On the morning of August 7, 1998, the United States embassies in Nairobi, Kenya, and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, were attacked. In Nairobi 213 people died. In Dar es Salaam 11 died. Twelve of the 224 dead were Americans, and more than 4,000 people were injured. On that day Wadih el-Hage was in Texas, living with his wife and seven children in Arlington, Texas, and working at a tire store. He had left Kenya almost a year earlier. He was never accused of carrying out either attack and was never charged with murder.
A federal jury in Manhattan convicted him all the same. On May 29, 2001, after a trial of several months, it found him guilty of three conspiracy counts: conspiring to murder United States nationals, conspiring to murder internationally protected persons and United States officers and employees, and conspiring to destroy buildings and property of the United States. It also convicted him on 18 counts of perjury for lies he told a federal grand jury. The government's case was that el-Hage, a naturalized American born in Lebanon, had been a personal secretary to Osama bin Laden in Sudan and had later run the Nairobi cell of al Qaeda, the organization the indictment charged with planning the attacks. He was sentenced to life imprisonment in October 2001. An appeals court upheld the convictions in 2008 but sent his sentence back to be imposed again, and in 2013 a second district judge gave him the same sentence. He has been in federal custody since September 1998.
El-Hage was born in 1960 in Sidon, in southern Lebanon, and grew up in Kuwait, where his father worked for an oil company. In 1978 he moved to Lafayette, Louisiana, to study urban planning at the University of Southwestern Louisiana. His studies were broken off for long stretches. At the start of the Soviet war in Afghanistan he left Louisiana for Pakistan, and he went back there several times in the late 1980s. He returned to the university in January 1985, graduated in May 1986, and settled in Arizona. He worked a series of low-paid jobs, among them a post as a city custodian, and became a United States citizen in 1989.
Around 1990 he moved his family to Arlington, Texas. It was the first of two periods in that city. The second, after his years in Africa, was the one that ended in his arrest.
Early in 1992 el-Hage took his family to Sudan, where Osama bin Laden was then based and where he ran a network of businesses. El-Hage went to work for him as a secretary. El-Hage himself admitted that he had been bin Laden's personal secretary. What he denied was that the work had anything to do with violence: he said he had worked only in bin Laden's legitimate businesses.
The government saw those years very differently, and the jury accepted its view. In the record on which the convictions were upheld, el-Hage took part in private meetings with bin Laden, acted as the paymaster for bin Laden's enterprises, and obtained false travel documents for members of the organization. A former member of the organization who became a government witness identified el-Hage as a key associate of bin Laden in Sudan.
El-Hage later said that he had had no contact with bin Laden after 1994.
In 1994 el-Hage moved to Kenya. There he became the director of a Muslim charity, which Kenyan documents described as working on malaria control, and he also traded in gems.
The Second Circuit's account of this period is the government's case as the jury accepted it. From the time of bin Laden's 1996 declaration of holy war against the United States until the embassy attacks, el-Hage headed the al Qaeda cell in Nairobi and carried financial and personnel responsibilities for bin Laden's enterprises. Telephone calls that American intelligence intercepted showed him discussing false travel documents and money matters in code, and passing messages between members of the organization. A man later charged in the same indictment as one of the planners of the attacks lived in el-Hage's Nairobi residence and worked as his secretary.
In May 1996 a senior military figure in the organization drowned in Lake Victoria. El-Hage traveled there afterward. A witness at the trial testified that he had seen el-Hage at the lake looking into that man's death. This episode later became the center of the perjury case against him.
In February 1997, the appeals court found, el-Hage traveled to Afghanistan, met bin Laden and his military commander, and came back to Nairobi with a message that the cell should prepare for military activity. Around April 1997 the Attorney General of the United States authorized the collection of intelligence aimed at him.
In August 1997, while el-Hage was away in Afghanistan, Kenyan police and FBI agents searched his Nairobi residence. When el-Hage returned to Nairobi he was questioned and told to leave the country. In September 1997 the family sold what they owned and flew back to the United States.
That same month a federal grand jury in New York, which was investigating al Qaeda, subpoenaed him. He testified under oath and, the jury later found, lied. He then went back to Arlington. He found work at a tire store and lived with his family near the University of Texas at Arlington.
Less than a year later the embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam were attacked. FBI agents came to question el-Hage about his ties to bin Laden.
On September 15, 1998, el-Hage appeared again before the federal grand jury in New York. He admitted that he had gone to Lake Victoria to look into a drowning, but he gave the dead man another name and said he did not know it referred to the senior figure who had drowned there. He denied that he had given an identification card to Mohamed Sadeek Odeh, a man arrested in connection with the attacks. Within days he was arrested and charged with perjury. On October 7, 1998, a new indictment added a charge of conspiring to kill United States nationals. On November 4, 1998, he was named with 20 other men, bin Laden among them, in the indictment that set out the government's case on the embassy attacks and the wider conspiracy behind them. The trial judge refused him bail, and he was held in solitary confinement in New York.
The pretrial phase lasted about 27 months. One of its most contested features was the Classified Information Procedures Act, the federal law that governs the use of secret evidence in criminal trials. Under it the court required defense lawyers to hold security clearances before they could see classified material, and el-Hage was kept out of hearings at which that material was discussed. He argued that the arrangement violated his rights to counsel, to confront witnesses and to be present at his own trial.
By the start of the trial four men remained to face a jury together: el-Hage, Odeh, Mohamed Rashed Daoud al-'Owhali and Khalfan Khamis Mohamed. Al-'Owhali and Mohamed, who were charged with murder in the two attacks, faced the death penalty. El-Hage asked to be tried apart from them, arguing that a jury chosen to decide a death case would be unfair to him. The request was refused.
The trial opened in federal court in Manhattan on February 5, 2001. El-Hage's defense did not try to separate him from bin Laden. It accepted the connection and argued that he had never been part of bin Laden's criminal activity.
The government presented its evidence over nine weeks. Former members of the organization testified, two of them as cooperating witnesses, and other witnesses placed el-Hage among bin Laden's associates. Jurors heard the intercepted calls from Nairobi. The prosecution rested on April 4, 2001. Closing arguments began on May 2, and the jury deliberated for 12 days.
On May 29, 2001, the jury convicted all four defendants. It was the first conviction in an American court of men accused of taking part in bin Laden's activities.
For el-Hage the verdict covered every count he faced. He was convicted on Count 1, conspiracy to murder United States nationals; Count 2, conspiracy to murder internationally protected persons and United States officers and employees; and Count 4, conspiracy to destroy buildings and property of the United States. He was not charged in Count 3, a further conspiracy count. He was not charged with any of the murder counts for the deaths in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam, which were brought against al-'Owhali, for the 213 in Kenya, and against Mohamed, for the 11 in Tanzania. He was also convicted on Counts 285 to 302, the perjury counts arising from his grand jury testimony. He was 40.
Because he faced no capital count, the verdict left him facing a possible sentence of life imprisonment. The penalty phase that followed concerned only al-'Owhali and Mohamed, and both were later sentenced to life.
The four men were sentenced in Manhattan in October 2001. El-Hage was the last of them, on October 18. He was 41.
He spoke for about half an hour. He condemned the attacks of September 11 and the embassy attacks alike, and he said that the killing of innocent people could not be accepted by any religion or set of values. He insisted that he was innocent. He described himself as a law-abiding American and a devout Muslim who rejected violence.
The court sentenced el-Hage to life imprisonment without parole. Each defendant was ordered to pay $33 million in restitution, $7 million to the families of the victims and $26 million to the United States government.
In 2002 the government disclosed that 12 pretrial video conferences between prosecutors and one of its main cooperating witnesses had been recorded and never handed over to the defense. In October 2003 the defendants asked for a new trial, relying partly on those recordings. A different district judge, who had taken over the post-trial proceedings, held hearings and denied the motion on November 2, 2005. One remark on which el-Hage relied as evidence in his favor turned out, on examination, to have been misheard.
The Second Circuit decided the appeals of el-Hage, Odeh and al-'Owhali on November 24, 2008, in three separate opinions. It affirmed every conviction.
The court found the evidence ample. El-Hage had argued that nothing proved he knew about the conspiracies or meant to join them, and that his lies to the grand jury could not by themselves make him a member. The court held that a rational jury could infer his knowledge, his agreement and his acts in support of the conspiracies from the record: the private meetings with bin Laden, his role as paymaster, the false travel documents, his leadership of the Nairobi cell and the message he carried from Afghanistan in 1997.
It rejected his challenge to the security-clearance rules, holding that the Classified Information Procedures Act allowed the requirement and that keeping him out of the classified hearings did not deny him due process. It upheld the refusal to try him separately, observing that his co-defendants' attempts to justify the attacks might even have made el-Hage look less culpable. It found that a co-defendant's statement to the FBI, with the name of el-Hage's charity removed, did not incriminate him. It approved the admission of statements by other members of the conspiracy and of the intercepted calls. It held that the defendants had not been prejudiced by the late disclosure of the witness recordings, that the loss of some intercepted recordings showed no bad faith, and that the shackling was justified by security concerns.
In a separate opinion the court dealt with el-Hage's challenge to the 1997 search of his Nairobi residence and the surveillance of his Kenyan telephone lines. The trial court had upheld both under a foreign intelligence exception to the warrant requirement. The appeals court took a different route to the same result. It held that the Fourth Amendment's requirement of reasonableness applies to searches of American citizens abroad, but its Warrant Clause does not. The search and the surveillance, it found, were reasonable, and the evidence had been properly admitted. It also approved the trial court's private review of secret government evidence on the suppression motion, on grounds of national security. El-Hage asked for rehearing, arguing that the court had never decided whether there was probable cause for the searches. The court answered that, even if a probable cause requirement applied, it was amply met, and denied the petition.
On the sentence el-Hage won. The court upheld each step of the Guidelines calculation, rejecting his argument that the enhancements counted the same conduct twice. But his life term had been imposed when the federal Sentencing Guidelines were treated as binding, and the Supreme Court had since held in 2005 that they could only be advisory. The court therefore vacated the sentence and sent the case back to the district court solely so that he could be resentenced.
The new sentencing took place in Manhattan on April 23, 2013, before a third district judge. El-Hage told the court that his conviction was an injustice and that the jury had been biased against him.
The court imposed life imprisonment once more and ordered him to pay $33.8 million in restitution. He was 52.
El-Hage appealed again. He argued that the Guidelines were now only advisory, that he had already endured about 16 years of harsh confinement in a federal prison in Colorado, and that he was less culpable than the men who had carried out the attacks. On January 21, 2015, the Second Circuit affirmed. It held that the resentencing judge had reasonably weighed his complaints about his confinement and had been entitled not to reduce the sentence for them, and it rejected the claim of lesser culpability, relying on the findings of the original sentencing judge and of the resentencing judge.
He then asked the Supreme Court to hear his case. The petition, filed under the name Wadih El-Hage, also known as Abdus Sabbur, was denied on June 8, 2015. That ended his direct appeals.
In November 2026 the Federal Bureau of Prisons listed Wadih el-Hage, 66, as serving a life sentence in a federal prison in Colorado.
El-Hage has always denied the conspiracies. He admitted his work for bin Laden in Sudan but said it was confined to legitimate business and that he had no contact with bin Laden after 1994. At his first sentencing he called himself a law-abiding American who rejected violence, and at his second he called the conviction an injustice and the jury biased. The jury rejected his account, and every court that has reviewed the verdict has upheld it.
He was never charged with the deaths in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam, and no court has found that he took part in carrying out either attack. His liability rests on the conspiracy counts.
Much of the picture of his years in Sudan and Kenya comes from the government's evidence as the jury accepted it: the testimony of former members of the organization who had become government witnesses, the intercepted calls, and the documents. Prosecutors also made claims about his conduct in the early 1990s that were never charged and never decided by any court. The verdict settled only what the indictment charged: three conspiracies and 18 counts of perjury, Counts 285 to 302, arising from his testimony before the grand jury.
Accounts of the case differ on three details. The appeals court's account places his false statements to the grand jury in September 1997; one profile dates his grand jury testimony to September 15, 1998, followed by his arrest days later; and a government wire report on the trial says the perjury counts covered testimony in both 1997 and 1998. The same profile says he was first charged with 11 counts of perjury, while the verdict covered 18. The charity he directed in Nairobi appears as Help Africa People in that profile and as Africa Help in the appeals court's opinion.
1960: Born in Sidon, Lebanon; raised in Kuwait.
1978: Moves to Lafayette, Louisiana, to study urban planning.
May 1986: Graduates from the University of Southwestern Louisiana; settles in Arizona.
1989: Becomes a United States citizen.
Early 1992: Moves his family to Sudan and works as a secretary to Osama bin Laden.
1994: Moves to Kenya; runs a charity and trades in gems.
February 1997: Travels to Afghanistan and meets bin Laden, the appeals court later finds.
August 1997: Kenyan police and FBI agents search his Nairobi residence.
September 1997: Returns to the United States; testifies before a federal grand jury in New York.
August 7, 1998: The embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam are attacked; 224 people are killed.
September 15, 1998: Testifies again before the grand jury; arrested days later on perjury charges.
October 7, 1998: Conspiracy charge added.
November 4, 1998: Named with 20 others in the embassy indictment.
February 5, 2001: Trial opens in Manhattan.
May 29, 2001: Convicted on three conspiracy counts and 18 perjury counts.
October 18, 2001: Sentenced to life imprisonment without parole.
November 2, 2005: Motion for a new trial denied.
November 24, 2008: Second Circuit affirms the convictions and vacates the sentence for resentencing.
April 23, 2013: Resentenced to life imprisonment.
January 21, 2015: Second Circuit affirms the new sentence.
June 8, 2015: Supreme Court denies certiorari.
November 2026: Serving life in a federal prison in Colorado.