Tatsuya Ichihashi was convicted in July 2011 of the rape and murder of Lindsay Ann Hawker, a young British woman who died in Ichikawa, a city in Chiba Prefecture just east of Tokyo, in March 2007. He became a fugitive that same month and stayed free for two years and seven months, until his arrest in Osaka in November 2009. At his trial before the Chiba District Court he admitted the rape and admitted causing her death, but denied that he had meant to kill her. The court found that he had, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The Tokyo High Court rejected his appeal in April 2012, he took the case no further, and the sentence became final.
She came from Brandon, a village near Coventry in the English Midlands, and she had moved to Japan in October 2006, about five months before her death. Ichihashi, then 28, knew her. He had studied in the horticulture faculty of Chiba University, and he had no criminal record of any kind, a fact that would matter at the very end of the case. The court found that he raped her and then killed her to cover up the rape. He never disputed the rape and never disputed that he caused her death. The single question the courts had to settle, at both levels, was whether he had meant to kill her.
For two years and seven months he was the subject of a nationwide search. On November 10, 2009, he was arrested in Osaka, and he remained in custody from that day on. The police first held him on suspicion of a lesser offense connected with the death. On December 2, 2009, they added the principal charges, murder and rape resulting in death.
While he waited for trial he wrote an account of his years as a fugitive, published in Japan in 2011 as Until the Arrest. It left out the crime itself and any explanation of why he had committed it. He presented it as a gesture of contrition, and it followed him into court.
The trial opened at the Chiba District Court on July 4, 2011, before a lay-judge panel, in which professional judges and citizens decide guilt and sentence together. Ichihashi was 32. On the first day he admitted the rape and admitted that he had caused her death, but he told the court that he had not intended to kill her. He said he was responsible for her death and meant to accept the blame for it. The defense case rested on that denial of intent; the prosecution's case was that the killing was deliberate and followed the rape as a way of hiding it.
The court delivered its judgment on July 21, 2011. It found Ichihashi guilty of rape and murder and rejected his account on the central issue: he had acted with a clear intent to kill, and he had killed her to conceal the rape. It gave no weight to his claims of remorse, pointing to the lengths he had gone to in order to avoid capture and to a book that it found showed none. The death penalty was available, but the court did not impose it. He had no previous criminal record, and the court found that some chance of rehabilitation remained. It sentenced him to life imprisonment, the term the prosecution had sought.
He appealed to the Tokyo High Court, arguing again that the death had not been intended and asking for a fixed term of years in place of life. On April 11, 2012, the High Court rejected the appeal and upheld the life sentence. Like the trial court, it found that he had intended to kill, and in weighing the sentence it took into account the time he had spent on the run and the false explanations he had given after his arrest.
He could have taken the case to the Supreme Court of Japan. He did not, and the High Court's judgment became final. He said he wished to atone for the crime quietly. As of May 2015 he was serving his life sentence in Japan.
The one contested question was intent. Ichihashi admitted the rape and admitted causing the death, but he maintained from his first day in court through his appeal that he had not meant to kill. The Chiba District Court and the Tokyo High Court both rejected that account, and with no further appeal their findings are final. His own published account of his years as a fugitive, written in custody, has never been tested in court.
October 2006: The victim moves from England to Japan.
March 2007: She dies in Ichikawa, Chiba Prefecture. Ichihashi becomes a fugitive and a nationwide search begins.
November 10, 2009: He is arrested in Osaka and first held on suspicion of a lesser offense.
December 2, 2009: Police add charges of murder and rape resulting in death.
2011: His account of his years as a fugitive is published in Japan.
July 4, 2011: His lay-judge trial opens at the Chiba District Court; he admits the rape and causing the death but denies intent to kill.
July 21, 2011: The court finds intent to kill and sentences him to life imprisonment for rape and murder.
April 11, 2012: The Tokyo High Court rejects his appeal and upholds the life sentence.
2012: He does not appeal to the Supreme Court, and the sentence becomes final.
May 2015: He is serving his life sentence in Japan.