Toru Toyoda

Victims
Murder conviction over the Tokyo subway attack, March 20, 1995. The attack killed 13 people and hurt thousands; sentenced to death in July 2000; executed in Tokyo, July 26, 2018.
Years active
March 20, 1995
Location
Tokyo; Hyogo Prefecture
Method
Murder and attempted murder, as found by the Tokyo District Court in July 2000, over an attack carried out by members of Aum Shinrikyo.
Status
Death sentence upheld on appeal and made final; executed in Tokyo on July 26, 2018.

Toru Toyoda was one of the members of Aum Shinrikyo who boarded crowded Tokyo subway trains on the morning of March 20, 1995. He was a physics graduate of the University of Tokyo, and his assignment was a train on the Hibiya Line. Thirteen people died as a result of the attack that morning, passengers and subway staff, and thousands more were hurt. Toyoda admitted his part from an early stage and offered no excuses. In July 2000 the Tokyo District Court convicted him of murder and attempted murder and sentenced him to death. His appeals failed, and on July 26, 2018, he was executed in Tokyo, one of the last six members of the group to be put to death.

Toyoda came from Hyogo Prefecture, in western Japan, and in 1986 he enrolled at the University of Tokyo, where he studied in the Faculty of Science. Around that time he came across a book by Chizuo Matsumoto, who then led a yoga circle and later took the name Shoko Asahara. Toyoda began attending the group's training hall, went on to earn a master's degree in physics, and joined the group in 1992, where he was put to work in its research and development section.

On the morning of Monday, March 20, 1995, at the height of the rush hour, members of the group boarded trains on three lines of the Tokyo subway operated by the Teito Rapid Transit Authority: the Marunouchi, the Chiyoda and the Hibiya. Five trains were involved, all heading for the area around Kasumigaseki, the district of central Tokyo that houses the national government ministries. Toyoda was one of two members assigned to the Hibiya Line. The other was Yasuo Hayashi. Kenichi Hirose, who would later stand trial beside Toyoda, was assigned to the Marunouchi Line. Shigeo Sugimoto served as one of the drivers in the operation.

The Hibiya Line runs from the city's western suburbs into Kasumigaseki. Toyoda boarded a Hibiya Line train and then left it.

The final count was 13 passengers and station staff, and more than 5,800 people were certified as injured under the national victim compensation law. One more death, in March 2020, brought the count to 14.

No one claimed responsibility. On March 22, two days after the attack, the Tokyo Metropolitan Police raided Aum Shinrikyo's facilities. The leader was arrested on May 16, 1995. In the months that followed police arrested almost the entire leadership of the group, and nearly 40 people were arrested in connection with the subway attack alone.

Toyoda was taken into custody in 1995. From an early point he admitted what he had done on the train, and he declined to make excuses, out of regard for the victims. About half a year after his arrest he submitted a formal notice of withdrawal from the group.

Toyoda was tried in the Tokyo District Court together with Kenichi Hirose, the other member on the trains tried beside him, and Shigeo Sugimoto, a driver in the operation. Toyoda pleaded guilty. He answered his own lawyers' questions candidly, and he also appeared as a witness at the trial of the group's leader and at the trials of other members, giving consistent and orderly accounts without volunteering more than he was asked. He told the court that he felt he did not deserve to have lived.

His lawyers did not dispute the facts. Their argument went to his state of mind. They contended that his capacity to be held responsible had been markedly diminished at the time. Toyoda himself made no such plea on his own behalf, and he refused throughout to offer any excuse, out of regard for the people who had died and been hurt.

The three were sentenced together in July 2000. The court pronounced that Toyoda and Hirose were each sentenced to death and Sugimoto to life imprisonment.

The court convicted Toyoda of murder and attempted murder over the subway attack. It rejected the defense argument that his responsibility had been markedly diminished. It gave weight to his remorse, but held that the death penalty could not be avoided.

Of the five members of the group charged in the subway attack at that point, four received death sentences and one received life imprisonment.

Toyoda and Hirose both appealed. The Tokyo High Court upheld his death sentence, the Supreme Court rejected his final appeal, and the sentence became final. He became one of 13 former members of the group whose death sentences stood.

The sentence then waited. Under Article 475 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the death sentences passed on the group's members were not carried out while the cases of their co-defendants remained open, and those cases ran for years after his own had become final. The last of the trials arising from the group's crimes ended on January 25, 2018.

On July 6, 2018, the group's leader and six other former members were executed. On July 26, 2018, the remaining six were executed, and Toyoda was among them. He was executed in Tokyo, without prior notice. The same day Hirose, Hayashi and Masato Yokoyama, three of the other men on the trains, were executed, together with Kazuaki Okazaki and Satoru Hashimoto, who had been convicted of other crimes. The Minister of Justice announced the executions at a news conference in Tokyo.

With the six deaths of July 26, every one of the 13 death sentences handed down over the group's crimes had been carried out.

Toyoda never contested the facts of his part in the attack. The only issue the defense pressed was his state of mind, and the Tokyo District Court rejected the claim that his responsibility had been markedly diminished. The higher courts left the death sentence in place.

Timeline

1986: Enrolls at the University of Tokyo.

1992: Joins the group after earning a master's degree in physics.

March 20, 1995: Boards a Hibiya Line train in Tokyo during the morning rush hour; 13 people die in the attack on the subway that day.

March 22, 1995: Police raid the group's facilities.

May 16, 1995: The group's leader is arrested.

1995: Taken into custody; admits his part; about six months later formally withdraws from the group.

July 2000: Convicted of murder and attempted murder and sentenced to death.

After 2000: The Tokyo High Court upholds the sentence; the Supreme Court rejects his final appeal.

January 25, 2018: The last trial arising from the group's crimes ends.

March 2018: Seven of the 13 condemned men are moved out of Tokyo; Toyoda remains in Tokyo.

July 6, 2018: The leader and six other members are executed.

July 26, 2018: Executed in Tokyo.