On June 29, 1972, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled, five votes to four, that the death penalty as imposed and carried out in the three cases before it in Furman v. Georgia was cruel and unusual punishment. None of the condemned men waiting in Arizona, Ohio, Washington or Texas had any part in those cases. Their lives turned on them all the same.
The same thing has happened, in other forms, all over the world. Sentences of death have been undone by a parliament in Ankara, a new constitutional court in South Africa and another in Ukraine, a presidential decree in Moscow, the pens of two Illinois governors and one in New Jersey, a colonial habit of mercy in Hong Kong, and the slowness of officials in Maharashtra who sat on two mercy petitions for almost eight years. In none of these cases did a court decide that the prisoner deserved to live. The law moved, and the sentence went with it.
Charles Schmid of Tucson was convicted by a Pima County jury on March 1, 1966, of the first-degree murders of Gretchen Fritz, 17, and her sister Wendy, 13, two girls he knew, and the jury fixed his punishment at death. In May 1967, partway through a second trial, he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the 1964 death of Alleen Rowe, 15, and was sentenced to 50 years to life. The Arizona Supreme Court took up his appeal in the Fritz case after Furman. On April 25, 1973, it affirmed both convictions, declared the death-penalty provision of the state’s murder statute unconstitutional and reduced the sentence to life imprisonment. Two years later, in 1975, Schmid died at 32 after an attack by other prisoners. Phoenix magazine, looking back in 2025, put it simply: what saved him from the gas chamber was the Supreme Court’s 1972 decision.
In Cincinnati, Posteal Laskey Jr., a former cab driver, was arrested in December 1966 while the city was hunting a man police believed had strangled several older women. He was charged with none of those killings, which remain unsolved. A Hamilton County jury found him guilty on April 13, 1967, of the first-degree murder of Barbara Bowman, 31, the previous August, and he was sentenced to die in the electric chair. WCPO reports that the sentence was commuted to life after the Supreme Court barred executions as they were then carried out; the accounts differ on the date and the mechanism, but not on the result. The Ohio Parole Board turned him down every time he came before it, the last time early in 2007. He died of natural causes at the Pickaway Correctional Institution on May 29, 2007, at 69, FOX19 reported, after about 40 years behind bars.
John Dwight Canaday, a Navy veteran who worked for the Seattle Water Department, was convicted by a King County jury in 1969 of the first-degree murders of Mary Annabelle Bjornson, 21, and Lynne Carol Tuski, 20, both killed in January of that year. Under the law of the time the same jury decided guilt and punishment in one proceeding, and it returned death on both counts. The Washington Supreme Court affirmed on September 23, 1971. In 1972, the Associated Press later reported, Canaday won a reprieve when a ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the death penalty in more than 30 states, Washington among them. His story had one more chapter. In 2004 a Seattle cold-case team matched DNA from the December 1968 murder of Sandra Bowman, 16, to Canaday’s profile in the state database. Confronted in prison, he admitted the killing and pleaded guilty. He died at the Clallam Bay Corrections Center in December 2012, at 68, serving three life sentences.
Of all the men spared in 1972, Kenneth Allen McDuff is the one Texas remembers. He was 20 in August 1966 when he abducted three teenagers near Fort Worth and killed them: Robert Brand, 17, Edna Louise Sullivan, 16, and Mark Dunnam, whose age is given as 15 or 16. A Fort Worth jury sentenced him to death in November 1966. Stays of execution followed in 1969 and 1970. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice’s register of commutations records his sentence commuted on September 18, 1972, and Gary Cartwright wrote in Texas Monthly that the Furman ruling led to the commutation of all 88 Texas death sentences then in force. McDuff had spent about six years on death row in Huntsville.
He became eligible for parole in 1976, and for 13 years the board refused him. What changed in 1989, Cartwright argued, was not McDuff’s case but the prison system. A federal court had found the Texas prisons overcrowded in 1972, and by 1987 the system was near breakdown. Governor Bill Clements ordered the parole board to release 750 prisoners a week to stay inside court-imposed population limits, and when too few prisoners qualified, the standards were lowered. More than 36,000 people were paroled in 1989. Old cases went to special review panels that gave them little scrutiny, and 20 former death row prisoners were released. McDuff walked out on October 11, 1989, after 23 years.
Within three years he was back in a courtroom. He was convicted of the capital murder of Melissa Ann Northrup, 22, abducted in Waco on March 1, 1992, and, as Texas Monthly reported, of the capital murder of Colleen Reed, 28, abducted in Austin in December 1991. Investigators linked him to other deaths that never went to trial. He was executed by lethal injection at Huntsville on November 17, 1998, at 52. His last words, as recorded by the state, were: "I’m ready to be released. Release me."
Thomas Eugene Creech carries both halves of the American story in a single file. In March 1976 Judge J. Ray Durtschi sentenced him to death by hanging for the November 1974 murders of two house painters, Edward Thomas Arnold, 34, and John Wayne Bradford, 40, who had given him a ride in Valley County, Idaho. That sentence did not last. After the U.S. Supreme Court barred automatic death sentences in 1976, it was converted to life in prison, the Associated Press reported. Creech was also convicted of murders committed in Oregon and California in 1974.
In May 1981, while serving his Idaho life terms, he killed David Dale Jensen, a 23-year-old fellow prisoner with physical and mental disabilities, at the Idaho State Correctional Institution. He pleaded guilty, and that killing brought the death sentence that has held ever since: imposed in 1982, vacated on procedure, read again in 1983, set aside in federal court and imposed for the last time on April 17, 1995. In January 2024 the Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole split three to three on his plea for clemency, and a tie meant no recommendation. On February 28, 2024, three members of a medical team tried eight times over 58 minutes to set an intravenous line, and the execution was called off. As of October 1, 2026, the Boise station KBOI reported, Creech remained on Idaho’s death row.
Melvin Davis Rees Jr. was never reprieved and never executed. A Spotsylvania County jury convicted him of the first-degree murder of Carroll Vernon Jackson Jr., who had disappeared with his family on a Virginia road in January 1959, and fixed the punishment at death; the Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed on October 8, 1962. A federal jury in Maryland had already convicted him of kidnapping two members of Jackson’s family, and he was serving two life terms. When Rees tried to abandon his last appeal in the mid-1960s, psychiatrists found him mentally ill, and in 1966 the U.S. Supreme Court ordered an inquiry into his competence. His petition then sat on the Court’s docket for about 28 years. He died of natural causes in prison in 1995, and in October of that year the Court dismissed the case.
Illinois carried out its last execution on March 17, 1999, at the new prison at Tamms. The prisoner was Andrew Kokoraleis, condemned by a DuPage County jury in 1987 for the murder of Lorraine Borowski, after the Illinois Supreme Court refused a stay and Governor George Ryan denied clemency the evening before. Amnesty International said he had been put to death despite doubts about his guilt. He was 35.
His co-defendant in the cases the press called the Ripper Crew, Edward Spreitzer, had pleaded guilty in 1984 to four murders in Cook County and was found guilty in March 1986, in DuPage County, of the murder and kidnapping of Linda Sutton. He was sentenced to death for her murder. The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed in 1988 and directed that an execution date be set for September 13, 1988; the date passed while the case moved into federal court, and in 1997 the Seventh Circuit said the death sentence should be reinstated. It was never carried out. In January 2003, as he left office, Governor Ryan commuted the sentences of all 167 people on the state’s death row, most of them to life in prison, ABC7 Chicago reported. Spreitzer’s became one of them. Two men from the same group of cases, condemned in the same county in 1987 and 1986: one was executed, and the other’s sentence became life.
Andrew Urdiales, a former Marine, had his death sentences taken away twice. A Cook County jury convicted him of the murders of Laura Uylaki and Lynn Huber, and he was sentenced to death in 2002. The Illinois Supreme Court dated Ryan’s commutation of that sentence January 10, 2003, and it became natural life without parole. A Livingston County jury then sentenced him to death again, in 2004, for the murder of Cassandra Corum, and the Illinois Supreme Court heard his appeal from that judgment in 2007. In March 2011 Governor Pat Quinn signed the bill that abolished the death penalty in Illinois and commuted the sentences of the 15 men then on death row, Urdiales among them. Within hours, CBS Chicago reported, prosecutors in Orange County, California, began seeking his extradition for the murders of five women in Southern California between 1986 and 1995. An Orange County jury convicted him in May 2018, and on October 5, 2018, he received five consecutive death sentences. A month later he was found dead in his cell on San Quentin’s death row, in what prison officials investigated as a suicide, the Times of San Diego reported.
Brian Dugan’s death sentence lasted fifteen months. He pleaded guilty in November 1985 to the murders of Donna Schnorr, a 27-year-old nurse, and Melissa Ackerman, 7, and received two life sentences. He offered to admit the 1983 murder of Jeanine Nicarico, 10, in DuPage County, but only if his life was spared. Prosecutors refused. Two other men had already been sentenced to death for that crime, and their cases ran on for another decade before both were cleared in 1995, the National Registry of Exonerations records. In November 2005 a DuPage County grand jury indicted Dugan on DNA evidence. He pleaded guilty without a deal on July 28, 2009, and on November 11 a jury voted for death. The sentence was formally imposed on December 16, 2009. On March 9, 2011, Governor Quinn signed abolition into law and commuted the death sentences then in force, and Dugan’s became life in prison, St. Louis Public Radio reported.
John Martini Sr. and his then-girlfriend abducted Irving Flax, a business executive from Fair Lawn, New Jersey, in 1989 and demanded ransom from his wife. After it was paid, Martini killed him. A Bergen County jury convicted him in 1990 and sentenced him to death, and the New Jersey Supreme Court later recorded that he had twice before been convicted of murder, in Pennsylvania and Arizona. An execution date was set for November 15, 1995. Martini said he wanted no more appeals; the Office of the Public Defender sought relief anyway, over his objection, and the stay that followed held for years while the courts argued over whether a competent prisoner could give up his own case.
The argument ended in December 2007, when the legislature voted to replace the death penalty with life in prison without parole. The Associated Press named Martini among the eight men on death row whom the bill would spare and quoted Irving Flax’s widow: "I feel the system has spit on me, has slapped me and I am fuming." Governor Jon S. Corzine commuted the eight sentences to life without parole and signed the bill, making New Jersey, as the legal news service JURIST noted, the first state to abolish the death penalty since executions resumed in the United States in 1976.
Adnan Çolak admitted killing eleven elderly people in Artvin province, in northeastern Turkey, between 1992 and 1995. The Zonguldak 1st Heavy Penal Court sentenced him to death six times and to a long prison term, given in most reports as 112 years. Which of the killings each death sentence covered has not been reported.
Turkey had carried out no judicial execution since 1984, Human Rights Watch noted in 2002, though its courts went on passing death sentences. On December 21, 2000, parliament adopted Law No. 4616, which the public came to call the Rahşan affı after the wife of the prime minister of the day. Its first article provided that death sentences for crimes committed before April 23, 1999, would not be carried out, and it cut ten years from long prison terms. On August 2, 2002, parliament abolished the death penalty for offenses committed in peacetime; 83 prisoners on death row were reprieved, among them the PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan. Çolak did not need the abolition. On May 28, 2005, Posta and the DHA news agency reported years later, he walked out of prison under the law of 2000.
Casper Kruger and a 19-year-old accomplice robbed and killed three men in Johannesburg in March 1991, one on March 1 and two in separate incidents on March 23, killing them so that they could not identify the robbers, according to the findings recorded on appeal. The Witwatersrand Local Division sentenced Kruger to death on each murder count. On May 24, 1994, the Appellate Division upheld the convictions and held that death was the only fitting punishment for his three murders, but it ruled that it had no jurisdiction over the constitutional questions now raised about the death penalty and postponed the appeal against sentence until the new Constitutional Court had spoken.
That court spoke on June 6, 1995. In S v Makwanyane, its first case, the eleven judges unanimously found the death penalty unconstitutional. Kruger’s sentences were commuted to three terms of life imprisonment and 22 years, IOL reported in 2006. He escaped from Pretoria Central Prison in May 1997, earning eight more years, and later slipped away from a clinic. In April 2006 he died in the police cells at Pinetown, near Durban, where he had been held for a month under a false name, shot by a police marksman during a hostage standoff.
Anatoly Onoprienko was convicted of 52 murders in two series: nine roadside robbery killings in the summer of 1989, and 43 killings between October 5, 1995, and March 22, 1996, most of them in rural homes in central and western Ukraine. The Zhytomyr Regional Court found him guilty on all counts in a verdict dated March 31, 1999, and sentenced him to death by shooting. When the trial began in November 1998, President Leonid Kuchma said in a media interview, as Amnesty International and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty reported: "As a human being I cannot see any punishment for him other than death."
Ukraine had promised the Council of Europe in 1995 to halt executions and abolish the death penalty, and a halt in practice began in March 1997, according to Amnesty International. The Supreme Court of Ukraine upheld Onoprienko’s sentence in August 1999. On December 29, 1999, the Constitutional Court ruled the death penalty unconstitutional, and life imprisonment entered the law on April 4, 2000; his sentence was replaced. He died in Zhytomyr prison on August 27, 2013, at 54. The preliminary diagnosis was a heart attack, Interfax-Ukraine reported.
Russia never formally abolished capital punishment. As a condition of joining the Council of Europe it undertook to abolish the death penalty in peacetime and to stop executions from its first day of membership, the business daily Vedomosti recounted in a 2026 history of the moratorium. On May 16, 1996, President Boris Yeltsin signed a decree on phasing out capital punishment. On February 2, 1999, the Constitutional Court ruled that no death sentence could be imposed until jury trials operated throughout the country, and in November 2009 it held that the moratorium had created an irreversible regime.
Vadim Yershov, an army deserter, was convicted by the military court of the Siberian Military District on June 9, 1998, of 19 murders, with attempted murders and other charges, committed in and around Krasnoyarsk between 1992 and 1995. He was sentenced to death by shooting, and the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court rejected his appeal on January 28, 1999. The sentence was later replaced with life imprisonment. In October 2026 Moskovsky Komsomolets reported that he was held in the Black Dolphin colony in the Orenburg region.
Alexander Maslich, a prisoner from Altai Krai, killed men he was held with. A court sentenced him to death in July 1995 for the killing of a fellow prisoner, Alexei Dzyuba, 23, at Rubtsovsk the year before, Interfax reported. In May 1996, while on death row in Barnaul, he killed a cellmate, and in December the Altai regional court sentenced him to death a second time; he told the court he had hoped to be found insane, which he believed would save him from execution for the first killing. The Interfax report of that day, printed in The Spokesman-Review, called him Andrei Maslich and described him as a four-time convicted murderer. Neither sentence was carried out. The Barnaul paper Altapress reported that his death sentence was commuted to life under the moratorium, and that he died at the Black Dolphin colony in 2015.
Dmitry Voronenko never received a death sentence at all. On March 20, 2008, the St. Petersburg City Court convicted him of the murders of four girls and young women, aged 11, 12, 18 and 20, with other charges. The prosecution had asked for death, calling it one of the rare cases in which it would truly be justified, and the court, pointing to the moratorium, imposed life imprisonment, Interfax reported that day. A victim’s mother told Interfax that he had said in court he was ready for any punishment, public execution included. The parents took their case to the Supreme Court of Russia, asking for death, and were refused, Moskovsky Komsomolets later reported. In 2024, after confessing from prison to the 2006 killing of a schoolgirl, he was charged again and brought back to St. Petersburg.
Lam Kor-wan, whom the Hong Kong press called the Rainy Night Butcher, was found guilty by a High Court jury of four counts of murder, and on April 8, 1983, he was sentenced to death. In August 1984 the sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. That was settled practice by then: since November 1966 the Governor had commuted every death sentence passed in Hong Kong, Amnesty International recorded in 1993. In April 1993 the Legislative Council voted 40 to 9, with two abstentions, to abolish the death penalty for all crimes. In October 2023, Sing Tao reported, Lam was still serving his life sentence.
Renuka Shinde and her sister Seema Gavit were convicted on June 28, 2001, by the Additional Sessions Judge at Kolhapur, in Maharashtra, of kidnapping children and of murder. Their mother, charged with them, had died in custody before the case was decided. The trial court found six murders proved and sentenced both sisters to death. The Bombay High Court reduced the murders to five in 2004, and on August 31, 2006, the Supreme Court of India dismissed their appeal and confirmed the death sentences. By the Supreme Court’s figures, none of the five children was older than 4.
The sisters then waited. Their mercy petitions took seven years, ten months and 15 days to be decided, and in August 2014, when they were close to becoming the first women hanged in independent India, a court stayed the execution, the Gulf Times reported. On January 18, 2022, the Bombay High Court held that the delay was the fault of state officials and commuted both death sentences to life imprisonment. The state appealed. On April 13, 2023, the Supreme Court let the commutation stand but directed that the sisters serve life for the rest of their natural lives, without remission, and urged that mercy petitions be decided at the earliest, warning that prisoners on death row were taking advantage of delay.
Hilda Nilsson took in infants born outside marriage, for a payment, in Helsingborg in southern Sweden, and killed eight of them. On June 13, 1917, she was sentenced to death. She appealed, and while the appeal was pending she was held in the women’s prison at the citadel in Landskrona, where she died by her own hand later that year, according to the city of Helsingborg’s encyclopedia and the district court’s historical account. One later account, in Nyheter24, dates her death to August 10, 1917, and says her sentence had been converted to life imprisonment that same day without her knowing it; the court’s own history does not mention a commutation.
The sentence she died under was one the country had already stopped using. Sweden’s last execution took place on the morning of November 23, 1910, when Alfred Ander was put to death, and in 1921 the death penalty was abolished in peacetime, according to Maria Maxén’s history of the guillotine in Sweden, published by the Nordiska museet.
António Luís Costa, a retired corporal of the Guarda Nacional Republicana from Santa Comba Dão, was convicted on July 31, 2007, by a court in Figueira da Foz, of the homicides of three young women from his district, Isabel Cristina Isidoro, Mariana Lourenço and Joana Oliveira, with other charges. Two of the three were 17. He had confessed to the Polícia Judiciária, retracted in court and blamed a relative of one victim. The court gave him 25 years, and there was nothing more it could give. At the close of the trial the prosecutor had asked for exactly that, telling the court, as Jornal de Notícias reported, that it was 25 years "because there is no more," and that the defendant deserved more. The Supreme Court of Justice confirmed the sentence in June 2008.
Portugal ended the death penalty for political crimes in 1852 and for common crimes in 1867, and it abolished life imprisonment in 1884, the country’s justice minister, Francisca Van Dunem, noted in 2021; the Constitution caps a sentence at 25 years so that a prisoner can return to society after serving it. Nothing in Costa’s case was commuted, because there was nothing higher to commute from. On August 31, 2026, Diário de Viseu, citing the broadcaster SIC, reported that he would be released in April 2027.
Set side by side, the cases show how little the outcome depended on the prisoner. Kenneth McDuff and Thomas Creech each had a first death sentence undone by a change in the law; one was commuted in 1972, paroled in 1989 and executed in 1998 for murders he committed after his release, and the other lost his first death sentence in 1976 and earned a second one in prison. Andrew Kokoraleis and Edward Spreitzer were condemned by DuPage County in 1987 and 1986 in cases from the same group; Kokoraleis was executed in 1999, and Spreitzer’s sentence was swept into Governor Ryan’s mass commutation in January 2003. In Turkey a man with six death sentences went home in 2005. In Portugal a man convicted of three homicides is reported due to leave prison at the end of a fixed term that the prosecutor himself called too short. What decided these lives, again and again, was the date: when the ruling came, when the decree was signed, when a governor left office, how long a petition lay on a desk.
• November 23, 1910: Sweden carries out its last execution.
• June 13, 1917: Hilda Nilsson is sentenced to death in Helsingborg; she dies in prison in Landskrona later that year with her appeal pending.
• 1921: Sweden abolishes the death penalty in peacetime.
• October 8, 1962: the Supreme Court of Virginia affirms Melvin Rees’s death sentence.
• March 1, 1966: a Pima County jury convicts Charles Schmid of two murders and fixes the penalty at death.
• November 1966: Kenneth McDuff is sentenced to death in Fort Worth. From this month, Hong Kong’s governors commute every death sentence passed.
• April 13, 1967: Posteal Laskey Jr. is found guilty in Hamilton County, Ohio, and sentenced to death.
• 1969: a King County jury sentences John Dwight Canaday to death on two counts.
• June 29, 1972: Furman v. Georgia.
• September 18, 1972: McDuff’s death sentence is commuted, according to the Texas prison register.
• April 25, 1973: the Arizona Supreme Court reduces Schmid’s death sentence to life.
• March 1976: Thomas Creech is sentenced to death in Idaho; the sentence is later converted to life.
• April 8, 1983: Lam Kor-wan is sentenced to death in Hong Kong; commuted August 1984.
• April 1993: Hong Kong abolishes the death penalty.
• May 24, 1994: South Africa’s Appellate Division upholds Casper Kruger’s convictions and postpones his death sentence appeal.
• April 17, 1995: Creech is resentenced to death for a 1981 prison killing.
• June 6, 1995: S v Makwanyane; South Africa’s Constitutional Court finds the death penalty unconstitutional.
• 1995: Melvin Rees dies in prison; the U.S. Supreme Court dismisses his petition in October.
• May 16, 1996: Boris Yeltsin signs a decree on phasing out the death penalty in Russia.
• June 9, 1998: Vadim Yershov is sentenced to death by a Russian military court.
• November 17, 1998: McDuff is executed in Huntsville.
• March 17, 1999: Andrew Kokoraleis becomes the last person executed in Illinois.
• March 31, 1999: Anatoly Onoprienko is convicted of 52 murders and sentenced to death.
• December 29, 1999: Ukraine’s Constitutional Court rules the death penalty unconstitutional.
• December 21, 2000: Turkey adopts Law No. 4616.
• June 28, 2001: Renuka Shinde and Seema Gavit are sentenced to death in Kolhapur.
• August 2, 2002: Turkey abolishes the death penalty in peacetime.
• January 2003: Governor George Ryan commutes all 167 Illinois death sentences.
• May 28, 2005: Adnan Çolak is released.
• July 31, 2007: António Luís Costa is sentenced to 25 years, the maximum in Portugal.
• December 2007: New Jersey abolishes the death penalty; John Martini’s sentence is commuted.
• March 20, 2008: Dmitry Voronenko is sentenced to life; the court cites the moratorium.
• December 16, 2009: Brian Dugan is formally sentenced to death.
• March 9, 2011: Illinois abolishes the death penalty; Dugan and Andrew Urdiales are among those commuted.
• October 5, 2018: Urdiales is sentenced to death in California; he dies on death row the next month.
• January 18, 2022: the Bombay High Court commutes the sisters' death sentences for delay.
• February 28, 2024: Idaho’s attempt to execute Creech is called off.
• April 2027: Costa’s reported release date.