Yacine Mihoub

Victims
1 murder, Paris, 2018; convicted November 10, 2021, of murder of a vulnerable person committed because of the victim's religion
Years active
March 23, 2018
Location
Paris (11th arrondissement), France (killing and trial)
Method
Stabbed (trial record)
Status
Life, 22-year minimum term (période de sûreté), November 10, 2021; appeal lodged November 15, 2021, withdrawn (reported January 10, 2023). Imprisoned in France as of January 2023.

In July 1942 a Jewish girl left occupied Paris with her mother, days ahead of the mass arrest of the city's Jews that came to be known as the Vel d'Hiv roundup. Decades later she was still living in the east of the same city, a widow who had raised two sons and outlived her husband. Her name was Mireille Knoll. On Friday, March 23, 2018, she was murdered in Paris. The man convicted of killing her, Yacine Mihoub, was the son of one of her neighbors. He had known her all his life.

In November 2021 the Cour d'assises de Paris found Mihoub guilty of murder, with two aggravating circumstances: that the victim was a vulnerable person, and that she was killed because of her membership of the Jewish religion. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 22 years. A second man, tried beside him, was acquitted of the murder and convicted of aggravated theft. Mihoub's mother was convicted of destroying objects linked to the crime. Mihoub appealed and later withdrew the appeal, and the judgment stands as final.

She was born into a Jewish family and was still a child in the summer of 1942. That July, French police acting under German occupation rounded up about 13,000 Jews in Paris and held them in the Vélodrome d'Hiver, a cycling stadium, before they were sent to Auschwitz.

She and her mother were already gone. With a Brazilian passport, mother and daughter crossed into Portugal, and the family made its way out of Nazi-occupied territory. When the war ended she came back to Paris.

There she married a man who had survived Auschwitz, and together they raised two sons. Her husband died in the early 2000s. For most of her adult life she lived in the same public housing complex in the 11th arrondissement, a modest place she loved. She was not observant, but she held to her Jewish identity, and she kept friends of many faiths. By 2018 she was frail and lived alone.

Yacine Mihoub was born in 1989 and grew up in the same housing complex, where his mother still lived. He had been in and out of her company since he was a small boy. She often welcomed him, and over the years he did odd jobs for her. She treated him almost as family.

By his late twenties he had a long criminal record. At trial the prosecution counted six previous convictions, among them offenses of violence and drug dealing. His most recent sentence, imposed in 2017, was for a sexual assault on a child committed during a visit to the woman he would later kill. After that conviction he was barred from the building, but he kept coming back.

In prison in 2017 he met a younger man who would later stand trial beside him. Both were released, and shortly before March 23, 2018, by their own accounts, they ran into each other again in Paris. On that Friday the two men went together to see her. She died in Paris that day.

The police moved quickly, and both suspects were identified within days. Mihoub was taken into custody on Saturday, March 24. During questioning he named the second man, who was arrested the next night. On March 26 the Paris prosecutor's office opened a judicial investigation, treating the killing from the start as a crime committed because of the victim's religion and against a vulnerable person. On March 27 both men were placed under formal investigation and jailed. On April 6 Mihoub's mother was charged with altering the evidence of a crime and placed under judicial supervision.

The two men told incompatible stories, and throughout the two years of the investigation each said the other had killed her. The question of motive turned largely on statements the second man made in police custody about remarks he attributed to Mihoub. His account shifted, and he later retracted part of it. Mihoub denied that he had ever said anything of the kind.

In July 2020 the investigating judges sent both men for trial before the Cour d'assises de Paris for murder of a vulnerable person committed because of the victim's religion, aggravated theft, and damage by means dangerous to persons. Mihoub's mother was sent for trial before the same court for destroying a document or object relating to a crime in order to obstruct the discovery of the truth. A defense challenge to the antisemitic aggravation failed before the investigating chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal in November 2020, and the aggravation went to trial intact.

The trial opened in Paris on Tuesday, October 26, 2021, with Mihoub's mother as the third accused. Both men denied killing her, each again blamed the other, and both rejected the charge that antisemitism had played any part. When Mihoub gave evidence he denied the murder and the theft, admitting only to the property damage, and said it was the second man who had been alone with her when she was killed and robbed. Neither man moved from his version.

On the evening of Wednesday, November 10, 2021, the court gave its verdicts. Mihoub was found guilty of murder. The court retained both aggravating circumstances: that the victim was particularly vulnerable and that he had killed her because of her membership of the Jewish religion. It sentenced him to réclusion criminelle à perpétuité, life imprisonment, with a période de sûreté of 22 years, the minimum he must serve before he can seek release.

In giving its reasons the court found that the motive of theft had been fueled by hatred of the victim's membership of the Jewish religion, by Mihoub's prejudices, and by his belief that riches might be hidden in her possession.

The second man was acquitted of the murder. He was convicted of aggravated theft, theft preceded, accompanied or followed by violence that caused death, with both the antisemitic motive and the victim's vulnerability retained against him, and was sentenced to 15 years of réclusion criminelle. Mihoub's mother was convicted of destroying objects linked to the crime and received a three-year sentence, much of it not to be served in prison.

On November 15, 2021, Mihoub's lawyer announced that he had appealed. On January 10, 2023, it was reported that Mihoub had withdrawn the appeal, closing the proceedings for good. The judgment of November 10, 2021, is final, and as of January 2023 he was serving life imprisonment in France.

Which of the two men killed her was the central dispute of the case, and the two accused never agreed on it. No confession and no direct testimony settled it. The jury resolved the question by convicting Mihoub of the murder and acquitting the second man of it.

The antisemitic motive rested in large part on the second man's statements in custody, which shifted and were partly retracted. Mihoub denied any religious motive. The investigating judges, the investigating chamber of the Court of Appeal and finally the trial court all found the antisemitic aggravation established.

Timeline

July 1942: The future victim and her mother leave Paris before the Vel d'Hiv roundup and cross into Portugal.

1989: Yacine Mihoub is born.

2017: Mihoub is convicted and imprisoned; in prison he meets his future co-defendant.

March 23, 2018: The victim is murdered in Paris.

March 24, 2018: Mihoub is taken into custody.

March 25, 2018: The second man is arrested after Mihoub names him.

March 26, 2018: The Paris prosecutor opens a judicial investigation.

March 27, 2018: Both men are placed under formal investigation and remanded in custody.

April 6, 2018: Mihoub's mother is charged with altering the evidence of a crime.

July 10, 2020: The investigating judges send both men and Mihoub's mother for trial before the Cour d'assises de Paris.

November 2020: The investigating chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal rejects the defense challenge to the antisemitic aggravation.

October 26, 2021: The trial opens in Paris.

November 10, 2021: Mihoub is convicted of murder with both aggravating circumstances and sentenced to life with a 22-year période de sûreté; the co-defendant is acquitted of murder and given 15 years for aggravated theft.

November 15, 2021: Mihoub appeals.

January 10, 2023: Mihoub's withdrawal of his appeal is reported, and the conviction becomes final.