, Hauts-de-Seine, France (kidnapping and captivity before the killing); Sainte-Geneviève-des-Bois, Essonne, France (killing; place of death).
Method
Stabbing and burning (his own admission at trial, May 2009)
Status
Life imprisonment with a 22-year minimum, July 10, 2009; not appealed. Further terms 2013, 2014 and 2017. Imprisoned in France as of January 2017, with release eligibility from 2028.

Youssouf Fofana was the leader and organizer of a group of young men and women from the southern suburbs of Paris who kidnapped Ilan Halimi on January 20, 2006, and held him for ransom until his death on February 13. The gang called itself the Barbarians. When the case came to judgment in 2009, the court did more than convict Fofana of murder: it retained the antisemitic character of the crime as an aggravating circumstance, finding that the young man had been killed because of his religion.

Fofana fled to Côte d'Ivoire and was arrested in Abidjan within days of the death, then handed over to France in early March. Three years later, after a ten-week trial held behind closed doors, the juvenile assize court in Paris convicted him on July 10, 2009, of premeditated murder committed because of the victim's religion and of kidnapping and confinement by an organized gang with a ransom demand, torture and acts of barbarity. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a 22-year minimum period before any release could be considered, the heaviest sentence the law allowed. He did not appeal. Twenty-four others were convicted with him and two were acquitted, and an appeal brought by the prosecution against the accomplices alone raised some of their sentences in 2010. Fofana went on to be convicted three more times, for offenses committed before the kidnapping and while in custody.

Fofana was born in Paris in 1980 and held French citizenship. By the time of the kidnapping he already had a record as a petty criminal.

He had also been running a campaign of threats for money. Between 2002 and 2004 he sent letters and ransom demands to about forty people, among them company executives and public figures. That campaign went unpunished for more than a decade; a Paris court tried it only in 2017.

On January 20, 2006, members of the gang kidnapped the young man in Sceaux, in the Hauts-de-Seine, and held him in the neighboring town of Bagneux. The gang demanded a ransom of 450,000 euros from his family. It was never paid.

He died on February 13, 2006, at Sainte-Geneviève-des-Bois, in the Essonne, south of Paris.

The case had begun as a kidnapping for ransom, and in its first weeks it was handled that way. On February 21, 2006, the investigating magistrate opened the way for aggravated charges based on hatred against members of the gang. By early March seventeen people had been placed under formal judicial investigation.

Fofana was no longer in France. He had left shortly after the death for Côte d'Ivoire, and Ivorian police, working with French officers, arrested him in Abidjan on February 22, 2006. In his first interviews there he admitted taking part in the kidnapping but denied the killing and denied any antisemitic motive.

France sought his extradition at once. The Ivorian head of state signed the order on March 3, 2006, and the next day Fofana was handed over to France. There he was placed under formal investigation and held in custody, and before the investigating judges he refused to answer questions.

The investigation took three years. By the spring of 2009, twenty-seven people stood committed for trial. Fofana alone faced the gravest charge: premeditated murder committed because of the victim's real or presumed membership of a particular religion. He was also charged with kidnapping and confinement by an organized gang with a ransom demand, torture and acts of barbarity, and he faced life imprisonment.

The others faced charges matched to the roles the investigation gave them: kidnapping by an organized gang, confinement by an organized gang followed by the death of the victim, and failure to assist a person in danger. Among them were the young men accused of seizing and guarding the captive, the caretaker of the building in Bagneux who had provided the space, and a young woman, a minor at the time, who had arranged the meeting.

The trial opened at the end of April 2009 before the Paris assize court sitting as a juvenile assize court. Two of the accused had been under 18 when the crimes were committed, and French law therefore required the hearings, for every defendant including the adults, to be closed to the public and the press.

Fofana had admitted the kidnapping while denying the murder. On May 29, 2009, a month into the hearings, he admitted the killing in court.

The verdicts came on July 10, 2009. The court convicted Fofana of premeditated murder and of the kidnapping, confinement and acts of torture, and it retained the antisemitic character of the crime as an aggravating circumstance. It sentenced him to life imprisonment with a security period of twenty-two years, the maximum available.

Twenty-four other defendants were convicted, eight of them women, with sentences running from six months suspended to eighteen years of criminal imprisonment. Fofana's two most active lieutenants received eighteen years and fifteen years. The young woman who had arranged the meeting was sentenced to nine years. Two defendants were acquitted. In fourteen of the twenty-seven cases the sentence fell below what the prosecution had requested.

Fofana's conviction and sentence, unappealed, became final. Days after the verdict, on the justice minister's order, prosecutors appealed every sentence lower than the one the state had sought. The appeal was heard behind closed doors before the assize court in Créteil, sitting on appeal, and Fofana was not among the defendants.

On December 17, 2010, that court convicted sixteen of the seventeen defendants before it and acquitted one. Fofana's two principal accomplices were each sentenced to eighteen years; for one of them that was an increase of three years. Six of those who took part in the kidnapping received between twelve and fifteen years, and seven others between eight months and eleven years. The caretaker was sentenced to ten years, and the young woman's nine-year sentence was confirmed.

Prison did not end Fofana's record. In 2012 the authorities found antisemitic videos he had made in custody and posted online. On February 13, 2013, the criminal court in Moulins convicted him of glorifying an act of terrorism, of incitement to racial discrimination and of a third, related offense, and sentenced him to seven more years.

In 2014 he was convicted of violence against corrections officers, and the appeal court in Caen sentenced him to four additional years.

On January 10, 2017, the Paris criminal court convicted him of attempted extortion accompanied by death threats, for the letters and demands he had sent to about forty-two people between 2002 and 2004, and imposed ten years. As of that ruling, the new term did not move the date from which he could apply for release, which fell in 2028.

Whether Fofana was driven first by antisemitism or by the hope of quick money was argued throughout the case. The court settled the legal question by retaining the antisemitic aggravating circumstance; his own early statements in Abidjan had denied any such motive.

His account of his role also shifted. In Côte d'Ivoire he admitted the kidnapping and denied the killing, and he held to that until May 29, 2009, when he admitted the murder in court.

The justice minister's order reopened fourteen sentences; seventeen defendants stood trial on appeal in Créteil.

Timeline

1980: Youssouf Fofana is born in Paris.

2002 to 2004: He sends threatening letters and ransom demands to about forty people.

January 20, 2006: The victim is kidnapped in Sceaux and held in Bagneux.

February 13, 2006: The victim dies.

February 21, 2006: The investigating magistrate opens the way for aggravated charges based on hatred.

February 22, 2006: Fofana is arrested in Abidjan.

March 4, 2006: Fofana is handed over to France.

April 2009: The trial of twenty-seven defendants opens in closed session in Paris.

May 29, 2009: Fofana admits the murder in court.

July 10, 2009: Life imprisonment with a 22-year security period; twenty-four co-defendants convicted, two acquitted.

July 2009: The justice minister orders appeals against the lighter sentences.

December 17, 2010: Sixteen accomplices are convicted on appeal and one is acquitted.

February 13, 2013: The Moulins criminal court adds seven years.

2014: The Caen appeal court adds four years for violence against corrections officers.

January 10, 2017: The Paris criminal court adds ten years for attempted extortion; release eligibility remains 2028.