William Heirens was 17, a student at the University of Chicago and a habitual burglar, when Chicago police caught him prowling an apartment building on June 26, 1946. Within days the police said his fingerprint matched one on the ransom note left in the bedroom of Suzanne Degnan, a six-year-old girl taken from her home on the North Side in January of that year. He was then linked to the killings of two women in their apartments in 1945, one of them the scene of a message written in lipstick that gave the case its name. On September 4, 1946, he pleaded guilty to all three murders and to 26 other indictments, and he was sentenced to three consecutive life terms.
He soon recanted. For the rest of his life he said he had confessed only to escape the electric chair, after police had questioned him for days, drugged him without consent and leaked an invented confession to the newspapers. The Illinois Supreme Court agreed in 1954 that the police had committed "flagrant violations of his rights," but held that his guilty pleas, entered more than a month later on the advice of his own lawyers, were not caused by that conduct. The convictions stood. He was refused parole and clemency again and again, and he died in custody in March 2012, at 83, after more than 65 years in prison, the longest term served by any Illinois inmate.
Heirens was born on November 15, 1928, in Evanston, Illinois, according to the New York Times obituary by Douglas Martin, as printed by The Bulletin of Bend, Oregon. His father ran a flower business that failed, and the family came close to poverty. Heirens said later that his parents fought often, and that he broke into houses to get away from the tension at home; he said he did not sell what he took.
His criminal record began at 13, according to the University of Chicago Library's guide to its collection of clippings on the case, and the Chicago Maroon reported that he had been arrested for burglaries since 1942. He was placed in two Catholic institutions for boys, where he did well in his studies, and later attended St. Bede's, a boarding school. He skipped his senior year and entered the University of Chicago at 16, planning to study engineering.
He was admitted under a policy of President Robert Maynard Hutchins that let gifted students start college before finishing high school, according to a University of Chicago study of the case by Sophia Posnock. Posnock found that he barely passed the entrance examinations and was a below-average student, and that classmates and staff remembered him as shy, well liked and unremarkable. At his father's request he was housed in Snell Hall with an older war veteran rather than in the dormitory set aside for the youngest students. The Maroon reported that he was vice president of the Calvert Club, a Catholic student group, drank whiskey with his roommate and dated casually. He also went on breaking into homes.
Josephine Ross, a 43-year-old widow, was found dead in her apartment on the North Side on June 3, 1945, according to the University of Chicago Library guide; other accounts give the month only. She had been stabbed. Her death was not then connected to any other case. Little else about her life, her work or her family was reported.
In December 1945 Frances Brown was killed in her apartment on the North Side. She was shot and stabbed, and the apartment had been ransacked. Her age is given as 32 by CBS Chicago in 2012 and as 31 by the Chicago Maroon, which reported that her body was found on December 11, 1945.
At the scene someone had written in lipstick, "For heaven's sake catch me before I kill more. I cannot control myself." The University of Chicago Library guide and the 1988 United Press International report place the words on a wall; the Associated Press obituary of 2012 places them on a mirror. The newspapers named the unknown killer for the message. The reports say nothing of Frances Brown's life beyond her name, her age and the place she died.
Suzanne Degnan was six. Her father was an executive with the federal Office of Price Administration, the Associated Press reported in January 1946. On January 7, 1946, the first day of school after the Christmas break, an intruder used a ladder to reach her bedroom and carried her away. A ransom note demanding 20,000 dollars was found in the house. She had been strangled.
Her family never accepted any doubt about who had killed her. Her older sister and her brother attended parole hearings for decades to ask that the man convicted of her murder stay in prison.
The Degnan case dominated the Chicago press. The Chicago Tribune called it one of the most atrocious American murders since the Leopold and Loeb case, the Chicago Maroon recorded. Four days after the kidnapping, an Associated Press report printed in the Greenville, North Carolina, Daily Reflector described "the collapse of one clue after another." Lieutenant Philip Brietzke led a special detail of 20 officers, and Mayor Edward J. Kelly said rewards totaling 37,500 dollars had been offered.
The first suspects were two janitors in the Edgewater district, a man of 65 (H. V.) and a man of 35 (D. S.). Both were released after the State's Attorney found no evidence on which to charge them. The older man's wife was not charged either. The Maroon reported that the older janitor had been treated brutally during his questioning and later won 20,000 dollars in a lawsuit against the police.
For months the police took the fingerprints of everyone they arrested, according to the Maroon, and compared them with the prints from the Degnan case. Parents kept their children indoors, Ed McManus wrote in Illinois Issues in 1995, and the search went on for five and a half months without an arrest.
On June 26, 1946, police caught Heirens prowling an apartment building in Rogers Park, on the far North Side. In a struggle an officer broke three flowerpots over his head, the Illinois Supreme Court recorded; Posnock writes that the officer was off duty and a traffic policeman, and that the blows fractured Heirens's skull. Police said he had aimed a gun at an officer and pulled the trigger twice, but it misfired, according to the New York Times obituary. He was later convicted, on his plea, of assault with intent to kill a police officer.
He was taken to a hospital unconscious and kept there as a bed patient for five days, the Supreme Court found, at the hospital of the Bridewell jail, according to the Maroon and Posnock. The same day, police searched his living quarters at the university and recovered stolen property. The University of Chicago Library guide says much of his loot and a collection of weapons were found in his room in Gates Hall and in Woodlawn Hall. The Maroon lists war bonds, jewelry, guns and cameras worth more than 3,400 dollars; Posnock lists a diamond brooch and 24 war bonds, and a scrapbook of pictures of Nazi leaders. The Maroon also reported that surgical kits were found; Heirens said he owned nothing of the kind beyond a razor blade for building model airplanes. The guide notes that most of the crimes later charged against him took place around Hyde Park and Woodlawn, near the university, and on the far North Side near Loyola University.
Sergeant Thomas Laffey of the Chicago police reported that a print of Heirens's matched one on the Degnan ransom note, and the FBI confirmed the match, Posnock writes. By June 30 police had linked him to the deaths of Josephine Ross and Frances Brown. The Maroon reported that his fingerprint showed nine points of similarity with a print from the Brown apartment, which officials called adequate for identification.
What happened next is recorded in the 1954 opinion of the Illinois Supreme Court, which reviewed the evidence taken at his post-conviction hearing. For two days he was questioned at intervals, and through the whole of the second night. His answers were incoherent. On the third day, at the direction of the State's Attorney, a psychiatrist injected him with sodium pentothal, without his permission or his parents'. Officials listened from behind screens while a stenographer took notes. Under the drug he talked about the crimes and blamed someone he called "George." The doctor who examined him testified that he was "a mentally sick boy," a psychotic schizophrenic and not a malingerer.
On June 30 police gave him a lie-detector test, also without his consent; he did not answer the questions. That evening he said he would tell everything and made a statement blaming a "George Merman," as the court spelled the name (other accounts write Murman). He printed out the text of a ransom note, and a handwriting expert later said the printing matched his. Posnock and the 2002 clemency petition, as reported by the Associated Press, also say he was given a spinal tap without anesthetic; the court's opinion does not mention one.
Heirens told the Maroon decades later that his questioning was rough but that he did not remember being beaten or drugged. In other accounts he said he had been beaten and given "truth serum," according to the New York Times obituary.
On July 1 he was brought to court on a habeas corpus petition filed by lawyers his parents had hired. He was charged first with burglaries and later with the murders.
On July 16, 1946, the Chicago Tribune published a detailed account of how he had committed the killings, presented as his confession, before he had confessed to anything, Posnock writes; other papers reprinted it. The Times obituary says the Tribune cited "unimpeachable sources" and that four other Chicago papers ran similar stories. Posnock counted 157 press items on the case in the ten weeks after his arrest. In later years Heirens said he had been "tried and convicted in the newspapers," as ABC7 Chicago reported at his death.
Four lawyers chosen by Heirens and his parents represented him. According to the Supreme Court's account, they consulted a psychiatrist, concluded that there was no proof he could not tell right from wrong, and negotiated an agreement: he would plead guilty, confess and submit to a psychiatric examination, and the prosecutors would recommend life terms running concurrently. Posnock writes that on July 17 he agreed to write a confession and then refused, and that his lawyers told him that without one he would probably be executed. On July 26 he signed a written confession and an authorization for his lawyers to go ahead.
On July 30, at the State's Attorney's office, with officials and reporters expecting a confession, he said he did not remember the crimes. The Times obituary reports that he said he had been about to sign for one life sentence but would not be "forced to lie to save myself." The deal collapsed. After further talks the State demanded that he accept consecutive life sentences or go to trial on pleas of not guilty, and he agreed to the new terms and to confess.
On August 6, by the court's date (Posnock gives August 7), he gave long statements about all three killings, took officials through reenactments, and was examined by three psychiatrists. Their report found no psychosis, average intelligence and emotional instability, the court recorded. The Times obituary notes that during the negotiations his memory seemed unreliable and that he worked into his account details that the prosecutors had taken from the Tribune story. Of the decision to plead, he said later: "I confessed to live."
On September 4, 1946, Heirens pleaded guilty in the Criminal Court of Cook County to three indictments for murder and 26 indictments for burglary, robbery and assault, after the court warned him of the consequences. At the hearing on aggravation and mitigation the State put in his confessions, the transcripts of the reenactments, the psychiatric report, the testimony of 18 witnesses and stipulations. The defense offered nothing in mitigation. The court imposed a life sentence on each murder indictment, to run consecutively, and sentences on the other indictments that ran concurrently with one another but consecutively to the life terms. The Maroon reports that the sentences were pronounced the day after the pleas.
There was no trial, and no hearing on whether he was competent to plead, McManus noted in 1988. At sentencing, McManus wrote, the prosecutor conceded that without the cooperation of defense counsel there would have been "small likelihood of a successful murder prosecution."
He was sent to Stateville prison as inmate C-06103, the Maroon reported. He recanted within a short time and from then on maintained that he was innocent.
On July 8, 1952, Heirens filed a petition under the Illinois Post-Conviction Hearing Act. After a hearing it was denied, and he took the case to the Illinois Supreme Court by writ of error, with two court-appointed lawyers, Calvin Sawyier and Arthur R. Seder Jr., as friends of the court. Justice Klingbiel wrote the opinion, issued on September 23, 1954.
The court called the search of his room, the prolonged questioning and the unauthorized use of sodium pentothal and the lie detector "flagrant violations of his rights," and said a conviction obtained by such conduct would deny due process. But the pleas had come more than a month later, and the court held that the earlier conduct "had no substantial connection with the pleas of guilty." It held that the publicity had not made the pleas involuntary, noting that no change of venue or delay had been sought and that the record showed strong signs of guilt and a wish to avoid the death penalty. It found his lawyers competent and devoted. Two arguments, that he was a minor without a guardian and that no sanity hearing was held, were not considered because they had not been raised in the lower court; the opinion observed that the evidence of his mental abnormality "might well have justified a finding" that he was not legally responsible, but did not decide the point. The judgment was affirmed.
A later writ of error, decided by the Illinois Supreme Court on May 21, 1964, went forward without a lawyer for Heirens. After the United States Supreme Court held in another case that such a petitioner was entitled to counsel, the federal Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, in an unsigned opinion of April 11, 1967, held his federal habeas corpus case in abeyance so that the Illinois Supreme Court could hear his claims with appointed counsel. In 1968 the federal courts again upheld the convictions, McManus reported, with Judge Luther Swygert dissenting on the ground that Heirens's sanity was in doubt and a hearing on his competency had been required.
Heirens became, by every account, a model prisoner. The University of Chicago would not let him take its courses, the Maroon reported, so he studied by correspondence. In 1972 he received a degree from Lewis University and became the first Illinois prisoner to earn a college degree while in prison. He later helped build education programs for other inmates and, by the account of his lawyer Steven Drizin, redesigned the prison library system. He also managed the prison garden factory, the Times obituary says. He earned a certificate as an emergency medical technician and, in the 1970s, drove an ambulance through a prison program, WBEZ reported. Drizin said he had had no disciplinary problems for 50 years.
By 1988 he was held at the Vienna Correctional Center, United Press International reported; McManus wrote in 1995 that it was a minimum-security prison and that Heirens worked there as secretary to the Catholic chaplain. He was later moved to Dixon Correctional Center. His parents and brother changed their surname to Hill, the Times obituary says, and he had no known surviving family at his death.
His life sentences carried the possibility of parole, the Associated Press reported, and he applied again and again. McManus wrote that a parole board member praised his rehabilitation at a hearing in 1975. At a November 1979 hearing the board's chairman, James Irving, made comments that a federal magistrate later cited as evidence that the board regarded him as rehabilitated; the board said in 1983 that Irving had spoken only for himself and had not been convinced Heirens was ready for parole.
On August 31, 1981, Heirens asked the federal court in southern Illinois for a writ of habeas corpus, arguing that the board had denied him parole under a standard adopted after his crimes, in breach of the ban on ex post facto laws. On July 15, 1982, a federal magistrate granted the petition and ordered a new hearing, at which the board could deny parole only on facts that had developed since 1979. The board heard his case again on August 10, 1982, and denied parole once more. Its written reasons cited the three murders, his statement that he had gained sexual satisfaction from the burglaries, and its judgment that the risk of further misconduct was too great, while it praised his "excellent institutional adjustment in a structured environment." The magistrate found that the board had not complied and, on April 20, 1983, ordered Heirens released, staying the order for 20 days.
The State appealed. On February 24, 1984, the Seventh Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Coffey, reversed. It held that the board had considered deterrence and retribution before 1973 as well, so applying the newer standard to him did no harm under the ex post facto clause.
He stayed in prison. In April 1988 the Prisoner Review Board denied him parole for the 28th time, United Press International reported. At that hearing he said he was rehabilitated and innocent; Suzanne Degnan's brother and sister asked the board to keep him in prison; and the Cook County State's Attorney, Richard Daley, dismissed the innocence claims as ridiculous, pointing to the fingerprints, the handwriting samples, the stolen goods found in his room and his confession.
McManus, who had written in 1988 that Heirens was "Probably" guilty, "but maybe not," argued in 1995 that it was time to release him. Heirens was then 66, had a job offer from a group in Albany, New York, that counseled former prisoners, and had watched other men serving life be paroled. The Cook County State's Attorney, the Illinois Attorney General and Suzanne's sister opposed his release.
In the 1990s the Chicago lawyer Jed Stone represented Heirens in a petition for clemency. Stone said several experts had concluded that the handwriting at the crime scenes was not Heirens's, and that his fingerprint appeared to have been planted: a rolled print showing both full edges, found on a door jamb, was not something that happened in ordinary life, he argued, according to ABC7 Chicago. CBS Chicago reported that Stone said in 1995 that the fingerprint evidence was fraudulent.
In 2002, students and law professors at Northwestern University's Center on Wrongful Convictions took up the case. Their petition to Governor George Ryan said that Heirens had been given a spinal tap without anesthetic, that police had given him sodium pentothal before he made admissions, and that the evidence was tainted, his defense incompetent and the pretrial publicity prejudicial, the Associated Press reported. The Times obituary says the lawyers argued that the case combined prosecutorial misconduct, poor defense, publicity, junk science, probably false confessions and mistaken eyewitness identifications. At the clemency hearing that year a Chicago police official, Thomas Epach, called Heirens "the yardstick by which all evil is judged." Ryan did not grant clemency; Drizin said the petition was denied. In an interview with the New York Times that year, Heirens said that friendships made in prison rarely lasted after release.
On August 2, 2007, the Illinois Prisoner Review Board voted 14 to 0 to deny him parole, the Associated Press reported. He was 78, had been in prison 61 years and used a wheelchair. Board members acknowledged that he had changed in six decades but cited the brutality of the crimes and said parole would show disrespect for the law. The board's chairman, Jorge Montes, told WBEZ that the board did not "go back and look at all the original facts and retry the case," and said the crimes were too grave for release despite his good prison record. A board member, Thomas Johnson, told him: "God will forgive you. But the state won't."
The day before the hearing, Drizin had told WBEZ that the corrections system's philosophy had shifted from rehabilitation to retribution, and that Heirens was still in prison because of that shift rather than anything he had done. Heirens had by then had more than 30 parole hearings, WBEZ reported. CBS Chicago reported in 2012 that the 2007 request was his last.
In his last years Heirens suffered from diabetes, which damaged his eyesight, and he used a wheelchair and lived in the prison hospital wing. He and his lawyers argued that his age and health meant he was no danger to anyone. The argument failed. The Maroon, interviewing him at Dixon, found that his memory had faded and that he often could not recall details of the case or of his burglaries.
Reuters reported that he was moved from Dixon Correctional Center to the University of Illinois at Chicago Medical Center on February 26, 2012, because of illness; the Associated Press reported that Dixon staff had found him unresponsive in his cell. He died at the hospital on the night of Monday, March 5, 2012, at 83. CBS Chicago reported that he had been suffering from renal failure and hypertension; the Cook County Medical Examiner's Office ordered an autopsy and gave no cause of death in the first reports. He was, by the reports of his death, the longest-serving prisoner in Illinois history.
Reactions divided along the old lines. Suzanne Degnan's sister, who had attended every one of his parole hearings over 30 years, said he was a sick man who had changed his story, and rejected his claims of innocence and rehabilitation. "After he was caught, his horrible crimes stopped," she told CBS Chicago. Suzanne's brother told ABC7 Chicago that the family's account had never changed and that Heirens had never answered where he was when the crimes happened. Richard Devine, a former Cook County State's Attorney, said Heirens deserved to spend the rest of his life in prison. Jed Stone said he regretted not winning Heirens's release and described him as bright and personable, "so much not a murderer." Steven Drizin said Heirens had been tortured before he confessed.
The Fritz Lang film While the City Sleeps (1956), about newspapermen competing to identify a killer of women, drew on the case, Reuters and ABC7 Chicago reported.
The arrest of a student for the Degnan murder changed the university, Posnock argues. The university tightened admissions screening, added questions about earlier trouble with the law, increased supervision of students and imposed dormitory rules, a step back from the hands-off approach it had favored. The early-admission program under which Heirens had entered ended two years after Hutchins left the university. The university's Office of Public Relations kept a file of newspaper clippings on the case from June 27, 1946, onward; it is now held by the library's Special Collections Research Center.
Proven by final judgment: Heirens pleaded guilty to, and stands convicted of, the murders of Josephine Ross, Frances Brown and Suzanne Degnan, and 26 indictments for burglary, robbery and assault. The Illinois Supreme Court upheld the pleas in 1954, and federal courts declined to disturb them. No court ever set the convictions aside, and as of October 2026 no exoneration has been reported.
His recantation: from shortly after sentencing until his death, Heirens said he was innocent and had confessed to save his life. He told the Maroon that police had invented the name George Murman and had fabricated the fingerprint evidence, and that they had picked him out because he was a known burglar.
What his supporters argue: McManus reported in 1995 that five handwriting experts had concluded that the lipstick message and the ransom note were written by two different people and that neither was Heirens. The handwriting expert who testified for the State, Herbert J. Walker, later said the samples had "few superficial similarities and a great many dissimilarities," the Maroon reported. Stone and others argued that the print in the Brown apartment had been planted. A handwriting analyst cited by McManus argued that the ransom note was written by another man, R. T., who had confessed to the Degnan crime but was released because police did not believe him; the Maroon reports that Dolores Kennedy of the Center on Wrongful Convictions, who wrote a book on the case, believes the same man was responsible, and that he confessed from a prison in Arizona and later recanted. A 1999 book by Richard Lindberg questioned whether the lipstick message was genuine, suggesting that a reporter may have written it, the Maroon reported. Supporters also point to what is now known about false confessions by teenagers.
What the State and the victims' families answered: prosecutors cited the fingerprints on the ransom note and at one of the women's apartments, the handwriting analysis, the stolen property and his detailed confession, and Suzanne Degnan's family never doubted his guilt.
Details that vary between sources: the date Josephine Ross was found (June 3, 1945, in the University of Chicago Library guide; other sources give June 1945 only); Frances Brown's age (32 or 31) and whether the lipstick message was on a wall or a mirror; the date of his long confession (August 6 by the court, August 7 by Posnock); whether he was sentenced on September 4 or 5, 1946 (the federal and state courts give the plea and judgment as September 4; the Maroon says sentence came the next day); and the Maroon's statement that the life terms were concurrent, which the court records contradict: they were consecutive. Some reports give the year of all three killings as 1946; Ross and Brown were killed in 1945.
November 15, 1928: William George Heirens is born in Evanston, Illinois.
1942: first burglary arrests, by the Maroon's account (the University of Chicago Library guide dates his record from age 13); later sent to Catholic institutions for boys and to St. Bede's.
1945: enters the University of Chicago at 16 under an early-admission program.
June 3, 1945: Josephine Ross, 43, is found stabbed to death in her apartment on the North Side.
December 1945: Frances Brown is shot and stabbed in her apartment; a lipstick message is left at the scene.
January 7, 1946: Suzanne Degnan, 6, is taken from her bedroom; a ransom note demands 20,000 dollars; she is found dead.
January 1946: two janitors are questioned and released without charge.
June 26, 1946: Heirens is arrested in Rogers Park during a burglary attempt and knocked unconscious.
Late June 1946: questioned for days; injected with sodium pentothal without consent; given a lie-detector test without consent; his print is matched to the ransom note.
July 1, 1946: habeas corpus hearing; charged with burglaries, later with the murders.
July 16, 1946: the Chicago Tribune publishes an account presented as his confession.
July 26, 1946: signs a written confession and authorizes a plea.
July 30, 1946: says at the State's Attorney's office that he remembers nothing; the concurrent-sentence deal collapses.
August 6, 1946: gives full statements and reenacts the crimes under the consecutive-sentence deal.
September 4, 1946: pleads guilty to three murders and 26 other indictments; three consecutive life sentences.
July 8, 1952: files a post-conviction petition, later denied.
September 23, 1954: the Illinois Supreme Court affirms.
May 21, 1964: a further writ of error is decided without counsel.
April 11, 1967: the Seventh Circuit holds his federal case in abeyance for a new state hearing with counsel.
1968: federal courts uphold the convictions; Judge Swygert dissents.
1972: earns a degree from Lewis University, the first Illinois prisoner to do so.
1975: a parole board member praises his rehabilitation.
November 1979: parole hearing; the chairman's comments are later cited in court.
August 31, 1981: files a federal habeas petition over the parole criteria.
April 20, 1983: a federal magistrate orders his release, stayed.
February 24, 1984: the Seventh Circuit reverses.
April 1988: parole denied for the 28th time.
1990s: clemency petition by Jed Stone.
2002: Northwestern's clemency petition to Governor Ryan is denied.
August 2, 2007: parole denied, 14 to 0, at his last parole hearing.
February 26, 2012: moved from Dixon Correctional Center to a Chicago hospital.
March 5, 2012: dies in custody at 83.