EIGHTEEN WHO WALKED OUT AND KILLED AGAIN

A release is a signature on a form. A parole board votes, a psychiatrist reports that the danger has passed, a Home Secretary consents, a sentence simply runs its course. Each time, someone with the file in front of them made the decision or let it be made, and within weeks, months or years another death came to light.

Some of these people were let go by boards that knew exactly what they had done. Others were let go by doctors who believed they had been cured. A few were not released at all in any lawful sense and simply walked away. What joins them is the gap between the door opening and the next name on an indictment.

Released from the hospital

Edmund Kemper was 15 in 1964 when he shot and killed both of his paternal grandparents. Because of his age, the case went through juvenile court, and he was sent to a maximum-security psychiatric facility in San Luis Obispo County. He was released into his mother’s care on his 21st birthday, Lookout Santa Cruz reported in 2024. Between May 1972 and April 1973, while living with her in Santa Cruz County, he killed seven women and a 15-year-old girl. The last of them was his mother, Clarnell Strandberg. A jury convicted him in 1973 on eight counts of first-degree murder. He is held at the California Medical Facility in Vacaville, where on July 9, 2024, a three-member panel denied him parole; it was the twelfth time he had qualified for it. The Santa Cruz County District Attorney, Jeff Rosell, told the panel that Kemper was "still dangerous." The next hearing was set seven years out.

Graham Young was 14 when the Central Criminal Court in London convicted him in July 1962 on three counts of causing grievous bodily harm by administering poison to his sister, his father and a schoolfellow, all of whom survived. The court ordered him detained in Broadmoor, a special hospital, and added a restriction: for 15 years he could not be discharged without the Home Secretary’s consent. In June 1970 the consultant responsible for him reported that he had changed profoundly and was no longer a danger to others. On that advice he was conditionally discharged in February 1971, aged 23, to live at an approved address under a probation officer’s supervision. He went first to a government training center at Slough and then to a job at a firm in Bovingdon, Hertfordshire. Men there began to fall ill, and two of them died that year. On June 29, 1972, a jury at St Albans Crown Court convicted him of murder and other offenses, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment.

Brandon Tholmer had been convicted of a 1975 sexual assault and robbery in Los Angeles and declared a mentally disordered sex offender, which sent him to Patton State Hospital. He was released in June 1979, according to the police account given at his arrest, and UPI later described the release as a parole. He remained in outpatient therapy under the supervision of a Superior Court judge. In November 1983 Los Angeles police arrested him in the investigation of a series of killings of elderly women. Police Chief Daryl Gates called his release "another failure of our system." A Superior Court jury convicted him of four counts of first-degree murder with special circumstances for the deaths of Rose Lederman, 80, Woolloomooloo Woodcock, 66, Mary Pauquette, 72, and Dorothy Fain, 72, killed between August 1981 and August 1983. It deadlocked on a fifth murder count and then declined to impose death. Judge Clarence Stromwall imposed four consecutive terms of life without parole, saying that in 40 years in the criminal justice system he had "not observed more vicious crimes."

The prison writer

Jack Unterweger was serving a life sentence, imposed in Salzburg on May 31, 1976, for the murder of Margret Schäfer, 18, who was killed in Herborn, West Germany, in December 1974. In Stein prison he became one of Austria’s best-known writers, the author of poems, plays and an autobiographical novel, Fegefeuer. Writers and public figures, among them the future Nobel laureate Elfriede Jelinek, campaigned for his early release, profil reported. He was released on parole on May 23, 1990, and held a press conference in Vienna the day before he formally left Stein, three members of the Austrian National Council recorded in a parliamentary question in 1992.

Less than four months later, on September 15, 1990, Blanka Bočková died in Prague. Hers was the first of eleven deaths, in Austria, Czechoslovakia and Los Angeles, for which Unterweger was eventually tried in Graz. On June 28, 1994, the jury returned guilty verdicts in nine of the eleven cases and he was sentenced to life. Within hours he hanged himself in his cell. Because he died before the verdict became final, the only murder conviction that stands against him is the one from 1976.

Long sentences, served

Richard Biegenwald was 18 in 1958 when he killed Stephen Sladowski, a Bayonne store owner who was also an assistant city prosecutor, during a robbery. He was convicted of murder in 1959, served seventeen or eighteen years, and was paroled in 1975, the New Jersey Supreme Court recorded. In January 1983, still a parolee, he was arrested in Asbury Park. A Monmouth County jury convicted him on December 7, 1983, of the murder of Anna Olesiewicz, 18, of Camden, and a jury in Mount Holly convicted him on February 16, 1984, of the murder of William J. Ward, 34. He was indicted in the deaths of Maria Ciallella, 17, Deborah Osborne, 18, and Betsy Bacon, 17. The state supreme court twice vacated his death sentence, and he died in custody on March 10, 2008, aged 67.

Terry Blair killed Angela Monroe, his former girlfriend and the mother of two of his children, in Kansas City in 1982. She was pregnant. He was sentenced to 25 years, served 21 and was paroled, and the Associated Press reported in September 2004 that he had been released about seven months before his arrest that month. Between July and September 2004 the deaths of six women came to light in Kansas City: Sheliah McKinzie, 38, Anna Ewing, 42, Patricia Wilson Butler, 45, Carmen Hunt, 40, Claudette Juniel, 31, and Darci I. Williams, 25. Under an agreement that took the death penalty off the table, Jackson County Circuit Judge John R. O’Malley heard the case without a jury and convicted Blair of six counts of first-degree murder on March 27, 2008. He received six consecutive terms of life without parole. He died in custody at Potosi Correctional Center on May 11, 2024.

Louise Peete was convicted in Los Angeles on February 5, 1921, of the first-degree murder of Jacob C. Denton, whose house she had leased, and was given life imprisonment. She served 18 years in the state penitentiary and was released in 1939, the Supreme Court of California recorded; the Palisadian-Post has described the release as a parole. In November 1943 Margaret R. Logan hired her to help care for an ailing husband. Margaret Logan died in 1944. From June to December of that year, Peete wrote the monthly parole reports Mrs. Logan was supposed to file on her and signed Mrs. Logan’s name to them, and the mismatched signatures drew suspicion. She was arrested on December 20, 1944, convicted of first-degree murder in 1945 without a recommendation of mercy, and executed in the gas chamber at San Quentin on April 11, 1947, at 66.

Thomas Neill Cream, a physician trained at McGill University, was convicted by an Illinois jury in 1881 of poisoning Daniel Stott, a railroad stationmaster, and sentenced to life in the state penitentiary at Joliet. According to the historian Jill Foran, the life term was reduced to 17 years and he was granted early parole, leaving prison in June 1891. McGill News reported that he had used his family’s money and connections to lobby for his freedom. He sailed for England and took a room in Lambeth, in south London. Ellen Donworth, 19, and Matilda Clover, 27, died there in October 1891, and Alice Marsh and Emma Shrivell in April 1892. Cream was charged with all four deaths but tried only for Clover’s. The Old Bailey jury convicted him of her murder in October 1892, and he was hanged at Newgate on November 15, 1892.

Silvo Plut served 13 years of a 15-year sentence for the 1990 murder of Marjanca Matjašič, a former schoolmate, in Slovenia, and was released early for good behavior, RTV Slovenija and Žurnal24 reported. He moved to Serbia. On November 18, 2004, Jasmina Djošić, 25, was killed near Aleksinac, a death for which the District Court in Niš later sentenced him in absentia to 40 years; he denied it. Back in Slovenia he was arrested in April 2005 over two armed robberies and released that December for lack of evidence. On February 24, 2006, he killed Ljubica Ulčar at Dolgo Brdo, near Ljubljana, and tried to kill her husband. On October 2, 2006, a Ljubljana court sentenced him to 30 years, the maximum under Slovenian law. He died in custody in Ljubljana on April 28, 2007, a death reported as suicide.

Joseph R. Miller’s case is set out by the Illinois Supreme Court in a few flat sentences. In the late 1970s, the court wrote, he murdered two women. In April 1993 he was released from prison. About five months later he killed three more women. A jury in the circuit court of Peoria County convicted him of six counts of first-degree murder and he was sentenced to death. The sentence was affirmed in 1996 and the United States Supreme Court declined review on March 31, 1997. While his post-conviction appeal was pending, the Governor commuted the sentence to natural life without parole or mandatory supervised release, and in April 2003 the state supreme court left the convictions in place.

Paroled, and the months after

Jerome Dennis was 25 and living in East Orange, New Jersey, when he was arrested in April 1992 and charged with killing five women since his parole the previous November, UPI reported on April 13, 1992. He had served ten years for armed robbery, with other charges. Three of the women named that day were Elizabeth Clenor and Stephanie Alston, both 30, of East Orange, and Robyn Carter, 41; the youngest was Jamillah Jones, and a fifth woman had not yet been identified. He was also charged with the attempted murder of two East Orange women. In Essex County Superior Court an assistant prosecutor, Norman Menz, said Dennis had admitted the killings, and Judge Joseph Falcone set bail at $2 million, citing his criminal history. How the case ended has not been reported, and the five killings stand as charged.

Nicholas Wiley had been sentenced in 1991 to 12 years in prison for an assault, with other charges, on a 16-year-old girl. He was released on January 22, 2004, and registered as a level 3 sex offender, New York’s highest risk category, the Syracuse radio station 98.1 The Hawk reported in 2024. In April and May 2004 three women were killed in Syracuse: Lottie Thompson, Tammy Passineau and Hannah Finnerty. An Onondaga County Court jury convicted him of one count of first-degree murder, under the provision covering two or more intentional killings in separate criminal transactions committed in a similar fashion, and three counts of second-degree murder; judgment was entered on October 18, 2006, before Judge Joseph E. Fahey. The Appellate Division, Fourth Department, affirmed on November 13, 2009, rejecting his claim that police had coerced his statements.

Mauricio Rodriguez Silva pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in the January 1978 death of Troy Crovella, 18. He was paroled from the state prison at Soledad in early May 1984; the California Supreme Court’s account gives May 7 in one passage and May 8 in another. A condition of his parole required an outpatient psychiatric evaluation, and he did not collect the referral slip. On May 18 he telephoned his parole office, asked whether a warrant had been issued for him and said he could not live on the outside. A warrant was issued two or three days before his arrest, but in the words of testimony the court summarized, it "did not get into the system, so it was cancelled." On the evening of May 28 he walked into the sheriff’s substation in Templeton, in San Luis Obispo County, and told a deputy he had killed three people: Walter Sanders, 16, Monique Hilton, and his 17-year-old half sister, Martha Kitzler. A Los Angeles County jury convicted him of second-degree murder in Sanders’s death and first-degree murder in the other two, and a second penalty jury returned death in 1986. On April 30, 2001, the California Supreme Court upheld the convictions and reversed the death sentence because the prosecutor’s stated reasons for striking a Hispanic prospective juror had no support in the record.

Vincent Groves was convicted of second-degree murder in the 1981 killing of Tammy Sue Woodrum, 17, in Colorado and sentenced to 12 years. On February 13, 1987, he was released on mandatory parole. In 2025 the Douglas County sheriff, Darren Weekly, said his office did not know why Groves had been released early. In February 1989 a jury acquitted him of attempted first-degree murder in a 1987 case. In 1990 he was convicted of the first-degree murder of Juanita Lovato, 19, and given life, and of the murder of Diann Mancera, 25, in Douglas County; accounts differ on the degree and the sentence in the Mancera case. He died in the custody of the Colorado Department of Corrections on October 31, 1996. Years later, DNA work led the Denver District Attorney’s Office in 2012 to attribute four more killings to him, three from 1979 and one from 1988, and the Douglas County Sheriff’s Office in 2025 to attribute the 1987 death of Rhonda Marie Fisher, 30. None of those cases was tried.

Leslie Allen Williams had a criminal record that went back to 1970, UPI reported. In 1983, less than two weeks after he was paroled from an earlier term, he committed an assault with intent to commit kidnapping, with other charges, to which he pleaded guilty. He was paroled again in 1990 after serving seven years of a seven-to-30-year sentence. In May 1992 he was arrested in Oakland County, Michigan, and confessed to killing four girls and young women who had disappeared over the previous eight months: Kami Villaneuva, 18, of South Lyon; Cynthia Jones, 15, of Milford; and the sisters Michelle Urbin, 16, and Melissa Urbin, 14, of Tyrone Township. He received a life sentence for each of the four murders and was serving them in December 2020, The Livingston Post reported.

The warning

Phillip Carl Jablonski was convicted of the second-degree murder of Linda Kimball, the mother of his daughter, who died on July 16, 1978. In prison he placed a personal advertisement in a newspaper. Carol Spadoni answered it, and in 1982 the two were married at San Quentin. By the summer of 1990, with his release approaching, both Spadoni and her mother, Eva Petersen, had said they were afraid of him. When his parole agent asked Spadoni whether Jablonski could live with her, she refused, because she was afraid of him, the California Supreme Court recorded. A Department of Corrections release report classified him as a psychiatric inmate and quoted a staff psychologist’s view that, though his illness was in remission, he "could become actively psychotic at any time." He was released from the prison at Vacaville in September 1990 under conditions that barred him from going to Burlingame, where the two women lived. On April 23, 1991, both were killed in Burlingame. A San Mateo County jury convicted him of their first-degree murders on April 25, 1994, and he was sentenced to death. The judgment was affirmed on January 23, 2006. He was also accused in the deaths of Fathyma Vann, 38, a classmate, near Indio, and of Margie Rogers, 58, in Grand County, Utah, where he was charged with capital homicide in July 1991; the outcome of those cases has not been reported. He died on San Quentin’s death row on December 27, 2019.

Two who left without leave

Daniel Camargo Barbosa was released once, in Colombia, after about five years of a sentence for an offense of the 1960s, for good behavior, the Ecuadorian magazine Vistazo reported. He was later sentenced to a long term on the prison island of Gorgona. On November 23, 1984, he escaped, and he was declared dead in Colombia. In Ecuador he confessed to killing 71 women and girls between 1984 and 1986 and in 1986 received 16 years, then the maximum Ecuadorian law allowed. Semana, the Colombian magazine, has put the estimated total at 157, an estimate rather than a court finding. He was killed by a fellow inmate in a Quito prison in November 1994.

Ricardo Caputo, an Argentine immigrant, called the police himself after Natalie Brown, 19, his fiancee, was killed in Nassau County, New York, in July 1971. A court held him incompetent to stand trial and committed him to a state hospital. In October 1974 Judith Becker, 26, a psychologist who had treated him there, was killed in Yonkers; UPI reported that he apparently killed her while on an unauthorized furlough from the hospital, and then he disappeared. He stayed at liberty for about 20 years, until he surrendered in New York in March 1994 with his lawyer. He confessed to two more killings, in San Francisco and in Mexico City in 1977, that did not go to trial. He pleaded guilty in the two New York cases, receiving 8 to 25 years for the Brown killing and, in August 1995 in White Plains, the maximum 25 years to life for the Becker killing, to run consecutively. He died of a heart attack at Attica on October 1, 1997, Canal 26 reported.

What the cases changed

Twice a release led directly to a change in the machinery that had granted it.

In Michigan, before 1992, the parole board was made up of professional civil servants with the power to grant parole to prisoners serving life after ten years, Bridge Michigan reported in 2014. After Williams confessed, Governor John Engler replaced that board with ten political appointees. "When you can’t keep violent criminals locked up, there’s something seriously wrong," Engler’s press secretary, John Truscott, said in May 1992, according to UPI. Parole eligibility for lifers rose from ten years to fifteen, and the interval between reviews from two years to five. The Urbin sisters' parents lobbied for a parole reform bill, which Engler signed hours before a memorial gathering on the first anniversary of their daughters' deaths. "It was something we had to do for them," their mother said.

In Britain the response was a matter of hours. On the day of Young’s conviction, the Home Secretary, Reginald Maudling, went to the House of Commons to explain how a man held dangerous as a boy had come to be working freely in the community. More than 300 patients had been released from Broadmoor in the previous 12 years, he said, and Young was the only one known to have killed again while under supervision. He announced that no restricted patient would be discharged from a special hospital without a concurring opinion from a second experienced consultant psychiatrist, and he set up two inquiries. The first, under Sir Carl Aarvold, the Recorder of London, reported on January 23, 1973, and led to an independent board to advise the Home Secretary on difficult discharges. The second, a committee under Lord Butler of Saffron Walden, examined how the criminal law dealt with mentally disordered offenders.

Slovenia’s reckoning came through the civil courts. Ljubica Ulčar’s husband and sons sued the state. In August 2009 the Ljubljana District Court ruled that the state bore no responsibility, but in March 2012 the Supreme Court confirmed that it did: a man already convicted of murder, and suspected of another killing in Serbia, had not been stopped in time, RTV Slovenija reported.

Elsewhere the files simply closed. Peete and Cream were executed. Blair, Biegenwald, Groves, Caputo and Jablonski died in custody. Unterweger hanged himself hours after the Graz verdict, and Plut died in custody in Ljubljana in April 2007. Kemper, at his last hearing, did not come to the room.

On the afternoon of Young’s conviction, Maudling had put the principle to the Commons in a single sentence. "The safety of the public must be the paramount consideration," he said, "and no patient is discharged unless it is considered safe to do so."

Timeline

• 1881: An Illinois jury convicts Thomas Neill Cream of murdering Daniel Stott; life at Joliet.

• June 1891: Cream leaves Joliet on parole after his term is reduced.

• October 1892: The Old Bailey convicts Cream of murdering Matilda Clover; hanged November 15, 1892.

• February 5, 1921: Louise Peete convicted of the first-degree murder of Jacob C. Denton; life.

• 1939: Peete released after 18 years.

• December 20, 1944: Peete arrested; convicted of Margaret Logan’s murder in 1945; executed April 11, 1947.

• 1959: Richard Biegenwald convicted of murder for the 1958 Bayonne killing.

• July 1962: Graham Young convicted at the Central Criminal Court and ordered detained in Broadmoor.

• 1964: Edmund Kemper, 15, kills his grandparents; committed through juvenile court.

• February 1971: Young conditionally discharged.

• July 1971: Natalie Brown killed in Nassau County; Ricardo Caputo committed to a state hospital.

• June 29, 1972: Young convicted at St Albans; the Home Secretary announces two inquiries.

• May 1972 to April 1973: Kemper kills eight people in Santa Cruz County; convicted in 1973.

• January 23, 1973: The Aarvold report on discharges from special hospitals is published.

• October 1974: Judith Becker killed in Yonkers while Caputo is out on an unauthorized furlough.

• 1975: Biegenwald paroled.

• May 31, 1976: Jack Unterweger sentenced to life in Salzburg for the 1974 murder of Margret Schäfer.

• January 1978: Troy Crovella dies; Mauricio Rodriguez Silva later pleads guilty to voluntary manslaughter.

• July 16, 1978: Linda Kimball dies; Phillip Carl Jablonski later convicted of second-degree murder.

• June 1979: Brandon Tholmer released from Patton State Hospital.

• 1982: Terry Blair kills Angela Monroe; sentenced to 25 years.

• November 1983: Tholmer arrested in Los Angeles.

• December 7, 1983, and February 16, 1984: Biegenwald convicted of murdering Anna Olesiewicz and William J. Ward.

• May 1984: Silva paroled from Soledad; on May 28 he surrenders at Templeton.

• November 23, 1984: Daniel Camargo Barbosa escapes Gorgona.

• February 13, 1987: Vincent Groves released on mandatory parole.

• May 23, 1990: Unterweger paroled from Stein.

• 1990: Leslie Allen Williams paroled in Michigan.

• September 1990: Jablonski released from Vacaville.

• September 15, 1990: Blanka Bočková dies in Prague.

• 1990: Groves convicted of the murders of Juanita Lovato and Diann Mancera.

• April 23, 1991: Carol Spadoni and Eva Petersen killed in Burlingame.

• April 1992: Jerome Dennis charged with five killings in Essex County, New Jersey.

• May 1992: Williams arrested and confesses to four killings; Michigan’s parole board is later replaced.

• April 1993: Joseph R. Miller released from prison in Illinois; about five months later three women are killed.

• March 1994: Caputo surrenders in New York.

• April 25, 1994: Jablonski convicted of two first-degree murders in San Mateo County.

• June 28, 1994: A Graz jury returns guilty verdicts against Unterweger in nine cases; he hangs himself that night.

• November 1994: Camargo killed in a Quito prison.

• August 1995: Caputo receives 25 years to life in White Plains.

• January 22, 2004: Nicholas Wiley released and registered as a level 3 sex offender.

• April and May 2004: Three women killed in Syracuse.

• July to September 2004: Six women’s deaths come to light in Kansas City; Blair arrested September 10.

• November 18, 2004: Jasmina Djošić killed near Aleksinac, Serbia.

• February 24, 2006: Ljubica Ulčar killed at Dolgo Brdo, Slovenia; Silvo Plut sentenced to 30 years on October 2, 2006.

• October 18, 2006: Judgment entered against Wiley in Onondaga County Court.

• April 28, 2007: Plut dies in custody in Ljubljana.

• March 27, 2008: Blair convicted of six murders.

• March 2012: The Slovenian Supreme Court confirms the state’s liability for Ulčar’s death.

• May 11, 2024: Blair dies in custody at Potosi.

• July 9, 2024: Kemper denied parole; next hearing set seven years out.

• December 2, 2025: The Douglas County Sheriff’s Office attributes the 1987 death of Rhonda Marie Fisher to Groves.