William Mansfield

Victims
5 CONVICTIONS - one in California for Rene Abbey Saling, and four by guilty plea in Florida, entered to avoid a death sentence. A sixth killing, of eighteen-year-old Carol Ann Barrett in 1980, was attributed to him and never charged because he was already serving life. He confessed to a further killing in January 2024. One of the two unidentified Florida victims has since been identified by DNA as sixteen-year-old Theresa Fillingim
Years active
December 31, 1975 - December 6, 1980
Location
Weeki Wachee Acres, Hernando County, Florida and Santa Cruz County, California, USA
Method
Shooting
Status
Arrested for the final time on October 26, 1981 and convicted in 1982. In California he was convicted of the first-degree murder of Rene Abbey Saling, whom he raped and strangled in Santa Cruz County, and sentenced to twenty-five years to life. He then pleaded guilty in Florida to the four murders of women and girls whose remains were found buried at the family property in Spring Hill, avoiding a death sentence, and received four life terms, served concurrently with the California sentence. Held at the California Health Care Facility in Stockton. Investigators long believed he had also killed eighteen-year-old Carol Ann Barrett in 1980 but brought no charge because he was already serving multiple life sentences. In January 2024 he confessed to the murder of another teenage girl in Florida, and DNA testing later identified one of the two unidentified Spring Hill victims as sixteen-year-old Theresa Fillingim. Acting on further statements from him, the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office and the FBI excavated the Spring Hill property again from June 22, 2026, the second such search after human remains were found there in October 2020 following his brother Gary’s arrest on drug charges.

William Mansfield was born in 1956, the eldest son of a man who was later sentenced to thirty years for child molestation. He had a police record of his own, including a year for sex offences in Michigan.

He was paroled in March 1980 and went back to the family home, a six-acre junkyard at Weeki Wachee Acres near Tampa. He lasted three months. On June 19 he was charged with battery and false imprisonment of a young woman, and in early September he left for California.

He was arrested at Santa Cruz on November 23, 1980 and released on fifteen hundred dollars' bail. The source describes that as a mistake, and says that by the time officers tried to correct it two weeks later it was already too late for one of his victims. Rene Sailing, thirty, was last seen leaving a California tavern with him on December 6. Her body, shot through, was recovered from a drainage ditch the next morning. Warrants were issued, and he was taken days later at Winnemucca, Nevada, along with his twenty-three-year-old brother Gary, who was charged as an accessory after the fact.

On March 16, 1981 Hernando County deputies arrived at the family home with a search warrant, having been told that a missing woman from Tampa, Sandra Graham, twenty-one, might be buried on the property. They came equipped to excavate.

They found the first skeleton on March 17, a white woman in her twenties. The second, a week later, was Elaine Zeigler, fifteen, a tourist from Ohio who had vanished from a nearby campground on New Year's Eve 1975. A third was found on April 3 and was never identified either. The fourth, four days after that, was Sandra Graham.

All four were buried within forty feet of the house. Two of them have never been named. Police concluded that neither his father, then serving his sentence, nor his mother, who said she knew nothing about the bodies, had any part in the killings. No further remains were found and the digging was stopped in mid-April.

He was also suspected of two other Florida murders that were never charged. Melinda Harder, twenty-one, was a neighbour of his in St Petersburg and disappeared on July 27, 1980. Carrol Barret, another woman from Ohio, was abducted from her motel room at Daytona Beach in 1980, shot, and left beside a highway near Jacksonville; Mansfield matched the description of her killer but no witness could identify him.

He was convicted in both states and is serving concurrent life sentences. The reference work that carries this account gives the disposition as concurrent life terms and nothing further; the accessible material has no account of either trial and nothing about where he is held or whether he is still alive.

That source also dates the end of the excavation to mid-April 1980, which cannot be right, since it began in March 1981.