Vera Brühne

Victims
2 people killed in Pöcking, Bavaria, April 1960. Convicted with Johann Ferbach of two joint murders, Munich, June 4, 1962; she always denied it
Years active
April 14, 1960 (date of death found by the court); deaths came to light April 19, 1960
Location
Pöcking and Munich, Bavaria, West Germany
Method
Murder (Mord), two counts, committed jointly with Johann Ferbach; the court found the motive was greed over an inheritance.
Status
Life imprisonment with loss of civil rights (June 4, 1962); revision rejected December 4, 1962; seven retrial bids rejected; pardoned 1979; died 2001.

On June 4, 1962, the jury court of the Landgericht München II found Vera Brühne and Johann Ferbach guilty of two murders committed jointly, with malice and out of greed, and sentenced each of them to life imprisonment. The dead were Otto Praun and his companion Elfriede Kloo, whose deaths in Pöcking, on Lake Starnberg southwest of Munich, had come to light on April 19, 1960. The court fixed the day of the killings as Maundy Thursday, April 14, 1960.

Brühne said she was innocent when the verdict was read, and she said it for the rest of her life. Ferbach said the same. The Federal Court of Justice rejected their appeal on points of law in December 1962, seven applications for a new trial failed, and Ferbach died in custody in 1970. Brühne spent eighteen years behind bars before Bavaria's Minister-President pardoned her in April 1979. She was never acquitted. She died in Munich on April 17, 2001, still convicted.

No direct evidence placed either defendant in Pöcking. The hour of death was uncertain, no traces had been secured where the two died, and the strongest testimony came from a man with fraud convictions and from a witness who withdrew her words under oath. Whether such a case proved anyone's guilt has been argued in Bavaria from the day of the verdict to the present.

Vera Brühne came from Essen-Kray in the Ruhr. By the late 1950s she lived in Munich, where she moved in the city's society circles. When police arrested her in October 1961, their report gave her age as 51.

In 1958 she met the man who would die at Pöcking, a wealthy Munich resident with property in Bavaria and in Spain. He took her on as his driver, and over the next two years the two were close companions; at times their relationship was a romantic one. She drove him to Spain, where he owned an estate on the Costa Brava. A year before his death he made a will that gave her the right to use that Spanish property for the rest of her life, an estate valued at about one million marks. That will became the hinge of the case. The woman who died with him shared his life in Pöcking as his partner.

Johann Ferbach grew up in Cologne and worked as a fitter. He was drafted into the Wehrmacht in 1939 and deserted on the Eastern Front in 1943, afterward living under the name Hans Spiess. His bond with Brühne went back to the war: during a 1944 air raid, when a bomb trapped her in the rubble, he insisted that rescuers keep digging until she was brought out alive. The two later had an intimate relationship. He was 46 when he was arrested.

The first police officer to take charge of the deaths decided the same evening that the dead man had killed his partner and then himself, and no traces were secured at the scene. For the authorities the matter appeared closed.

It was reopened by the will. Once its terms were known, a criminal complaint alleging murder led to a fresh examination of the deaths, and in the summer of 1960 that examination showed that both had been killed by another person. The extended-suicide theory collapsed, and the inquiry turned toward the woman who benefited from the will and toward the man closest to her.

More than a year passed before the arrests. Police took Brühne into custody on October 3, 1961. Ferbach was arrested eleven days later. The Munich prosecution charged both of them with double murder.

The prosecution built its case on circumstance and testimony rather than on direct proof. No scene evidence tied either defendant to Pöcking. The hour of death was itself uncertain, and the case depended on fixing it. Against that, the prosecution set the will, which gave Brühne a motive; Brühne's own conduct, which damaged her badly; and two witnesses who said they had heard confessions.

Under questioning Brühne contradicted herself. The court heard that she had altered her diary and had tried to influence witnesses, and she was shown to have lied. None of that proved she had taken part in a killing, but it cost her nearly all her credibility.

The first confession witness was a man who had shared a cell with Ferbach while he was held on remand. He told the court that Ferbach had confessed the killings to him around Christmas. He had several convictions for fraud and had long worked as a police informant, and he became the prosecution's principal witness.

The second was Brühne's daughter. She had first told a reporter and the police that her mother had confessed to her. In court she withdrew that statement and said the reporter had put her under pressure. The court relied on what she had said before the trial, not on what she said under oath.

The main hearing opened on April 25, 1962, before the Schwurgericht, the jury court of the Landgericht München II, and lasted about six weeks. Much of it turned on contested medical evidence about when the two had died. The defense did not try to name another killer. Its case was that the prosecution had not shown that Brühne and Ferbach were the people responsible.

In its judgment the court held that Brühne feared the dead man was about to change his will and cost her the Spanish estate, that she planned the killings with Ferbach, and that Ferbach carried them out at her direction out of his dependence on her. Both were sentenced to life imprisonment with loss of civil rights.

Both defendants sought revision before the Federal Court of Justice. On December 4, 1962, it rejected the appeal and held that the judgment was free of contradictions and errors of reasoning. The convictions were final. Brühne's lawyers filed seven applications for a new trial over the following years, and all seven were rejected. Both served their sentences in Bavaria. Ferbach died in custody on June 21, 1970, still maintaining his innocence.

The case did not stay in the courts. Lawyers, journalists and writers kept working on it, and it became a political matter in Bavaria, raised in the state parliament by one of its members. A group of lawyers petitioned the Minister-President for clemency on Brühne's behalf. She joined the petition only reluctantly, because what she wanted was a new trial, not mercy.

In May 1974 the Minister-President rejected the petition without giving reasons. The Landtag's petitions committee also examined the verdict and found no legal or logical flaws in it.

In April 1979 a new Minister-President granted the pardon, and Vera Brühne, then 70, was released after eighteen years in prison. She never gave up the hope of clearing her name. She died in Munich on April 17, 2001. The conviction stands.

The core dispute is whether Vera Brühne and Johann Ferbach had anything to do with the deaths at all. They were sentenced although their guilt was never proven by direct evidence, and both denied the killings until they died.

The hour and date of death are the most contested facts. The court settled on Maundy Thursday, April 14, 1960, and a fixed hour. A long report by a medical expert from Freiburg, later submitted for the defense, concluded that the court's hour was impossible, though it did not reopen the case, and the date has been disputed in other accounts as well.

The case against Ferbach rested chiefly on a fellow prisoner with fraud convictions, and the court accepted the daughter's account of a confession that she had herself withdrawn under oath.

Timeline

1944: During an air raid, Johann Ferbach helps save Vera Brühne from the rubble.

1958: Brühne becomes the driver of a wealthy Munich man who later names her in his will.

April 14, 1960: The date of death later fixed by the court, in Pöcking.

April 19, 1960: The two deaths come to light; police first treat them as an extended suicide.

Summer 1960: After the will is read, a renewed examination shows both were killed by another person.

October 3, 1961: Brühne is arrested; Ferbach is arrested eleven days later.

April 25, 1962: The trial opens before the Schwurgericht at the Landgericht München II.

June 4, 1962: Both are convicted of two murders committed jointly, with malice and out of greed, and sentenced to life imprisonment.

December 4, 1962: The Federal Court of Justice rejects the revision.

June 21, 1970: Ferbach dies in custody in Bavaria.

May 1974: The Minister-President rejects a clemency petition.

April 1979: Brühne is pardoned and released after eighteen years.

April 17, 2001: Vera Brühne dies in Munich.