Théoneste Bagosora was a colonel in the Rwandan army and the Director of Cabinet in the Ministry of Defense when the genocide of 1994 began. The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, tried him together with three other senior army officers in the case known as Military I. On December 18, 2008 Trial Chamber I convicted him of genocide, crimes against humanity and serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. On December 14, 2011 the Appeals Chamber affirmed his convictions for genocide, crimes against humanity, and serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II. It reversed a number of the trial findings, held him liable as a superior rather than directly for the crimes at roadblocks in the Kigali area, and entered a new sentence of 35 years. He died in Mali on September 25, 2021.
Four accused were tried jointly over 408 trial days. A central question was whether the highest levels of the army had planned the genocide in advance, and the Trial Chamber rejected the conspiracy charge against all four accused. The convictions that followed rested on the responsibility of the accused as superiors and, in part, on their own orders, and on appeal Bagosora's liability was settled as that of a superior.
Bagosora was born in 1941 in the prefecture of Gisenyi, in the north-west of Rwanda. He graduated from the officers' school in Kigali in 1964 as a second lieutenant and later took a certificate in advanced military studies at a French staff college. His postings included the post of second-in-command at the Ecole Supérieure Militaire in Kigali and command of the military camp at Kanombe.
He retired from the army on September 23, 1993 but kept his post as Director of Cabinet in the Ministry of Defense, which he held until he left Rwanda in July 1994. In that post he managed the ministry's day-to-day affairs when the Minister of Defense was absent. The Appeals Chamber later examined whether, in the days after the death of President Juvénal Habyarimana on April 6, 1994, Bagosora exercised effective control over the Rwandan armed forces. It upheld the finding that he was the highest military authority in the country from 6 to April 9, 1994, and that finding underlies his liability as a superior.
After leaving Rwanda in July 1994, Bagosora was detained in Yaoundé, Cameroon, on March 9, 1996 under an international arrest warrant issued by a Belgian investigating judge. The Tribunal's prosecutor asked that Belgium defer its own investigation and proceedings against him to the Tribunal, and the Trial Chamber granted the request. On May 17, 1996 a judge of the Tribunal ordered his provisional detention for up to thirty days and his transfer to the Tribunal's detention unit. The allegations at that stage included that he had masterminded massacres of Rwandan civilians and was responsible for the murder of ten Belgian soldiers serving with the United Nations mission in Rwanda.
He was transferred to the Tribunal's custody in Arusha on January 23, 1997. At his initial appearance on February 20, 1997 he pleaded not guilty to all charges.
The indictment against Bagosora contained twelve counts. They included conspiracy to commit genocide, genocide, complicity in genocide, direct and public incitement to genocide, crimes against humanity, and violations of the Geneva Conventions. The prosecution alleged that he had made speeches in 1994 inciting ethnic hatred and had ordered militia groups to kill Tutsi and moderate Hutu civilians; these were allegations in the indictment. His indictment was separate from the others, though his trial was joint with theirs.
Three other senior officers were tried with him. Anatole Nsengiyumva, a lieutenant colonel, had commanded military operations in the Gisenyi sector in 1993 and 1994 and had earlier been chief of military intelligence within the high command. Aloys Ntabakuze, a major, had commanded the Para-Commando Battalion. Gratien Kabiligi, a brigadier general, had been chief of military operations within the high command. Nsengiyumva faced eleven counts, and Ntabakuze and Kabiligi were charged in a joint indictment of ten counts. All four pleaded not guilty.
The joint trial was scheduled to open on April 2, 2002 before the Tribunal in Arusha. The prosecution rested its case on October 14, 2004 after calling 82 witnesses. The defense opened on April 11, 2005 and closed its case in January 2007 after 160 witnesses, bringing the total to 242 witnesses over 408 trial days. At the closing arguments on May 28, 2007 the prosecutor asked for life imprisonment for each of the four accused.
The Trial Chamber also dealt with the length of the accused's detention before the proceedings began. It found that the right of Kabiligi and Bagosora to an initial appearance without undue delay had been violated and treated a formal recognition of the violation as the appropriate remedy.
Three international judges delivered the judgment in Arusha on December 18, 2008. It ran to about 500 pages, and one of the judges read a summary in court.
The Trial Chamber convicted Bagosora of genocide; of crimes against humanity for murder, extermination, persecution, rape and other inhumane acts; and of serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II for violence to life and outrages upon personal dignity. It held him responsible under Articles 6(1) and 6(3) of the Tribunal's Statute and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The court found that he held the highest authority in the Ministry of Defense in the first days after the President's death and that he was responsible for the killing of the Prime Minister and of other officials on April 7, 1994, for the killing of ten Belgian peacekeepers at Camp Kigali, and for organised killings in Kigali and Gisenyi between 6 and April 9, 1994.
The Chamber did not find that the four accused had agreed on a plan to commit genocide before April 7, 1994. It reasoned that the evidence was also consistent with a political or military power struggle and with the continuing war with the Rwandan Patriotic Front, and that it was therefore not satisfied that conspiracy was the only reasonable inference. All four were acquitted of conspiracy to commit genocide. The judgment also recorded that the crimes were directed mainly at Tutsi civilians and at Hutu who were seen as sympathetic to the Rwandan Patriotic Front or as opponents of the regime, and that not every member of those groups had committed crimes.
For the co-accused the outcomes were these. Nsengiyumva was convicted of genocide, crimes against humanity and a serious violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and sentenced to life. Ntabakuze was convicted of the same categories of offense and sentenced to life. Kabiligi was acquitted of all counts and ordered released.
Bagosora and Nsengiyumva appealed together, and the Appeals Chamber, composed of five judges, scheduled its judgment for December 14, 2011. It delivered it on that date.
The Appeals Chamber affirmed Bagosora's convictions for genocide; for crimes against humanity, namely murder, extermination, persecution, rape and other inhumane acts; and for serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II, namely violence to life and outrages upon personal dignity. At the same time it reversed a series of findings that had supported the trial convictions. These were the findings on the killings of two named individuals, on the killings of the Belgian peacekeepers that took place before Bagosora's visit to Camp Kigali, and on the events in Gisenyi town, at Mudende University and at Nyundo Parish. It also reversed several convictions for murder as a crime against humanity. A conviction for other inhumane acts connected with the Prime Minister was set aside by majority, one judge dissenting.
On the mode of liability the Appeals Chamber set aside the finding that Bagosora had ordered the crimes at roadblocks in the Kigali area. It held him liable for them as a superior under Article 6(3) of the Statute instead. The Trial Chamber had already held him responsible as a superior under that article for genocide, crimes against humanity and serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions, and the Appeals Chamber's treatment of his effective control over the armed forces between 6 and April 9, 1994 formed part of its review of that finding.
Because the reversals reduced the extent of his responsibility, the Appeals Chamber set aside the sentence of life imprisonment and entered a new sentence of 35 years. Two judges dissented from the decision on the sentence.
Nsengiyumva's outcome on appeal was different in extent. The Chamber affirmed his convictions for genocide, for crimes against humanity (extermination and persecution) and for serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions, all in relation to the killings in Gisenyi town, held him liable as a superior rather than as one who had ordered the killings, and reduced his sentence from life to 15 years. Ntabakuze's appeal was decided later, on May 8, 2012, and his life sentence was reduced to 35 years. Kabiligi remained acquitted of all counts, as decided on December 18, 2008.
In July 2012 the Tribunal announced that Bagosora and three other convicts had been transferred to Mali to serve their sentences; others were sent to Benin in the same period. Bagosora had been in detention since 1996, and by 2019 he had served two-thirds of his sentence. He applied for early release in March 2019. On April 1, 2021 the President of the Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals, which had taken over the Tribunal's residual functions, denied the application in a decision of 19 pages. The President found that the gravity of the crimes weighed very strongly against release, that Bagosora had not expressed remorse and was seeking to minimize his responsibility, and that he had not shown that the countries in which he proposed to live, the Netherlands or Mali, would accept him. The prosecutor and the government of Rwanda had opposed release.
Bagosora died in Mali on September 25, 2021, at the age of 80. The Registrar of the Mechanism confirmed the death on the following day.
The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda was established in 1994 and closed on December 31, 2015. In 2010 the United Nations Security Council created the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals to carry on the essential continuing functions of the Rwanda Tribunal and of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, which had been set up in 1993 and closed on December 31, 2017. Appeals, enforcement of sentences and requests for early release in the Rwanda cases passed to the Mechanism, which is why the President of the Mechanism decided Bagosora's application in 2021.
Two forms of individual responsibility under the Tribunal's Statute mattered in this case: Article 6(1), under which the Trial Chamber held Bagosora responsible for some findings, and Article 6(3), responsibility as a superior. In the Military I appeal judgment the Appeals Chamber stated, in the part concerning Nsengiyumva, that for superior responsibility it is not necessary for the accused to have had the same intent as the perpetrator of the criminal act. The prosecution has to show that the superior knew or had reason to know that a subordinate was about to commit the act or had done so.
The prosecution alleged that Bagosora had masterminded the 1994 killings. The Trial Chamber did not find that the accused had agreed on a plan before April 7, 1994, and all four were acquitted of conspiracy to commit genocide. On appeal the finding that he had ordered the roadblock crimes was set aside and replaced by liability as a superior.
The reduction of the sentence to 35 years was itself contested within the Appeals Chamber, where two judges dissented.
1941: Born in Gisenyi prefecture, Rwanda.
1964: Graduates from the officers' school in Kigali as a second lieutenant.
September 23, 1993: Retires from the army and keeps his post as Director of Cabinet in the Ministry of Defense.
April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana dies; the Appeals Chamber later found that Bagosora was the highest military authority in Rwanda from 6 to April 9.
July 1994: Leaves Rwanda.
March 9, 1996: Detained in Yaoundé, Cameroon.
May 17, 1996: The Tribunal orders his provisional detention and transfer to its detention unit.
January 23, 1997: Transferred to Arusha.
February 20, 1997: Pleads not guilty at his initial appearance.
April 2, 2002: Military I trial scheduled to open.
May 28, 2007: The prosecutor asks for life imprisonment for each accused at closing arguments.
December 18, 2008: Trial Chamber I convicts him and sentences him to life imprisonment.
December 14, 2011: The Appeals Chamber affirms his convictions, holds him liable as a superior for the Kigali-area roadblock crimes, and enters a new sentence of 35 years.
May 8, 2012: Ntabakuze's sentence reduced to 35 years on appeal.
July 2012: Transferred to Mali to serve his sentence.
December 31, 2015: The Tribunal closes.
April 1, 2021: The President of the Mechanism denies his request for early release.
September 25, 2021: Dies in Mali.