Timur Bekmansurov

Victims
6 murders in Perm, Russia, September 20, 2021; also convicted of attempted murder of 59 more people, attempt on an officer's life and property damage.
Years active
September 20, 2021
Location
Perm, Perm Krai, Russia (killings); Perm, Russia (trial); Nizhny Novgorod, Russia (appeal); Moscow, Russia (Supreme Court)
Method
Shot. Convicted of murder under Article 105, Part 2, paragraphs a, e and i, Russian Criminal Code.
Status
Life imprisonment, December 28, 2022; upheld on appeal, Nizhny Novgorod, summer 2023; cassation rejected by the Supreme Court May 7, 2024. Serving life in Russia as of May 2024.

On the morning of September 20, 2021, Timur Bekmansurov, an 18-year-old in his first weeks in the law faculty of Perm State University, killed six people and injured dozens of others in Perm, the largest city of the Perm region in the western Urals. One of the dead was a man and five were women. He was detained the same morning and wounded in the process, and part of one leg was later amputated. He admitted his guilt from the first days of the investigation, refused to testify and never offered an account of why he had done it.

On December 28, 2022, the Perm Territory Court convicted him on every count: the murder of six people, the attempted murder of fifty-nine others, an attempt on the life of a law enforcement officer, and the deliberate destruction or damage of property. It sentenced him to life imprisonment. An appeal court in Nizhny Novgorod upheld the life term in the summer of 2023 while trimming parts of the verdict, and on May 7, 2024, the Supreme Court of Russia rejected his last complaint and left the sentence unchanged.

The surviving record of his life before that autumn is thin. He finished School No. 60 in Perm in June 2021, having joined it in the ninth grade. At the start of September he was admitted to the law faculty on a fee-paying place during an additional intake, and he was a first-year student when the events of September 20 took place.

The killings took place in Perm on the morning of Monday, September 20, 2021. By the afternoon the Investigative Committee had settled on six dead, after official counts earlier in the day had run as high as eight. The number of injured grew as the full picture emerged, from two dozen in the health authorities' first count to the fifty-nine people covered by the attempted-murder counts at trial.

He was detained the same morning by a junior lieutenant of the traffic police and was wounded during his detention. The Investigative Committee said he had resisted, and his charges would later include an attempt on the life of a law enforcement officer. That morning the Committee opened a criminal case under Part 2 of Article 105 of the Russian Criminal Code, the provision on the murder of two or more persons, and assigned it to its central Main Investigative Directorate rather than to regional investigators. That night the Perm region's Ministry of Territorial Security published the names of the six people who had died.

Margarita Engaus was the oldest of them. She was from Perm. People who knew her well described her as kind and responsive, someone who avoided quarrels and was always ready to help.

Yaroslav Aramelev was the only man among the dead. He had finished a music school as a violinist, competed in sports aerobics and was drawn to robotics, entering technical competitions. He hoped to work in information technology, and he had already built a working prototype of a robot meant to clear ice and icicles from roofs.

Ksenia Samchenko came from a small town in the Perm region and had recently settled in Perm. Ekaterina Shakirova lived in Perm.

Anna Aigeldina was born and lived in Kambarka, a town in Udmurtia about 300 kilometers from Perm.

Alexandra Mokhova ran track and had always been strong at mathematics. Friends described her as bright, warm and kind, someone who tried to help people and with whom it was easy to talk openly.

For days Bekmansurov's own life was in danger. Part of one of his legs was amputated, and on September 24, 2021, the regional health ministry said he had regained consciousness, though his condition was still serious. On October 14, 2021, the Dzerzhinsky District Court of Perm, sitting in the hospital where he was still being treated, ordered him held in custody for two months, and he did not object. The Investigative Committee told the court he had admitted his guilt in full during questioning. That admission never wavered, and neither did his silence about the reasons: he refused to give testimony and offered no explanation for what he had done.

In January 2022 a comprehensive psychological and psychiatric examination found him legally sane, meaning he could be held criminally responsible. He had said that he considered himself mentally ill. As the experts' findings were later summarized in court, he had been diagnosed with a schizoid personality disorder, but he did not suffer from a mental illness and was capable of understanding the danger of his actions.

On July 25, 2022, the Investigative Committee announced that the investigation was complete, and the case went to the Perm Territory Court. The indictment charged him with four offenses: the murder of two or more persons, the attempted murder of two or more persons, an attempt on the life of a law enforcement officer, and the deliberate destruction or damage of property.

The trial opened on September 5, 2022. At the first hearing Bekmansurov told the court that he admitted his guilt in full. About sixty people had been recognized as victims in the case. On November 28 the prosecution asked for life imprisonment, while acknowledging the circumstances in his favor: his admission of guilt, his state of health and the injuries he had suffered during his detention.

He gave his final statement the next day. He again admitted his guilt and said that he repented. He asked the court to take into account that his disability had confined him to a wheelchair for life, and to weigh his active cooperation with the investigation. He asked the judges not to impose a life sentence. He promised to compensate the victims out of his disability pension, and out of wages if he were allowed to work in a colony, and he had already accepted the victims' civil claims.

The court delivered its verdict on December 28, 2022. The presiding judge found Bekmansurov guilty on all counts: murder under paragraphs a, e and i of Part 2 of Article 105 of the Russian Criminal Code; attempted murder under Part 3 of Article 30 together with the same paragraphs of Article 105; deliberate destruction or damage of property under Part 2 of Article 167; and an attempt on the life of a law enforcement officer under Article 317. The court found that he had killed six people out of hooligan motives and by a means dangerous to the public.

He was sentenced to life imprisonment, the first three years to be served in prison and the rest of the term in a special-regime penal colony, with the time already spent in custody counted toward the sentence. The court accepted as mitigating circumstances his active assistance to the investigation, his confession, his chronic illnesses, his disability, his young age and his positive references, and found an aggravating circumstance connected with the means he had used. It granted the civil claims of the victims and of the relatives of the dead, which totaled 25.2 million rubles.

The verdict did not answer the question the case had raised from its first morning. He never explained his motives, and the legal finding of hooligan motives was the court's description of the crime, not an account from him.

Both sides went to the Fourth Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction in Nizhny Novgorod. In the summer of 2023 it upheld the life sentence while changing the verdict on points raised in the prosecutors' own appeal. It excluded three items from the evidence: the results of a trace examination, the testimony of one witness and one record of an inspection of the scene. It removed the aggravating circumstances on one of the charges and reduced the sentences on several of the other charges. None of these changes touched the life term for the murders.

Bekmansurov then filed a cassation complaint with the Supreme Court of Russia. On May 7, 2024, its Judicial Board for Criminal Cases left the complaint unsatisfied and the verdict unchanged. With that ruling the conviction and the life sentence were final, and as of May 2024 he was serving life imprisonment in Russia.

The central question in the case remains open. Bekmansurov admitted his guilt at every stage but refused to testify and never explained why he killed. The court's finding of hooligan motives is a legal classification, not his account.

His mental state was argued but settled in law. He said he considered himself mentally ill; the court-ordered examination found him sane and able to understand his actions, while recording a schizoid personality disorder, and the courts accepted the finding of sanity.

The count of the wounded rose from two dozen on the first day to the fifty-nine people covered by the attempted-murder counts; the six deaths were never in doubt after the afternoon of September 20, 2021.

Timeline

June 2021: Bekmansurov finishes School No. 60 in Perm.

Early September 2021: He is admitted to the law faculty of Perm State University in an additional intake.

September 20, 2021: Six people are killed and dozens injured in Perm; he is detained and wounded the same morning; the Investigative Committee opens a case under Article 105, Part 2; that night the names of the six dead are published.

September 24, 2021: Health officials say he has regained consciousness.

October 14, 2021: The Dzerzhinsky District Court of Perm, sitting in the hospital, orders two months' custody.

January 2022: A psychological and psychiatric examination finds him sane.

July 25, 2022: The Investigative Committee completes the investigation.

September 5, 2022: Trial opens at the Perm Territory Court; he admits guilt in full.

November 28, 2022: The prosecution asks for life imprisonment.

November 29, 2022: His final statement; he asks the court not to impose a life term.

December 28, 2022: Convicted on all counts and sentenced to life imprisonment.

Summer 2023: The Fourth Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction in Nizhny Novgorod upholds the life sentence and amends parts of the verdict.

May 7, 2024: The Supreme Court of Russia rejects his cassation complaint; the verdict stands.