Hervé Cornara lived in Fontaines-sur-Saône, a small town on the Saône just north of Lyon, and he died on the morning of Friday, June 26, 2015. The man accused of killing him was Yassin Salhi, a 35-year-old delivery driver who worked for the transport firm where the victim was his employer, and who lived with his family in Saint-Priest, in the eastern suburbs of Lyon. The same morning an explosion at the Air Products industrial gas plant in Saint-Quentin-Fallavier, in the Isère department, injured two people, and Salhi was detained at the site within minutes.
France opened a terrorism investigation that day. Four days later an anti-terrorism investigating judge in Paris placed Salhi under formal investigation for murder linked to a terrorist enterprise, for kidnapping and unlawful detention with a view to that murder, and for two further offenses arising from the explosion and from violence against people carrying out a public service. He was remanded in custody. According to investigators, he admitted the killing but denied any religious or terrorist motive, and the question of why he did it was never put to a court. On December 22, 2015, he died by suicide in custody in the Paris region. He was never tried, and no verdict was ever given on any of the charges.
Salhi was born in Pontarlier, a town in the Doubs department close to the Swiss border. His exact date of birth is not on record. The president of the town's mosque later remembered him as a calm child, easy to have around, and another man who had known him there spoke of a quiet boy who was not highly strung.
The interest of the French intelligence services began in Pontarlier. In the early 2000s, investigators said, he fell in with a man they described as a radical preacher, who had gathered a group of seven or eight young followers in the town. The prosecutor in Paris later said that Salhi's ties to radical Islam went back to 2003. Investigators described the last identified contacts between the two men as dating from long before 2015, and the preacher was not suspected of any crime.
In 2006 the intelligence services opened a file on Salhi over his links to the Salafist movement. It was not renewed when it lapsed in 2008. The interior minister said after the events of June 2015 that Salhi had no criminal record.
In 2011 Salhi moved with his wife and children to Planoise, a large housing district on the edge of Besançon. A friend from those years remembered him as calm and kind, and said he talked about religion but never about terrorism. His name came back to the intelligence services in 2013, when he was seen keeping company with people suspected of links to radical Islam, and further intelligence notes followed in 2013 and 2014. A source close to the investigation said he had shown no harmful activity in that period.
At the end of 2014 the family left the Franche-Comté and moved to Saint-Priest, east of Lyon. Salhi found steady work as a delivery driver with a transport company in the Lyon area. By the summer of 2015 he had a permanent job, an apartment in a modest suburb and a clean criminal record. In the course of his rounds he had made deliveries to the Air Products plant in Saint-Quentin-Fallavier.
The victim was a husband and a father, and the town where he lived remembered him as a man who gave his time to the people around him and took part in local affairs. He was a keen football fan. Colleagues thought well of him.
He worked in Chassieu, east of Lyon, and was Salhi's employer at the transport firm. A few days before June 26 the two men had clashed at work. Investigators confirmed that the employer had sharply reprimanded Salhi after a mistake caused a pallet of costly equipment to fall.
Salhi went to the firm early on the morning of Friday, June 26, and was seen with his employer there shortly afterward. By his own later account, he killed him in the Lyon suburbs before going on to Saint-Quentin-Fallavier, about 30 kilometers south of Lyon.
The plant belonged to Air Products, an American industrial gas company with its headquarters in Pennsylvania. Soon after Salhi arrived there, an explosion went off at the site and injured two people; the charges later brought against him covered the explosion. A firefighter detained him at the scene, and he was handed over to police.
By the end of the day officials had confirmed that a local man had been killed, and the Paris prosecutor's counterterrorism section took over the case. In the first hours, officials allowed for the possibility that a second person had been involved. Nothing in the later investigation supported it.
Salhi was held first by the judicial police in Lyon. His custody began on the evening of June 26, and under the rules for terrorism cases it could run for up to 96 hours before he had to be brought before a judge. For several hours he said nothing to the detectives questioning him.
Police also took his wife and his sister into custody, together with a third person. The two women were released on Sunday, June 28, after two days, and the third person was released as well.
On Sunday, June 28, Salhi began to talk. He admitted that he had killed his employer, said he had acted alone and gave detectives an account of the circumstances. He spoke of the recent dispute at work and of difficulties in his marriage, and he said he had wanted to take his own life in a way that would draw wide attention and look like a terrorist act. Investigators found no sign of accomplices. The same evening he was moved to the headquarters of the anti-terrorism police in Levallois-Perret, outside Paris.
By then investigators had established that on the morning of June 26 Salhi had sent images connected with the killing to a number in Canada. They treated that number as a relay. The final recipient, the prosecutor later said, was a man from the same eastern region of France with whom Salhi had been in regular contact, a convert who had left for Syria in November 2014 and was believed to be with the Islamic State group there. How the two men had come to know each other was never made public. Asked about the images, Salhi told investigators he did not remember sending them.
On Tuesday, June 30, at the end of the 96 hours, Salhi was brought before an anti-terrorism investigating judge in Paris, who placed him under formal investigation that day.
The charges were "assassinat en relation avec une entreprise terroriste," the French offense of premeditated murder linked to a terrorist enterprise; "enlèvement et séquestration en vue de préparer ou de faciliter la commission du crime d'assassinat," kidnapping and unlawful detention to prepare or facilitate that murder; "destruction ou dégradation par l'effet d'une substance explosive, incendiaire ou de nature à créer un danger pour les personnes," destruction or damage by an explosive substance, over the explosion at the plant; and "violences volontaires sur personnes chargées d'une mission de service public," deliberate violence against people carrying out a public service mission. He was jailed the same day.
The prosecution's case was that the evidence as a whole pointed to a terrorist motive, and that choosing as a victim a man with whom he was in conflict did not rule that motive out. Salhi's position, through his lawyer, was that his reasons were personal and had nothing to do with religion. On the images and on other questions about the morning, Salhi declined to answer or said he could not remember.
Salhi spent the rest of 2015 in pretrial detention near Paris while the investigating judges worked on the case. He had not been considered a suicide risk. On Tuesday, December 22, 2015, he died by suicide in custody, and the authorities announced his death the following day.
His death came before any trial and before the judicial investigation had been completed. The charges against him were never heard by a court, his account of his motives was never tested against the prosecution's, and no judge ever ruled on what happened on June 26, 2015.
The central question in the case, the reason for the killing, was never settled. Salhi admitted killing his employer and said he had acted for personal reasons, citing the dispute at work and his marriage, and he said he had meant to end his own life in a way that would resemble a terrorist act. The prosecution held that the evidence pointed to a terrorist motive and that a personal grievance did not exclude one. Neither account was tested at a trial.
The part played by the man in Syria who received the images was never established in court. Investigators described regular contact between the two men, but how they met, and whether that contact shaped the events of June 26, was never made public.
In the first hours officials allowed for a second person at the plant. Salhi said he had acted alone, investigators found no sign of accomplices, and the three people taken into custody with him were released.
2003: Investigators later date Salhi's ties to radical Islam from about this year, through contacts in Pontarlier, Doubs.
2006: The French intelligence services open a security file on him over links to the Salafist movement.
2008: The file lapses and is not renewed.
2011: He moves to the Planoise district of Besançon.
2013 to 2014: He comes back to the attention of the intelligence services.
Late 2014: He moves to Saint-Priest, near Lyon, and later works as a delivery driver for a transport firm in the Lyon area.
June 26, 2015: Salhi's employer is killed in the Lyon area; an explosion at the Air Products plant in Saint-Quentin-Fallavier, Isère, injures two people; Salhi is detained at the site and a terrorism investigation opens.
June 28, 2015: Salhi admits the killing to detectives in Lyon; three people held with him are released; he is moved to Levallois-Perret.
June 30, 2015: An anti-terrorism investigating judge in Paris places him under formal investigation for murder linked to a terrorist enterprise and other offenses; he is remanded in custody.
December 22, 2015: Salhi dies by suicide in custody in the Paris region, untried.