Thomas DelGiorno spent the first half of the 1980s climbing the ranks of the crime family that Nicodemo Scarfo ran from South Philadelphia and Atlantic City. He ran the family's most profitable numbers business for a decade, was inducted as a full member in January 1982, made acting captain in the fall of 1984 and full captain in February 1986. By the late summer of that year Scarfo had stripped him of his rank, and DelGiorno learned, as he later told a detective, that he was scheduled to be killed. In about November 1986 he and another member of the family, Nicholas Caramandi, went to federal authorities and agreed to tell what they knew.
What they knew included murder. Testifying under a plea agreement at the federal racketeering trial of Scarfo and sixteen others in October 1988, DelGiorno told the jury that he had taken part, on Scarfo's instructions, in the killing of John Calabrese, an associate of the family, in Philadelphia in October 1981. He and Caramandi also testified at a state trial that they had been part of the plot against a captain of the family in September 1984. No murder conviction of DelGiorno himself is on record. He testified, in the words of the federal appeals court, "pursuant to a plea agreement with the government," and by July 1989 he had been sentenced to five years in prison. He and Caramandi became the witnesses on whose credibility the government's racketeering case against the family largely depended.
DelGiorno's money came from gambling. He ran a numbers business from 1976 until 1986, the year he began cooperating, and the federal appeals court that later reviewed the racketeering case described it as the most profitable numbers business the family had. He kept between ten and thirty salaried writers taking bets. Another associate began working for the operation in the late 1970s and managed it from the early 1980s until the middle of 1985. In 1982 DelGiorno went into partnership with another member of the family in a second numbers business in the Philadelphia area that ran until February 1986. In 1983 he and two other members, one of them Joseph Pungitore, whose name the racketeering appeal would later carry, each put $25,000 into a sports betting business.
He also owned a bar. Under oath at a public hearing in 1992, DelGiorno told the New Jersey State Commission of Investigation that he had owned Cous' Little Italy, a restaurant and bar in South Philadelphia, from about 1975 to 1982, that his partners were all fellow mobsters, and that Scarfo had taken a share of the money when he sold it. Philip Leonetti, Scarfo's nephew and later his underboss, gave the commission a fuller history: DelGiorno had bought the bar in the late 1970s from Leonetti's great-uncles, who had run it since the 1950s, and sold it in the early 1980s to another member of the family. DelGiorno also admitted to the commission that he had been a partner, with two other family members, in a second South Philadelphia club acquired in about 1982 or 1983, and that the partners sold it shortly after one of them was killed in September 1984.
The family DelGiorno served had been through a violent change of leadership. Its longtime boss, Angelo Bruno, was killed in 1980. His successor was killed in March 1981, and Scarfo became boss that month. The violence that began with Bruno's death lasted more than five years and took the lives of more than two dozen men in and around the organization.
According to Leonetti's account to the New Jersey commission, Scarfo ordered the 1981 killing not long after taking over. Scarfo believed that the victim had once tried to get close to him in order to set him up, and that after the March 1981 killing he had tried to extort money from the family with an invented story. Scarfo, Leonetti said, put a member he had just raised to captain in charge, and approved DelGiorno and two other associates, none of them yet a member, as the team.
The victim died in Philadelphia on October 6, 1981. Seven years later DelGiorno described the killing from the witness stand. The Third Circuit, summarizing the trial record, wrote that DelGiorno testified that he, the new captain and one of the other associates, acting on Scarfo's instructions, carried out the killing, and that the motive was a quarrel over money Scarfo wanted from the victim. Leonetti's account, given separately to the New Jersey commission, names the same men.
In January 1982, a few months after the killing, Scarfo inducted DelGiorno and the two other associates of the team into the family. After the ceremony Scarfo, Leonetti and the new members went to a restaurant to celebrate. DelGiorno later described to a jury what the step meant in the family's eyes: the difference, he said, between the minor leagues and the major leagues.
No separate trial for the 1981 killing is on record. DelGiorno's account of it was part of the evidence in the federal racketeering case that ended in convictions in November 1988.
The early years of DelGiorno's membership were years of open conflict inside the organization. From 1982 Scarfo was at war with a small faction led by Harry Riccobene. The racketeering case later charged attempts on Riccobene's life in June and August 1982, the attempted murder of Frank Martines in October 1983, and the murders of Salvatore Tamburrino in November 1983 and of Riccobene's younger brother, Robert, in December 1983.
One member of the 1981 team did not survive long. He was murdered on April 26, 1983, in a killing ordered from inside the family; the orders went to Caramandi and another associate. The same year the captain who had led the team went to prison, and the crew he had run with the murdered man passed in time to DelGiorno and his fellow inductee.
The crew's business was the shakedown. The captain had told DelGiorno that he had formed a crew with Scarfo's permission, and he suggested that DelGiorno form one of his own. Scarfo, Leonetti, DelGiorno and another member, the appeals court found, supplied the crews with the names of people to be squeezed, and DelGiorno was among those who carried the tally sheets to Scarfo or Leonetti. He testified that decisions about whom to approach needed his approval. In 1983, with the captain's authorization, he arranged a drug deal and handed half of the $150,000 proceeds to him. He told the jury that he had only made the introductions and had never handled the drugs himself.
In November 1984 Scarfo raised DelGiorno and his fellow inductee to acting captain, and in February 1986 to full captain; Scarfo announced the promotion at a making ceremony at which he also named Leonetti underboss. The rise did not last the year.
The second killing DelGiorno is tied to was that of a member of the family. Salvatore Testa, the son of the boss killed in March 1981, was a captain and DelGiorno's partner in the sports betting bank and the South Philadelphia club. He was killed in South Philadelphia on September 14, 1984.
DelGiorno and Caramandi testified in 1988 that they had been part of the plot, and Leonetti's account to the New Jersey commission names both men among those involved.
No one was convicted of the killing in the state prosecution. Scarfo and eight associates went on trial in the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia, and on May 10, 1988, the jury acquitted all nine on all 27 counts, including murder and conspiracy.
By 1986 DelGiorno's standing had collapsed. In the late summer of that year, Leonetti told the New Jersey commission, Scarfo held a meeting in the office of a South Philadelphia restaurant and announced that he had taken DelGiorno down from captain; anyone who had reported to DelGiorno would now report to his fellow inductee, the other acting captain. A detective of the New Jersey State Police Intelligence Bureau later testified that DelGiorno had agreed to cooperate after learning he was scheduled to be killed.
In about November 1986, DelGiorno and Caramandi went to federal authorities. Both, the New Jersey commission wrote, had decided to become government witnesses, and Scarfo and Leonetti understood at once how much the two men knew. Shortly after the defections Scarfo named a senior member acting consigliere and told his captains that this man would run the family once he and Leonetti were in prison. DelGiorno's numbers business ended with his cooperation; the sports betting bank of about $300,000 passed to Pungitore.
DelGiorno's information reached a courtroom within two months. At a federal bail hearing in Philadelphia in January 1987, after Scarfo's arrest on an extortion indictment, the State Police detective testified that he had learned of a list of intended victims from DelGiorno, and that DelGiorno had told him Scarfo had been present in person after two killings. Scarfo had not been charged with any of the deaths at that point; the information was offered to keep him in custody.
Three trials followed in quick succession, with DelGiorno and Caramandi as the government's principal witnesses in each. In August 1987 a federal jury convicted Scarfo, a Philadelphia city councilman and the councilman's aide of racketeering in a scheme to extort $1 million from a real estate developer. In December 1987 another federal jury acquitted Scarfo and associates of running a drug ring. In May 1988 came the state acquittals in the September 1984 killing.
The decisive case was the federal racketeering prosecution of Scarfo, Leonetti and fifteen other members and associates in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. The indictment charged a criminal enterprise that had committed murders, attempted murders, extortion, gambling, loan sharking and drug trafficking; the appeals court later counted thirty-nine predicate acts of racketeering behind the convictions. DelGiorno took the stand on October 10, 1988, and testified over several days about membership, the numbers and sports betting businesses, the shakedowns, the drug deal and the killings, including his own part in the 1981 killing. He also testified that Scarfo had told him and others that he had ordered the 1978 killing of a former municipal judge in Atlantic City, Edwin Helfant, and that a member of the family had described to him his own part in the 1982 attempt on the life of Joseph Salerno Sr. in Wildwood Crest, New Jersey.
The defense made the trial a contest over his credibility. Lawyers set out his criminal record, his plea agreement, his earlier inconsistent statements and the preparation of his accounts in FBI reports, and put it to him on cross-examination that New Jersey State Police officers had supplied his answers. He denied it. In November his son, called as a surprise defense witness, testified that FBI agents had coached, coerced and at times fabricated DelGiorno's testimony; law enforcement officers denied the claim, and an FBI agent who had guarded DelGiorno's family testified in rebuttal.
The trial ended on November 19, 1988. Scarfo and all sixteen co-defendants were convicted of racketeering and racketeering conspiracy; jurors found Scarfo guilty of directly taking part in eight killings. In May 1989 a federal judge sentenced Scarfo to 55 years. By the Mob Museum's account, DelGiorno's information helped the authorities solve 24 homicides and led within about three years to convictions for nine of them.
DelGiorno's information also led to the state murder prosecution for the July 1985 death of Frank D'Alfonso. In April 1989 a jury in the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia convicted Scarfo and co-defendants of that killing, and they were sentenced to life in prison. The verdict did not hold. On June 18, 1992, a panel of the Pennsylvania Superior Court overturned the convictions, ruling that the defendants had been denied a fair trial because of prosecutorial misconduct in the closing argument, and all were acquitted at a second trial.
DelGiorno's own sentence came under his plea agreement with the federal government. By July 1989 he had received five years in prison, and he was expected to serve no more than ten months. The charges covered by his plea are not on record. Caramandi, who pleaded guilty to racketeering, including conspiracy in several murder plots, and to extortion, was sentenced to eight years on July 26, 1989; by then he had testified in 11 trials that produced 52 convictions.
The racketeering convictions went to the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which decided the appeals in United States v. Pungitore on August 1, 1990. The court acknowledged that the government's case had depended largely on whether the jury believed DelGiorno and Caramandi, both of whom had plea agreements with favorable terms, and it found the prosecutor's rebuttal to the defense claim that agents had scripted their testimony largely a fair response.
DelGiorno testified in public once more in 1992, before the New Jersey State Commission of Investigation at a two-day hearing on organized crime's control of bars. DelGiorno, described by the commission as a former captain of the family, testified about his ownership of Cous' Little Italy and the other club, identified his partners, and, with a former associate whose identity was concealed for his protection, explained why organized crime was drawn to businesses holding liquor licenses: to launder money, and to have a safe place to meet and conduct illegal business, including the planning of murders. The two witnesses identified members and associates of seven La Cosa Nostra families who had held hidden interests in or influence over bars in New Jersey.
His date of birth, the place where he served his sentence, the date of his release and his present circumstances are not on record; the latest account of his sentence dates from July 1989.
No murder conviction of DelGiorno is on record. His part in the 1981 killing rests on his own testimony at the 1988 federal trial and on Leonetti's account to the New Jersey commission; no separate trial of that killing is on record. His part in the death of the captain in September 1984 rests on his and Caramandi's testimony and on Leonetti's account, and the state jury that heard the case acquitted all nine defendants. The defense case at every trial was that DelGiorno lied in exchange for leniency, and that agents shaped his testimony; the officers denied it, and the Third Circuit found the prosecutor's answer to those attacks largely fair.
The dates of his rise differ slightly between the official accounts. The appeals court gives his induction as about January 1982, his elevation to acting captain as the fall of 1984 and to full captain as February 1986; Leonetti's account to the New Jersey commission gives November 1984 for acting captain and describes the full-captain announcement at a ceremony in 1986. The claim that he had been marked for death came from a State Police detective relaying what DelGiorno had told him.
The count in the 1985 murder case also differs: the New Jersey commission's report gives six members and associates convicted on April 5, 1989, while UPI and the AP give Scarfo and seven others, eight in all, sentenced to life.
1976: Begins running the family's most profitable numbers business, which he keeps until 1986.
About 1975 or late 1970s to 1982: Owns Cous' Little Italy, a bar in South Philadelphia.
March 1981: Scarfo becomes boss of the family.
October 6, 1981: An associate of the family is killed in Philadelphia; DelGiorno later testifies that he took part on Scarfo's instructions.
January 1982: Inducted into the family by Scarfo, with the two other associates of the 1981 team.
1982: Partners with another member of the family in a second numbers business.
1983: Invests $25,000 in a sports betting business; arranges a drug deal with his captain's authorization.
April 26, 1983: One member of the 1981 team is murdered.
September 14, 1984: A captain of the family is killed in South Philadelphia; DelGiorno later testifies that he was part of the plot.
Fall (November) 1984: Made acting captain.
February 1986: Made full captain.
Late summer 1986: Scarfo announces that DelGiorno has been taken down from captain.
About November 1986: DelGiorno and Caramandi go to federal authorities.
January 14, 1987: A State Police detective testifies at Scarfo's bail hearing to information from DelGiorno.
August 1987: Scarfo convicted in the federal extortion case with DelGiorno as a witness.
December 1987: Scarfo acquitted in a federal drug case.
May 10, 1988: State jury acquits Scarfo and eight associates of the September 1984 killing.
October 10, 1988: DelGiorno begins testifying at the federal racketeering trial.
November 19, 1988: Scarfo and sixteen co-defendants convicted of racketeering.
April 5, 1989: Scarfo and co-defendants convicted in the 1985 murder case.
By July 1989: DelGiorno sentenced to five years in prison.
August 1, 1990: Third Circuit decides United States v. Pungitore.
1992: Testifies at the New Jersey State Commission of Investigation's hearing on bars.
June 18, 1992: Pennsylvania Superior Court overturns the 1985 murder convictions; the defendants are later acquitted on retrial.