Veselin Šljivančanin and Mile Mrkšić

Victims
194 prisoners murdered at Ovčara, Croatia, 1991. Mrkšić convicted of aiding and abetting the murders, torture and cruel treatment; Šljivančanin of aiding and abetting torture only
Years active
November 20 to 21, 1991
Location
Vukovar and Ovčara, Croatia; The Hague, Netherlands; Belgrade, Serbia; Portugal
Method
Murder, torture and cruel treatment of prisoners of war, aided and abetted; carried out by Serb Territorial Defense and paramilitary forces
Status
Mrkšić: 20 years (2007, upheld 2009); died in custody in Portugal, 2015. Šljivančanin: 5 years (2007), 17 years (2009), 10 years on review (2010); early release July 2011

On November 20, 1991, two days after the Croatian town of Vukovar fell to the Yugoslav People's Army, more than 200 men were taken from the town's hospital under armed guard. They were Croats and other non-Serbs, nearly all of them members of the Croat forces that had defended the town or believed to be. By the following morning at least 194 of them were dead, murdered at Ovčara, near Vukovar, by local Serb Territorial Defense units and Serb paramilitaries. The army officers who had held the prisoners in their custody all that day were not the men who committed the killings. The question that took the United Nations war crimes tribunal in The Hague more than fifteen years to answer was what those officers owed the prisoners, and what they had done with that duty.

Two of them were convicted. Mile Mrkšić, the colonel who commanded the army's elite Guards Motorised Brigade and every Serb force in the area, was found guilty in September 2007 of aiding and abetting the murder of 194 identified people, and of aiding and abetting their torture and cruel treatment. He was sentenced to 20 years. Veselin Šljivančanin, the major who served as the brigade's security officer and ran the evacuation of the hospital, was found guilty of aiding and abetting torture and given five years. A third officer tried with them, a captain who commanded an infantry company, was acquitted on every count. What followed for Šljivančanin was one of the most unusual sentencing histories the tribunal produced: an appeal that added a murder conviction and raised his term to 17 years, then the tribunal's first review judgment, which removed that conviction and set the sentence at 10. He was released in 2011. Mrkšić died in Portugal in 2015 while serving his sentence.

Two officers of the Guards Brigade

Mile Mrkšić was born on July 20, 1947, in Kozarac, near Vrginmost, in Croatia. He made his career in the Yugoslav People's Army, known by its initials as the JNA, and by 1991 he was a colonel commanding the Guards Motorised Brigade, the unit that carried the main burden of the assault on Vukovar. In the final phase of the battle he also commanded Operational Group South, which gave him authority over all Serb forces in the area where the crimes took place: JNA troops, local Territorial Defense units and volunteer and paramilitary formations.

After the fall of Vukovar he was promoted to general. He later commanded the 8th JNA Operational Group in the Kordun area of Croatia, and in May 1995 he became commander of the army of the self-declared Republic of Serbian Krajina. He retired in August 1995, after that army's defeat.

Veselin Šljivančanin was born on June 13, 1953, in the municipality of Žabljak, in Montenegro. In November 1991 he was a major and the head of the security organ of both the Guards Motorised Brigade and Operational Group South, with command of a military police battalion attached to the brigade. After Vukovar he was promoted to lieutenant colonel and placed in command of a Yugoslav Army brigade in Podgorica, Montenegro, and he later rose to colonel before resigning from the army.

The third man named in the indictment with them was a JNA captain who commanded an infantry company in the brigade's first battalion. The trial chamber later found no evidence that he had been at Ovčara and acquitted him of all charges.

The siege of Vukovar

The JNA laid siege to Vukovar in late August 1991, in the war that followed Croatia's declaration of independence. The siege lasted about three months. JNA shelling largely destroyed the city, and hundreds of people were killed in it. The case at The Hague did not cover the siege itself, the civilian deaths it caused or the destruction of the town; the trial chamber's findings concerned only what happened to the people taken from the hospital on November 20.

The Croatian forces in the Vukovar area capitulated on November 18, 1991. That day Croatian fighters from the Mitnica district surrendered to Operational Group South under an agreement monitored by the International Committee of the Red Cross, and on Mrkšić's orders they were sent on to a prisoner-of-war facility at Sremska Mitrovica, in Serbia. That evacuation passed without incident, and the court later treated it as the model Mrkšić had meant to follow with the men from the hospital.

The same day, in Zagreb, the Croatian government and JNA representatives agreed on the evacuation of Vukovar hospital. Patients fit to travel were to be taken to Croatia, the hospital was to be placed under the protection of the Red Cross, and the European Community Monitoring Mission was to have full access to every stage of the evacuation. The hospital, badly damaged in the fighting, was full beyond capacity. Civilians had gathered there in the hope of leaving with the convoy, alongside patients and staff. The trial chamber also found, against the evidence of some Croat witnesses, that members of the Croat forces were inside, presenting themselves as patients or staff.

November 19

Operational Group South entered the hospital on November 19, and that afternoon the JNA moved most of the civilians who had gathered there to Velepromet, a large warehouse complex nearby. The international monitors were kept out: the JNA prevented the European monitors from reaching the hospital on November 18 and 19, and a Red Cross representative was allowed only limited access on the 19th. In Mrkšić's presence, the international representatives were told that members of the Croat forces, whether patients or not, would not leave in the evacuation but would be held as prisoners of war and later exchanged. The agreement signed the day before was being ignored.

That day Mrkšić ordered the evacuation of the hospital for the following morning and put Šljivančanin in charge of it. The people in the hospital were to be divided into two groups. Those the order called war crimes suspects, meaning members of the Croat forces, were to be taken under JNA guard to Sremska Mitrovica; civilians were to be taken to Croatia or Serbia as they chose. Šljivančanin was made responsible for the security of the prisoners of war until they reached Sremska Mitrovica.

The same day, Territorial Defense and paramilitary forces killed and mistreated Croat prisoners of war held at Velepromet. Mrkšić was told of those killings. So was Šljivančanin, and the trial chamber later found that he also knew of similar incidents around Vukovar in October and November 1991. During the night, officers of the JNA security administration warned Mrkšić's command that the local forces would not let the JNA take the prisoners away to Serbia.

November 20: the hospital

Early on November 20, while Šljivančanin held a meeting with the hospital staff, JNA soldiers went through the building and told everyone who could walk to leave. At the exit the soldiers separated the men from the women, the children and the elderly. More than 200 men, and two women, were put onto buses under armed guard. All of them were Croat or non-Serb, and all were, or were believed to have been, involved with the Croat forces. The women, children and a few elderly men were evacuated separately to Serbia or Croatia, and the court accepted that on Šljivančanin's own decision some spouses and relatives of hospital staff were allowed to join the civilians evacuated to safety.

The international monitors tried to reach the hospital that morning and were stopped on the way. Šljivančanin told them they could not go on for safety reasons, an explanation the trial chamber found false. When the monitors finally reached the hospital, the men were gone.

The prisoners were held first at the JNA barracks in Vukovar, where local Territorial Defense men and paramilitaries threatened and abused them until JNA military police cleared them from the compound. A dozen or so identified men were taken back to the hospital, where Šljivančanin, together with local Territorial Defense leaders, questioned them about their role in the fighting. Some were returned to the barracks; others were allowed to leave with the convoy of women and children.

November 20: the local government and the change of orders

While the prisoners were held at the barracks, the self-described government of Slavonia, Baranja and Western Srem, set up by local Serbs, met at Velepromet, with officers of Operational Group South present. The meeting strongly opposed letting the JNA take the prisoners to Serbia. Operational Group South's chief of staff passed on a message from Mrkšić that he was prepared to act on whatever the meeting decided. No final decision was taken in the room, but late that day the local government announced that the prisoners would be held in detention camps around Vukovar.

The trial chamber found that Mrkšić had meant at first to send the men to Sremska Mitrovica, to be exchanged later for Serb prisoners held by Croatia, as had happened with the prisoners from Mitnica. That was the order he gave Šljivančanin. During the morning of November 20 he changed his mind, and then his orders. After the meeting the prisoners were taken not to Serbia but to Ovčara.

November 20: Ovčara

At Ovčara the prisoners were subjected to severe physical abuse from the moment they arrived, and they were held there under inhumane conditions until late in the evening. Most of them suffered repeated abuse, and several who were thought to have been prominent in the Croat forces were singled out. Those responsible were Serb Territorial Defense soldiers and paramilitaries.

JNA soldiers, most of them military police of the 80th Motorised Brigade, a unit placed under Operational Group South, were there to guard the prisoners, but their protection was inconsistent and inadequate. At some times the Territorial Defense men and paramilitaries were kept outside; at others, above all when the prisoners first arrived, they had free access to them. Several senior JNA officers came to Ovčara that afternoon, saw what was happening and tried to make the military police more effective. Their efforts worked briefly or not at all.

Šljivančanin was one of the officers who came. He denied it, but the trial chamber found that he was at Ovčara for a time while the mistreatment was going on and saw for himself the conduct of the Territorial Defense and paramilitary forces. He did not seek or order more troops. He gave the military police no orders to strengthen the protection. He did nothing to stop the abuse or to keep it from continuing.

Mrkšić also took no step that afternoon to reinforce the guards at Ovčara or to improve the security of the prisoners, although officers had reported to him what was taking place at the barracks and at Ovčara. That evening the order came from his command for the JNA military police guarding the prisoners to withdraw. The military police withdrew, and the prisoners passed into the unrestricted custody of the Vukovar Territorial Defense. The court found that it was at the moment of this order that Mrkšić finally decided to leave the men in the hands of the local forces.

That night Territorial Defense and paramilitary forces took the prisoners away in small groups and killed them.

The dead

The indictment named 264 people alleged to have been taken from the hospital and murdered near Ovčara on the night of November 20 to 21. The trial chamber found that 200 people died there on those dates, and that 190 of them had been identified and were among those named in the indictment. The evidence also established that four more identified prisoners held at Ovčara that day had suffered severe abuse and were dead, though it could not be determined whether they were among the ten who remained unidentified. On that basis the court held it established that 194 of the people named in the indictment were murdered at Ovčara by Serb forces on November 20 and 21, 1991. The chamber added that its findings did not rule out that more people died there; the evidence simply did not allow the larger number to be proved.

Nearly all the dead were men, and almost all of them had been fighters in the defense of Vukovar or were believed to have been. They had been chosen because of that known or suspected role, and the men who killed them treated them as prisoners of war. Among them were two women, Ružica Markobašić and Janja Podhorski, and two boys. Of the 194, the chamber found, 181 were known to have been active in the Croat forces in Vukovar, in the National Guard, the Croatian army, the police or smaller local units; for 13 the evidence established no military involvement at all. The chamber accepted that a small number of civilians may have been among the murdered, but it found that the men who killed them acted in the understanding that they were killing members of the Croat forces.

Indictment and the years of refusal

The tribunal confirmed its first indictment against Mrkšić, Šljivančanin and the captain on November 7, 1995, over the removal and murder of the men from the hospital. None of them was handed over. The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, made up of Serbia and Montenegro, would not arrest them. In April 1996, after a public hearing held because the court could not obtain custody of the accused, the tribunal issued international arrest warrants for the three officers and reported Yugoslavia's refusal to cooperate to the UN Security Council.

Years passed. Mrkšić surrendered and was transferred to The Hague on May 15, 2002, and pleaded not guilty to all charges. Šljivančanin did not surrender. Serbian authorities arrested him in Belgrade on June 13, 2003, and he was transferred to The Hague on July 1; he too pleaded not guilty.

In its final form the indictment alleged that the three men had taken part in a joint criminal enterprise to persecute the Croats and other non-Serbs found at the hospital after the fall of the city. It charged them with persecutions, extermination, murder, torture and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity, and with murder, torture and cruel treatment as violations of the laws or customs of war, both on the basis of their own conduct and as superiors.

The trial

The trial of the three officers opened on October 11, 2005, before Trial Chamber II. Among the witnesses were people who had worked at the hospital in November 1991, JNA officers who had served in Operational Group South and representatives of the international organizations that had been kept away from the evacuation.

The defense contested nearly everything. Mrkšić's case was that the killings happened while he was away in Belgrade. Šljivančanin denied having been at Ovčara while the prisoners were being mistreated. In his closing statement Mrkšić told the chamber that he was sorry for the people of Vukovar and their defenders and that he would have prevented the events had he known.

The judgment of September 2007

Trial Chamber II delivered its judgment on September 27, 2007. It began by dismissing the five counts charged as crimes against humanity. Under the tribunal's statute, it held, the victims of those crimes had to be civilians, and the men removed from the hospital and murdered at Ovčara had been singled out for their known or suspected role in the Croat forces; their killers treated them as prisoners of war. Those charges fell away for all three men, and the prosecution's later appeal against that ruling failed.

The three war crimes counts remained: murder, torture and cruel treatment as violations of the laws or customs of war. The chamber found the murders established for 194 identified victims. It found that the severe physical abuse of the prisoners, inflicted to punish them for their part in the defense of Vukovar, amounted to torture, and that the conditions in which they were held at Ovčara amounted to cruel treatment.

On the question of who was responsible, the chamber rejected the prosecution's central theory. There was no direct evidence that the three officers had acted together to bring about the murders, and the facts it had found ruled that out: neither Šljivančanin nor the captain had played any part in the process by which Mrkšić decided to give up the JNA's custody of the prisoners. There was a complete absence of evidence that Mrkšić had ordered the crimes. The actual perpetrators of the murders, torture and abuse were members of the Serb Territorial Defense, many of them from the Vukovar area, and Serb paramilitaries.

Mrkšić's guilt rested on the withdrawal order. He knew, the chamber found, of the intense animosity of the local forces toward members of the Croat forces; he had been told of the conduct at the barracks and at Ovčara that day and of the killings at Velepromet the day before. By ordering the military police away when he knew of the high risk of serious violence and death, he aided and abetted the murders that followed. By failing during the afternoon to strengthen the guard despite reports of severe mistreatment, he aided and abetted torture and cruel treatment. He was the commander of all Serb forces at Ovčara on November 20 and 21.

For Šljivančanin, the chamber found that he had no command over the Territorial Defense or paramilitary forces and had ordered none of the crimes. But on November 20 he exercised command authority, conferred by Mrkšić, over the military police who evacuated the prisoners and guarded them. The laws of war, his role as security officer and Mrkšić's specific instruction all placed on him a duty of care for those prisoners. Having seen the abuse at Ovčara and knowing of the killings at Velepromet, he used none of the measures open to him, and his failure to act facilitated the continuing torture. He was not held responsible for the conditions of detention, because the evidence did not show that he had gone into the building where the prisoners were held, and the chamber entered no separate conviction for cruel treatment against him, since it would have duplicated the torture conviction for the same conduct. Nor was he held responsible for the murders. They were committed after the military police withdrew on Mrkšić's order, and by that order, the chamber reasoned, his responsibility for the prisoners' security had come to an end.

The captain was acquitted. The evidence placed him at the hospital, but not at the selection of prisoners and not at Ovčara, and the chamber could not rely on the prosecution witnesses who had linked him to the crimes.

The sentences

Mrkšić was convicted of three counts: Count 4, murder, a violation of the laws or customs of war, for having aided and abetted the murder of 194 persons identified in the schedule to the judgment, at Ovčara on November 20 and 21, 1991; Count 7, torture, a violation of the laws or customs of war, for having aided and abetted the torture of prisoners of war at Ovčara on November 20, 1991; and Count 8, cruel treatment, a violation of the laws or customs of war, for having aided and abetted the maintenance of inhumane conditions of detention there the same day. He received a single sentence of 20 years. Šljivančanin was convicted of Count 7, torture, a violation of the laws or customs of war, for having aided and abetted the torture of prisoners of war at Ovčara on November 20, 1991, found not guilty on all other counts and sentenced to five years. The captain was found not guilty on all counts and ordered released.

In setting the terms the chamber took account, as the statute required, of sentencing practice in the former Yugoslavia, and noted that under the law of Serbia and Croatia the maximum sentence for murder and for aiding and abetting murder committed in 1991 in these circumstances was 20 years. It declined to treat Mrkšić's surrender as mitigation, because it came almost seven years after the indictment and the international arrest warrant, and it did not accept his closing statement as remorse for his own conduct, because the statement rested on the defense account that the killings happened in his absence, which the evidence had disproved. For Šljivančanin it weighed against him the false explanations he had given to keep the international representatives from the hospital, and in his favor the relatives of staff he had allowed to leave with the civilians and a past record with nothing adverse in it.

Šljivančanin, held since June 2003, was granted provisional release in December 2007 while the appeals went forward.

The appeal of 2009

Both men appealed, and so did the prosecution, which asked the Appeals Chamber to reverse the acquittals on the crimes against humanity counts, to overturn Šljivančanin's acquittal on the murder count and to increase both sentences. It did not appeal the acquittal of the captain.

The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on May 5, 2009. It dismissed all of Mrkšić's grounds and the prosecution's grounds against him and upheld his 20-year sentence. On Šljivančanin it reached a different result.

The crimes against humanity counts touched both men, and on them the trial chamber had been wrong in law. Nothing in the statute, the Appeals Chamber held, required the individual victims of crimes against humanity to be civilians; men who had laid down their arms and were held as prisoners could be victims too. The civilian status of the victims mattered only to the separate question of whether there had been an attack directed against a civilian population. But the acquittals stood. The trial chamber had found that a widespread and systematic attack on the non-Serb civilian population of the wider Vukovar area had taken place alongside the military operation, and the crimes at Ovčara still had to be part of it. They were not. The men who abused and killed the prisoners had acted in the understanding that their victims were members of the Croat forces, and that understanding, the Appeals Chamber held, ruled out any intent that their acts form part of the attack on the civilians of Vukovar and left them too far removed from it to supply the link the statute required.

The judges accepted the trial chamber's view that while JNA troops remained at Ovčara, Šljivančanin could reasonably have believed their presence would stop the abuse from turning into killing, so that during the afternoon he lacked the state of mind needed for aiding and abetting murder. But the trial chamber had made no finding about whether or when he learned of the withdrawal order. That night Šljivančanin met Mrkšić at the brigade's command post. The Appeals Chamber held that the only reasonable conclusion was that Mrkšić told him of the order at that meeting, and that once he knew of it, he must have understood that the prisoners would likely be killed and that his failure to act would assist the killers.

It then held that the trial chamber had been wrong to find that his duty to the prisoners ended with Mrkšić's order. Under the Third Geneva Convention, the duty to protect prisoners of war included an obligation not to hand them over to anyone without first making sure they would not be harmed, and Mrkšić's order did not relieve Šljivančanin of his obligations as a JNA officer. He could have told the military police that the order breached the overriding duty to protect the prisoners and was therefore illegal; he could have tried to persuade Mrkšić to cancel it; failing that, he could have sought the help of a general in Belgrade. Had he succeeded in getting the military police sent back, the court held, the murders would have been substantially less likely, and his failure to act therefore contributed substantially to them.

By a majority, with two of the five judges dissenting, the Appeals Chamber quashed Šljivančanin's acquittal on Count 4 and convicted him of aiding and abetting murder by omission. It also held that even before the new conviction, five years did not reflect the gravity of his crimes, given the consequences of the torture for the victims, the particular vulnerability of the prisoners and the very large number of victims. It quashed the five-year term and imposed 17 years, and he returned to custody.

The review of 2010

In January 2010 Šljivančanin applied for review of the appeal judgment. His application rested on a new witness: the former chief of staff of the Guards Brigade and Operational Group South, who said he had been close enough to hear the conversation between Šljivančanin and Mrkšić on the night of November 20 and that Mrkšić had not told Šljivančanin about the withdrawal.

The witness gave evidence in June 2010, and the Appeals Chamber granted the request for review, holding that the information was a new fact that, if proved, would show a miscarriage of justice by removing the basis for the finding that Šljivančanin had the state of mind for aiding and abetting murder.

The review judgment, delivered on December 8, 2010, was the first in the tribunal's history. The Appeals Chamber found the former chief of staff credible, and the new fact was proved. Because the murder conviction had depended on the inference that Mrkšić told Šljivančanin of the withdrawal that night, and that inference was now untenable, the chamber vacated the conviction for aiding and abetting murder.

That left the question of sentence. The conviction for aiding and abetting torture stood, and the Appeals Chamber had already held five years too low for it. The judges treated the reversal of the murder conviction as a significant reduction in his culpability, but held that the mistreatment of the prisoners was an extremely serious crime. They quashed the 17-year sentence and imposed 10 years, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since July 2003.

Release and later years

Šljivančanin was granted early release on July 5, 2011, after serving two thirds of his sentence, and he went back to Belgrade. Within days he gave a newspaper interview in which he maintained that he had acted within the law and the regulations then in force and said he had never imagined that captured fighters would be killed. As of 2024 he lived in Serbia.

Mrkšić stayed in the tribunal's custody after the appeal while a country was found to hold him. In 2012 the tribunal designated Portugal, and he was transferred there on August 16, 2012, with credit counted from his surrender on May 15, 2002. In December 2013 the tribunal's President refused his application for early release. He did not finish the term. Mile Mrkšić died on August 16, 2015, in Lisbon, while serving his sentence.

The law in the case

Every conviction in the case was entered under Article 3 of the tribunal's statute, which covers violations of the laws or customs of war and applies to offenses against prisoners of war. The crimes against humanity charges under Article 5 failed at both levels, but for different reasons: the trial chamber held that the victims had to be civilians, and the Appeals Chamber, rejecting that requirement, held instead that the crimes at Ovčara had no link to the attack on Vukovar's civilian population, because the killers had treated their victims as members of the Croat forces. Neither officer was found to have committed, ordered or planned the killings, and the joint criminal enterprise alleged in the indictment was not proved. Both were convicted under Article 7(1) for aiding and abetting: Mrkšić through an act, the withdrawal order, and through his failure to act during the afternoon; Šljivančanin through his failure to act alone. Whether he could be held to a duty that outlasted his formal authority over the military police was the point on which his murder conviction first stood and then fell.

Disputed and unproven points

The scale of the crime is the first. The indictment named 264 people alleged to have been taken from the hospital and murdered; the trial chamber held 194 identified murders proved and said only that it could not determine whether more died, so 194 is the number on which the convictions rest, while the higher figure remains an allegation.

Šljivančanin's own account has never matched the findings against him. He denied being at Ovčara while the prisoners were mistreated, and the trial chamber found that he was. He has maintained that he acted lawfully; the review removed only the murder conviction, and his conviction for aiding and abetting torture is final.

Whether he knew of the withdrawal order on the night of November 20 divided the courts. The trial chamber made no finding on it; the Appeals Chamber in 2009 inferred that he did, with two judges dissenting from the resulting murder conviction; and the review chamber in 2010 found that inference untenable in light of new testimony. The last ruling is the final one.

Why Mrkšić withdrew the guard was never settled. The trial chamber found that his full reasons were known only to him, and that the wishes of the local Serb government, which had no lawful power to direct him or the JNA, appeared to have been a significant factor. He said he would have prevented the killings had he known; the chamber rejected his account that the killings followed from his absence.

Timeline

Late August 1991: The JNA lays siege to Vukovar.

November 18, 1991: Croatian forces in the Vukovar area capitulate; in Zagreb, an agreement is signed on evacuating Vukovar hospital.

November 19, 1991: Mrkšić orders the evacuation of the hospital and puts Šljivančanin in charge; international monitors are kept away.

November 20, 1991: More than 200 men are taken from the hospital, held at the JNA barracks and then at Ovčara; Mrkšić's command orders the military police guarding them withdrawn.

November 20 to 21, 1991: Territorial Defense and paramilitary forces murder at least 194 identified prisoners at Ovčara.

November 7, 1995: The tribunal confirms the indictment of Mrkšić, Šljivančanin and a JNA captain.

April 1996: International arrest warrants are issued; Yugoslavia's refusal to cooperate is reported to the Security Council.

May 15, 2002: Mrkšić surrenders and is transferred to The Hague.

June 13, 2003: Šljivančanin is arrested by Serbian authorities in Belgrade; he is transferred to The Hague on July 1.

October 11, 2005: The trial opens before Trial Chamber II.

September 27, 2007: Mrkšić is sentenced to 20 years, Šljivančanin to 5 years; the captain is acquitted.

May 5, 2009: The Appeals Chamber upholds Mrkšić's sentence and raises Šljivančanin's to 17 years, adding a conviction for aiding and abetting murder.

December 8, 2010: The first review judgment in the tribunal's history vacates Šljivančanin's murder conviction and sets his sentence at 10 years; his conviction for aiding and abetting torture stands.

July 5, 2011: Šljivančanin is granted early release.

August 16, 2012: Mrkšić is transferred to Portugal to serve his sentence.

December 13, 2013: The tribunal's President refuses Mrkšić's application for early release.

August 16, 2015: Mrkšić dies in Lisbon while serving his sentence.