In December 1934 a jury at Lewes Assizes, in Sussex, spent a little over two hours deciding whether Tony Mancini had killed the woman he lived with, and then found him not guilty. He was 26, a drifter with a criminal record and more than one name, and almost everyone who followed the case, Mancini included, had expected a conviction. The verdict freed him and closed the case in law. In 1976 he told a Sunday newspaper that he had been responsible for her death after all, a claim he later withdrew. By then no court could try him for it again, and none ever tested what he said. No one has been convicted of her death.
The woman at the center of the trial was Violette Kaye, who also went by the name Violet Saunders. She was older than Mancini. She had been living in London when the two of them left the capital together and settled in Brighton in September 1933. The relationship was a stormy one, a matter of quarrels as well as affection, and the prosecution later built its case on the quarrels.
Mancini had used several names before he arrived on the south coast; he was also known as Jack Notyre, and his first name appears as both Tony and Toni. He had a record for petty crime, and that record shaped what he said once suspicion fell on him.
That summer Brighton police were already investigating the unrelated death of an unidentified woman found in the town in June 1934; it was never solved, and police found no link to Mancini.
On July 15, 1934, her death came to light in Brighton, and her identity was quickly established. Mancini had already left the town. He was traced to south-east London, arrested, and charged with her murder.
From the start he denied killing her. He said that he had been afraid that a man with his record would never be believed, and he suggested that someone else had been responsible.
The trial opened at Lewes Assizes on December 10, 1934. Mancini pleaded not guilty to murder, an offense for which he faced a possible sentence of death.
The prosecution's case was that Mancini had killed her during one of their quarrels. Its central witness was a pathologist, whose evidence on how she had died carried the case against him. The Crown also relied on scientific evidence about stains on clothing connected to Mancini, and on witnesses who spoke to the couple's life together in Brighton.
Defense counsel attacked each strand. Cross-examination put the pathologist's conclusions under sustained pressure, and the evidence about the clothing was challenged as well. The defense put forward the possibility that another person had been responsible. Witnesses described the couple as affectionate, which weakened the motive the Crown had proposed.
Mancini gave evidence himself and told the jury that he had not killed her.
On December 14, 1934, the jury retired and returned after about two and a quarter hours. Its verdict was not guilty. Mancini left the court a free man, and a week later he married.
In 1976 he gave an interview to a reporter from a Sunday national newspaper and said that his account at Lewes had been false. He said she had died during a fierce argument between them, which began when she accused him of making advances to another woman, and that he had acted in self-defense.
The admission had no legal consequence for the death itself. The Director of Public Prosecutions ruled that Mancini could not be tried again for murder. A prosecution for perjury, based on the evidence he had given at Lewes, was considered and then dropped for lack of corroborating evidence. Mancini later withdrew the confession.
Two accounts of her death exist, and neither has been tested to the standard the law requires. The jury at Lewes heard the Crown's case and Mancini's denial and found him not guilty. The 1976 admission, given to a newspaper rather than to a court, contradicted his sworn evidence, but it was never examined in cross-examination or corroborated, and he later retracted it. In law Mancini remains a man acquitted of murder.
September 1933: Mancini and the woman he lived with move from London to Brighton.
July 15, 1934: her death comes to light in Brighton.
July 1934: Mancini is arrested in south-east London and charged with murder.
December 10, 1934: his trial opens at Lewes Assizes.
December 14, 1934: the jury finds him not guilty after about two and a quarter hours.
December 1934: Mancini marries, a week after the verdict.
1976: Mancini tells a Sunday newspaper that his trial account was false. Afterward the Director of Public Prosecutions rules he cannot be retried, and a perjury prosecution is considered and dropped for lack of corroborating evidence. He later withdraws the confession.