Tihomir Blaškić was the commander of the Croatian Defense Council, the Bosnian Croat army known as the HVO, in the Central Bosnian Operative Zone during the war between Bosnian Croats and Bosnian Muslims in 1993. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia tried him for a campaign of crimes against the Muslim population of the Lašva Valley, among them the attack on the village of Ahmići on April 16, 1993. On March 3, 2000, Trial Chamber I found him guilty on 19 counts of grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, violations of the laws or customs of war and crimes against humanity, and sentenced him to 45 years' imprisonment.
Four years later the Appeals Chamber took most of that judgment apart. Working with the trial record and more than a hundred items of new evidence drawn largely from Croatian archives opened after the death of President Franjo Tuđman, it reversed every conviction connected with Ahmići and the other attacked villages, including the counts of wilful killing and murder. It affirmed three counts: inhuman treatment of Muslim detainees held in Vitez, cruel treatment for ordering detainees to dig trenches, and inhuman treatment arising from the use of detainees as human shields. On July 29, 2004, it sentenced him to nine years. Having already spent more than eight years in custody, he was released four days later. He has no final conviction for any death. The Prosecution tried to reopen the case and failed in November 2006.
Blaškić was born on November 2, 1960, in Brestovsko, in the municipality of Kiseljak, in central Bosnia. He trained at the Military Academy in Belgrade and served as a career officer in the Yugoslav People's Army, the JNA, where he rose to the rank of captain first class. By early 1992 he had resigned from the JNA and was in Vienna. In his own account to the Tribunal, the municipal council of Kiseljak called him back that February to help organize the defense of the municipality against Serb forces.
At first, Croats and Muslims in Kiseljak worked together toward that end. The partnership did not hold. Bosnia and Herzegovina declared independence on April 6, 1992. On April 8 the Bosnian Croats, organized within the Croatian Community of Herceg-Bosna, established the HVO as both a military and a political body, and a day after that the Muslims formed the Territorial Defense, which by the end of 1992 had become the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the ABiH. On April 10, the president of Herceg-Bosna outlawed the Territorial Defense on Herceg-Bosna territory. On May 11, 1992, Blaškić signed an order in Kiseljak stating that the only lawful military units in the municipality were HVO units and that the Territorial Defense was unlawful there.
On June 27, 1992, Blaškić, then a colonel, was appointed commander of the HVO's Central Bosnian Operative Zone. The appointment was ordered by a general of the army of the Republic of Croatia, and the zone took in the municipalities of Vitez, Busovača and Kiseljak, the heart of the Lašva Valley northwest of Sarajevo. The 1991 census had counted Muslims and Croats there in nearly equal numbers: 11,514 Muslims and 12,675 Croats in Vitez, 8,451 and 9,093 in Busovača, and 9,778 and 12,550 in Kiseljak.
Through the second half of 1992 the relationship between the two communities deteriorated. The Trial Chamber described rising incidents, the first destruction of mosques and Muslim property, and a contest for control of villages and former military depots, all set against the larger war with Serb forces nearby. Blaškić, meanwhile, built a brigade structure within his zone, and in September 1992 he sat on the interim presidency of the HVO for the municipalities of central Bosnia. His headquarters were in Vitez.
On January 2, 1993, the Vance-Owen peace plan proposed dividing Bosnia and Herzegovina into ten largely autonomous provinces, most of the Lašva Valley falling in a province where the Croats would hold the main responsibilities. On January 15, the president of Herceg-Bosna issued an ultimatum to the Muslims of the area to hand over their arms. When they refused, HVO forces moved against them. Hundreds of Muslims were arrested in the weeks that followed. The Trial Chamber found that many were beaten and that most were made to dig trenches.
A second ultimatum followed on April 15, 1993. That day Blaškić issued orders to his brigades, to the military police and to the Vitezovi, an independent special unit, placing them on the highest level of readiness. On April 16 he issued what he called a combat order to the Vitez Brigade and other units, telling them to block the villages in the defense area and prevent movement in and out.
On April 16, HVO forces moved against Vitez, Stari Vitez, Ahmići, Šantići, Pirići and Nadioci in the Vitez municipality, and against villages in the neighboring Busovača municipality. Over the following days the operations spread to Kiseljak, where villages north of the town were taken between April 18 and 21, and they returned to southern Kiseljak in June. The Trial Chamber found that, across the valley, Muslim civilians were killed or wounded, mosques were destroyed or damaged, Muslim property was plundered and set alight, and families were separated, the men detained and the women, children and elderly left with no choice but to leave. On April 18, an attack in Stari Vitez that both chambers later accepted as a crime against humanity took further lives; the Appeals Chamber found no evidence cited that Blaškić ordered it.
Ahmići, in the Vitez municipality, was a village with a strong Muslim majority. The Trial Chamber found that at least 103 people were killed there, a count drawn from the European Community Monitoring Mission. No soldier of the HVO, its military police or any other unit was punished for what happened in Ahmići. The Trial Chamber found that Blaškić did not call for an investigation until early May 1993; the Appeals Chamber found that the evidence supported his account that he asked for one.
The crimes on which Blaškić's final conviction rests concern the men and women HVO forces detained in and around Vitez during and after the April fighting. In the town itself, Bosnian Muslims were held in the Vitez Cultural Centre and in the town's veterinary station, both close to Blaškić's headquarters. The Appeals Chamber found that he knew they were held there unlawfully, that he knew the conditions of their detention were unlawful, and that, although he had effective control over the subordinates responsible, he neither punished them nor reported the crimes to the competent authorities. That is count 15, inhuman treatment as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions, and he stands convicted of it as a superior.
Detainees across the zone were taken to the front lines to dig trenches and build fortifications. The Appeals Chamber held that compelling people who take no part in the fighting to prepare military works against the side they identify with is a serious attack on human dignity and constitutes cruel treatment, and that Blaškić had ordered trenches to be dug by detainees in specific instances. That is count 16, cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war.
On April 20, 1993, during fighting in Vitez, detainees were brought out and kept in front of Blaškić's headquarters as protection against the opposing army. They were threatened and told they might be killed, and they were treated in a way meant to frighten and humiliate them. The Appeals Chamber found that this caused them serious mental harm and amounted to a serious attack on human dignity. It found no proof that Blaškić had positively ordered it. It held him responsible instead for a deliberate omission to protect people in his forces' custody. That is count 19, inhuman treatment as a grave breach.
The Tribunal's Prosecutor indicted Blaškić on November 10, 1995, together with five other men. He surrendered voluntarily on April 1, 1996, was flown to The Hague the same day and pleaded not guilty. His case was separated from the others, and amendments brought the indictment to 19 counts. It charged him with personal responsibility under Article 7(1) of the Tribunal's Statute and with superior responsibility under Article 7(3) for crimes committed between May 1, 1992, and January 31, 1994: persecutions, murder and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity; wilful killing, wilfully causing great suffering, extensive destruction of property, inhuman treatment and the taking of civilians as hostages as grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions of 1949; and unlawful attacks on civilians and civilian objects, murder, violence to life and person, plunder, destruction of religious and educational institutions, cruel treatment and the taking of hostages as violations of the laws or customs of war.
The trial opened on June 24, 1997, and ran into the summer of 1999. Blaškić testified in his own defense from February 17 to May 8, 1999. His case was that he had been besieged in Vitez by a Muslim army bent on cutting the valley apart, that his communications with outlying units were broken, that his troops were poorly trained men who listened to local authorities more readily than to him, and that the worst crimes, Ahmići first among them, were the work of units outside his chain of command, chiefly the military police and its special unit known as the Jokers, and the Vitezovi. He pointed to the many written orders in which he had told his forces to respect humanitarian law, and he argued that the law of the time permitted detainees to be put to work digging trenches.
The judges rejected nearly all of it. They found that he had built and used a working chain of command, that the military police and the Vitezovi had been placed under him before the attack of April 16, and that his orders of April 15 and 16 were genuine attack orders. They found that the operation against the Muslim population had been planned, that its object was to make that population leave, and that Blaškić had redeployed forces he knew had committed crimes. They also noted his humanitarian orders and other measures for civilians, and concluded that these did not outweigh the rest.
On March 3, 2000, the Trial Chamber found Blaškić guilty on every count before it. It held that the conflict was international in character because the Republic of Croatia exercised overall control over Herceg-Bosna and the HVO, a finding that opened the grave-breaches provisions of the Geneva Conventions. It convicted him of ordering persecution as a crime against humanity in Ahmići, Nadioci, Pirići, Šantići, Očehnići, Vitez, Stari Vitez, Donja Večeriska, Gačice, Lončari, Grbavica and a list of villages in Kiseljak, and of the underlying counts, wilful killing and murder among them. The disposition added that, in any event, as a commander he had failed to prevent the crimes or punish those who committed them.
The chamber acquitted him of one part of the case. Many civilians died in Zenica on April 19, 1993, in an attack the judges considered likely to have come from the HVO, but they found the evidence insufficient to hold Blaškić accountable for it.
In mitigation the court weighed his voluntary surrender, his cooperation with the Prosecution, his indirect role, the context of the war and the remorse he expressed, though it found that remorse in conflict with orders it held had led to the crimes. In aggravation it weighed the number of victims, his motives and the planned character of the attack on Ahmići, and it held that the aggravating factors clearly outweighed the mitigating ones. It imposed a single sentence of 45 years.
Blaškić appealed; the Prosecution did not. The appeal turned as much on evidence as on law. Croatia had not cooperated fully with the Tribunal during the trial, and its archives opened only after Tuđman died in December 1999. Blaškić asked the Appeals Chamber to admit thousands of pages of new material. It ruled that a retrial was not warranted, admitted 108 items and heard witnesses in December 2003.
The Appeals Chamber first corrected the law. The trial court had held that a commander who orders an act knowing there is any risk of crimes, and accepts that risk, is responsible for them. The Appeals Chamber held that the risk must be a substantial likelihood: a person who orders an act with awareness of the substantial likelihood that a crime will be committed in its execution has the required state of mind. On superior responsibility, it held that a commander is liable only if information available to him put him on notice of his subordinates' offenses. It ruled that a conviction under both Article 7(1) and Article 7(3) for the same count on the same facts was a legal error, and it found that the trial judgment had defined persecution too broadly. It agreed with Blaškić that the second amended indictment had not pleaded the material facts with enough particularity, but found that the defects had not made his trial unfair.
He also argued that Bosnian Muslims held by Bosnian Croats could not be protected persons under the Fourth Geneva Convention, and that Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina had been co-belligerents. The Appeals Chamber rejected both arguments, holding that the two states had been in conflict with each other. Counts 15 and 19, both grave breaches, rest on that holding.
Then the Appeals Chamber applied those standards to the facts, assessing the trial evidence together with the new material. On Ahmići it concluded that the trial evidence did not support the finding that Muslim forces were not preparing for combat in the area, and that the additional evidence showed a Muslim military presence in the village and gave Blaškić reason to believe the ABiH meant to attack along that axis. No reasonable trier of fact could have found that his order of April 16 was issued with the intention that the crimes in Ahmići be committed. The new evidence pointed to the military police and the Jokers as the perpetrators and identified others as responsible for planning and ordering what happened there. It also showed that those units did not recognize his authority and that his orders to them were not carried out, so he lacked the effective control that superior responsibility requires. The evidence supported his account that he asked for an investigation into Ahmići, that a security service in Mostar took it over, and that he was never told the results or the names of those responsible. A majority reversed every conviction for Ahmići, Šantići, Pirići and Nadioci; one judge dissented.
The chamber reversed the remaining findings on the attacked villages unanimously. It could not find beyond reasonable doubt that the April 16 attack on Vitez itself was directed at civilians, or that Blaškić ordered the July 18 attack on Stari Vitez with awareness that civilians would be targeted. It found no direct evidence that he ordered the attacks on Lončari and Očehnići in Busovača, and no evidence that he ordered the June 1993 attacks in Kiseljak. On the April operations in Kiseljak it held that the orders had military motives and did not prove an intent to drive out civilians. The counts of hostage-taking fell because an order to defend Vitez did not make him responsible for someone else's unlawful choice to take hostages.
What remained were three counts. The chamber affirmed his conviction under count 15, inhuman treatment as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions, as a superior for the detention-related crimes in the two Vitez facilities; under count 16, cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war, for ordering the use of protected persons to build defensive military installations; and under count 19, inhuman treatment as a grave breach, for the inhuman treatment of detainees occasioned by their use as human shields. None of the three is a killing offense.
The chamber then sentenced him afresh. It found two aggravating circumstances: his position as a colonel and regional commander, and the fact that many of the victims of his crimes were civilians. Against them it set his voluntary surrender, his good character with no previous convictions, his conduct at trial and in detention, his personal circumstances including his health, more than eight years in detention awaiting a final outcome, his circumstances at the outbreak of the war and, contrary to the trial court, his real and sincere remorse. By majority, with the same judge dissenting, the chamber imposed nine years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since April 1, 1996.
The Tribunal's President granted early release on the day of the appeal judgment, before any transfer to a state to serve the sentence. The release took effect on August 2, 2004, and Blaškić returned to Zagreb.
On July 29, 2005, a year to the day after the appeal judgment, the Prosecution asked the Appeals Chamber to review or reconsider it, putting forward six alleged new facts, most aimed at restoring his responsibility for Ahmići. On November 23, 2006, the Appeals Chamber dismissed the request in its entirety. It found that none of the six was a new fact, since each was either already in issue or merely more evidence on a point the parties had litigated, and it held that it had no inherent power to reconsider a final judgment. With that decision the case against him came to an end. His sentence was fully served with his release in 2004, and no other conviction stands against him.
The central dispute in the case is responsibility for Ahmići. The Trial Chamber found that Blaškić ordered the attack, commanded the units that carried it out and failed to punish them. The Appeals Chamber, by majority, found none of that proved beyond reasonable doubt once the new evidence was weighed, and one appeals judge dissented on that ground and on the sentence. The Prosecution's attempt to reopen the issue in 2005 was dismissed without reaching the merits of its new material, because the court held that none of it was a new fact.
Blaškić has no final conviction for any death. The Trial Chamber's convictions for wilful killing and murder, and for persecution, unlawful attacks, destruction and plunder, were all reversed or left without a finding on July 29, 2004. His only final convictions are counts 15, 16 and 19, inhuman and cruel treatment of detainees. The appeal judgment did not decide who planned and ordered the crimes in Ahmići; it said only that documents admitted on appeal identified others as responsible.
His command role after the war is recorded in two forms. One Tribunal summary records his promotion to general and his appointment as commander of the HVO at the beginning of August 1994; the Trial Chamber described him serving between June and October 1994 as the HVO's deputy chief of staff responsible for investigating war crimes. The Trial Chamber also recorded that he later held the rank of general in the General Inspectorate of the army of the Republic of Croatia.
November 2, 1960: born in Brestovsko, Kiseljak municipality, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
1979 to 1980: trains at the Military Academy in Belgrade; later serves in the JNA, reaching captain first class.
February 1992: called back from Vienna to Kiseljak after resigning from the JNA.
April 8, 1992: the HVO is established; the Territorial Defense is formed the next day.
May 11, 1992: signs an order declaring the Territorial Defense unlawful in Kiseljak.
June 27, 1992: appointed commander of the HVO Central Bosnian Operative Zone with the rank of colonel.
January 15, 1993: first ultimatum to the Muslims of central Bosnia; mass arrests follow.
April 15 and 16, 1993: issues readiness and combat orders; HVO forces move against Ahmići, Vitez and neighboring villages.
April 18 to 21, 1993: villages north of Kiseljak are taken.
April 20, 1993: detainees are held in front of his headquarters in Vitez as human shields.
June to September 1993: further operations in southern Kiseljak, Stari Vitez and Grbavica.
August 1994: promoted to general and appointed HVO commander.
November 10, 1995: ICTY indictment confirmed.
April 1, 1996: surrenders voluntarily and is transferred to The Hague.
June 24, 1997: trial opens before Trial Chamber I.
February 17 to May 8, 1999: testifies in his own defense.
March 3, 2000: convicted at trial on 19 counts, wilful killing and murder among them, and sentenced to 45 years.
July 29, 2004: Appeals Chamber reverses the convictions for wilful killing and murder and every other count tied to the attacked villages, affirms counts 15, 16 and 19 (inhuman and cruel treatment of detainees) and imposes nine years; early release granted.
August 2, 2004: released and returns to Zagreb.
July 29, 2005: Prosecution requests review.
November 23, 2006: Appeals Chamber dismisses the review request.