MURDER WITHOUT A BODY: THIRTEEN CASES

A murder prosecution usually starts with a body. The body proves that a person is dead, and very often it shows how, when and where. Take it away and the state has to prove both halves of the crime from everything else: from the life the victim left behind, from what the accused said and did, from paperwork, witnesses and the long silence of a person who never came home. Juries in New Jersey, Maine, New York and France have convicted without one. Elsewhere the missing body is the reason a count stops short, why a confession was never tested, or why a man suspected of many deaths was tried only for the people who lived to accuse him.

Rosemary Calandriello and a ruling that still stands

Rosemary Calandriello was 17 and lived in Atlantic Highlands, a borough on the Monmouth County shore of New Jersey. At about six in the evening of August 25, 1969, according to the New Jersey Supreme Court, she left home to buy milk and ice pops with two dollars in her pocket, told her family she would be right back, and was not seen again. Two days later Robert Zarinsky of Linden, in Union County, was arrested. The first charge, abduction, was dismissed in June 1970 because it had not been put to a grand jury without unnecessary delay.

A Monmouth County grand jury indicted him for her murder on February 20, 1975, some five and a half years after she disappeared. The State had no body and no confession to police. The Appellate Division later said the case rested largely on circumstantial evidence and that prosecutors had needed time to assemble proof that she was dead. Schoolmates placed her in his car. Three men who had been held with him in jail testified to things he had said, and the courts found that the rest of the evidence corroborated them. Zarinsky did not testify; relatives gave him an alibi. The jury convicted him of first degree murder, and he received the mandatory life sentence.

His appeal turned on time. New Jersey’s five-year limit on prosecutions exempted offenses "punishable with death," and he argued that murder no longer qualified once the state’s death penalty could not be enforced after 1972. The Appellate Division rejected that in July 1976 and wrote: "The failure to produce the victim’s body does not preclude a finding that she is dead." On November 17, 1977, the New Jersey Supreme Court went further. "We hold that there is no statute of limitations for murder in New Jersey," Justice Pashman wrote. The conviction stood. WABC-TV later reported that during an unsuccessful bid for parole Zarinsky admitted guilt and claimed her death had been an accident involving his car, an account no court ever tested.

Prosecutors returned to him for the rest of his life. In May 2001 a jury in Elizabeth acquitted him of the 1958 shooting of Charles Bernoskie, a Rahway police officer, after eight hours of deliberation, CBS News reported. He was later indicted for the 1968 killing of Jane Durrua, a 13-year-old eighth-grader from Keansburg, pleaded not guilty, and died in the hospice unit of South Woods State Prison in November 2008 before that case could be tried. In February 2016 the New Jersey State Police and the Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Office said a DNA profile linked him to the 1965 killing of Mary Agnes Klinsky, an 18-year-old high school senior; had he been alive, the acting prosecutor said, he would have been charged. Rosemary Calandriello’s body has not been found.

Maine’s first case

Jennie Cyr Hicks was 23, the mother of a young son and daughter, and lived with her husband in a trailer in Carmel, Maine, when she disappeared on July 19, 1977. James Rodney Hicks told people she had left him and the children. In 1983 he was charged in her death, and William R. Stokes, then an assistant attorney general, took the case to trial with no body. E. James Burke of the University of Maine School of Law explained the burden to the Bangor Daily News: the state must prove that the person is dead and that the defendant killed her, and convictions without a body are "very, very rare." Stokes said such cases are easier to win when the defendant and the victim had an established relationship, as husband and wife do.

In 1984 a jury deliberated for nine hours and found Hicks guilty. The Bangor Daily News has called it the first murder conviction in Maine with no corpse, no weapon and no bloodstains in evidence, and described the offense as fourth-degree murder, the equivalent of manslaughter today. He lost his appeal, served six years of a 10-year sentence and was released in July 1990.

He was by then the main suspect in a second disappearance: Jerilyn Towers, 34, of Newport, last seen with him in October 1982. A third followed in May 1996, when Lynn Willette, 40, an Army veteran and former paramedic who had ended their relationship that spring, vanished in the Bangor area. Each time police had a suspect and no body, and no charge was brought. In 2000, after his arrest in Texas for robbing a woman at gunpoint, Hicks confessed to all three killings in return for serving his Maine sentence first. He pleaded guilty in Penobscot County Superior Court to the murders of Jerilyn Towers and Lynn Willette, and Justice Andrew Mead gave him two concurrent life sentences. Maine has no parole. William Stokes, who had tried the 1984 case, set out the state’s evidence.

A widow on the Upper East Side

Irene Silverman was 82 in the summer of 1998, a former dancer and the widow of a businessman, living in the Manhattan townhouse she had shared with her husband and renting rooms in it. On the afternoon of July 5, 1998, she was gone. That evening federal fugitive agents arrested Sante Kimes, 63, and her son Kenneth on an unrelated bad-check warrant from Utah. Later that year a grand jury indicted them for her murder.

At the trial in Manhattan in 2000, the prosecutor told the jury there would be no hair, blood or DNA evidence and no body. "Irene Silverman is dead," she said. On May 18, 2000, the jury convicted mother and son, and Sante Kimes’s convictions included three counts of second-degree murder, the Honolulu Star-Bulletin reported; she was sentenced to an aggregate 120 years to life. In November 2000 Kenneth Kimes told police that he had killed Silverman. On December 7, 2006, the Appellate Division, First Department, affirmed Sante Kimes’s conviction and held the evidence of murder legally sufficient without a body, pointing to motive, opportunity and means and to the victim’s keys and papers in the defendants' hands. By then a Los Angeles jury had convicted her, in July 2004, of the first-degree murder of David Kazdin, a businessman her son testified he shot on her orders. She was found unresponsive in her cell at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility on May 19, 2014, at 79, still denying both killings. Silverman’s body has not been recovered.

The Bluebeard of Gambais

The oldest of these cases is also the most complete demonstration that a murder case can be built from paper. Henri Désiré Landru, a Paris fraudster with a long record, used marriage advertisements during the First World War to meet women who were widowed, separated or alone. He courted them as a prosperous widower, took their savings and furniture, and brought them to rented houses at Vernouillet and Gambais, west of Paris. Then they disappeared. Relatives of the missing women pressed the police, and on April 12, 1919, Inspector Jules Belin of the mobile brigades arrested him in Paris, at first for fraud and breach of trust.

Belin seized a small notebook. It recorded dates that matched the disappearances, ordinary expenses and the train fares to Gambais, including, as RTBF and Infosyvelines both noted, a return ticket for Landru and a single for the woman travelling with him. The trial opened at Versailles on November 7, 1921, on eleven counts of murder: ten women and the teenage son of one of them. Landru admitted the frauds and denied the killings, and dared his accusers to prove them. On November 30, 1921, the Cour d’assises de Seine-et-Oise found him guilty and sentenced him to death. No body was ever found. He was guillotined outside the Saint-Pierre prison at Versailles at dawn on February 25, 1922.

The historian Richard Tomlinson, who has written a biography of Landru, told the magazine Connexion that he had no doubt Landru killed the ten women and the young man, but that how, where and what became of their bodies are still unknown. He also cited a police record listing 72 other women who had been in contact with Landru and were never traced, and stressed that the record does not show Landru killed them, only that the police did not know.

The eighth woman in Łódź

Between 1952 and 1956 six women and girls were strangled around Gałkówek, a village east of Łódź where Stanisław Modzelewski had served in the army as a driver. Investigators chased a theory that the killer was a railway worker, and in 1957 the prosecutor’s office in Łódź closed the case unsolved. About ten years later, on September 14, 1967, Maria Gałecka, 87, was found dead in Warsaw. Suspicion fell on a former neighbor with whom she had quarrelled, and Modzelewski was arrested on September 24.

He admitted her killing and then the earlier ones, and in the investigation he confessed to eight. On February 5, 1969, the Voivodeship Court in Łódź sentenced him to death for seven murders and for attempted murders; the Supreme Court upheld the sentence in July 1969, the Council of State refused clemency, and he was hanged that November. The eighth killing never reached the court. He said he had killed a woman in Łódź at some time between 1956 and 1967. According to Super Express, her body was not found, and Ewa Gruza of the University of Warsaw writes that the eighth murder could not be proved against him.

Twenty-one or twenty-six

Vasile Tcaciuc, a thief of Bessarabian origin, was already in the hands of the Iași police on robbery and theft charges in 1935 when six people were found dead in the city and the deaths were traced to him. He denied any part until investigators confronted him with two women who had lived with him. Then he confessed to the six and to about twenty more killings over five years, one of them of a child, all, by the Romanian accounts, for robbery.

The totals differ from one account to the next. Adevărul wrote in 2013 that about 26 deaths were confessed but that only 21 could be proved, because the other bodies were not found; the history magazine Evenimentul Istoric gave the same 21 against at least 26. Even the 21 was proof only in the investigators' sense. During a police reconstruction of one of the killings Tcaciuc tried to run, and a policeman shot him dead. He was 35. No court heard evidence on any of the deaths.

Seventeen confessed, fewer found

Joel Rifkin, an unemployed landscaper from East Meadow on Long Island, was arrested on June 28, 1993, at the end of a state police chase that began over a missing license plate. He admitted killing Tiffany Bresciani, 22, and 16 other women. The New York State Police say 15 of the women he described were identified by the task force formed after his arrest, and that charges were filed or considered in ten jurisdictions.

The courts dealt with fewer. A Nassau County jury rejected his insanity defense and convicted him of Bresciani’s murder in May 1994. Guilty pleas followed in Suffolk, Brooklyn and Queens. In Brooklyn, on December 1, 1995, he pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree murder, one of them for a woman who has never been identified, United Press International reported. At his 1994 trial two of the women he described had not been found; Associated Press reports in 2011 put the number of victims never found at four. Newsweek, writing in June 2024 when he was 65 and held at Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, listed the women linked to him by name and added two who have never been named.

Bellingham, 1987

Wendy L. Aughe was 29, a beauty-school student in Bellingham, Washington, and the mother of an eight-year-old daughter. She was last seen in the early morning of April 25, 1987, after a date with a man who had introduced himself as Mike, and was reported missing three days later when she failed to pick up her daughter. In 1989 Darren Dee O’Neall was convicted in Whatcom County Superior Court of stealing her car. No murder charge followed. Her body was not found.

By then O’Neall had been on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list over a different killing, that of Robin Smith, 21, of Des Moines, Washington, who disappeared in March 1987. He was convicted in Pierce County of her murder in the first degree, the Whatcom County prosecutor told a court in 2023, and an Oregon jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree kidnapping, with other charges, in a case for which he received 135 years. In August 2015 the Washington State Patrol Crime Laboratory reported a DNA match to him in the Aughe investigation. Whatcom County charged him with Wendy Aughe’s murder in the second degree in October 2022, and on March 1, 2023, Bellingham officers brought him from an Oregon prison to the county jail, where bail was set at $10 million. The police chief credited "three generations of BPD detectives." In the Aughe case he is accused, not convicted, and as of March 2023 he had not been tried.

Never charged with murder

David Parker Ray lived near Elephant Butte Lake in New Mexico. In 1999 he was charged with kidnapping and related offenses, and he was convicted of kidnapping and other charges involving two women who survived. He was sentenced to more than 223 years and died in state prison in 2002, the FBI said in 2011. He was never charged with murder. Ray claimed, the FBI said, to have abducted about 40 victims from several states, and investigators suspected he might have killed an unknown number of them. The FBI and the Albuquerque police named him as a suspect in the disappearance and possible death of Jill Troia, who was last seen in Albuquerque on the night of September 30 or early on October 1, 1995. As of the FBI’s statement in October 2011, no bodies had been found, and the Associated Press repeated the point in February 2012.

The only murder charge in the case, the Associated Press reported in April 1999, was filed against a 27-year-old associate of Ray’s, in the disappearance of Marie B. Parker, 22, who had been last seen on July 5, 1997. No body had been found at that time either.

The church in Brooklyn

Devernon LeGrand, born in North Carolina in 1924, ran a church of his own in Brooklyn from 1956. Police raided its townhouse on September 1, 1965, according to CrimeReads. Three women, Anne Sorise, Mary Horan and Lulu King, had been reported missing and were last seen in 1963; what became of them was not established. In 1970 Ernestine Timmons disappeared. She was never found.

LeGrand’s record grew in the 1970s. In February 1975 he and his son Noconda were convicted in a case involving a teenage girl; that September he was convicted of bribery. Two state witnesses, Gladys Stewart and Yvonne Rivera, vanished in 1975. On March 6, 1977, LeGrand and his son Steven were convicted of their murders. The Brooklyn district attorney believed LeGrand may have killed as many as 20 girls and women, but no other charge of murder against him was reported. He was denied parole, with the board citing "depraved indifference for human life," and died at Green Haven Correctional Facility in 2006, at 82.

Counts that rest on the courtroom

In three more cases the court record, not the search for a body, sets the number. In Shenzhen in 2003, Ma Yong, a 43-year-old man from Hunan, and Duan Zhiqun, 20, killed young women who had come to a job agency in Buji looking for work. The first, named by Time as Zhang Ping, 19, of Hubei province, disappeared on May 26, 2003. Her father, who had come to the labor market with her, called after her to keep her phone switched on; she did not answer it again. By late September eleven more women had disappeared from Buji. On November 27, 2003, the Shenzhen Intermediate People’s Court convicted both of robbery and sentenced both to death, finding twelve killings against Ma and five in which Duan took part, China Youth Daily reported. Time added that one of China’s four main police forensic laboratories was reported to have carried out the identifications of the victims. Whether every woman was found has not been reported.

In Syracuse, New York, Nicholas Wiley was convicted in October 2006 of the murders of Lottie Thompson, Tammy Passineau and Hannah Finnerty, killed in April and May 2004. The first-degree count rested on the New York provision for two or more intentional killings in separate criminal transactions committed in a similar fashion. On November 13, 2009, the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, affirmed the convictions and held that detectives' false claim to have found incriminating evidence did not make his statements involuntary.

In Victoria, Australia, John Leslie Coombes of Preston pleaded guilty in May 2011 to murdering Raechel Betts, a 27-year-old childcare worker, on Phillip Island in August 2009. Only then did the court and the public learn that he had already served more than 20 years in prison for two other murders and had been on parole when she died. Justice Geoffrey Nettle sentenced him on August 26, 2011, to life imprisonment without parole, finding no remorse and a real risk that he would kill again, and a Court of Appeal judge refused leave to appeal that December. The names of the two earlier victims, and when and how they died, have not been reported.

What the missing body costs

In New Jersey, Maine and Manhattan, and at Versailles a century earlier, prosecutors took on the double burden of proving a death and proving a killer, and won; appeal courts in New Jersey and New York then held that a jury may find a person dead without a body. Elsewhere the missing body is where the record stops. Modzelewski was hanged for seven killings, not the eighth he described. Tcaciuc’s confession ran to about 26 deaths and the investigators' proof to 21. Ray died convicted of kidnapping. The families of Rosemary Calandriello, Irene Silverman, Wendy Aughe, Ernestine Timmons and Jill Troia were left with verdicts, charges or suspicions, and with nowhere to bury the people they had lost.

Timeline

• 1915 to January 1919: Henri Désiré Landru’s eleven victims disappear at Vernouillet and Gambais.

• April 12, 1919: Landru is arrested in Paris.

• November 30, 1921: Landru is convicted of eleven murders at Versailles and sentenced to death.

• February 25, 1922: Landru is guillotined at Versailles.

• 1935: Vasile Tcaciuc, held for robbery in Iași, confesses to about 26 killings; he is shot dead during a reconstruction before any trial.

• 1952 to 1956: Six women and girls are killed around Gałkówek, near Łódź.

• 1957: The Łódź prosecutor closes the Gałkówek investigation unsolved.

• September 1, 1965: Police raid Devernon LeGrand’s church in Brooklyn.

• September 24, 1967: Stanisław Modzelewski is arrested after the killing of Maria Gałecka in Warsaw.

• February 5, 1969: Modzelewski is sentenced to death in Łódź for seven murders; he is hanged in November 1969.

• August 25, 1969: Rosemary Calandriello, 17, disappears in Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey.

• 1970: Ernestine Timmons disappears.

• February 20, 1975: Robert Zarinsky is indicted for Calandriello’s murder; a jury convicts him later that year.

• March 6, 1977: LeGrand and his son Steven are convicted of the murders of Gladys Stewart and Yvonne Rivera.

• July 19, 1977: Jennie Cyr Hicks disappears in Carmel, Maine.

• November 17, 1977: The New Jersey Supreme Court affirms Zarinsky’s conviction and holds that murder has no statute of limitations in the state.

• 1984: James Rodney Hicks is convicted of killing his wife, with no body in evidence.

• April 25, 1987: Wendy Aughe is last seen in Bellingham, Washington.

• June 28, 1993: Joel Rifkin is arrested on Long Island; he admits 17 killings.

• May 1994: A Nassau County jury convicts Rifkin of Tiffany Bresciani’s murder.

• 1995: Jill Troia is last seen in Albuquerque on the night of September 30 or early on October 1.

• May 1996: Lynn Willette disappears in the Bangor area.

• July 5, 1998: Irene Silverman disappears in Manhattan; Sante Kimes and her son are arrested that evening.

• May 18, 2000: Kimes and her son are convicted of Silverman’s murder.

• 2000: Hicks confesses and pleads guilty to the murders of Jerilyn Towers and Lynn Willette.

• May 2001: Zarinsky is acquitted of the 1958 killing of Officer Charles Bernoskie.

• 2002: David Parker Ray dies in prison, never charged with murder.

• November 27, 2003: Ma Yong and Duan Zhiqun are convicted of robbery and sentenced to death in Shenzhen.

• 2006: LeGrand dies at Green Haven Correctional Facility.

• October 2006: Nicholas Wiley is convicted of three murders in Syracuse.

• December 7, 2006: The Appellate Division affirms Kimes’s conviction without a body.

• November 2008: Zarinsky dies in prison awaiting trial in the Durrua case.

• August 26, 2011: John Leslie Coombes is sentenced to life without parole for the murder of Raechel Betts.

• May 19, 2014: Kimes dies at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility.

• February 2016: DNA links Zarinsky to the 1965 killing of Mary Agnes Klinsky.

• October 2022: O’Neall is charged with Aughe’s murder.

• March 1, 2023: O’Neall is booked into the Whatcom County Jail.