Walter Reder

Victims
Civilians massacred at Monte Sole and in Tuscany, 1944. Convicted by a Bologna military tribunal, 1951, of the massacres; life sentence, pardoned 1985
Years active
August 1944 (Tuscany); September 29 to October 5, 1944 (Monte Sole)
Location
Marzabotto, Grizzana Morandi, Monzuno, Fivizzano, Gaeta, Bari, Graz, Vienna
Method
War crimes against civilians: killings of noncombatant civilians by troops under his command
Status
Life imprisonment (ergastolo), confirmed in part by the Tribunale supremo militare, March 1954; pardoned January 23, 1985; released January 24, 1985; died 1991

Walter Reder was the Austrian SS officer whose battalion carried out the largest massacre of civilians in German-occupied Italy. Between September 29 and October 5, 1944, his men and other units killed about 800 people in 115 separate places in the hill country around Monte Sole, south of Bologna, in the communes of Marzabotto, Grizzana Morandi and Monzuno. A few weeks earlier, in the Apuan Alps of northern Tuscany, the same battalion had killed the civilians of Vinca, Valla and Bardine di San Terenzo.

On October 31, 1951, the Tribunale militare territoriale di Bologna sentenced Reder to life imprisonment, holding him jointly responsible for the massacres at Monte Sole, Vinca, Valla and Bardine. He served more than three decades of that sentence in the military fortress at Gaeta, south of Rome, where for years he and Herbert Kappler were the best-known German prisoners in Italy. In January 1985, after a long campaign in Austria and Germany and a letter in which he asked Marzabotto for forgiveness, the Italian government pardoned him and flew him to Austria. Within days of his return he disowned the remorse he had expressed. He died in Vienna in 1991.

Reder was born on February 4, 1915, in Freiwaldau, a town in the Sudetenland that was then part of Austria-Hungary and is now Jeseník in the Czech Republic. He was Austrian by nationality. From 1922 he belonged to the Deutscher Turnerbund, a gymnastics league of the German nationalist movement.

In 1928 he moved to Vienna, and he finished his secondary schooling at a Realschule there in 1931. The next year he went to Linz to attend a commercial college. In Linz he joined the Hitler Youth, and on December 23, 1932, he entered the 37th SS Regiment. He joined the Nazi Party in 1935. In the years when the party was banned in Austria he was convicted for putting up notices, setting off firecrackers and party membership, and in 1934 he was expelled from the Austrian school system. He crossed into Germany to avoid arrest and lost his Austrian citizenship the same year.

In Germany he served in the Austrian Legion, the force of Austrian Nazis who had fled across the border, and in 1935 he went to the SS officer school at Braunschweig. In April 1936 he was commissioned an SS-Untersturmführer and posted to the Totenkopf units at Dachau, the guard formations of the concentration camp system. From that point until the autumn of 1944 he served under the same commander, Max Simon.

Reder's units took part in the annexation of Austria, the occupation of Czechoslovakia and the campaigns in Poland, France and the Soviet Union. In the spring of 1940 he was an adjutant on the staff of SS-Totenkopf Infantry Regiment 2.

In the summer of 1941 he fought in Simon's regiment on the Eastern Front, first commanding a company and then a battalion. He was wounded in the Valdai Hills on September 20, 1941, and he spent most of 1942 in the fighting around the Demyansk pocket before the division was moved to France in October 1942, where he attended a course for battalion commanders. He returned to the east in February 1943 for the battles around Kharkov. On March 10, 1943, he was badly wounded and lost his lower left arm. He received the Knight's Cross and was promoted to SS-Sturmbannführer, the rank he held to the end of the war.

In mid-December 1943 he wrote to Simon, who by then commanded the 16th SS Panzergrenadier Division "Reichsführer-SS," and asked to be given a front-line post despite his injuries. In the late spring of 1944 he took command of the division's SS Panzer Reconnaissance Battalion 16 on the Italian front. The unit became widely known in Italy by his name.

In August 1944 the battalion was moved into the Apuan Alps near Carrara and then into the area of Sarzana, on the border between Tuscany and Liguria, where the Italian partisan war was at its height.

The first of the massacres for which Reder was later convicted took place at Bardine di San Terenzo and Valla, in the commune of Fivizzano, in the province of Massa-Carrara, on August 19, 1944. Two days earlier, partisans had attacked a German detachment near Bardine and killed sixteen German soldiers, and the German commands meant the killings as a reprisal. Reder held operational command, and he was among the officers who signed the order to kill the people his men had rounded up at Valla.

The second came days later, between August 24 and 27, 1944, at Vinca, a village on the slopes of Monte Sagro in the same commune, where Reder's battalion operated alongside other German units and members of the Carrara branch of the Fascist Black Brigades. The sweep followed a partisan attack near Monzone on August 18 in which a German officer was killed, and the division commander placed Reder in command of the operation. Most of the dead at Vinca were women.

In late September the division was sent east to the Apennines south of Bologna, where the German defensive line known as the Gothic Line crossed the hills between the valleys of the Reno and the Setta. The area around Monte Sole was held by a partisan brigade, the Stella Rossa.

The operation began on September 29, 1944, and lasted until October 5. The whole of Reder's battalion was committed, together with other SS, army and Luftwaffe units. The military tribunal at La Spezia, which reexamined the operation in a later case against other men, found that the killing of unarmed civilians had begun before the only real engagement with the partisans and went on in places where Reder's men met no hostility at all. It ruled out both the idea of incidental casualties of combat and the idea of soldiers acting on their own beyond their orders. The men of Reder's battalion were responsible for most of the killings.

The total has been counted in different ways. A figure of 1,830 was used at the first commemoration in 1946; it came from comparing the prewar census with the ration cards issued after the war, and it measured the loss of population across the district rather than the dead of a single operation. The regional committee for the commemoration of the victims of Marzabotto later confirmed a figure of about 770, verified place by place across the 115 sites. The La Spezia tribunal described the operation as having caused the deaths of about 800 people in the three communes.

Reder kept command of the battalion until the German surrender in Italy in the spring of 1945.

In 1945 Reder was taken prisoner in Austria. He was held in the internment camps at Glasenbach, near Salzburg, and Wolfsberg, in Carinthia, and the British authorities who controlled that part of occupied Austria handed him over to Italy in May 1948 to answer for war crimes. His commander, Max Simon, had already been sentenced by a British military court at Padua in 1947 for the division's crimes in Italy; the sentence was later reduced, and Simon was released in 1954.

Italian investigators questioned Reder repeatedly before his trial, in 1949 and again in 1951. He placed his staff with the battalion command during the operations at Vinca and Monte Sole, and he acknowledged that the orders to his company commanders had come from him.

The trial opened before the Tribunale militare territoriale di Bologna on September 18, 1951. On October 31, 1951, the tribunal found Reder guilty and sentenced him to life imprisonment, in Italian "ergastolo." The judgment held him jointly responsible for the massacres at Monte Sole, Vinca, Valla and Bardine di San Terenzo: command responsibility for the killing of civilians in Tuscany and around Monte Sole by the battalion that bore his name.

He appealed. In March 1954 the Tribunale supremo militare, the highest court of Italian military justice, confirmed the sentence for some of the counts, among them the Monte Sole massacre. The life term stood.

Reder served his sentence in the military prison inside the fortress of Gaeta, on the coast of Lazio between Rome and Naples. For years he shared it with Herbert Kappler, the former SS police chief in Rome who had been sentenced to life for the massacre at the Ardeatine Caves. The two men were the only German or Austrian war criminals sentenced to life in Italy who were never pardoned and who spent decades behind bars.

In Austria and West Germany, veterans' publications took up his cause, and a support group in Germany collected signatures for his release. In 1956 he recovered the Austrian citizenship he had lost in 1934, and from then on the Austrian Foreign Ministry paid for his legal defense.

His pardon became a standing item in Austria's dealings with Rome. During the parliament of 1971 to 1975, members of the Austrian National Council formally asked the foreign minister what steps could be taken to secure it. In March 1982 the Austrian government made an official request to the Italian authorities that he be allowed to return to Austria.

On April 30, 1967, Reder wrote to Marzabotto asking forgiveness for the killings. Almost all the people of Marzabotto rejected the letter.

Kappler escaped from custody in Rome in August 1977 and died in Germany the next year. That left Reder the last war criminal of the Second World War still held in an Italian prison, and the campaign for his release grew stronger.

In March 1979 the military tribunal at La Spezia rejected his application for release. At that stage he still declined to express remorse and maintained that he had only followed orders. In December 1979 the Tribunale supremo militare in Rome set aside the La Spezia decision, holding that the lower tribunal had not taken sufficient account of Reder's repentance, and the application passed to the military tribunal at Bari.

In July 1980 the Bari tribunal granted him conditional release, in Italian "libertà condizionale," on terms that kept him at Gaeta for five more years with the status of a prisoner of war. The court took into account his conduct in prison and the time he had served, and it accepted that he had repented. The term was set to end on July 15, 1985.

In December 1984 Reder wrote an open letter to Marzabotto in which he acknowledged his personal part in the killings and asked for forgiveness.

The Austrian government asked Italy to release him early on humanitarian grounds, six months before the sentence was due to end, after long negotiations in which the Catholic Church also had a part. On January 23, 1985, the Italian prime minister signed a decree of pardon. The next day, January 24, 1985, Reder left Gaeta. An Italian military aircraft flew him to Graz, where he was handed over to the Austrian military authorities under the rules for prisoners of war. Austria had undertaken that he would stay in custody until his sentence ran out in July. From July 14, 1985, he was entirely free, and he settled in Carinthia.

Within days of his return, Reder took back the remorse he had expressed in Italy. He said he owed no one any justification and that his repentance had been only a move by his lawyer. In the years that followed he attended reunions of his former comrades.

Walter Reder died in Vienna on April 26, 1991. He had never been tried again, and his conviction by the Bologna tribunal stood at his death.

The number of people Reder's battalion killed has never been fixed in a single figure. The 1,830 used in Marzabotto since 1946 counts the whole district's wartime loss of population; the 770 confirmed later by the regional committee counts the identified dead of the Monte Sole operation; the La Spezia tribunal spoke of about 800.

Accounts differ on the year of his conviction. The verdict of the Tribunale militare territoriale di Bologna was given on October 31, 1951; the appeal that made it final was decided in March 1954.

Reder's remorse was the hinge of his release. He wrote to Marzabotto asking forgiveness in 1967 and again in 1984; in 1979 he still maintained that he had only followed orders; in 1980 the Bari tribunal accepted that he had repented; and after his return to Austria in 1985 he withdrew the repentance and called it a move by his lawyer.

Timeline

February 4, 1915: Born in Freiwaldau, Austria-Hungary (now Jeseník, Czech Republic).

December 23, 1932: Joins the 37th SS Regiment in Linz.

1934: Expelled from the Austrian school system; leaves for Germany and loses Austrian citizenship.

April 1936: Commissioned SS-Untersturmführer; posted to the Totenkopf units at Dachau.

March 10, 1943: Badly wounded near Kharkov; promoted SS-Sturmbannführer.

Late spring 1944: Takes command of SS Panzer Reconnaissance Battalion 16 in Italy.

August 19, 1944: The killings at Bardine di San Terenzo and Valla, in the commune of Fivizzano.

August 24 to 27, 1944: The operation around Vinca, in the same commune, under Reder's command.

September 29 to October 5, 1944: The Monte Sole operation in the communes of Marzabotto, Grizzana Morandi and Monzuno.

1945: Taken prisoner in Austria; held at Glasenbach and Wolfsberg.

May 1948: Extradited by the British authorities to Italy.

September 18, 1951: Trial opens before the Tribunale militare territoriale di Bologna.

October 31, 1951: Sentenced to life imprisonment.

March 1954: The Tribunale supremo militare confirms the sentence for some counts, among them Monte Sole.

1956: Regains Austrian citizenship.

April 30, 1967: Writes to Marzabotto asking forgiveness; Marzabotto rejects the letter.

March 1979: The La Spezia military tribunal rejects his application for release.

December 1979: The Tribunale supremo militare sets aside the La Spezia decision and returns the case.

July 1980: The Bari military tribunal grants conditional release with five more years at Gaeta.

December 1984: Open letter to Marzabotto acknowledging his part and asking forgiveness.

March 1982: The Austrian government formally asks Italy to let him return to Austria.

January 23, 1985: Pardoned by decree of the Italian prime minister.

January 24, 1985: Released from Gaeta and flown to Graz.

July 14, 1985: His custody in Austria ends.

April 26, 1991: Dies in Vienna.