Vincent Coll was 23 years old when he died in Manhattan in February 1932, and for the last seven months of his life the police, his former employer and a rival organization were all looking for him. On July 28, 1931, a five-year-old boy died in East Harlem and other children were hurt in an attack that the police blamed on Coll and the men around him. The city put more officers on the streets, rewards were offered, and after about three months in hiding he was taken in the Bronx. A Manhattan grand jury indicted him for murder. In December 1931 he stood trial, the prosecution's case fell apart when its principal witness was exposed on the stand, and he was acquitted. Less than two months later he was dead, killed in Manhattan by men who were never arrested.
He was never convicted of any killing. Earlier, at 19, he had been charged with two murders, and those charges came to nothing. In the years since, he has been blamed for a string of killings of rival gang members during his feud with the bootlegger Dutch Schultz, but none of those deaths was ever brought to court in his name. What the legal record holds is narrow: two charges that went nowhere, one indictment, one acquittal.
Coll was born on July 20, 1908, in Gweedore, an Irish-speaking parish in County Donegal. His name in Irish was Uinseann Ó Colla, and he was born above a pub. Emigration was the county's largest industry in those years, and his parents left for America in 1909, when he was about a year old. The family settled in the Bronx.
The childhood that followed was spent in deep poverty. By the time Coll was 12, five of his siblings had died. His father left and never again contacted the children who survived, and his mother died in 1916. An older sister looked after him for a time.
He was a difficult child and did not stay long in any classroom. He was expelled from several Catholic schools in the Bronx and was sent, more than once, to Catholic reform schools that functioned as juvenile correction institutions. He was expelled from those as well. Before he reached his teens he had left formal schooling behind and joined the Gophers, a street gang led by Owney Madden, who years later would be one of Coll's most dangerous enemies.
The police knew him early. He was first arrested at 16, and by his early twenties he had been arrested at least a dozen times.
Prohibition made fortunes for the men who controlled the city's liquor, and one of the richest was Dutch Schultz, who ran speakeasies across New York City. Schultz took on the teenage Coll as an enforcer, and over the following years Coll became one of his trusted men.
In 1927, when he was 19, Coll was charged with murder in the deaths of Anthony Borrello and Mary Smith. Accounts differ on how the case ended, one saying the charges were dropped before trial and another that a jury acquitted him, but no court ever held Coll responsible for either death.
Coll's standing inside the organization did not last. In 1929 he robbed a Bronx dairy company without Schultz's permission. At about the same time he asked to be made an equal partner in Schultz's business, and he was refused. He left, and with his older brother, Peter, he formed his own gang.
The breach became open hostility in early 1931. Coll was arrested in January of that year on another charge, and Schultz posted a bond of $10,000 to get him out. Coll did not appear for his trial, the bond was forfeited, and he refused to repay the money. Between the two men and their followers, the dispute turned into a war.
Peter Coll was killed in Harlem in the course of that conflict. Later reporting attributed to Vincent Coll a campaign of reprisal against Schultz's men that cost as many as twenty of them their lives. No court ever tested that claim, and none of those deaths produced a charge against him.
According to later accounts, Coll also turned to kidnapping other underworld figures for ransom, a line of business that brought in money and multiplied his enemies. One of those he seized was a member of Owney Madden's West Side organization. Madden paid the ransom, and he and Schultz then put a bounty of $50,000 on Coll.
On Tuesday, July 28, 1931, men attacked a social club in East Harlem that was known as the gathering place of Joey Rao, one of Schultz's men. Rao was not hurt. A five-year-old boy died, and four other children were hurt and survived.
The police said that Coll and his men carried out the attack and that the target was Rao. Accounts have never agreed on what the men meant to do: some say they meant to kill Rao, others that they meant to kidnap him. Coll was 22 years old.
The death of a child in a dispute between bootleggers caused an outcry. More officers were put on patrol across the city. The police department offered a reward of $10,000 for information leading to an arrest, and newspapers added rewards of their own. Most of the people who had been outside the club could not describe the attackers. One witness came forward and named Coll.
Coll went into hiding. He dyed his fair hair dark, grew a mustache and wore glasses, and he stayed out of reach for about three months before the police found him in the Bronx in the autumn of 1931. Several men connected to him were held with him and put in a lineup at Police Headquarters in Manhattan.
He denied any part in the attack. He told the police that on July 28 he had been in Albany. A Manhattan grand jury heard the evidence and indicted him for the murder of the five-year-old boy.
The trial opened in Manhattan in December 1931. The prosecution rested its case on one eyewitness, the man who had told the police that he saw Coll among the attackers. On the stand he identified Coll as one of the men responsible. Under cross-examination the defense set out to show that the witness was not the chance bystander he presented himself as. The questioning established that he had testified at other trials before and that he made a quiet living as a witness for hire. His story did not survive the exposure; he went to pieces on the stand, and with him went the prosecution's case.
Coll was acquitted in the last days of December 1931. The witness had been the prosecution's only one, and Coll walked out of court a free man. For the rest of his short life he maintained that he was innocent of the boy's death. Soon after the trial he married, and the couple lived in Manhattan.
The acquittal settled nothing outside the courtroom. The $50,000 bounty that Schultz and Madden had put on him still stood. In February 1932 Coll was expecting to speak with Madden by telephone about what was supposed to be a truce.
Coll was killed in Manhattan on February 8, 1932. He was 23. Later accounts say Schultz and Madden arranged the truce talk so that he could be found. Neither man was charged, and no one was ever arrested for Coll's death.
Accounts differ on whether the 1927 murder charges were dropped before trial or ended in a jury's acquittal; either way he was never held responsible for either death.
The East Harlem attack was never proved against anyone in court. The single eyewitness who named Coll was discredited at trial, and the acquittal is the final legal word on Coll's part in the boy's death. The purpose of the men in the car, whether to kill Joey Rao or to kidnap him, has never been settled.
The claim that Coll killed as many as twenty of Schultz's men after his brother's death has never been tested in court, and no charge was ever brought against him for any of those deaths.
The killing of Coll himself remains unsolved in law. The roles later assigned to Schultz and Madden are attributions, and neither man was charged with his death.
July 20, 1908: Coll is born in Gweedore, County Donegal, Ireland.
1909: His parents emigrate with him to New York and settle in the Bronx.
1916: His mother dies.
1927: Charged at 19 with the murders of Anthony Borrello and Mary Smith; accounts differ on whether the charges were dropped or he was acquitted.
1929: Robs a Bronx dairy company without Schultz's permission and is refused a partnership; forms his own gang with his brother.
January 1931: Arrested; Schultz posts a $10,000 bond; Coll fails to appear and the bond is forfeited.
1931: His brother Peter is killed in Harlem.
July 28, 1931: A five-year-old boy dies and four other children are hurt in East Harlem; the police blame Coll.
Autumn 1931: Coll is arrested in the Bronx after about three months in hiding; a Manhattan grand jury indicts him for murder.
December 1931: Trial in Manhattan; the prosecution's eyewitness is discredited and Coll is acquitted.
Late December 1931: Coll marries.
February 8, 1932: Coll is killed in Manhattan at 23; no one is arrested.