Tristan van der Vlis

Victims
6 people killed in Alphen aan den Rijn, April 9, 2011; never tried. Police and prosecutors attributed the deaths to him alone; 16 people were injured.
Years active
April 9, 2011
Location
Alphen aan den Rijn, South Holland, Netherlands (killings; death)
Method
Shot (police and prosecutors' account; never tried).
Status
Never tried. The Supreme Court of the Netherlands held the police liable for the damage, September 2019. Died untried, by suicide, in Alphen aan den Rijn, South Holland, April 9, 2011.

On Saturday, April 9, 2011, six people died in Alphen aan den Rijn, a town in the province of South Holland. Sixteen more were injured, two young girls among them. Dutch police and prosecutors attributed every one of those deaths and injuries to a single local man, Tristan van der Vlis, who was 24. He died by suicide the same day. He was never charged and never tried, and no criminal court ever tested the case against him. The record was built instead by a prosecution-led investigation, a series of official inquiries and civil litigation that went all the way to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands.

That litigation is why the case is remembered in Dutch law. Van der Vlis held his weapons legally, under a licence the regional police had granted him in 2008. Two years before that, police officers had helped carry out his compulsory admission to a psychiatric institution. The information was in police hands when his application was assessed, and nobody weighed it.

The deaths took place in the space of a few minutes. Six people died, three women and three men, all of them adults, and their names were never made public. When it was over, Van der Vlis was dead by his own hand. He left a farewell letter. It dealt with his intention to end his own life, gave no sign that he had planned to harm anyone else, and offered no reason for what he did. No motive was ever made public.

Because he was dead, there could be no prosecution. The Public Prosecution Service in The Hague set up a large-scale investigation all the same, led by a public prosecutor, to reconstruct the events and find out whether anyone had helped him. Its central finding, reported to parliament in July 2011, was that there were no co-perpetrators and no accomplices. As far as anyone could establish, he had acted alone.

The inquiries into the licence told a longer story. Van der Vlis grew up in Alphen aan den Rijn, and his licensing record began years before the licence itself. In 2003, when he was about 16 or 17, he was involved in two incidents that were entered in the police and judicial registers. When he first applied for a licence under the arms law, a regional police meeting refused the application on October 3, 2005, and the 2003 incident was the ground. The National Police Internal Investigations Department, the Rijksrecherche, later confirmed that reason, found that the officer who handled the application had recorded nothing about psychological problems, and found no evidence that the police had been told of any in 2005.

In September 2006 he was admitted against his will to a mental health institution because of a risk of suicide. Police officers assisted with the admission, and the Hollands-Midden police force held a record of it in its own systems.

He applied again, and in 2008 the Hollands-Midden police granted the licence. Checks renewed it in 2009 and again in 2010. The Rijksrecherche's main finding, reported to parliament in July 2011, was that the 2006 information held by the force was not considered when the 2008 application was assessed: either the force's information desk did not pass it on, or the officer handling the file overlooked it.

The earlier refusal had been lost as well. When the force moved its licensing records from an older computer system to a new one in 2006, the paper file on the 2005 application was not fully transferred and was not preserved, and the officer who assessed the 2008 application did not know of the refusal. The Dutch Safety Board found that the older system could not record refusals at all. Further information about Van der Vlis sent to the force by email could no longer be opened, and a case file on him went astray after an office move. The yearly checks brought none of it to light. Looking at the national system as a whole, the Safety Board found it sound in its basic design but weak in both design and operation, because it did not guarantee that the officials deciding whether misuse was to be feared could reach the information they needed.

In 2012 relatives of the dead, injured survivors, eyewitnesses and shopkeepers took the police to court in The Hague, arguing that Van der Vlis should never have been granted the licence. The District Court agreed on that point in February 2015 and found that the police had acted carelessly by failing to take the earlier refusal into account, but it held that they were not liable for the damage, because the duty of care in granting licences was not meant to protect against that kind of harm. The Court of Appeal in The Hague reversed that conclusion on March 27, 2018. The rule requiring a licence to be refused where misuse is feared, it held, exists to protect citizens against the consequences of exactly that misuse, and the failure to pass on information was the responsibility of the police as an organization, whatever the officer personally knew. It limited liability to personal injury and death damages and excluded damage to shops and buildings.

On September 20, 2019, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands went further. It held the police liable for both material and immaterial damage resulting from the deaths and injuries, for losses already suffered and for losses still to come, leaving the amounts to be settled in further proceedings. The police and their insurer then set up a foundation to assess and pay the claims at arm's length; by May 4, 2021, it had 71 registered cases, 32 of them settled.

Van der Vlis was never tried, and no court ever examined the evidence against him in a criminal case. The attribution of the deaths and injuries rests on the findings of the police and the Public Prosecution Service, which found that he acted alone; the civil courts proceeded on the same basis.

No motive was established. The farewell letter dealt with his own death and gave no reason for the deaths of others.

Accounts of the death toll differ: the official documents count six people dead, while some later news reports say five were killed directly and a sixth died of a heart attack during the events.

Whether the police knew of psychological problems as early as 2005 was disputed, and claims raised in April 2012 that a lost 2005 file had recorded psychiatric treatment were examined and found to have no supporting evidence; what is established is that the 2006 admission was known to the police and was not considered in 2008.

Timeline

2003: Van der Vlis, about 16 or 17, is involved in two incidents in Alphen aan den Rijn that are entered in police and judicial registers.

October 3, 2005: a regional police meeting refuses his first application for a licence under the arms law, citing the 2003 incident.

2006: the paper file on the 2005 refusal is not preserved when the Hollands-Midden police change computer systems.

September 2006: he is compulsorily admitted to a mental health institution, with police assistance.

2008: the Hollands-Midden police grant him a licence under the arms law; the 2006 information is not considered.

2009 and 2010: yearly checks renew the licence without bringing the earlier information to light.

April 9, 2011: six people die and 16 are injured in Alphen aan den Rijn; he dies by suicide the same day.

July 11, 2011: parliament is told that the criminal investigation found no accomplices and that the 2006 information was not considered in 2008.

September 2011: the Dutch Safety Board publishes its report on licensing.

2012: relatives, survivors and shopkeepers begin civil proceedings against the police.

February 4, 2015: the District Court of The Hague finds the police acted carelessly but holds them not liable.

March 27, 2018: the Court of Appeal in The Hague holds the police liable for personal injury and death damages.

September 20, 2019: the Supreme Court of the Netherlands holds the police liable for material and immaterial damage.

May 4, 2021: the compensation foundation has 71 registered cases, 32 of them settled.