On the morning of Thursday, November 14, 1991, four employees of the post office in Royal Oak, Michigan, a suburb about ten miles north of downtown Detroit, were killed and four more were wounded. Police attributed the killings to Thomas McIlvane, a 31-year-old letter carrier from neighboring Oak Park who had worked there until his dismissal the year before. He died by suicide the next day. He was never charged with any crime and never stood trial, and no court ever heard the evidence.
The killings came one day after an arbitrator rejected his appeal against the dismissal, the last step in a grievance that had run for more than a year. For most of that year his co-workers had heard him say what he would do if he lost. A committee of the United States House of Representatives later spent seven months asking how a man who had issued so many threats, in front of so many witnesses, could come back to the building. What it found was a chain of failures that began on the day the Postal Service hired him.
Before he joined the Postal Service, McIlvane served in the Marine Corps, and he left it with a general discharge under honorable conditions, a lesser grade than an honorable discharge. The Postal Service hired him in January 1985 as a custodian and made him a letter carrier in 1986. The House committee found that its screening at the time "did not include interviewing past employers," so the problems in his military record went unnoticed.
His years as a carrier were marked by conflict with management. His disciplinary files describe vulgar and disrespectful conduct toward supervisors and record, again and again, his belief that management was out to get him. The files tell only one side, and the committee's own findings cast doubt on how they were compiled: discipline at Royal Oak, "including discipline of Mr. McIlvane, was not used properly," and the process there "had become counterproductive."
He was removed from the Postal Service in 1990. Through his union he challenged the removal, and the case went to arbitration. The committee compared it with the ten previous removal arbitrations in the Detroit area and found that his had taken far longer than any of them. "One year is an unconscionable time period to complete a grievance arbitration proceeding on a removal," it wrote, adding that such a period "indicates dilatory tactics."
Throughout that year McIlvane talked openly about violence. Co-workers said he told his supervisors that if he did not get his job back he was going to get "even," and that he predicted he would come back to the post office. He spoke of an earlier killing at a post office in Oklahoma and said that what happened in Royal Oak would be worse. After the termination process began, his files record 21 separate threats to kill his managers.
The committee found that he "issued many threats in the presence of employees," and that nobody with the power to act on them did. Employees said they had reported the threats to the Postal Inspection Service, the agency's own law enforcement arm, but the Inspection Service had no record of most of those contacts. There was no established procedure at Royal Oak or in the Detroit Division for reporting threats, and the committee found that the Inspection Service's performance evaluations were "designed in a manner which discourages Inspectors from investigating threats." Neither union had any procedure for a member who threatened violence, and the local union officials who handled his grievance did not pass his threats to Royal Oak management.
The post office he returned to was already troubled. The committee found that managers with a history of labor and management problems in Indianapolis had been transferred or promoted to Royal Oak without any independent review by Postal Service headquarters, so the problems traveled with them. Complaints from Royal Oak employees had also reached the office of one of Michigan's United States senators, and a staff memorandum dated September 10, 1991, after two months of inquiry, summarized patterns of harassment and intimidation, allegations of favoritism, and very poor labor relations. The facility had no security control officer, and its management did not know the position was required.
On Wednesday, November 13, 1991, the arbitrator rejected McIlvane's appeal and upheld his dismissal. The next morning, by the police account, he came back to the Royal Oak post office. Four employees were killed and four others were wounded, and police attributed every one of those deaths and injuries to him.
Christopher Carlisle lived in Rochester, Michigan. He grew up in Tucson, Arizona, served in the Army in Germany and came to Michigan from Indianapolis. Keith Ciszewski lived in Livonia. Mary Benincasa lived in Clinton Township, and Rose Marie Proos lived in Sterling Heights.
McIlvane died by suicide on Friday, November 15, 1991. Because he died before he could be charged, the facts of that morning rest on the police account and on the later federal inquiries, not on any verdict.
The House Committee on Post Office and Civil Service released its report on June 15, 1992, seven months after the killings. Its findings ran in a straight line from his hiring to the morning he returned: screening that missed his record; threats made openly in front of employees, union representatives and supervisors; no procedure for reporting threats and no record of most of the reports employees said they made; inspection rules that discouraged the investigation of threats; unions with no way to handle a threatening member; discipline that had become counterproductive; managers transferred from Indianapolis without review; no security control officer; and an arbitration that took more than a year. "This tragedy, like every other," the committee wrote, "has lessons to be learned and not to be ignored."
Because McIlvane was never tried, his responsibility for the four deaths rests on the police account and the House committee's report rather than on any verdict, and no court ever examined his state of mind. The reason for his dismissal was itself reported two ways: postal officials called it insubordination, while early wire reports spoke of time-card fraud. Early wire reports also put the number of wounded at six or seven; later reporting and the committee's account give four.
January 1985: McIlvane is hired by the Postal Service as a custodian.
1986: He becomes a letter carrier.
1990: He is removed from the Postal Service and contests the removal through his union.
September 10, 1991: A staff memorandum from a U.S. senator's office summarizes a two-month inquiry into harassment and poor labor relations at the Royal Oak post office.
November 13, 1991: An arbitrator rejects his appeal and upholds the dismissal.
November 14, 1991: Four postal employees are killed and four wounded at the Royal Oak post office; police attribute the deaths to McIlvane.
November 15, 1991: McIlvane dies by suicide, uncharged.
June 15, 1992: The House Committee on Post Office and Civil Service releases its report on the killings.