COUNTS THAT FELL AT TRIAL: WHEN THE CONVICTION IS SMALLER THAN THE CASE

A victim count looks like the simplest fact in a criminal case. It is usually the first number a reader meets and the last one anyone questions. Yet the figure that reaches the record is the product of a long series of choices and accidents: which deaths the police connected, which ones a prosecutor charged, which ones a jury or judge found proved, and whether the defendant lived long enough, or was well enough, to be tried at all. In the cases that follow, the count that survived the courtroom was smaller than the count that went into it, sometimes by one death and sometimes by dozens. The reasons differ from case to case, and they say as much about the courts as about the men and women in the dock.

Charged with thirty-five

Cedric Maake, a married father of four from La Rochelle in southern Johannesburg, went on trial in the Johannesburg High Court facing 133 charges, among them the murders of 35 people, the South African Press Association reported. The crimes had been committed across the south of the city in 1996 and 1997, and the victims ranged in age from 15 to 74. Judge Geraldine Borchers delivered her findings over several days in early 2000. On February 29 she found him guilty on 20 counts; on March 1 the court added 15 more, IOL reported. When the judgment was complete he stood convicted of 27 murders, 26 attempted murders, 41 armed robberies and a series of other counts, and he was acquitted on others.

On March 15, 2000, Judge Borchers sentenced him to 27 life terms, one for each murder. With the sentences on the other counts the total was reported as 1,340 years and three months, to run concurrently. Survivors and relatives of the dead applauded in the gallery. The murder counts that fell away did not shorten the time Maake would serve; they narrowed only what the court was prepared to say he had done.

A count still being decided

In Thailand the gap between accusation and verdict was still open in the autumn of 2026. Sararat Rangsiwuthaporn, the former wife of a police lieutenant colonel, was arrested in Bangkok in April 2023 after a friend collapsed and died during a merit-making trip in Ratchaburi province. By the end of June that year police had sent prosecutors fifteen cases of suspected cyanide poisoning going back to 2015, fourteen of them fatal, and the charge sheet ran to more than 75 counts, CBS News and Agence France-Presse reported.

The prosecutions were then tried one by one in Bangkok’s Criminal Court, and each verdict was its own decision. On November 20, 2024, the court convicted her of murdering Siriporn Khanwong, the friend who had died in Ratchaburi, and sentenced her to death. In March 2026 it acquitted her in a third case, finding the evidence that she had possessed the poison unclear. In July it acquitted her of the death of a vegetable seller, citing a lack of evidence connecting her to it. By September 22, 2026, the tally stood at five murder convictions, three of them carrying death sentences and two in which death was reduced to life, against three acquittals, with the remaining cases and an attempted murder charge still to be decided and a further judgment set for November 25. All five convictions were open to appeal, and her lawyers said she maintained her innocence. In this case the number is not settled; it is being written one judgment at a time.

Seventeen deaths on a ward

In Wuppertal, in western Germany, a ward nurse on the intensive care unit of the Petrus-Krankenhaus went on trial in 1989 over the deaths of 17 patients. The German press, following the national practice, identified her as Michaela R. Colleagues had noticed how many patients died on her shifts, and prosecutors examined every death from her first day on the unit; 28 bodies were exhumed, the Berliner Kurier recalled in 2025. She admitted six cases.

The Landgericht Wuppertal gave its judgment on September 11, 1989. It did not convict her of murder. It found her guilty of manslaughter in five cases, and in one case each of killing on request and negligent homicide, and sentenced her to eleven years in prison, according to a 2022 study of patient killings in German hospitals by the sociologist Stefan Bär in the online criminology journal KrimOJ. The Berliner Kurier listed an attempted manslaughter as well. The prosecution had asked for a murder conviction, a life sentence and a ban on her working as a nurse, and it appealed. In May 1991 the Federal Court of Justice rejected that appeal and the judgment stood. The trial court had accepted her account that she acted from compassion, a finding Bär described as widely disputed. The trial began with 17 deaths and ended without a single conviction for murder.

A number he produced himself

Gerald Stano’s count ran in the other direction. A short-order cook in the Daytona Beach area, he was arrested on April 1, 1980, after a woman he had attacked escaped and went to the police. Within hours he confessed to the murder of Mary Carol Maher, a 20-year-old college student, and over the next two years, mostly in interviews with a Daytona Beach police sergeant, he confessed to many more. The figure most often printed in later years was 41 women in Florida, New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

The courts found ten. Stano pleaded guilty in Volusia County in 1981 to the murders of Mary Carol Maher, Toni Van Haddocks and Nancy Heard. In 1983 he pleaded guilty to three more, Ann Arceneaux, Janine Ligotino and Barbara Bauer, and then to the murders of Susan Bickrest and Mary Kathleen Muldoon, for which he was sentenced to death. A Brevard County jury convicted him of murdering Cathy Lee Scharf, and he received a third death sentence. In January 1984 a judge in Seminole County convicted him of killing a woman who was never identified. Three of the ten convictions carried death sentences, and the State of Florida executed him in the electric chair at Florida State Prison on March 23, 1998, for the murder of Cathy Lee Scharf.

For years his lawyers argued that many of the confessions had been shaped by the detective who took them, and state and federal judges heard and rejected the claim. In a written statement released after his execution, Stano said he had confessed to crimes he did not commit. In 2024 the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office identified a woman found dead in 1980 as Pamela Kay Wittman and said investigators attributed her death to Stano. He was never tried for it. The distance between his 41 and the courts' ten is not a measure of evidence lost. It is the distance between a man’s own claims and what could be shown to be true.

Five convictions, fourteen deaths

Milton Johnson came home to Joliet, Illinois, in early 1983 after serving about half of a 25-to-35-year sentence for a 1970 attack in the city’s Pilcher Park. That summer 14 people were killed in and around Will County, and authorities later tied every one of those deaths to him, Patch reported.

He was tried twice. In 1984 an Iroquois County jury convicted him of the murder of Anthony Hackett, 18, a teenager from Emden, Illinois, killed on July 17, 1983, near Wilmington, together with other charges arising from an attack on the young woman with him, who survived and identified him. A Will County jury then convicted him of four counts of murder and four of felony murder for the deaths of Marilyn Baers, 45, Barbara Dunbar, 38, Anna Ryan, 75, and Pamela Ryan, 29, killed in a Joliet ceramics shop on August 20, 1983. He was sentenced to death in both cases, and the Illinois Supreme Court affirmed both judgments.

The other nine deaths, among them two elderly sisters, Zita Blum and Honora Lahmann, and five people killed on a rural road in Homer Township, two of them auxiliary deputies of the Will County Sheriff’s Department, were never charged. Investigators cited matching ammunition and other links, but none of that evidence went before a jury. Johnson spent decades challenging his convictions without success and never admitted guilt, retired investigators told Patch. He died at Menard Correctional Center on May 16, 2025, the day after his 75th birthday. Dave Simpson, one of the Will County investigators on the case, told Patch in 2023 that the families of the other victims had never received justice.

Truro

In South Australia the gap arose because one of the two men named in the case was dead before anyone knew there was a case. Seven young women disappeared around Adelaide in the summer of 1976 to 1977. About a week after the seventh death, Christopher Robin Worrell was killed in a car crash. The deaths came to light only a couple of years later, around Truro, a country town northeast of Adelaide, and in the Adelaide area. One of the seven was Julie Mykyta.

The prosecution rested on Worrell’s companion that summer, James William Miller. In 1980 Miller was jailed for life for his part in the murders of six of the seven women, ABC News reported; the conviction did not cover the seventh. To the end of his life Miller maintained that he had only helped to bury the women and that Worrell had done the killing. Worrell, whom ABC News described in 2025 as a convicted rapist and a suspect in the series, was never charged with anything, because he was dead before the police knew of the deaths. Miller spent 28 years in prison, staged a 43-day hunger strike and wrote a book about the case, and died of cancer at a hospice in North Adelaide on October 22, 2008. His version was never tested against the man he blamed.

When the state stopped

Some counts fell away because no one ever brought them. In Onslow County, North Carolina, Marcus Shrader, a former Navy corpsman, was sentenced to death in 1974 for killing Cheryl Potter Boyd, the eastern North Carolina television station WCTI reported. The sentence was later reduced to life in prison after a ruling of the United States Supreme Court. He was accused of killing three other women, but he was not tried for those deaths. In 2005 the North Carolina commentator Chris Fitzsimon wrote a column arguing that he should never be paroled. He died in prison of a chronic illness, WCTI reported on August 2, 2010.

Robert Dean Weeks was convicted in Nevada in April 1988 of murdering two women who had passed out of his life years apart: his former wife, Patricia Weeks, last seen in Clark County on April 25, 1968, and Cynthia Jabour, a real estate agent he had dated, last seen on October 5, 1980. Neither body was found. He had been arrested in Tucson in 1987 on fraud and embezzlement charges after a viewer recognized him from a segment on the television program Unsolved Mysteries. He was sentenced to life and died in a Nevada prison on September 20, 1996.

Two other cases never reached a courtroom. James Shaw, a business associate, disappeared in Las Vegas on May 5, 1971, after what police described as an argument with Weeks. In 1986 Carol Ann Riley, a nurse at a San Diego clinic, vanished on the day she planned to see a man she knew as Robert Howard Smith, an alias of Weeks. A woman found dead in Mohave County, Arizona, in May 1987 remained unidentified until July 2025, when the California Department of Justice matched her to Riley. Her death is treated as a homicide, and investigators said they believed Weeks was responsible. Weeks had died in prison long before, and he was never charged.

No murder conviction at all

Robin Gecht was a member of the Chicago-area group known as the Ripper Crew, which Patch described in 2017 as believed to have murdered 18 women in the 1980s; CBS Chicago put the number at up to 20. Among them was Lorry Ann Borowski, 21, of Elmhurst, killed in 1982. Two other members, Andrew Kokoraleis and Edward Spreitzer, were convicted in the killings and sentenced to death. Kokoraleis was executed by lethal injection in 1999; Spreitzer’s sentence was commuted to life by Governor George Ryan in 2003. A third, Thomas Kokoraleis, won a new trial on appeal, pleaded guilty to Borowski’s murder alone, received 70 years and was released on March 29, 2019.

Gecht was not convicted of any killing. A court convicted him of crimes against a teenager who survived, and he was sentenced to 120 years. In 2017 the Illinois Department of Corrections gave his projected parole date as 2042, Patch reported. He remains the one member of the group whose record carries no killing at all.

Bartolomeo Gagliano, a man of Sicilian origin from Savona, in Liguria, has no murder conviction either, for a different reason. Italian courts found that he had killed a woman near Savona in January 1981 and two people near Genoa in 1989, during an escape from a judicial psychiatric hospital. Each time they judged him incapable of understanding and willing his acts, acquitted him on that ground and committed him to secure psychiatric hospitals, so that he served no prison sentence for the three deaths, Il Giornale reported. He escaped from custody several times. In December 2013, on a good-conduct leave from Marassi prison in Genoa, he failed to return, seized a car at gunpoint and was caught three days later across the French border at Menton. On January 14, 2015, a Genoa court sentenced him to six years and ten months for the escape, kidnapping and armed car theft. On January 22, 2015, ANSA reported that he had died by suicide in prison.

When the count belonged to someone else

The hardest cases are those in which part of a series had already been laid at another person’s door.

In Belinsky, a town of about nine thousand people in Russia’s Penza Oblast, men had been going missing since 2009. After the bodies of three men were found in the town in September 2010, police detained a local man with a childhood disability and a mental disorder. A court relieved him of criminal liability and ordered him into compulsory psychiatric treatment, NEWS.ru reported, dating the ruling to December 2011. In January 2012 police investigating the burglary of a household goods shop detained Alexander Bychkov, then 23. He told investigators about killings and handed over a diary in which he had recorded what he had done. Investigators checked him against 17 deaths in all, and the diary was later reported to describe 11 killings.

On March 22, 2013, the Penza Regional Court convicted him of the murders of nine people, under the counts of murder of two or more people and murder to conceal another crime, and of the theft from the shop, and sentenced him to life in a special regime colony, PenzaInform reported. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation upheld the verdict in June 2013. The man who had been sent for treatment was freed only after Bychkov confessed, NEWS.ru wrote in 2024; according to the Russian outlet 360, he was released under an amnesty, and a criminal case against the police investigator who had sent him to court was closed. Bychkov was reported in 2024 and 2025 to be serving his sentence at Correctional Colony No. 5 on Ognenny Island in Vologda Oblast.

In Buffalo, New York, the cost was measured in years of another man’s life. Anthony Capozzi, a Buffalo man with schizophrenia, was convicted in April 1987 of two attacks on women in Delaware Park in 1984 and sent to prison. He spent about 22 years in custody. In January 2007 a joint task force arrested Altemio Sanchez, a factory worker and father of two from Cheektowaga, after matching his DNA to a series of attacks on women around Buffalo that went back to the early 1980s. Slides from the two Delaware Park cases were found at Erie County Medical Center that March, and DNA testing excluded Capozzi and matched Sanchez. On April 2, 2007, at a hearing that lasted seven minutes, an Erie County judge vacated Capozzi’s convictions and dismissed the charges. New York later settled his claim for $4.25 million.

Sanchez himself was convicted of three deaths. On May 16, 2007, he pleaded guilty to the second-degree murders of Linda Yalem, 22, a University at Buffalo student, in 1990; Majane Mazur, 32, in 1992; and Joan Diver, 45, in 2006. He was sentenced on August 14, 2007, to 75 years to life. The sexual assaults that prosecutors linked to him by DNA were never charged, because New York’s statute of limitations had run, and his lawyer’s own accounts of how many he had admitted were never tested in court. Sanchez died in state custody on September 22, 2023; the State Commission of Correction later gave the manner of death as suicide.

In Philadelphia, the count has never been settled at all. Between 1985 and 1990 eight women were killed in Frankford, a neighborhood in the northeast of the city, and police came to treat the deaths as a possible series. In May 1990 they arrested Leonard Christopher, 38, a worker at a neighborhood seafood market, and charged him with murder in the death of Carol Dowd, 46, found on April 28, 1990, United Press International reported. He was not charged in any of the seven earlier deaths. Twenty years later Philadelphia police told CBS 3 that all eight cases remained open and unsolved, and described a different prime suspect, a man who had posed as a counselor in the neighborhood, moved out of state as they closed in, and had since died. He was never named or charged.

Evidence that arrived too late

John Paul Phillips, a Carbondale native, was sentenced to death in 1986 for the 1981 murder of Joan Wetherall, a waitress in the southern Illinois town, the Associated Press reported. At his sentencing a former cellmate testified that Phillips had boasted of killing two Southern Illinois University students: Theresa Clark, 22, a graduate student from Lemont, in January 1975, and Kathleen McSharry, 24, a junior from Chicago, in 1976. Prosecutors never tried him for either death. He died of a heart attack on death row at Menard Correctional Center in 1993.

In 2001 a Williamson County judge allowed police to test his DNA against evidence from the unsolved student killings. In September 2008 the Illinois State Police crime lab, using techniques that had not been used in the state before, tied Phillips to the death of Kathleen McSharry, WSIU Public Broadcasting reported, and police said they had concluded that he also killed Theresa Clark. The conviction count in his case is still one. The record of who killed Kathleen McSharry now carries his name, but no court ever heard it.

What a count measures

Set side by side, these cases show how many things can stand between a death and a verdict. Maake’s missing counts were charges the prosecution could not prove; Johnson’s were deaths that never reached a charge sheet. Michaela R.'s were deaths a court weighed and declined to call murder. Stano’s were largely his own words, and Rangsiwuthaporn’s are still in front of the judges. Worrell, Phillips and Weeks were beyond the reach of any court by the time the evidence arrived. Gecht and Gagliano carry no murder conviction for very different reasons: Gecht was convicted only over an attack on a woman who survived, and the Italian courts found Gagliano not responsible for the deaths they found he had caused. And in Belinsky and Buffalo, part of the count had first been charged to men who were later freed.

A conviction count records what a court found proved, in one jurisdiction, with the evidence and the defendant available at the time. The deaths that fell away still belonged to someone, and in most of these cases the families were left without a verdict for them.

Timeline

• 1968, April 25: Patricia Weeks is last seen in Clark County, Nevada.

• 1974: Marcus Shrader is sentenced to death in North Carolina for the killing of Cheryl Potter Boyd; the sentence is later reduced to life.

• 1975, January: Theresa Clark is killed in Carbondale, Illinois; Kathleen McSharry follows in 1976.

• 1976 to 1977: Seven young women disappear around Adelaide; Christopher Robin Worrell dies in a car crash about a week after the seventh death.

• 1980, April 1: Gerald Stano is arrested in Daytona Beach and confesses the same day.

• 1980: James William Miller is jailed for life for his part in six of the seven Truro murders.

• 1981 and 1989: Italian courts find that Bartolomeo Gagliano killed three people in Liguria, judge him not responsible and commit him to psychiatric hospitals.

• 1983, June to August: Fourteen killings in and around Will County, Illinois; Milton Johnson is later convicted of five.

• 1984 to 1986: Johnson’s two trials end in death sentences, both affirmed; John Paul Phillips is sentenced to death in 1986.

• 1985 to 1990: Eight women are killed in Frankford, Philadelphia.

• 1987, April 6: Anthony Capozzi is convicted in Buffalo of two 1984 attacks.

• 1988, April: Robert Dean Weeks is convicted in Nevada of two murders.

• 1989, September 11: The Landgericht Wuppertal convicts Michaela R. of manslaughter in five cases and two lesser counts after a trial over 17 deaths.

• 1990, May: Leonard Christopher is charged in the death of Carol Dowd; no one is charged in the other Frankford deaths.

• 1991, May: The Federal Court of Justice rejects the prosecution’s appeal in the Wuppertal case.

• 1993: Phillips dies on death row.

• 1996, September 20: Weeks dies in prison.

• 1998, March 23: Stano is executed for the murder of Cathy Lee Scharf.

• 2000, March 15: Cedric Maake is sentenced to 27 life terms after being convicted of 27 of the 35 murders charged.

• 2007, April 2: Capozzi’s convictions are vacated; on May 16 Altemio Sanchez pleads guilty to three murders.

• 2008, September: DNA ties Phillips to the death of Kathleen McSharry.

• 2008, October 22: Miller dies in North Adelaide.

• 2010, August: WCTI reports that Shrader has died in prison.

• 2010, December: Philadelphia police say the eight Frankford cases remain open.

• 2013, March 22: Alexander Bychkov is convicted of nine murders in Penza.

• 2015, January 22: ANSA reports Gagliano’s death in prison.

• 2019, March 29: Thomas Kokoraleis is released; Robin Gecht remains in prison.

• 2023, September 22: Sanchez dies in state custody.

• 2024, November 20: Sararat Rangsiwuthaporn is convicted of murder for the first time and sentenced to death.

• 2025, May 16: Johnson dies at Menard Correctional Center.

• 2025, August 5: Carol Ann Riley’s identification is announced in Arizona.

• 2026, September 22: Rangsiwuthaporn’s fifth murder conviction; further judgments are pending.