U Saw

Victims
9 killed in Rangoon, July 19, 1947, including Aung San; convicted by a special tribunal for the killings (conspiracy and murder) and sentenced to death
Years active
July 19, 1947
Location
Rangoon (now Yangon), Burma (Myanmar) (killings, trial, execution); detained in Uganda, 1942 to 1946
Method
Shot by gunmen in military uniform during a council meeting; U Saw convicted as the man behind the killings
Status
Sentenced to death by the special tribunal; no appeal to the Privy Council after independence; executed in Rangoon, Burma, May 8, 1948.

On July 19, 1947, less than six months before Burma was to leave British rule, Aung San and six of his colleagues on the Executive Council were killed in Rangoon while the council was meeting. Nine people died in all. The council's leader had negotiated the terms of Burma's independence with the British government that January. Within a day the police had arrested U Saw, a former premier of the colony, a newspaper owner and party leader who had spent most of the war in British detention and who had refused to join the settlement his rival brought home from London.

A special tribunal convicted U Saw of conspiracy and murder and sentenced him to death. The conviction came while Burma was still under British rule, and by the time his case had run its course the country was independent and the old right of appeal to the Privy Council in London no longer reached him. He was executed in Rangoon on May 8, 1948. A British officer later admitted that, shortly before the killings, he had arranged an illegal issue of military stores from an army depot to U Saw, and a Burmese court sent him to prison for five years.

U Saw was born in 1900 in British Burma. He never took a university degree, but he qualified to practice as a lawyer, and in 1932 he was among those who defended Saya San, the leader of the 1931 and 1932 rising against British rule. In 1935 he bought the Rangoon newspaper Thuria, "The Sun," and he went on to found his own political party, the Myochit, or "Patriot," party.

In 1940 he helped bring down the government of Ba Maw, and he became premier himself, an office he held until early 1942.

In the autumn of 1941 he flew to London to ask for a promise of dominion status for Burma. He met Winston Churchill and Leopold Amery, the Secretary of State for India and Burma, and came away with little more than an assurance that self-government would be discussed after the war. He went on to Washington hoping that President Roosevelt might press the principles of the Atlantic Charter on Burma's behalf, and he was in Honolulu when Japanese aircraft attacked Pearl Harbor. He made his way back to the United States and left for Lisbon by air the day before Christmas.

In January 1942 the British government announced that U Saw had been detained, saying he had been in contact with Japanese authorities since the outbreak of war with Japan and had admitted it. He would not be allowed to return to Burma. His travelling companion, Tin Tut, was the only other person detained in connection with the action against him. A new ministry under Sir Paw Tun took office in Rangoon on January 20, 1942. U Saw spent the next four years in British custody in Uganda. By the end of 1945, with the war over, American officials still could not learn from the British where he was being held.

U Saw did return to Burma after the war, and he built up a private army. By then the dominant force in Burmese politics was the AFPFL, led by his future rival, the commander who had raised a Burmese army under the Japanese and then turned against them as the war ended. He led the delegation that went to London in January 1947 to settle the terms of independence, and U Saw went with it as a member of the governor's Executive Council, holding the education portfolio, and as leader of the Myochit party.

In London he called on the American embassy on January 21, 1947. He told the American chargé that the governor had erred in giving the leadership to the AFPFL leader instead of to himself, spoke of his deep distrust of the man, and said he was not convinced that anything would come of the talks. He was also receiving treatment in London for an injury to his right eye and planned to stay on after the delegation left.

He refused to sign the agreement the AFPFL leader reached with the British government, arguing that too much had been conceded. Another politician, Thakin Ba Sein, also held out, and the American consul general in Rangoon reported early in February that both men might have to resign from the Executive Council for failing to go along with the arrangement. Both resigned from the council that month.

On the morning of July 19, 1947, the Executive Council was in session in Rangoon. The council's leader was killed there, and so were six of his colleagues, Thakin Mya among them. U Ohn Maung, a senior official, also died. Nine people were killed. One council member survived, and two others who were present were unhurt.

Those two council members told the governor, Sir Hubert Rance, that they suspected U Saw, and the governor passed the suspicion on to the American consul general that afternoon. A curfew was set for that evening. By the next day U Saw had been arrested, and the governor had asked Thakin Nu, the president of the Constituent Assembly, to form a new council. Within days the consulate was reporting further evidence against the former premier.

In London, Clement Attlee told the House of Commons on July 21 that the causes of the plot were not yet clear and that efforts were being made to trace those responsible.

On July 30 Attlee gave the Commons a fuller account. A number of arrests had been made, and the government believed that the men who carried out the killings were among those held. The killings, he said, had been part of a plot to overthrow the government. Two important consignments of military stores had been obtained from the Base Ordnance Depot at the end of June, and most of the material had since been recovered. A military court of inquiry had been set up at once, the officer in charge of the depots had been relieved of his duties, and the police and military authorities were pressing the investigation together.

On August 1 Thakin Nu, now leading the government, told the American consul general that a special tribunal would be established to try the accused. The Government of Burma Act of 1935 still governed the colony when the tribunal was set up, and Burma's courts still answered, at the top, to the Privy Council.

By November 1947 U Saw was on trial before the special tribunal, as Churchill noted in the Commons on November 5 while Parliament debated the bill that would give Burma its independence.

The tribunal convicted U Saw of conspiracy and murder and sentenced him to death. The judgment was delivered before Burma's independence took effect on January 4, 1948, and the conviction therefore came under British rule.

Burma became independent on January 4, 1948. Under British rule, a man convicted in Burma's courts had a right of appeal to the Privy Council in London. Independence closed that door. On April 6, 1948, the point was raised in the Commons: U Saw and two British officers held in Burma had been convicted under British rule, when that appeal was open to them, and the right had since been taken away. At that point the execution was expected on April 9. It did not take place then.

U Saw was executed in Rangoon on May 8, 1948.

The investigation reached into the British forces in Burma. Captain David Vivian, an officer of the old Indian Army seconded to the Rangoon police, admitted that shortly before July 19, 1947 he had arranged the illegal issue of military stores from an army ordnance depot to U Saw. The case went to the civil courts, not a military court. Vivian confessed, and on August 9, 1948 a regular Burmese civil court sentenced him to five years' rigorous imprisonment for an offense under the arms law.

U Saw was convicted, and the sentence was carried out, but the full circumstances of the killings were never cleared up. The British officer's admission that he arranged military supplies for U Saw before July 19 left open the question of who else had helped him. In the Commons, Attlee acknowledged rumors linking the British government and the governor to the killings in July 1947, and a Labour member's suggestion that Conservative politicians had encouraged U Saw was ruled out of order.

Timeline

1900: U Saw is born in British Burma.

1932: He is among the lawyers defending the rebel leader Saya San.

1935: He buys the newspaper Thuria and later founds the Myochit party.

1940: He helps remove Ba Maw and becomes premier of Burma.

Autumn 1941: He travels to London to seek dominion status and meets Churchill.

December 1941: He is in Honolulu during the attack on Pearl Harbor.

January 1942: The British government announces his detention over contact with Japanese authorities.

January 20, 1942: A new ministry under Sir Paw Tun takes office.

1942 to 1946: He is held in Uganda.

January 1947: He goes to London as a member of the Executive Council and refuses to sign the independence agreement.

February 1947: He resigns from the Executive Council.

July 19, 1947: The council's leader, six other council members and others are killed in Rangoon; nine die.

July 20, 1947: U Saw is under arrest; Thakin Nu forms a new council.

July 30, 1947: Attlee tells the Commons that arrests have been made and calls the killings part of a plot to overthrow the government.

August 1, 1947: Thakin Nu says a special tribunal will try the accused.

November 5, 1947: U Saw is on trial before the special tribunal.

Before January 4, 1948: The special tribunal convicts U Saw and sentences him to death.

January 4, 1948: Burma becomes independent.

April 6, 1948: The loss of the Privy Council appeal is raised in the Commons.

May 8, 1948: U Saw is executed in Rangoon.

August 9, 1948: Captain David Vivian is sentenced to five years' rigorous imprisonment.