The sums were rarely large. Thomas Higgins was worth a little over 108 pounds to the women who insured him in Liverpool in 1883. Mary Ann Britland claimed 10 pounds when her daughter died in 1886. Diana Lumbrera’s children carried policies of 3,000 to 5,000 dollars apiece. What the twelve cases share is less a fortune than a mechanism: an ordinary financial product that paid out on the death of someone in the household, held by a person who also had charge of that household.
In most of these cases the deaths were first written down as natural. A doctor certified dysentery, epilepsy, heart failure, bronchopneumonia or polyneuritis, and the policy paid. The questions came later, and they came from outside the family: a brother who went round the insurance offices, a son who went to the police, a restaurant worker who wrote a letter, a surgeon in Kansas, an investigator in Boise, a woman who escaped a closed household in Hyogo Prefecture.
Catherine Flannagan, 55, and her younger sister Margaret Higgins, given as 41, were Irish-born women who had settled in the poorest streets of Liverpool. In the early 1880s they kept a lodging house. Among the lodgers were a widower, Thomas Higgins, and his eight-year-old daughter, Mary, and a man named Patrick Jennings and his daughter, Margaret, according to the historical record kept by Capital Punishment UK. Burial societies and small life policies were part of working-class life in the city, sold on the promise of a decent funeral, and the sisters held them on the people around them.
A young man of 22 in the household, John, died in December 1880, and 71 pounds was paid out. Margaret married Thomas Higgins in October 1882; within six months his daughter Mary was dead, and Margaret collected 22 pounds. Margaret Jennings, 19, died in January 1883. Thomas Higgins himself died in early October 1883. His doctor put the illness down to dysentery brought on by drink.
His brother was not satisfied. He went round the local insurance offices and discovered five policies on Thomas’s life, worth 108 pounds and 19 shillings in all, and he took what he had learned to the police. The coroner’s officer and the police arrived on the day of the funeral, while the wake was going on. Margaret was arrested on the spot; Catherine slipped away. Both sisters were charged with murder on October 16, 1883.
At the Liverpool Assizes in St George’s Hall a grand jury returned true bills on February 7, 1884, for the murders of Thomas Higgins, Margaret Jennings and a John Flannagan. The trial on the Thomas Higgins indictment opened before Mr. Justice Butt on February 14. Two days later the jury, after 50 minutes, convicted both sisters, and both were sentenced to death; the other indictments were not pursued. They were hanged together at Kirkdale Gaol on the morning of March 3, 1884, by Bartholomew Binns.
The case did not end with the sisters. Hoping for a reprieve, Catherine accused three or four other women in the district of poisonings, and estimates of the dead later ran as high as 17. The prosecuting solicitor, William Marks, wrote to the Director of Public Prosecutions that February that six people had probably been poisoned, but that it would be hard to prove anyone other than the sisters responsible. No one else was prosecuted.
Two years later the same pattern surfaced in Ashton-under-Lyne, outside Manchester. Mary Ann Britland, born in Bolton, had married Thomas Britland at St Michael’s Church in Ashton in 1866. In 1886 she bought packets of a vermin killer for mice in her rented house and signed the chemist’s poison register, as the law required.
Her daughter, Elizabeth, died in March 1886. A doctor certified natural causes, and a few days later her mother claimed on a life policy worth 10 pounds, according to Capital Punishment UK. Thomas Britland died next; his death was put down to epilepsy, and again his widow claimed on his insurance. She then moved in with neighbors, Mary Dixon and her husband, and Mary Dixon became the third to die.
Three deaths around one woman in a few months, with the same signs of illness, drew police questions. An analysis pointed to poison, and Britland was arrested. At the Manchester Assizes on July 22, 1886, before Mr. Justice Cave, she was tried for murder. Her defense argued that the insurance was too small a sum to stand as a motive for losing a husband and a daughter. The jury deliberated at length and convicted her. "I am quite innocent, I am not guilty at all," she told the court. James Berry hanged her at Strangeways on August 9, 1886. She was the first woman executed there, the Tameside Reporter noted when the town revisited her case in 2020.
Belle Gunness was never charged with anything, and no court ever ruled on a single death attributed to her. Her place in any history of insurance and murder rests on what happened in Chicago before she ever saw Indiana.
Born Brynhild Paulsdatter Storset in Selbu, Norway, in 1859, she emigrated in 1881 and in 1884 married Mads Sorenson in Chicago. Sorenson died in 1900, on the only day on which two of his life insurance policies, from different mutual associations, were both in force, the historian Ted Hartzell wrote in American History magazine. The payout was 8,500 dollars. The family doctor blamed heart failure; poisoning was suspected, but she was never charged. According to Judge R. Marc Kantrowitz, writing in 2013, the money bought her a farm near La Porte, Indiana, in 1901. Her second husband, Peter Gunness, died about eight months after their 1902 wedding; she was cleared at the inquest, Hartzell wrote, and collected 3,500 dollars.
A fire destroyed her farmhouse on April 28, 1908. In May 1908 the deaths of several men who had answered her matrimonial notices came to light at La Porte, and the county’s coroner, sheriff and prosecutor treated the widow as responsible. By then she was presumed dead in the fire. The coroner ruled that she had died, but the ruling was doubted at the time and has been ever since; DNA tests in 2007 and 2008 did not settle it. Her former hired man, Ray Lamphere, was tried for murder over the fire and convicted of arson only. Estimates of the number of dead range from 10 to 14, the figure most researchers accept according to Hartzell, to the 25 or more proposed by the forensic researcher Andrea Simmons. As Indiana Public Media reported in April 2026, whether she died that night is still an open question.
In April 1925 a young man lay critically ill in a Chicago hospital, and his doctors concluded that he had been poisoned. His mother, Anna Cunningham, a widow of Gary, Indiana, given as 49 or 50, was questioned by the state’s attorney’s office in Chicago, and within days the deaths of her husband, David, and four of her children over six years were under investigation, according to wire reports printed in The Daily Reflector of Greenville, North Carolina. Charles had died in 1922 and Walter in 1923. Relatives told the Cook County coroner that the money paid out on insurance policies after the deaths, with her surviving son’s wages, had been her sole support.
She was turned over to Gary police and held in the Lake County jail at Crown Point. There, on or about April 16, she confessed to Sheriff Benjamin Strong to poisoning three of her children, whom the report named as Isabelle, Charles and Walter, and to giving poison to the son in the Chicago hospital. She denied poisoning her son Harry. The reason she gave was not money: she said she wanted to join her husband in heaven. On April 18 she was arraigned in her cell and bound over without bail to the criminal court of Lake County on a charge of first-degree murder. No trial on that charge has been reported, and the insurance remains her relatives' account of how she lived, not a motive any court accepted.
Vienna’s version of the pattern ran through the 1930s. Martha Marek, born Martha Löwenstein according to the reference work Women in World History, first came before the courts in the 1920s with her husband, Emil, over a claim on his accident insurance after he lost a leg. The outcome is disputed: Time reported in 1938 that the couple had collected 42,875 dollars, while Women in World History says the claim failed and that both were convicted of bribery and served four months.
Emil Marek died in 1932, and their small daughter, Ingeborg, died soon after. In 1934 an aunt who had made Martha Marek her sole heir died, the Austrian magazine News reported. When the inheritance ran out, Marek took a room in the home of a master seamstress and persuaded her landlady to take out life insurance naming Marek as beneficiary; the landlady then died. Time described the seamstress as the family seamstress and wrote that Marek had been present at each of the deaths. The seamstress’s son went to the police. Women in World History adds that Marek had reported insured paintings stolen, and that a detective traced them to a warehouse, which turned the investigators back to the deaths. Police concluded that all four had been poisoned, News reported.
A Vienna court sentenced her to death in May 1938, two months after Germany annexed Austria. Time’s report of the verdict said the court held that she had killed her daughter, her aunt and the seamstress to collect insurance. She was executed by guillotine at the Vienna criminal court later that year; Capital Punishment UK gives the date as December 6, 1938.
Rhonda Belle Thomley was born in Lucedale, Mississippi, on November 4, 1906, and grew up in Mobile, Alabama, according to an account by the genealogist James Pylant. She married five times. With her second husband, George Garrett, a railroad switchman, she had five daughters. Garrett died on Christmas morning, 1939, in a Montgomery hospital; the cause was given as bronchopneumonia. Her mother died in Mobile in 1944. In October 1948 she married Claude Martin, a widower who worked with her at a glass factory. He died on April 27, 1951, after a six-week illness diagnosed as polyneuritis, and no autopsy was done. That December she married his son, Ronald.
Ronald Martin fell seriously ill and survived. By March 1956 investigators had identified six deaths in her family with the same symptoms, and she was charged with murder and held in Montgomery. She confessed on March 12, 1956, to the deaths of six relatives: her mother, two husbands, George Garrett and Claude Martin, and three of her daughters. She denied having anything to do with the deaths of two other daughters. She said she had profited only from the 2,000 dollars collected after Claude Martin’s death.
Her trial for murder opened in Montgomery on June 4, 1956. She pleaded insanity, and she was convicted and sentenced to death. The Alabama Supreme Court heard the automatic appeal and in June 1957 denied a rehearing and set an execution date of September 27. Governor James E. Folsom granted a two-week reprieve so that a sanity examination could be sought, then refused clemency. She died in the electric chair at Kilby Prison on October 11, 1957.
In the 1950s Anjette Lyles ran a downtown restaurant in Macon, Georgia, that drew the town’s lawyers, judges and businessmen. Between 1952 and 1958 four members of her family died: her first husband, Ben F. Lyles Jr., in 1952; her second husband, Joe Neal Gabbert, an airline pilot, in December 1955; her mother-in-law in September 1957; and her elder daughter, Marcia Elaine Lyles, nine years old, on April 5, 1958. Each death brought her money. The Supreme Court of Georgia later wrote that she "collected a substantial amount of money from the death of each victim." WMAZ, the Macon television station, reported that prosecutors pointed to her spending after Gabbert’s life insurance was paid.
The child’s death was the one that broke the pattern. A worker at the restaurant wrote to the family warning that Marcia was being poisoned, WGXA reported in 2015; the girl died before relatives could reach Macon. A Bibb County grand jury returned a special presentment charging Lyles with murdering Marcia with arsenic. She was also charged in the three earlier deaths, according to WMAZ, but was tried only for her daughter’s.
The trial in the fall of 1958 turned on paper as much as on medicine. The state put in canceled checks, a 1955 letter to the Veterans Administration in Gabbert’s name, a 1957 instrument in her mother-in-law’s name directing that a burial payment go to the defendant, and a copy of the mother-in-law’s will, and offered evidence that the documents were forgeries she had made. Witnesses testified that the three earlier deaths had the same cause as the child’s. The state’s theory, as a son of one of the special prosecutors later put it to WMAZ, was simple: "Anjette was doing this for the money, for life insurance money." The jury convicted her of murder without a recommendation of mercy, and she was sentenced to die in the electric chair.
On July 8, 1959, the Supreme Court of Georgia affirmed. It held that the earlier deaths were properly admitted to show a plan, scheme and motive, since each came from the same uncommon poison and each had brought her money, and it described the evidence as showing a scheme to "murder an innocent child for no cause except to satisfy her selfish desire for money." The sentence was never carried out. A sanity board declared her criminally insane, and she was committed to Central State Hospital at Milledgeville, where she died in 1977, at 52.
The longest paper trail in the group belongs to Judias Buenoano, called Judy, who in 1962 married James E. Goodyear, an Air Force man. Goodyear died in the naval hospital in Orlando in 1971 after an illness his doctors could not explain; nobody suspected poison at the time, and his widow collected on several life insurance policies, according to a history of the case published by the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida. She later lived with Bobby Joe Morris and moved with him to Colorado, where he died in Trinidad; CBS News, drawing on the Associated Press, gave the year as 1977, the court history as 1978. She collected on three policies on his life. She was never charged with his death.
Her elder son, Michael Goodyear, joined the Army in 1979 and became seriously ill. He was discharged into his mother’s care on May 12, 1980, and drowned the next day in the East River in Santa Rosa County, Florida, when a canoe she was in overturned. He was 19. He was covered by several policies, some of them owned by his mother, and none of which had required a medical examination; after his death she received more than 100,000 dollars as beneficiary, the First District Court of Appeal recorded. On March 31, 1984, a Santa Rosa County jury convicted her of first-degree murder and of first-degree grand theft, the theft being more than 20,000 dollars obtained from Prudential by fraud over Michael’s death. She was sentenced to life, and the appeals court affirmed on October 29, 1985.
The inquiry that reached back to 1971 began with her fiancé, John Gentry. The two had taken out life insurance on each other, and she later raised the policy on his life to 500,000 dollars, the district court’s history says. Gentry survived two attempts on his life in 1982 and 1983. An Escambia County jury convicted her of attempted first-degree murder, and she was sentenced to 12 years. Investigators then reexamined the death of James Goodyear. In Orange County she was convicted of his first-degree murder in November 1985 and sentenced to death; the courts accepted that he had died of arsenic poisoning. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the denial of federal habeas relief in January 1996.
She denied every charge to the end. On March 30, 1998, she was executed in Florida’s electric chair, the first woman put to death in the state since 1848. CBS News reported that investigators had noticed that the surname she used, Buenoano, is Spanish for Goodyear.
Between 1976 and 1984 six young children died in Diana Lumbrera’s care in West Texas: five of her own and the six-week-old daughter of a cousin. The causes recorded at the time pointed away from crime: a convulsive disorder, "multiple natural causes," aspiration, heart failure, septicemia. Each of the children had been insured, for sums between 3,000 and 5,000 dollars, according to an account published by the Garden City Police Department in Kansas, which adds that a second policy on her daughter Melissa was bought the day before the three-year-old died in 1978.
In 1985 Lumbrera moved to Garden City. Her son Jose Antonio, four, died there on May 1, 1990, a day after she had taken him to the hospital with vomiting. A surgeon grew suspicious, and the pathologist ruled the cause of death asphyxia due to smothering. He had been insured for 5,000 dollars. Lumbrera was arrested on May 5, 1990, and charged with first-degree murder. At the preliminary hearing the county attorney described her motive as "a combination of sympathy and money," and testimony showed she had taken out loans by telling lenders that the boy had cancer and that her father had been killed driving him to Mexico for care, The Castro County News of Dimmitt, Texas, reported. Her father was alive.
A Finney County jury convicted her. The Kansas Supreme Court reversed that conviction in December 1992 for cumulative trial errors, a second jury convicted her again in April 1993, and on March 10, 1995, the court affirmed. Its opinion records that she had been convicted in Texas, on pleas of no contest, of the murders of two more of her children, Jose Lionel Garza and Melinda Garza, and that she "had obtained life insurance on each of the children and financially benefitted from their deaths." The trial court had noted that in each case the funeral cost less than the insurance paid.
Robin Lee Row is the one case in the group that turned on a single event, and the courts never treated it as more than that. On February 10, 1992, a fire at the family’s duplex apartment in Boise killed her husband, Randy Row, and her children, Joshua, 10, and Tabitha, 8. All three died of carbon monoxide poisoning. Row was staying with a friend that night.
Investigators turned up six life insurance policies on the three, totaling 276,500 dollars, with Row as beneficiary; the most recent had been bought on January 24, 1992, seventeen days before the fire, the Idaho Supreme Court recorded. Police also uncovered evidence that she had been stealing from the YWCA bingo operation where she worked, and she was arrested on February 13 on a grand theft charge. Murder charges followed on March 20, and she was arrested on them three days later. On March 5, 1993, an Ada County jury convicted her of three counts of first-degree murder and one of aggravated arson. A judge sentenced her to death on December 16, 1993, and the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed on March 18, 1998.
Her past drew scrutiny of its own. Gary Raney, the lead investigator in 1992 and later Ada County sheriff, told KTVB that he believed she had also killed a 15-month-old daughter in New Hampshire, whose death in 1976 was recorded as sudden infant death, and a six-year-old son, Keith, in a 1980 fire, probably in California, after which she collected 28,000 dollars in insurance. She was never charged in either death. On March 31, 2023, U.S. District Judge B. Lynn Winmill dismissed her federal habeas petition, Idaho Reports said, writing that he did so "with great reluctance" because the Supreme Court’s decision in Shinn v. Ramirez barred him from weighing evidence of brain dysfunction that her lawyers had not raised in state court. In March 2026 the Idaho Department of Correction still listed her on death row.
The single man in the group lived in Hamilton, Ontario. Sukhwinder Singh Dhillon was convicted of the first-degree murders of his wife and of a business partner, both strychnine poisonings, and was sentenced to life imprisonment, CHCH News of Hamilton reported. He was suspected in at least three further strychnine deaths in India, of a later wife and of twin boys born to another wife; whether he was ever tried for them has not been reported. He was held at Warkworth Institution, and in November 2013 Correctional Service Canada said that he had died in a hospital in Kingston. He was 54.
The most recent case is also the one in which the principal figure never stood trial. Miyoko Sumida headed a household in Amagasaki, in Hyogo Prefecture, that drew in relatives, in-laws and adopted members over some 25 years. The case came to light in Amagasaki in November 2011, when a woman who had been held in the household escaped and went to the police. Sumida was arrested that month, indicted in February 2012 over the death of a 66-year-old woman, and re-arrested on November 7, 2012, with relatives, on charges including murder. Police confirmed eight deaths around the household.
Insurance sat at the center of one of them. A man of 51, born into the Hashimoto family, died in a fall in Okinawa in July 2005. Prosecutors charged members of the household with murder and fraud, arguing that he had been driven to his death so that his life insurance would be paid. Sumida’s sister-in-law told the Kobe District Court in May 2015 that the household had been short of money and that the insurance went to pay debts. The court rejected the defense that he had chosen to die for the family; the 2016 judgment against Sumida’s daughter-in-law called it a murder for insurance money and "the most unforgivable" of the household’s crimes.
Sumida died in a holding cell at the Hyogo Prefectural Police headquarters in Kobe on December 12, 2012, at 64, and police treated the death as suicide. No court ever weighed the evidence against her. Between November 2014 and February 2016 the Kobe District Court convicted seven members of her household, finding in each case that they had conspired with her. Their sentences ran from 15 years to life; the life sentence, for her cousin by marriage, became final when the Supreme Court dismissed his appeal in March 2018.
Most of these cases began inside a family, with policies on husbands, children, parents and in-laws. The policies themselves were unremarkable: small life and burial policies in Liverpool and Ashton-under-Lyne, mutual association policies in Chicago, commercial life insurance in Florida, small policies on infants in Texas. What made them dangerous was proximity. Again and again the person who held the policy was also the person who kept the house, called the doctor and arranged the funeral.
So was the delay. Thomas Higgins was buried as a drinker with dysentery, Thomas Britland after a death put down to epilepsy, Mads Sorenson after a diagnosis of heart failure, Diana Lumbrera’s children after illnesses that no one questioned. In case after case it took a relative’s suspicion, a third or fourth death, a detective or a forged signature to bring a policy before a jury. The courts that did hear these cases returned again and again to the same piece of evidence: the money, and who collected it.
• December 1880: John, 22, a member of the Liverpool lodging household, dies; 71 pounds is paid out.
• October 1882: Margaret Higgins marries Thomas Higgins; his daughter Mary dies within six months.
• January 1883: Margaret Jennings, 19, dies in Liverpool.
• October 1883: Thomas Higgins dies; his brother traces five policies on his life, and on October 16 both sisters are charged with murder.
• February 16, 1884: Catherine Flannagan and Margaret Higgins are convicted of murder at the Liverpool Assizes.
• March 3, 1884: the sisters are hanged at Kirkdale Gaol.
• March 1886: Elizabeth Britland dies in Ashton-under-Lyne; her mother claims 10 pounds in life insurance.
• July 22, 1886: Mary Ann Britland is tried for murder at the Manchester Assizes and convicted.
• August 9, 1886: Britland is hanged at Strangeways.
• 1900: Mads Sorenson dies in Chicago on the one day two of his policies overlap; 8,500 dollars is paid.
• 1901: Belle Sorenson buys a farm near La Porte, Indiana.
• April and May 1908: fire destroys the Gunness farmhouse on April 28; the deaths of men who answered her notices come to light at La Porte in May.
• April 1925: Anna Cunningham confesses at Crown Point, Indiana, and is bound over on a charge of first-degree murder.
• 1932: Emil Marek dies in Vienna; his daughter, Ingeborg, dies soon after.
• 1934: Martha Marek’s aunt, who had made her sole heir, dies.
• May 1938: a Vienna court sentences Martha Marek to death.
• December 6, 1938: Marek is executed in Vienna (date per Capital Punishment UK).
• April 27, 1951: Claude Martin dies in Alabama.
• 1952 to 1957: Ben F. Lyles Jr., Joe Neal Gabbert and Lyles’s mother-in-law die in Georgia.
• March 12, 1956: Rhonda Belle Martin confesses to six deaths in her family.
• June 4, 1956: Martin’s murder trial opens in Montgomery; she is convicted and sentenced to death.
• October 11, 1957: Martin is executed at Kilby Prison.
• April 5, 1958: Marcia Elaine Lyles, 9, dies in Macon.
• Fall 1958: Anjette Lyles is convicted of her daughter’s murder and sentenced to death.
• July 8, 1959: the Supreme Court of Georgia affirms the Lyles verdict.
• 1971: James Goodyear dies in Orlando.
• 1976 to 1984: six young children die in Diana Lumbrera’s care in West Texas.
• 1977: Anjette Lyles dies at Central State Hospital, Milledgeville.
• May 13, 1980: Michael Goodyear drowns in the East River, Santa Rosa County, Florida.
• March 31, 1984: Judy Buenoano is convicted of Michael’s murder and of grand theft from an insurer.
• November 1985: Buenoano is convicted in Orange County of James Goodyear’s murder and sentenced to death.
• May 1, 1990: Jose Antonio, four-year-old son of Diana Lumbrera, dies in Garden City, Kansas.
• February 10, 1992: Robin Lee Row’s husband and two children die in a fire in Boise.
• March 5, 1993: Robin Lee Row is convicted of three counts of first-degree murder and aggravated arson.
• December 16, 1993: Row is sentenced to death.
• March 10, 1995: the Kansas Supreme Court affirms Lumbrera’s second conviction.
• March 18, 1998: the Idaho Supreme Court affirms Row’s convictions and death sentence.
• March 30, 1998: Buenoano is executed in Florida.
• July 2005: a man of 51 from the Sumida household dies in a fall in Okinawa; members of the household are later convicted over his death.
• November 2011: the Sumida case comes to light in Amagasaki.
• December 12, 2012: Miyoko Sumida dies in police custody in Kobe.
• November 2013: Sukhwinder Dhillon dies in a Kingston hospital.
• November 2014 to February 2016: seven members of Sumida’s household are convicted by the Kobe District Court.
• March 2018: Japan’s Supreme Court makes the life sentence of Sumida’s cousin by marriage final.
• March 31, 2023: a federal judge dismisses Row’s habeas petition.
• March 2026: Row is listed on Idaho’s death row.