Vince Muscat was the first person convicted over the killing of Daphne Caruana Galizia, the investigative journalist whose death on October 16, 2017, in the village of Bidnija led to international calls for accountability. He was arrested less than seven weeks later with the brothers Alfred and George Degiorgio, and for more than three years he denied everything. Then, on February 23, 2021, at a hearing in Valletta, he changed his plea. Muscat admitted every charge against him, and the court sentenced him to 15 years in prison.
The plea was only the start of his part in the case. In exchange for a reduced term, and for a separate presidential pardon covering another killing, Muscat became a witness for the state. Over the next five years he testified against the Degiorgio brothers, against two men accused of supplying the means used in the murder, and finally in the trial of a businessman charged with complicity. Two of those prosecutions ended in convictions and long sentences. The last ended in September 2026 with the businessman's acquittal.
Muscat was born in 1963. He was not a stranger to the courts. All three men charged in December 2017 had criminal records, and when Muscat was sentenced in 2021 the judge found him to be a recidivist.
Most of what became known about him came from his own statements to the police and from the testimony he gave under oath after he changed sides. In that testimony he described himself as a man who did not like to ask questions. He said he had been recruited for the 2017 murder by Alfred Degiorgio, who told him the three men would be paid 150,000 euros.
She was a columnist and editor and one of the most outspoken voices in Maltese public life. In 2008 she set up a blog, Running Commentary, on which she wrote about corruption in government, about questionable business deals and about the links between politics, big business and organized crime. In her last years she was working on stories that built on the Panama Papers.
Her work set her against powerful people. When she died she was facing more than 40 libel suits, 36 of them filed in the nine months before her death. Her final blog post ended with a line that was quoted around the world: "There are crooks everywhere you look now."
She was killed in Bidnija, the small village in northern Malta where she lived. The government offered a reward of one million euros for information and asked the Federal Bureau of Investigation and Europol to help the Maltese police.
On Monday, December 4, 2017, the police arrested ten men in a series of raids. Muscat and the Degiorgio brothers were taken together in Marsa. Seven of the ten were released on police bail. The next day Muscat, Alfred Degiorgio and George Degiorgio were brought before a magistrate and charged with murder, and all three pleaded not guilty. At that stage it was not clear whether the police believed the three had acted on their own account or had been hired.
Years later Muscat gave his own account of those weeks. He testified that the men had known about the coming raid for two or three weeks before it happened. In that time, he said, he had seen the Degiorgio brothers whispering together and falling silent when he came near, and he had begun to worry that one of them had made a mistake. Once they knew a raid was coming, Muscat said, the men began clearing away anything that might be used as evidence. He said he had expected to be questioned and released, not charged. "If I knew, I wouldn't have gone there," he told a jury in 2026.
After their arraignment the three men were held together in prison, and their requests for bail were refused again and again.
The case moved slowly. In November 2019 the investigation changed course. A self-confessed middleman in the plot received a presidential pardon in exchange for his testimony, and the police arrested a prominent businessman, who was later charged with complicity in the murder. He denied any involvement.
Muscat, meanwhile, had begun trying to bargain. For about three years he sought a pardon or a reduced sentence, offering information about the 2017 murder and other crimes. He argued that what he had already told investigators had led to the arrest and charging of the middleman. In January 2021 the Cabinet turned down his request for a pardon over the 2017 murder. On February 17, 2021, he unexpectedly withdrew his appeal against a ruling that had rejected the defense's legal objections to the case.
Six days later, on February 23, 2021, the three men were back in court in Valletta. Muscat's lawyer told the court that his client wished to change his plea, and Muscat confirmed that he admitted all the charges, among them murder, criminal conspiracy and further offenses connected with the killing.
The court accepted a plea bargain put forward jointly by the defense and the prosecution and sentenced Muscat to 15 years in prison, to begin at once, with about 42,930 euros in court costs. The term reflected his cooperation with the police, and under the arrangement it depended on the truthfulness of the evidence he would give in the trials still to come. The Degiorgio brothers kept their pleas of not guilty, and their case went on.
The same day brought two further developments. The police arrested three men suspected of supplying the means used in the killing: the brothers Adrian and Robert Agius and their associate Jamie Vella, all of whom had been arrested and released without charge in 2017. And the government announced that the Cabinet, on the advice of the Commissioner of Police and the Attorney General, had agreed to grant Muscat a presidential pardon for his part in a different killing: the death of Carmel Chircop in Birkirkara in October 2015.
The 2015 killing had gone unsolved for more than five years. According to the prime minister's announcement, Muscat had admitted his guilt in it and would name the person who had ordered it. The pardon covered only his involvement in that one killing and was given in return for everything he knew about it. Muscat has never been charged with or convicted over that death, and his account of it has never been tested against him in any court.
He testified about it in March 2021. By his account, George Degiorgio had first told him of the plan in the autumn of 2015, he had taken part in the plot along with Jamie Vella, and he had been paid 20,000 euros. He said he knew little about the motive.
On February 25, 2021, the three men arrested two days earlier were charged. Robert Agius and Jamie Vella were accused of complicity in the 2017 murder. Jamie Vella and George Degiorgio were charged with the 2015 killing, and Adrian Agius with ordering it.
Muscat made his first public statement after his plea in March 2021, when he took the stand at the compilation of evidence against the Degiorgio brothers. With the victim's family in the courtroom, he apologized to them. He set out how the plot had been put together, how the men had been recruited and how the work had been shared out, and he described his own part in it.
Later that month he asked for a second pardon, offering information about other crimes. On April 19, 2021, the Cabinet, again on the advice of the Attorney General and the Commissioner of Police, rejected his new request along with pardon requests from the Degiorgio brothers.
The trial of Alfred and George Degiorgio opened in Valletta on Friday, October 14, 2022. At the start of the day both brothers pleaded not guilty. Within hours they reversed themselves and admitted every charge: wilful homicide, criminal conspiracy, promoting, organizing or financing an organization to commit criminal offenses, active participation in a conspiracy and two further offenses. They confirmed their pleas, and each was sentenced to 40 years in prison and ordered to pay 50,000 euros out of the money received for the crime, along with court costs.
Muscat was not part of that trial. He was the third man in the killing, the one who had avoided trial by changing his plea and who was already serving his sentence as a state witness.
In 2025 Muscat testified again, this time before a jury in the trial of Robert Agius and Jamie Vella over the 2017 murder and of the men accused in the 2015 killing. He gave evidence under the terms of his pardon, on condition that he tell the whole truth.
In June 2025 the jury found Robert Agius and Jamie Vella guilty of complicity in the 2017 murder, and on June 10 the court sentenced both to life imprisonment, the maximum penalty Maltese law allows. In the 2015 case, George Degiorgio and Adrian Agius were also convicted and sentenced to life.
Robert Agius and Jamie Vella appealed, attacking among other things the credibility of the key state witness. On January 21, 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed their appeal and confirmed their convictions and life sentences.
The final prosecution was that of the businessman. By the summer of 2026 he was on trial before a jury in Valletta, charged with complicity in the wilful homicide and with criminal association. He denied both charges.
Muscat, still serving his sentence, took the stand for the prosecution on July 13, 2026. He told the jury about the warning that had come before the Marsa raid, about the anxious meetings of the weeks before it, and about the months that followed in prison, where, he said, the Degiorgio brothers had telephoned the middleman.
On September 2, 2026, the jury found the businessman not guilty on both counts, by a vote of eight to one. He was the last of about six people charged in the plot to come to trial.
Muscat's plea settled his own guilt in the 2017 murder, but much of what he said about others has never been tested to a verdict. Several of his claims about other people led to no charges.
No one has been convicted of ordering the killing. The businessman charged with complicity was acquitted by a jury in September 2026, and the pardoned middleman was never tried.
The 2015 killing stands apart. Muscat admitted his part in it and testified about it under the protection of a pardon, but no court has convicted him of it.
Muscat was serving his 15-year sentence in Malta as of July 2026, when he testified at the last trial in the case.
1963: Vince Muscat is born.
October 2015: A man is killed in Birkirkara; Muscat later admits a part in the killing under a pardon and is never charged.
October 16, 2017: The victim is killed in Bidnija.
December 4, 2017: Muscat and the Degiorgio brothers are among ten men arrested; the three are taken together in Marsa.
December 5, 2017: The three are charged with murder before a magistrate and plead not guilty.
November 2019: The middleman receives a presidential pardon; a businessman is arrested and later charged with complicity.
January 2021: The Cabinet refuses Muscat a pardon over the 2017 murder.
February 17, 2021: Muscat withdraws his appeal on the defense's legal objections.
February 23, 2021: Muscat pleads guilty to all charges and is sentenced to 15 years; the Cabinet grants him a pardon over the 2015 killing.
February 25, 2021: Robert and Adrian Agius and Jamie Vella are charged.
March 2021: Muscat testifies against the Degiorgio brothers and asks for a second pardon.
April 19, 2021: The Cabinet rejects the second pardon request.
October 14, 2022: The Degiorgio brothers plead guilty and are sentenced to 40 years each.
June 10, 2025: Robert Agius and Jamie Vella, convicted of complicity in the 2017 murder, are sentenced to life imprisonment.
January 21, 2026: The Court of Appeal upholds their convictions.
July 13, 2026: Muscat testifies at the businessman's trial.
September 2, 2026: The jury acquits the businessman on both counts.