Thomas Ketchum

Victims
Train assault near Folsom, New Mexico Territory, 1899; no deaths. Convicted 1900 of assault upon a railway train with intent to commit a felony, a capital crime; no homicide conviction.
Years active
Offense of conviction: August 16, 1899; attributed deaths 1895 to 1899
Location
San Saba County and Tom Green County, Texas; Liberty, Folsom and Clayton, New Mexico Territory; Camp Verde, Arizona Territory; Trinidad, Colorado
Method
Train robbery; assault upon a railway train with intent to commit a felony; homicides attributed but never tried
Status
Sentenced to death, 1900; appeal rejected by the Supreme Court of the Territory of New Mexico, 1901; executed at Clayton, April 26, 1901

Thomas Edward Ketchum was executed at Clayton, in the Territory of New Mexico, on April 26, 1901, for a crime in which no one died. On August 16, 1899, he made a lone attempt on a Colorado and Southern passenger train near Folsom. It failed, he was taken into custody the next day, and a year later a Union County court found him guilty of assault upon a railway train with intent to commit a felony. Under the territorial law of the day that offense carried the death penalty, and he became the only person ever put to death under it.

The killings that followed his name across Texas, New Mexico and Arizona never reached a courtroom. A Texas grand jury indicted him for one death in 1896, and the case was never tried. Two men died in eastern New Mexico that same year, and no one was charged. Two more died at Camp Verde, Arizona, in July 1899, and Arizona asked New Mexico to hand him over; the request was refused because the territory meant to try him first for the train. On the morning he died he admitted robbing trains and denied ever having killed anyone. His case is a record of one conviction and a longer list of accusations that stayed accusations.

Ketchum was born on October 31, 1863, in San Saba County, Texas, and worked as a cowhand in west Texas. About 1890 he left the state for cow outfits in the Pecos Valley of New Mexico, and by 1894 his older brother had joined him there.

On December 12, 1895, John N. Powers died in Tom Green County, Texas. A grand jury indicted Ketchum and two other men for the killing early in 1896, the nearest any court came to a homicide charge against him. None of the three was tried for it. In 1901 Ketchum acknowledged his own part in the death in court, but the indictment stayed open for the rest of his life.

By the summer of 1896 the brothers were living as fugitives in eastern New Mexico. On June 11, 1896, two men lost their lives near Liberty, a small settlement in the territory: Levi Herzstein and Merejildo Gallegos. The men sought afterward were the Ketchum brothers and their companions. Which of them caused the deaths is not established, and no one was ever charged with either death.

The brothers turned next to the railways. Through 1897 the gang held up trains in Texas and the New Mexico Territory, among them a Colorado and Southern passenger train near Folsom in September of that year, a holdup for which Ketchum was among the men indicted. In 1898 a quarrel split the band. The gang came to be blamed for many robberies it may not have committed.

On July 2, 1899, two men died at Camp Verde, in Yavapai County, Arizona Territory: Mack Rogers and Clinton Wingfield.

The deaths were attributed to Ketchum, and once he was in New Mexico's hands the Territory of Arizona sought his extradition by a writ of requisition. New Mexico's territorial governor refused it, so that the train case in his own territory could be tried first. Ketchum was never tried in Arizona, and in Camp Verde the identity of the actual killer is still regarded as unknown.

On July 11, 1899, his brother and others held up the Colorado and Southern train near Folsom once more. Ketchum was not with them; he had parted from the band after the quarrel of 1898. His brother was captured and died at the territorial penitentiary at Santa Fe on July 24, 1899. None of the deaths from that raid was ever attributed to Thomas Ketchum.

On August 16, 1899, Ketchum went back to the same railway alone and tried to stop the Colorado and Southern train near Folsom. The attempt failed, and the next day, August 17, he was taken into custody. He was held first at Trinidad, Colorado, and later at Clayton, the seat of Union County, where the attempt had taken place. For more than a year he waited on the territory's prosecutors.

Before the territory tried him, the United States did. The holdup had interfered with a mail train, and in federal court he faced a charge of delaying the passage of the United States mail. He pleaded guilty. The territory's prosecution was the one that could cost him his life.

That prosecution began at Clayton in September 1900. The charge was assault upon a railway train with intent to commit a felony, brought under the territorial statute that made an attack on a train for the purpose of robbery or another felony a capital crime. Ketchum pleaded not guilty. He was convicted in September 1900, and the court sentenced him to death. The sentence fell on a man who had killed no one in the offense for which he stood trial: the charge required only the assault upon the train and the intent behind it, and the territory's law fixed death as the penalty.

Ketchum's lawyers took the case to the Supreme Court of the Territory of New Mexico. Early in 1901 the court rejected the appeal and left the conviction and the sentence standing. The execution, first set for March 22, 1901, was postponed more than once before it was fixed for April 26.

Ketchum was executed at Clayton on April 26, 1901. He was the first and only person executed under the territorial law that made an assault on a train a capital offense.

Ketchum was convicted of one crime, the assault upon the train near Folsom, and that offense involved no death. Every killing attached to his name is unproven in law.

The 1895 death in Tom Green County led to an indictment, but no trial, verdict or plea.

The two deaths near Liberty in 1896 were laid to the Ketchum brothers and their companions, but who caused them was never established and no charge was ever brought.

The two deaths at Camp Verde in 1899 were laid to him strongly enough for Arizona to seek his surrender. The request was refused, he was never tried for them, and the killer is still regarded locally as unidentified.

The wider totals of dead laid to the gang were never tested in any court. On the morning of his execution, Ketchum denied that he had ever killed anyone.

Timeline

October 31, 1863: born in San Saba County, Texas.

About 1890: leaves Texas for the Pecos Valley of New Mexico.

1894: his older brother joins him in New Mexico.

December 12, 1895: a man dies in Tom Green County, Texas; Ketchum is indicted with two other men early in 1896.

June 11, 1896: two men die near Liberty, New Mexico Territory; no one is charged.

September 1897: Colorado and Southern train held up near Folsom; Ketchum is among the men indicted.

1898: the gang splits after a quarrel.

July 2, 1899: two men die at Camp Verde, Arizona Territory; the deaths are attributed to Ketchum.

July 11, 1899: his brother's band holds up the train near Folsom without him.

July 24, 1899: his brother dies at Santa Fe.

August 16, 1899: Ketchum's lone attempt on the Colorado and Southern train near Folsom.

August 17, 1899: taken into custody; later held at Trinidad and Clayton.

September 1900: tried and convicted at Clayton of assault upon a railway train with intent to commit a felony; sentenced to death.

Early 1901: the Supreme Court of the Territory of New Mexico rejects his appeal.

April 26, 1901: executed at Clayton.