On the evening of May 6, 2002, Pim Fortuyn, the politician whose new party had upended the Dutch election campaign, was killed in Hilversum minutes after giving a radio interview. The man arrested for it within minutes was Volkert van der Graaf, a 32-year-old environmental and animal-rights activist from the small town of Harderwijk. He had no criminal record. Eleven months later the Amsterdam district court convicted him of murder, of an offense under the arms law and of threatening a man in the minutes after the killing, and sentenced him to 18 years' imprisonment. The prosecution had asked for life. It asked again on appeal, and in July 2003 the Amsterdam Court of Appeal gave the same answer: 18 years.
That number became a story of its own. Van der Graaf left custody on May 2, 2014, and spent the next six years in a run of court cases against the state and the prosecution over the terms of his release, most of which he won. On April 30, 2020, his probation ended. In the words of the Public Prosecution Service that day, no conditions applied to him any longer.
The victim was a newcomer to electoral politics. He had once been a member of the Labor Party. In 2001 he became the lead candidate of Leefbaar Nederland, a young protest party, and on February 10, 2002, its board removed him over public remarks about Islam and the constitution's article against discrimination that it considered unacceptable. He then led a party of his own, the Lijst Pim Fortuyn (LPF). In March 2002 the local party he also led, Leefbaar Rotterdam, became the largest party on the Rotterdam city council with about 35 percent of the vote.
Polls taken in the spring gave the LPF around 17 percent, and the general election was set for May 15, 2002.
The killing took place in Hilversum on Monday, May 6, nine days before the vote. The politician had just finished a radio interview in the town. He died shortly afterward. Van der Graaf was arrested in Hilversum soon after, and a threat he made against a man in the minutes between the killing and the arrest became the third count against him.
The election went ahead on May 15.
Van der Graaf was arraigned within days. He was 32. He lived in Harderwijk, a town on the edge of the Veluwe, and had been active for years in environmental causes.
For months he said nothing about why. In the first weeks after the arrest he did not cooperate with prosecutors, and his motive remained unknown while the investigation ran through the summer and fall of 2002. Before any trial could be scheduled, he was sent for a psychiatric examination that was expected to take weeks, which put the start of the case well beyond the election. In November 2002 he admitted the killing.
The trial opened at the end of March 2003 before three judges of the Amsterdam district court in a high-security courtroom. Dutch criminal cases have no jury, and the panel had to decide both the facts and the sentence. The trial was set down for four days.
The charges were premeditated murder, which carries a maximum of life imprisonment, an offense under the arms law, and threats. On the first day Van der Graaf confessed in open court. He said the plan had not become concrete until the last moment, the day before. He gave a political motive. The court was also asked to consider his mental state at the time and whether the offense could be attributed to him.
The prosecution asked for life imprisonment.
The court gave its judgment on Tuesday, April 15, 2003. It convicted Van der Graaf of murder, of the offense under the arms law and of the threat, and sentenced him to 18 years' imprisonment. In setting the term they weighed the manner of the killing, its premeditation, its effect on the democratic process, the damage to the legal order and the need for general deterrence. They did not adopt the prosecution's argument that the murder was an attack on democracy as such, and they declined to impose life, holding that a man with no record who was unlikely to kill again had to keep the prospect of rehabilitation and of returning to society.
By the date of the judgment Van der Graaf had already spent nearly a year in pretrial detention, which counted toward the sentence.
Both sides appealed. The case came before three judges of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal in the first week of July 2003, again in a high-security courthouse outside the city. The prosecution renewed its demand for life imprisonment.
On July 18, 2003, the Court of Appeal gave its judgment. It confirmed the sentence of 18 years' imprisonment for the murder. On August 2, 2003, that judgment became final, and the conviction and the term were settled.
Van der Graaf served his sentence in the Dutch prison system. As the two-thirds point approached, the question of his release moved from the courts into politics. In early October 2013 a justice advisory board recommended a controlled early release. Days later the State Secretary for Security and Justice refused it.
The State Secretary had also refused him leave from detention. On December 10, 2013, the appeals committee of the Council for the Administration of Criminal Justice and Juvenile Protection, the RSJ, overruled that refusal. It ordered that he be granted general leave, the first by February 1, 2014 and then once a month for at least 24 hours, so that he could prepare for life outside. The State Secretary complied. The first leave took place over the weekend of January 18 and 19, 2014, and three more followed in February, March and April. By late March three of them had passed without any problem, and he had kept to every instruction and arrangement.
The release itself was prepared by the prosecution's central unit for conditional release, the CVvi. It gathered advice from the director of the prison where he was held and from Reclassering Nederland, the national probation service, which assessed him with its standard risk instrument, the RISc. The prosecution's advocate-general also commissioned a multidisciplinary forensic behavioral examination from the Netherlands Institute of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology, the NIFP. A reflection group inside the prosecution service then examined the outside reports and the proposed decision, and staff of the CVvi spoke with the surviving relatives and with a victim.
The advice ran one way. The prison director saw no grounds to delay or withhold the release. The probation service put his risk of reoffending at low. The NIFP's experts reached the same conclusion, and, unlike what had emerged at the time of the criminal trial, they found no psychological disorder. Both the probation service and the NIFP recommended that strict special conditions accompany the release, because his leaves had only just begun and because no one yet knew how the public would react, where he would live or whether his return would cause trouble.
The law gave the prosecution until April 2, 2014, to ask the Amsterdam district court to delay or cancel the release. It found none of the grounds the Criminal Code allowed: no serious misconduct in prison, no evidence that conditions could not contain the risk, and no refusal on his part to accept them. He had said he was willing to comply. On March 26, 2014, the State Secretary informed parliament that he endorsed the prosecution's conclusion and that Van der Graaf would be released on May 2. The prosecution service formally took the release decision, with its conditions, on April 30.
Van der Graaf left custody on Friday, May 2, 2014, having served just under 12 years. His release was a voorwaardelijke invrijheidstelling, a conditional release. The general condition was that he commit no offense before the end of the probation period, the proeftijd, which was set at six years. The special conditions were strict. He had to report to the probation service every week. He was barred, for as long as the probation service and the CVvi thought necessary, from Rotterdam, Hilversum and The Hague and from the towns where the victim's surviving relatives and a second victim lived, and his compliance was to be watched by GPS through an electronic ankle monitor. He was forbidden any contact with the relatives and with the second victim. He was required to accept mandatory guidance from a psychologist or psychiatrist.
The media ban was written into the release decision in detail. During the probation period he was to have no contact of his own with the media, publish nothing on his own and give no interviews through any medium without the CVvi's approval; in particular, he was not to publish or be interviewed about his personal story in connection with the crimes he had committed, and every request from journalists, researchers or anyone else had to go through the probation service to the CVvi. The prosecution read the ban as aimed at statements about his offenses.
He went to court almost at once. In summary proceedings, a kort geding, brought against the state and heard on July 14, 2014, a judge in The Hague ruled on July 30 that the ankle monitor and the area bans had to go: they restricted his freedom of movement considerably and did not serve their purpose of protecting society. The prosecution appealed. On October 14, 2014, the Court of Appeal in The Hague confirmed that the conditional-release regime in force since July 1, 2008, applied to him and declined to reinstate either the area bans or the electronic monitoring, finding no need for them now that the period since the end of July had passed without problems. Every other condition stayed in force, including the ban on contact with the victim's family and the media ban, and the conditions were to be reviewed every three months.
In September 2015 a television broadcast showed recordings of Van der Graaf, made without his knowledge, in which he talked about his release and its conditions. At the prosecution's request the probation service reported again on how he had kept to every condition over the whole period since his release. In February 2016 the justice ministry told parliament the result: he had breached none of them. He had met his reporting duty and kept to the contact ban and the media ban, and he had observed the area ban for as long as it applied. The guidance by a psychiatrist had by then ended. The prosecution decided to follow it with mandatory guidance by a psychologist and ordered a new risk assessment.
The psychiatric condition came next. In February 2016 a court found that he did not require psychiatric care, and the prosecution appealed. At a hearing in May 2016 the court suggested mediation. On September 20, 2016, the court in The Hague ruled against the prosecution: he had no psychiatric problems needing treatment, and his own psychiatrist had concluded that further treatment made no sense. The weekly reporting duty, the contact ban and the media ban remained.
On January 23, 2017, the prosecution asked the Amsterdam court, which had imposed the sentence at first instance, to revoke his release in part, for one year. Just over three years of the probation period remained, and the request was framed so that the probation service could go on supervising him once the year was over. The prosecution argued that he had breached the reporting duty and the duty to cooperate with supervision that came with it. In the earlier civil proceedings both the district court and the court of appeal had held that he had to cooperate actively with the reporting duty and with supervision, including by answering the probation service's questions. On February 6, 2017, the Amsterdam court refused the request, holding that he had met his reporting obligation. There was no appeal from that ruling.
In May 2018 he brought a second kort geding against the state, this time to be relieved of the duty to report to the probation service every six weeks, which he said made it impossible to emigrate. The prosecution opposed it, wanting to keep watch on his progress. On May 29, 2018, the district court in The Hague ruled in his favor. The NIFP had found no sign of a psychological disorder and judged the risk of repetition very small, and neither the NIFP nor the probation service considered the reporting duty necessary. The court held that the seriousness of the offense no longer played a role in that question; what mattered was whether the condition still reduced the risk of reoffending. The ban on contact with the media and with the victim's surviving relatives, and the general condition that he commit no offense, continued until the end of the probation period.
The state appealed, and the case came before the Court of Appeal in The Hague on September 10, 2018. At the court's suggestion the prosecution and Van der Graaf talked, and they reached an arrangement that let him move abroad. The reporting duty was restored with immediate effect, in a new form: a written report every eight weeks, and an evaluation meeting with the prosecution every six months. The probation service would supervise him on that basis. The media ban and the ban on contact with the victims and the relatives stayed in force.
Van der Graaf's sentence was never a question of whether he would be released before its end, but when and on what terms. Dutch prisoners serving a fixed term are normally released after two thirds of it, and a prisoner who has served that period without incident is entitled to leave; that is why it was already clear in April 2003 that he could be free in about 11 years. Under the law in force since July 1, 2008, which the Court of Appeal in The Hague held applied to him, the release could be delayed or withheld only on grounds listed in the Criminal Code, and only a court could do so, on a request from the prosecution. The release itself was decided by the Public Prosecution Service, which also set and enforced the special conditions; the courts, in summary proceedings against the state and in the prosecution's revocation case, then tested each condition against its purpose. The probation period was tied to the length of the sentence, six years in his case, and with credit for the time he had spent in pretrial detention it was due to end in April 2020.
The probation period ended on April 30, 2020. On that day the Public Prosecution Service announced that Van der Graaf had served his sentence in full, that he was no longer under the supervision of the prosecution or the probation service, and that no conditions applied to him any longer. Eighteen years after the killing in Hilversum, the sentence that two courts had set and declined to raise was complete.
The motive Van der Graaf gave in court, a political one, was his own account, and neither court adopted a different one. The courts' findings rest on his confession in open court, the circumstances of his arrest and the evidence gathered in the investigation. No court found that anyone else took part in the killing, and no one else was charged with it.
February 10, 2002: Leefbaar Nederland removes its lead candidate, the later victim; he goes on to lead the LPF.
March 2002: Leefbaar Rotterdam becomes the largest party on the Rotterdam city council.
May 6, 2002: Killing in Hilversum; Van der Graaf arrested shortly afterward.
May 15, 2002: General election; the LPF wins 26 seats.
November 2002: Van der Graaf admits the killing.
Late March 2003: Trial opens before the Amsterdam district court; he confesses in court.
April 15, 2003: Convicted of murder, an arms-law offense and a threat; sentenced to 18 years' imprisonment.
July 2003: Appeal hearing before the Amsterdam Court of Appeal; the prosecution again seeks life.
July 18, 2003: Court of Appeal confirms 18 years' imprisonment.
August 2, 2003: The judgment becomes final.
October 2013: State Secretary refuses an early release.
December 10, 2013: RSJ appeals committee orders monthly general leave.
January 18 and 19, 2014: First leave from detention; three more follow by April.
March 26, 2014: The prosecution's conclusion that no grounds exist to delay the release is reported to parliament.
April 30, 2014: Prosecution's release decision with general and special conditions.
May 2, 2014: Conditional release begins; six-year probation period.
July 30, 2014: Hague court lifts the ankle monitor and area bans.
October 14, 2014: Hague Court of Appeal declines to restore them and confirms the 2008 regime applies.
February 2016: Prosecution finds no breach of any condition; a Hague court finds no psychiatric care is required.
September 20, 2016: Hague court confirms no psychiatric treatment is required.
January 23, 2017: Prosecution asks the Amsterdam court to revoke the release for one year.
February 6, 2017: Amsterdam court refuses to revoke his release.
May 29, 2018: Hague district court lifts the duty to report to the probation service.
September 10, 2018: Appeal hearing in The Hague; the parties agree on written reporting.
October 2018: Reporting duty restored as a written report every eight weeks; he may move abroad.
April 30, 2020: Probation period ends; sentence served in full.