Yosef Haim Ben-David

Victims
1 murder: a 16-year-old Palestinian boy from Shuafat, East Jerusalem, July 2, 2014; convicted with two minors of murder and kidnapping, with other charges.
Years active
July 2, 2014
Location
Jerusalem, Israel (killing; abduction in Shuafat, East Jerusalem); Adam, West Bank (residence); Jerusalem, Israel (trial); HaSharon Prison, Israel (prison and death)
Method
Beaten and set on fire (court findings).
Status
Life imprisonment plus 20 years, May 3, 2016; Supreme Court rejected his appeal, February 8, 2018. Died in custody in Israel after transfer to hospital, September 24, 2026.

Yosef Haim Ben-David was the adult at the center of a killing that Israel's highest court later described as a "strategic terror attack." On July 2, 2014, he and two minors, both his nephews, abducted a 16-year-old Palestinian boy from the Shuafat neighborhood of East Jerusalem and murdered him in Jerusalem. The three told investigators they had acted in revenge for the abduction and murder of three Israeli teenagers in the West Bank the month before. All three confessed. The two minors were convicted in November 2015, and Ben-David, whose verdict was held back while the court examined a late claim that he was insane, was convicted of murder in April 2016 and sentenced to life imprisonment plus 20 years.

The case came in the middle of a summer that ended in a 50-day war in Gaza. The trial court found that Ben-David had acted from "nationalistic" motives and that he understood what he was doing, and the Supreme Court upheld the convictions in February 2018. He died in custody on September 24, 2026, at the age of 42.

In the summer of 2014 Ben-David was 29 and lived in Adam, an Israeli settlement in the West Bank just outside Jerusalem. He owned an eyewear store in Jerusalem. He had also volunteered with ZAKA, the Israeli volunteer rescue and recovery service, and he later told the court that he had done that work for Jews and Arabs alike. He was ultra-Orthodox, and all three defendants had grown up in Orthodox families.

His mental health was part of the case from the first day. The indictment itself stated that he had a history of mental illness and was taking psychiatric medication, and it said the same of one of the two minors. That history would become the core of his defense, and the main question in both of the courts that heard his case.

The two minors who stood trial with him were his nephews. Israeli law bars the publication of the names of minors on trial, and neither has ever been publicly named. One came from Jerusalem and the other from Beit Shemesh. Their ages at the time of the crime are given as 16 and 17.

The killing cannot be separated from what came before it. On June 12, 2014, three Israeli teenagers were abducted in the West Bank by Hamas operatives, and an Israeli crackdown on Hamas followed. On June 30 it became known that all three had been murdered. Ben-David and the two minors later said that they had resolved to harm Arabs once that news broke.

The indictment also covered earlier acts. It charged two of the defendants with setting fire to a Palestinian-owned store in the West Bank village of Hizma in June 2014 and with an attempt to set fire to vehicles. On July 1, the evening before the killing, the three tried to abduct a seven-year-old boy in the Beit Hanina neighborhood of Jerusalem. That attempt failed. The court later ordered Ben-David to pay compensation to that boy's family.

The victim was a 16-year-old boy from Shuafat, a Palestinian neighborhood in the north of East Jerusalem. He did not know the three men who took him. On July 2 he was abducted in Shuafat, and he was murdered in Jerusalem that same morning. The trial court found that all three defendants took part in the abduction and the killing.

Israel Police and the Israel Security Agency, the domestic intelligence service known as the Shin Bet, ran the investigation together. On Sunday, July 6, 2014, four days after the killing, they detained a group of young Jewish suspects from Jerusalem, Beit Shemesh and Adam, and a court placed a gag order on most details of the case.

By that evening three of them had confessed. The other suspects were released within days. The three who remained, Ben-David and the two minors, confessed during interrogation and walked investigators through the abduction and the killing.

On Thursday, July 17, 2014, the Jerusalem District Attorney's Office filed an indictment against the three in the Jerusalem District Court. They were charged with murder and kidnapping, with other offenses. The indictment stated that the three had kidnapped and murdered him "simply for being an Arab." The charges went beyond the murder: Ben-David and one of the minors were charged over the failed attempt in Beit Hanina the night before, and two of the defendants were charged over the arson in Hizma.

The adult's name was at first covered by the gag order. On July 20, 2014, the courts allowed it to be published. The minors' names stayed protected by law.

The trial was heard in the Jerusalem District Court. The facts were never in real doubt: all three had confessed, and none of them tried to prove his innocence. The argument at trial was about responsibility and intent.

The two minors each told the court a version that made his own part smaller. The older said Ben-David had pressured him into taking part. The younger admitted the kidnapping but said he had not known it would end in a death. Ben-David did not testify. His defense argued that he was not responsible for his actions; the prosecution's position was that he was fit to stand trial and fully responsible.

The verdict was set for November 30, 2015. A few days before it, Ben-David's lawyer filed a formal claim that his client had been insane at the time of the killing, and the court agreed that the claim would be examined.

On November 30, 2015, the Jerusalem District Court convicted the two minors. The court found that all three defendants had committed the abduction and the murder, and it set out Ben-David's part in detail, but it did not enter a verdict against him. His case was split off so that the court could decide the insanity claim first.

The minors were sentenced on February 4, 2016. The older of the two received life imprisonment and was ordered to pay NIS 35,000 to the boy's family. The younger received 21 years in prison and was ordered to pay NIS 30,000. The court treated the younger boy's part as the smaller one.

Ben-David's case returned to the same court on April 19, 2016. The court rejected the insanity claim and convicted him of murder. The Justice Ministry summarized the ruling: the court found that he "was not psychotic, fully understood the facts, was responsible for his actions." The court also found that he had acted from "nationalistic" motives and that he had been aware of his actions on the night of the killing.

Sentencing took place in the Jerusalem District Court on May 3, 2016. The prosecution asked for life imprisonment with further consecutive terms for the kidnapping and the other offenses, and the defense argued that his mental state should reduce his responsibility.

When the court gave him the chance to speak, Ben-David apologized for the first time. "I request forgiveness from the family for what happened; it wasn't under my control," he said. He also spoke of his volunteer work with ZAKA.

The court sentenced him to life imprisonment plus 20 years, the added term for the kidnapping. It ordered him to pay NIS 150,000, about $39,000, to the murdered boy's family, and NIS 20,000, about $5,000, to the family of the boy in Beit Hanina whom the group had tried to abduct the night before.

All three appealed to the Supreme Court of Israel, which gave judgment on February 8, 2018. Ben-David's appeal rested almost entirely on the insanity defense, drawing on an earlier psychiatric assessment that questioned his sanity. The minors argued that they had agreed to the kidnapping and to violence against the boy but had not known that Ben-David meant to kill him, and that their own roles had been minor.

The court rejected every appeal. It refused to disturb the trial court's finding that Ben-David was responsible for his actions, and it held that all three had "made a decision to cause death" in a "spontaneous partnership." It upheld the convictions and all three sentences: life plus 20 years for Ben-David, life for the older minor and 21 years for the younger. The court described the murder as "a strategic terror attack" and said the case "exceeded the boundaries of a regular criminal case." With that judgment the convictions became final.

Ben-David served his sentence at HaSharon Prison. On Thursday, September 24, 2026, he was taken from the prison to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead. He was 42. The Israel Prison Service said that, as with any death of a prisoner, an investigation team had been set up, and it declined to release any information about his health, citing privacy law.

Ben-David's responsibility was the one real contest in the case. His defense said that mental illness had left him unable to control what he did, and he told the sentencing court that the act "wasn't under my control." Two courts rejected that claim. The trial court found that he was not psychotic and understood his actions, and the Supreme Court refused to overturn that finding. The indictment itself recorded his history of mental illness and medication; the courts' finding was that it did not remove his criminal responsibility.

The two minors each said at trial that his own part had been smaller than the prosecution claimed, and on appeal both said they had not intended a death. The Supreme Court rejected those arguments and held that all three had decided to cause death. The difference between their sentences reflects the trial court's finding that the younger boy played the smaller part.

The arson in Hizma and the attempt to set fire to vehicles were charged in the indictment, but the published reports do not set out which of those counts ended in conviction for each defendant.

Timeline

June 12, 2014: Three Israeli teenagers are abducted in the West Bank.

June 2014: A Palestinian-owned store in Hizma is set on fire; two of the three defendants are later charged.

June 30, 2014: The deaths of the three teenagers become known.

July 1, 2014: The three try to abduct a seven-year-old boy in Beit Hanina, Jerusalem.

July 2, 2014: A 16-year-old boy from Shuafat is abducted and murdered in Jerusalem.

July 6, 2014: Israel Police and the Israel Security Agency detain a group of suspects; three confess.

July 17, 2014: Ben-David and the two minors are indicted in the Jerusalem District Court for murder and kidnapping, with other charges.

July 20, 2014: The courts allow Ben-David's name to be published.

November 30, 2015: The two minors are convicted; Ben-David's verdict is held back over a late insanity claim.

February 4, 2016: The minors are sentenced to life and to 21 years.

April 19, 2016: The court rejects the insanity claim and convicts Ben-David of murder.

May 3, 2016: Ben-David is sentenced to life imprisonment plus 20 years and ordered to pay compensation.

February 8, 2018: The Supreme Court rejects all three appeals and upholds the convictions and sentences.

September 24, 2026: Ben-David dies in custody after transfer from prison to a hospital, at the age of 42.