Waseem Azeem

Victims
1 death in Multan, 2016; convicted 2019, acquitted 2022. A life sentence for the murder of his sister was set aside on appeal, Lahore High Court, February 14, 2022.
Years active
July 15, 2016 (death); September 27, 2019 (conviction); February 14, 2022 (acquittal)
Location
Multan; Dera Ghazi Khan; Punjab, Pakistan
Method
Murder (qatl-i-amd); claimed "honor" motive in his own public admission, later held not established on appeal
Status
Life imprisonment (2019); acquitted on appeal February 14, 2022, released February 19, 2022; state appeal to the Supreme Court filed March 2022

Waseem Azeem was arrested in July 2016, a day after his sister Qandeel Baloch, born Fouzia Azeem and by then one of the most widely followed and argued-over public figures on Pakistani social media, died in Multan, in the south of Punjab province. The next day he admitted the killing in front of reporters. The case became the most closely watched of its kind in Pakistan's recent history, and the trial that followed in Multan ran until 2019.

In September 2019 a model court in Multan convicted him of wilful murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. In February 2022 the Lahore High Court set the conviction aside. The appeal judge accepted the compromise offered by her legal heirs, held that the prosecution had not established an honor killing once the confession was put aside, and noted that every prosecution witness had gone back on earlier testimony. Waseem Azeem walked out of custody on Saturday, February 19, 2022. The Punjab prosecution department took the acquittal to the Supreme Court of Pakistan in March 2022. On the legal record he stands acquitted, with that state appeal pending.

She first came to wide notice in 2014 through a short video that spread across Pakistani social media. She had auditioned for a televised singing contest, and she went on to build a following of about 800,000 people on her Facebook page through videos, photographs and comments that broke openly with conservative norms. She appeared on television talking about the empowerment of women, and many young Pakistanis took her as a symbol of it. She was also abused and threatened online in large numbers.

In the weeks before her death she wrote to federal officials and the police in Islamabad to ask for protection, saying she was receiving threatening calls, and she had spoken of leaving Pakistan because she feared for her safety. In July 2016 she was in Multan for the Eid holiday.

She died on the night of Friday, July 15, 2016, in Multan. The case was registered the next day on a complaint that named Waseem as the person who had killed her. Late on Saturday, July 16, officers found him in Dera Ghazi Khan district and took him into custody.

On Sunday, July 17, the Multan police brought him before reporters. He admitted that he had killed his sister and claimed that he had acted for the family's "honor." The police announced that they would charge him with an honor killing.

The case was opened under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code, read with Sections 109 and 34. Waseem later made a statement before a judicial magistrate under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and that statement went on the file as his judicial confession. The case against him came to rest on it, on evidence placing him in Multan that night, and on further evidence that the prosecution said linked him to the death. The charge sheet named six other people, among them his two other brothers and a cleric. One brother, abroad at the time, was declared a proclaimed offender. Multan police took him into custody with Interpol's help in October 2019, and at that point no court had charged him.

On Tuesday, December 6, 2016, an additional sessions judge in Multan formally charged Waseem with murder, together with two other men accused with him, and all three pleaded not guilty. The case later went to a model court in Multan, under a sessions judge, with the case against Waseem joined to the cases against the other accused. In August 2019 his parents, treated as her legal heirs, told the court that they had forgiven him and asked for the case to end. The judge refused "for the time being," holding that whether the killing was an honor killing could only be decided once all the evidence was in.

On Friday, September 27, 2019, the court found Waseem Azeem guilty of qatl-i-amd, wilful murder, and sentenced him to imprisonment for life. It rested that finding on three things: evidence that he had been present in Multan at the time of the killing, his judicial confession, and further evidence that the court found corroborated the confession. At the trial he retracted the statement he had made before the magistrate, saying it had been given under police pressure; the court relied on it all the same. The judgment found that he had killed her in the name of "honor," and the life sentence was imposed under Section 311 of the Penal Code. The same judgment acquitted five of the other accused, among them the elder brother tried with him and the cleric, holding that there was no convincing circumstantial evidence against them. Waseem was sent to serve his sentence in custody in Punjab.

His appeal was heard at the Multan Bench of the Lahore High Court by a single judge. On Monday, February 14, 2022, the High Court allowed it, set aside the conviction and life sentence, and acquitted him. The judgment found grave illegalities in the way the judicial magistrate had recorded his confession and put the confession aside. It pointed to how little time had passed between his production before the magistrate and the recording of the statement, to doubt over whether he had been in handcuffs as he made it, to the number of court staff present and to problems in rendering his words between Urdu and English. The only reason for the killing anywhere in the confession, the court noted, came in its last line. Without it, the court held, nothing in the prosecution's case established an honor killing, so Section 311 did not apply and the general law of murder, under which the heirs may forgive, governed the case. The acquittal was made on the basis of the heirs' compromise.

He was freed on Saturday, February 19, 2022, at the age of 38. A private petition and, on March 19, 2022, a state appeal filed by the Punjab prosecution department both asked the Supreme Court to restore the 2019 conviction and sentence. As of March 21, 2022, the court had not fixed a date to hear either.

Pakistan's law lets the heirs of a murder victim waive punishment or settle with the killer, but Section 311 lets a court still sentence the killer as fasad-fil-arz, a crime against society. A 2016 amendment, passed less than three months after the death in Multan, provided that "if the offence has been committed in the name or on the pretext of honour, the punishment shall be imprisonment for life." Whether that amendment could reach a killing that came before it was argued at the trial and raised again before the Supreme Court.

The motive remains contested in law. Waseem Azeem's own admission to the press in July 2016 named "honor," and the trial court sentenced him under Section 311, but the High Court held that the prosecution had not proved an honor killing once the confession was put aside. The brother declared a proclaimed offender had not been charged by any court when he was taken into custody in October 2019, and the five men acquitted in 2019 were cleared of any part in the death. Whether the 2016 amendment applied to a death three months before it was passed has not been decided, and the Supreme Court had not ruled on the state's appeal as of March 2022.

Timeline

July 15, 2016: His sister dies in Multan.

July 16, 2016: The case is registered; late that night Waseem Azeem is arrested in Dera Ghazi Khan district.

July 17, 2016: He admits the killing before reporters in Multan.

December 6, 2016: He is formally charged with murder in Multan and pleads not guilty.

August 2019: The trial court refuses the heirs' compromise "for the time being."

September 27, 2019: The model court in Multan convicts him of qatl-i-amd and sentences him to life imprisonment; five co-accused are acquitted.

February 14, 2022: The Lahore High Court, Multan Bench, acquits him on appeal.

February 19, 2022: He is released from custody.

March 19, 2022: The Punjab prosecution department files a state appeal in the Supreme Court.