On the evening of Wednesday, February 19, 2020, nine people were killed in Hanau, a city in the state of Hesse about 15 miles east of Frankfurt. The killings happened in the city center and in the district of Kesselstadt. Six other people were injured, some of them seriously. The man the authorities held responsible, a 43-year-old German named in the German manner as Tobias R., then, in Kesselstadt, killed his mother and died by suicide. He was found dead the next morning.
Germany's Federal Prosecutor General took over the case that night. Almost two years later, after an inquiry that pursued about 300 leads, questioned more than 400 witnesses and examined several hundred items of evidence, the federal prosecutors concluded that Tobias R. had planned and carried out the killings alone, and that he had acted from a racist motivation. Because he was dead, no court ever tried him, and every finding about his responsibility comes from the prosecutors' investigation rather than from a verdict. The investigation, which had formally run against unknown persons, was discontinued on December 16, 2021.
The nine people killed on February 19, 2020, were Gökhan Gültekin, Sedat Gürbüz, Said Nesar Hashemi, Mercedes Kierpacz, Hamza Kurtović, Vili Viorel Păun, Fatih Saraçoğlu, Ferhat Unvar and Kaloyan Velkov.
In the federal prosecutors' finding, the victims had been selected by racist criteria.
Tobias R. was born in Hanau and grew up there. He completed an apprenticeship at a bank and went on to take a degree in business administration. For a time he lived and worked in Munich. By 2020 he was back in Hanau, living in Kesselstadt.
Nothing in his public history pointed toward violence. He had not come to the notice of investigators, he was not known for hostility to foreigners, and he did not appear in police records. The federal prosecutors found no earlier convictions and no earlier investigations with any political connection. In the federal government's later account to the Bundestag, neither the police nor the security services had held any prior knowledge relevant to the offense.
In the months before the killings he did turn to the authorities himself, though not as a suspect. In November 2019 he sent criminal complaints against unknown persons to two offices at once: the public prosecutor's office in Hanau and the Federal Prosecutor General in Karlsruhe.
In the weeks before the attack he put writings and videos online. The federal prosecutors later cited this material, together with the rest of the evidence, as showing a racist motive. The Federal Criminal Police Office and the federal prosecutors concluded that he held a right-wing extremist ideology and had taken earlier right-wing attacks as a model.
The killings in the city center and in Kesselstadt took place within minutes of each other on a Wednesday evening. During the night officers found Tobias R. dead, and his mother dead with him.
Hanau woke on Thursday, February 20, to the news that 11 people were dead: the nine people killed the evening before, the mother of the man held responsible, and Tobias R. himself.
The Federal Prosecutor General's office in Karlsruhe took over the investigation overnight because of the special significance of the case. On Thursday the Federal Prosecutor General announced at a news conference in Karlsruhe that he had assumed the case. The Federal Criminal Police Office (the BKA) took over the detailed work together with the Hesse State Criminal Police Office.
From the first day, the prosecutors set out what they needed to learn. They wanted to know whether anyone else had known of the plan, had helped to prepare it, or had encouraged it. They examined the suspect's surroundings and his contacts in Germany and abroad, and analyzed the writings and videos he had left. By Friday, February 21, about 40 witnesses had already been questioned.
The BKA ran the first weeks of the case through a special command structure, the Besondere Aufbauorganisation Hanau. On March 13, 2020, that structure issued its closing situation report and handed the work on to a standing investigation group. The federal government later told the Bundestag what such a report was: a provisional collection of information for the BKA's leadership, the federal Interior Ministry and the Federal Prosecutor General, meant to keep them informed as the case developed and never intended for the prosecutors' case file.
The early assessment hardened as the months passed. In a written answer to the Bundestag dated May 29, 2020, the federal government stated that, although the investigation was not yet finished and the BKA had not yet delivered its final report, the Federal Prosecutor General saw no reasonable doubt that the attack had been planned, prepared and carried out for racist and right-wing extremist reasons. Further personal dispositions or motives of the suspect, the government added, could not change that assessment. The BKA held the mandate for the police work, but the decision to close the case, and the final assessment, belonged to the Federal Prosecutor General alone, who would report to parliament once it was made.
Whether he had been criminally responsible at the time of the killings was itself part of the inquiry. The Federal Prosecutor General commissioned an expert assessment of the man on the basis of the investigation's findings about him, and in July 2020 it was still being prepared. By then the BKA had decided not to write a single final report but a series of notes, one for each strand of the investigation. The government expected the work to be finished before the end of 2020, though it warned that the coronavirus pandemic made any forecast unreliable. The investigation in fact ran for almost two years.
On Thursday, December 16, 2021, the Federal Prosecutor General's office announced in Karlsruhe the discontinuance of the investigation into the attack in Hanau of February 19, 2020. The case was closed under Section 170(2) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure. The proceedings had formally been directed against unknown persons, since the man held responsible could no longer be prosecuted, and the question that remained was whether any living person shared the guilt.
The prosecutors' answer was no. After every relevant line of inquiry had been exhausted, they said, there were no sufficient factual indications that any further person had taken part as a co-perpetrator, instigator or accessory, or had known of the plan in advance. Nothing suggested that anyone else had been told of the attack. The acts of preparation, the office found, had been carried out by Tobias R. alone and on his own responsibility. There was no sufficient initial suspicion against any other person.
The announcement set out what lay behind that conclusion. Investigators had pursued the leads that came in from every quarter. They had examined the material secured in the case for its relevance as evidence. They had looked into his contacts of every kind over the preceding years and found no one who had known what he intended.
The same announcement restated the core of the case: on February 19, 2020, in Hanau, Tobias R. had killed nine people from a racist motivation and had injured numerous others, some of them seriously, before killing his mother and himself.
On July 7, 2021, the Hesse state parliament voted to set up a committee of inquiry into the killings, and the committee began its work on July 14, 2021, with 15 members and a mandate to examine possible failures by the state government and the authorities under it. It met in 42 sessions between December 2021 and November 2023 and presented its final report in December 2023.
No court ever heard the case against Tobias R., and none can. He died on the night of the attack, and the federal investigation, which could have reached only the living, closed in December 2021 without finding anyone who shared the guilt. The findings of the Federal Prosecutor General remain the last official word on who did what in Hanau on February 19, 2020.
Tobias R. was never charged or tried, and no court ever ruled on his guilt. The nine killings and the death of his mother are attributed to him by the Federal Prosecutor General, whose findings that he acted alone and from a racist motivation rest on the investigation closed in December 2021.
Whether anyone else carried any share of responsibility was the central open question of the federal investigation. The prosecutors concluded that no one had taken part, helped or known of the plan in advance. The separate question of what the state authorities knew before the attack and did on the night itself was taken up by the Hesse state parliament inquiry.
November 2019: Tobias R. contacts the Federal Prosecutor General's office with a criminal complaint against unknown persons; no proceedings follow.
February 19, 2020: Nine people are killed in Hanau, in the city center and in Kesselstadt; six others are injured.
February 20, 2020: Tobias R. and his mother are found dead in Kesselstadt; the Federal Prosecutor General takes over the investigation.
February 21, 2020: About 40 witnesses have been questioned; the Federal Prosecutor General confirms that his office received a complaint from Tobias R. in November 2019 and opened no investigation on it.
March 13, 2020: The BKA's special command structure issues its closing situation report; the work passes to an investigation group.
May 29, 2020: The federal government tells the Bundestag that the Federal Prosecutor General sees no reasonable doubt of a racist, right-wing extremist motive.
July 7, 2021: The Hesse state parliament votes to set up a committee of inquiry.
July 14, 2021: The committee begins its work.
December 16, 2021: The Federal Prosecutor General discontinues the investigation, finding that Tobias R. acted alone from a racist motivation.
December 2023: The Hesse state parliament committee presents its final report after 42 sessions.