Thomas Thurmond and John Holmes

Victims
1 man kidnapped for ransom and killed, 1933; accused never tried. Both accused men were lynched before trial; Thurmond confessed and named Holmes, who denied it.
Years active
November 9, 1933
Location
San Jose, California (kidnapping; place of the killing not established by any court); San Francisco, California (federal indictment); San Jose, California (jail; lynching)
Method
Cause of death not established by any court (no trial was held); the account of the killing rests on Thurmond's confession, which no court tested.
Status
No trial, verdict or sentence; federal and state kidnapping charges pending. Both lynched by a mob before trial, San Jose, California, November 26, 1933 (killed before trial).

On the evening of November 9, 1933, Brooke Hart was kidnapped in San Jose, California, and held for a ransom of $40,000. He was popular in his city, and his disappearance became national news. Within a week two San Jose men, Thomas Harold Thurmond and John Maurice Holmes, were under arrest. Thurmond confessed and named Holmes as his partner. Holmes denied any part in it. On November 22 a federal grand jury in San Francisco indicted both men, and they were sent back to San Jose to face state kidnapping charges that could carry a death sentence. They never stood trial.

Because neither man was tried, no court ever weighed the confession, the denial or the evidence said to tie them to the crime. What survives is an accusation that was never tested.

Thurmond was arrested in San Jose on November 15, 1933. He confessed, and in his confession he named Holmes as his accomplice; Holmes was arrested in the city soon afterward. Thurmond's account, which no court ever examined, described the kidnapping and killing as the work of both men and put the young man's death on the night he was taken.

Holmes gave a different answer. He denied any wrongdoing, and an alibi was offered on his behalf. By early December, national coverage was describing both men as having confessed. What Holmes himself said, and whether he would have stood by it before a jury, was never settled.

The two men faced the law on two levels at once: the federal indictment returned in San Francisco, and the state charges that held them in the Santa Clara County jail in San Jose. No trial date was reached in either court. On November 26, 1933, the day the young man's death was confirmed, a mob took Thurmond and Holmes from the jail and lynched them. Seven people were later arrested over the lynching, and none was convicted.

Neither man was convicted of anything. The account of the kidnapping and of the young man's death rests on Thurmond's confession, which no jury weighed and no defense lawyer cross-examined. Whether it was freely given, and how far it could have been used against Holmes, were questions a trial would have settled.

Holmes's part is the largest open question. He denied wrongdoing after his arrest and an alibi was offered for him; later national coverage spoke of both men as confessed, but the content of any statement Holmes made, and whether he would have repudiated it in court, was never established. The lynching ended both cases before any of this could be tried.

Timeline

November 9, 1933: A young San Jose man is kidnapped in San Jose and held for a $40,000 ransom.

November 15, 1933: Thomas Harold Thurmond is arrested in San Jose; he confesses and names John Maurice Holmes.

November 1933: Holmes is arrested in San Jose and denies wrongdoing.

November 22, 1933: A federal grand jury in San Francisco indicts both men; they are returned to San Jose to face state kidnapping charges.

November 26, 1933: The victim's death is confirmed; that night a mob takes Thurmond and Holmes from the Santa Clara County jail and lynches them, before any trial.

After November 26, 1933: Seven people are arrested over the lynching; none is convicted.