ELEVEN ESCAPES THAT DID THE INVESTIGATION’S WORK

Most serial cases close from the outside. Detectives work back from the dead, from a pattern of dates, a fingerprint, a DNA profile, a confession taken once the evidence is already on the table. A smaller number close from the inside, because someone the offender meant to keep, or meant to kill, got away and walked into a police station. In each of the eleven cases that follow, from Cleveland to Kitakyushu, that one act did what months or years of official work had not.

They divide roughly in two. In the first group the authorities already held what they needed: a complaint, a name, a license plate, a charge sheet. The escape forced them to use it. In the second there was no investigation worth the name until a frightened person arrived at a front desk and told a story that sounded, to some of the officers who heard it, too strange to be true. How each person got away matters less than what that person said once safe, who listened, and how long it took anyone to act.

Anthony Sowell: Cleveland, 2008 and 2009

Anthony Sowell came out of prison in 2005 after fifteen years for a sex offense and registered as a sex offender at a house on Cleveland’s east side. On December 8, 2008, a woman got away from that house and reached a police car. Officers arrested Sowell. He was released without charges. The Supreme Court of Ohio, reviewing the trial record years later, said the release came about because the arresting officer mislabeled the offense on the incident report. When CBS News obtained the sex crimes detective’s file in 2010, it showed a visit to the house but nothing about Sowell’s record, although police said it had been checked, and it recorded that detectives and prosecutors judged the evidence insufficient to prosecute.

City officials defended the work. "I wouldn’t say we dropped the ball, we were very vigilant in what we did," the police chief, Michael McGrath, told CBS. Tim McGinty, then a Cuyahoga County Common Pleas judge, described a practice detectives called "straight release," in which suspects were routinely let go rather than indicted. "They release 'em, it’s like trout fishing where you catch and release," he said.

Nine months later it happened again. On September 22, 2009, another woman got away from the house and reported that Sowell had sexually assaulted her. Police did not go to the house for more than a month, CBS News reported. On October 28, 2009, an officer working her complaint obtained warrants for his arrest and for the house. Sowell was gone when officers arrived the next evening. On October 31 a member of the public recognized him from television news, and he was arrested.

In July 2011 a Cuyahoga County jury convicted him on 81 counts, among them the aggravated murders of eleven women: Tonia Carmichael, Nancy Cobbs, Tishana Culver, Crystal Dozier, Telacia Fortson, Amelda Hunter, Leshanda Long, Michelle Mason, Kim Yvette Smith, Diane Turner and Janice Webb. The counts also covered the kidnapping, attempted murder and sexual assault of the women who had survived. Judge Dick Ambrose imposed eleven death sentences in August 2011, and the Supreme Court of Ohio affirmed them on December 8, 2016. Sowell died in state custody of a terminal illness on February 8, 2021, never executed.

The city answered with a commission. Mayor Frank Jackson’s Special Commission on Missing Persons and Sex Crimes Investigations reported on March 31, 2010, with 26 recommendations, all accepted by the mayor’s office, among them a missing persons unit inside the police department and an end to any waiting period before a missing person report could be taken. The families of six of the women sued the city over the December 2008 release, arguing that the detective assigned had failed to investigate it properly. In September 2018 Cleveland agreed to pay 1 million dollars, divided among the families of Nancy Cobbs, Telacia Fortson, Amelda Hunter, Leshanda Long, Diane Turner and Janice Webb, Ideastream reported.

Robert Pickton: Port Coquitlam, 1997

In March 1997 a woman escaped from Robert Pickton’s pig farm in Port Coquitlam, British Columbia. On April 1 he was charged with attempted murder, assault with a weapon and forcible confinement. On January 26, 1998, Crown counsel stayed the charges; The Canadian Encyclopedia reports that prosecutors did not consider her a competent witness. The Missing Women Commission of Inquiry later established that police had interviewed her only once and had taken no formal statement. It described "serious limitations on the initial investigation" by the Coquitlam RCMP and called it "patently unreasonable" that the case had not been pursued more fully. Clothing seized from Pickton in 1997 was not tested at the time. When publication bans lifted in 2010, CTV News reported that it held evidence that could have tied him to two other missing women.

Doug LePard, a Vancouver deputy chief who examined his own department’s handling of the case, reported in August 2010 that tips pointing to Pickton in 1998 and 1999 should have produced a more vigorous investigation, and that the delays likely cost the lives of more than a dozen women. Pickton was not arrested until February 2002, after officers executed a warrant on the farm over illegal firearms. On February 22, 2002, he was charged with two counts of first-degree murder. In his cell he told an undercover officer that he had killed 49 women, a claim no court ever tested.

On December 9, 2007, a jury in New Westminster convicted him of the second-degree murders of Sereena Abotsway, Mona Wilson, Andrea Joesbury, Brenda Ann Wolfe, Georgina Faith Papin and Marnie Frey, and he was sentenced to life with no parole eligibility for 25 years. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the convictions on July 30, 2010; five days later the Crown stayed twenty further first-degree murder charges. Commissioner Wally Oppal’s report, Forsaken, released in December 2012, called the investigations "a blatant failure" and said the women had been "forsaken by society at large and then again by the police." Pickton died on May 31, 2024, after he was assaulted by another inmate at Port-Cartier Institution in Quebec.

Herb Baumeister: Indianapolis and Westfield, 1994 to 1996

Herb Baumeister was never charged with any killing, and the case against him was never put to a jury. In 1994 the families of two missing Indianapolis men, Allen Wayne Broussard and Roger Allen Goodlet, hired Virgil Vandagriff, a former police detective working as a private investigator. That August, according to the police records WRTV later described, a man told investigators that someone calling himself Brian had tried to kill him at a large house with a swimming pool in the northern suburbs, and that he had got away. He could not find the house again. Detective Mary Wilson of the Indianapolis Police Department drove the area with him repeatedly, without result.

The break came eleven months later. In July 1995 the man saw the same person in a bar, and friends took down the license plate of his vehicle. It traced to Baumeister. In August 1995 Wilson went to his estate, Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, and saw that it matched the man’s description. A judge declined to sign a warrant. Vandagriff later told WRTV that Hamilton County judges did not consider the witness credible enough. On November 1, 1995, Wilson and a lieutenant confronted Baumeister, who said he would call them after speaking to a lawyer. Weeks later the lawyer told police his client would not consent to officers entering the property, and in December his wife, on her own lawyer’s advice, also declined.

The case moved again only in late June 1996, when the lawyer representing his wife in their divorce brought new information to Wilson and investigators entered the property with the wife’s consent. Baumeister had already gone to Ontario. On July 3, 1996, he took his own life in Pinery Provincial Park, near Grand Bend. A note he left spoke of his marriage and his businesses and said nothing about the missing men. Investigators came to regard him as the only suspect in the deaths of the men linked to Fox Hollow Farm, the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis records. The survivor of 1994 has never been accused of anything.

Robert Berdella: Kansas City, 1988

Kansas City was full of visitors for the NCAA Final Four basketball tournament on Easter weekend in 1988 when a young man escaped from Robert Berdella’s house in the Hyde Park neighborhood and went for help. Berdella was arrested that weekend. The man’s account was not taken at face value by everyone. Troy Cole, then a sergeant in the homicide unit and later a co-author of a book on the case, admitted afterward that his first impression was that the young man had been in a lovers' quarrel, The Pitch reported.

The murder cases followed within months. Berdella pleaded guilty on August 3, 1988, to the first-degree murder of Larry Pearson and was sentenced to life without parole. He also stood convicted of felonious restraint of the man who escaped and of a sexual offense against him, convictions the Supreme Court of Missouri later listed in a lawsuit he brought from prison. Prosecutors agreed not to seek the death penalty in return for his confessions and information, UPI reported, and on December 19, 1988, in Jackson County Circuit Court, he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murder of Robert Allen Sheldon and to the second-degree murders of Jerry Howell, James Ferris and Todd Stoops. At that hearing he gave the date of Howell’s death as July 6, 1984. Berdella died of a heart attack in prison in 1992.

Jeffrey Dahmer: Milwaukee, 1991

Two escapes bracket the end of Jeffrey Dahmer’s series, and only the second was acted on. In May 1991 a 14-year-old boy, Konerak Sinthasomphone, got away from Dahmer’s apartment in Milwaukee. A neighbor called the police, and the officers who answered returned the boy to the apartment, TMJ4 recounted in 2021. He was among the seventeen people Dahmer later admitted killing. The police chief, Philip Arreola, fired two of the officers, John Balcerzak and Joseph Gabrish, for failing to investigate. A state judge ruled the firings unreasonable because the evidence showed only a negligent failure to investigate, and the Board of Fire and Police Commissioners replaced them with 60-day suspensions and reinstated both men, according to a 1998 ruling of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

On a Monday night that July, Tracy Edwards, a 32-year-old father of six, escaped from the same apartment and alerted the police, the Deseret News reported, and Dahmer was arrested. He told detectives he had killed eleven people in the apartment, and police said they believed he had killed six others. In the end he admitted seventeen killings. He pleaded guilty but insane to fifteen counts of first-degree intentional homicide, and in February 1992 a Milwaukee jury rejected the insanity claim, voting ten to two on every count, enough under Wisconsin law, UPI reported. He was sentenced to fifteen consecutive life terms. Edwards testified at the trial. Dahmer was killed in prison on November 28, 1994.

Daniel Lee Corwin: College Station, 1988

On October 20, 1988, a Texas A&M University student was abducted on the College Station campus. She survived. She described the man to Karen T. Taylor, a forensic artist with the Texas Department of Public Safety, and police released the composite on October 24. More than a hundred tips came in, The Battalion, the university’s student newspaper, reported. One, an anonymous Crime Stoppers call from Madison County passed on by the county sheriff, Ed Fannin, named Daniel Lee Corwin.

Corwin was not a student, investigators learned. He was a parolee living in Huntsville, released on November 20, 1985, after serving about nine years of a 40-year sentence for a 1975 case in Bell County, a conviction with other charges. Police watched him because he resembled the sketch, and Bob Wiatt, director of the university police, obtained his fingerprints from authorities in Huntsville. They matched prints from the case, and a witness picked Corwin out of a photo lineup. Officers from the university police, the College Station and Huntsville police and the Walker County Sheriff’s Office arrested him at his home in late October 1988. He was 30.

He pleaded guilty in Brazos County to attempted capital murder and was sentenced to 99 years in early 1989. Later that year, while serving that term, he confessed to abducting and killing three women in 1987: Alice Martin, 72; Debra Ewing; and Mary Risinger, 36. The Montgomery County district attorney, Peter Speers, said his office held numerous signed statements and a videotaped confession. In March 1990 a jury in Conroe convicted Corwin of capital murder under the Texas provision for killing more than one person in separate transactions under the same scheme or course of conduct, and sentenced him to death. He was executed at Huntsville on December 7, 1998. Wiatt told The Battalion afterward that it was the A&M case that got Corwin identified.

Beoria Simmons: Louisville, 1983

On June 11, 1983, Beoria Simmons tried to abduct a woman in Louisville, Kentucky. She escaped and helped police identify him, and he was arrested the same day, WAVE News reported. The arrest closed a series of killings that had begun in 1981. At his 1985 trial in Jefferson County he was convicted of murder for the deaths of Robin Barnes, Shannon House and Nancy Bettman, and of four counts of kidnapping, with other charges, and he received six death sentences.

The appeals ran for a quarter of a century. Simmons, who is Black, argued that Jefferson County prosecutors had systematically kept minority jurors off his panel. In December 2009 U.S. District Judge Charles Simpson ruled that he could investigate how prosecutors had chosen his jury, calling the Kentucky Supreme Court’s refusal of a hearing a ruling that "defies logic," the Associated Press reported. In March 2010 Jefferson Circuit Judge Mary Shaw approved an agreement that changed the six death sentences to six terms of life without parole. Simmons dropped every appeal, and prosecutors ended their effort to execute him. Robin Barnes’s cousin told WAVE what prosecutors had explained to the families: after 29 years, a new trial could fail because many of the original detectives and witnesses might no longer be available.

Huang Yong: Pingyu County, 2003

Pingyu County lies in the southeast of Henan province, under the city of Zhumadian. The killings there went undetected until November 2003, when a youth escaped from Huang Yong, a 29-year-old farmer, and reported to the police. Huang was arrested on November 21, 2003, People’s Daily Online reported. A police record drawn up that month, quoted the following spring by the Beijing Youth Daily, has Huang telling the youth who escaped that he had already killed more than 20 people.

The court that tried him, sitting in his home county, held that between September 2001 and November 2003 he had killed 17 young people, most of them students, and had injured one more. On December 9, 2003, it convicted him of intentional homicide and sentenced him to death. He did not appeal. The Henan Higher People’s Court conducted the death penalty review, and on December 26, 2003, China News Service reported that he had been shot that morning. The official count was disputed. In November 2003 relatives of victims said county police had given them a figure of 23 dead, 18 of them students. In April 2004, after further material connected to the case came to light, police acknowledged failings in the earlier investigation and removed the head of the police technical unit responsible, the Beijing Youth Daily reported.

Alexander Komin: Vyatskiye Polyany, 1997

Alexander Komin, born in 1953 in Vyatskiye Polyany in the Kirov region, held people captive in a garage in the town in the mid-1990s. The case reached the police only when a woman he had taken there got away and went to them. The officers did not believe her at first, Novaya Gazeta Europe reported in a 2026 review of the case. Their view changed as she named people who had gone missing, and when officers acted on her account it was confirmed. Two other women who had been held captive survived. Rambler’s weekend magazine, in a 2025 account, dated the police operation to July 21, 1997.

Komin was said to have killed four people: Nikolai Malykh, Yevgeny Shishov, Tatyana Nazimova and Vera Talpaeva. On June 12, 1999, the Kirov Regional Court sentenced him to life imprisonment and his accomplice, Aleksandr Mikheev, to 20 years. Four days later Komin was dead in custody, reportedly by suicide. Mikheev was released in 2017 and died in 2022.

Futoshi Matsunaga: Kitakyushu, 2002

Seven people died in Kitakyushu between 1996 and 1998, and the deaths came to light only in 2002, because a 17-year-old girl who had been held by Futoshi Matsunaga and his common-law wife, Junko Ogata, got away from them in early 2002, and on March 6 of that year went to the police with her grandfather. On March 7 Fukuoka Prefectural Police arrested a man and a woman, both about 40, for confining and assaulting her. Neither would give a name.

Early reports treated it as a confinement case. On September 18, 2002, the couple were arrested on suspicion of murder for the first time, and further arrests followed death by death. Investigators had almost no physical evidence of the killings. The prosecution rested on the testimony of the girl and of Ogata, who largely admitted the charges and said Matsunaga had directed everything, according to the journalist Kazuteru Ono, who has covered the case since 2002.

On September 28, 2005, the Kokura Branch of the Fukuoka District Court convicted both of six murders and one count of injury resulting in death, with confinement causing injury, fraud and robbery, and sentenced both to death. The court held that the victims, the girl’s father and six members of Ogata’s family, had died between 1996 and 1998. The Fukuoka High Court upheld Matsunaga’s sentence on September 26, 2007, and reduced Ogata’s to life imprisonment. The Supreme Court of Japan rejected his appeal on December 12, 2011, making the death sentence final. In 2024 he was held at the Fukuoka Detention Center, and no execution of him had been reported as of October 2026.

Michel Fourniret: Ciney, 2003

On June 26, 2003, a 13-year-old girl survived an abduction by Michel Fourniret in Ciney, in the Belgian province of Namur, and Belgian police arrested him. For a year he was held at Dinant on that attempted abduction alone, and no one connected him with the dead girls and young women in France.

The connection came from his wife. In June 2004, questioned by Belgian police, Monique Olivier began to describe her husband’s past, and faced with her statements Fourniret admitted eight homicides in France and Belgium since 1987. On May 28, 2008, the Ardennes assize court at Charleville-Mézières convicted him of seven murders, with other charges, of Isabelle Laville, Fabienne Leroy, Jeanne-Marie Desramault, Elisabeth Brichet, Natacha Danais, Céline Saison and Mananya Thumpong, and of the attempts on three girls and young women who had escaped, the Ciney girl among them. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with no possibility of release. On November 16, 2018, the Yvelines assize court at Versailles sentenced him to life for the murder of Farida Hammiche.

He confessed to three more deaths, of Marie-Angèle Domèce, Joanna Parrish and Estelle Mouzin, but died in a Paris hospital on May 10, 2021, at 79, before he could be tried for them. In December 2023 Olivier was convicted on her own of complicity in all three and sentenced to life.

What the escapes exposed

Two of these cases produced formal public reckonings, and both turned on the response rather than on the offender. Cleveland’s commission wrote 26 recommendations about how the city took missing person reports and handled sex crimes complaints. Oppal’s inquiry in British Columbia identified seven critical police failures and made 63 recommendations. In Milwaukee two officers were fired and then reinstated. In Pingyu an official lost his post. In Kansas City and Vyatskiye Polyany the first officers to hear the account doubted it, and in Hamilton County a judge would not sign the warrant the account supported.

Credibility was the hinge each time. The woman who escaped the Port Coquitlam farm in 1997 was judged an unsuitable witness, and the charges against Pickton were stayed. The woman who got out of Sowell’s house in December 2008 saw the man she accused released without charges. Where the survivor was believed at once, the arrest followed fast: the same day in Louisville, within the same month in College Station and in Pingyu.

Ciney stands apart. The girl who got away there was believed and the man was arrested. Even so, it took his wife’s statements a year later before anyone understood whom the Belgian police were holding.

Timeline

• 1981 to 1983: the Louisville killings for which Beoria Simmons was later convicted.

• June 11, 1983: a woman escapes from Simmons in Louisville; he is arrested the same day.

• July 6, 1984: the date Robert Berdella later gave for the death of Jerry Howell.

• 1985: Simmons is convicted in Jefferson County and receives six death sentences.

• November 20, 1985: Daniel Lee Corwin is paroled in Texas.

• April 1988: a young man escapes from Berdella’s house in Kansas City; Berdella is arrested.

• August 3 and December 19, 1988: Berdella pleads guilty to five murders in Jackson County.

• October 20, 1988: a Texas A&M student survives an abduction in College Station; a composite is released on October 24, and Corwin is arrested later that month.

• 1989: Corwin pleads guilty to attempted capital murder and confesses to three 1987 killings.

• March 1990: Corwin is convicted of capital murder in Conroe and sentenced to death.

• May 1991: a 14-year-old boy gets away from Jeffrey Dahmer’s apartment in Milwaukee; officers return him.

• July 1991: Tracy Edwards escapes from the same apartment; Dahmer is arrested.

• February 1992: a Milwaukee jury rejects Dahmer’s insanity claim; he receives fifteen consecutive life terms.

• 1992: Berdella dies in prison.

• August 1994: a man tells investigators in Indianapolis that he got away from a man calling himself Brian.

• November 28, 1994: Dahmer is killed in prison.

• July and August 1995: the same man takes down a license plate that traces to Herb Baumeister; a judge declines to sign a warrant.

• July 3, 1996: Baumeister takes his own life in Ontario, never charged.

• March 1997: a woman escapes from Robert Pickton’s farm in Port Coquitlam; charges follow on April 1.

• July 1997: police act on the account of a woman who escaped from Alexander Komin in Vyatskiye Polyany.

• January 26, 1998: the charges against Pickton are stayed.

• December 7, 1998: Corwin is executed in Huntsville.

• June 12, 1999: the Kirov Regional Court sentences Komin to life; he dies in custody four days later.

• February 22, 2002: Pickton is charged with two counts of first-degree murder.

• March 6 and 7, 2002: a 17-year-old girl goes to the police in Kitakyushu; Futoshi Matsunaga and Junko Ogata are arrested.

• June 26, 2003: a 13-year-old girl escapes from Michel Fourniret in Ciney; he is arrested in Belgium.

• November 21, 2003: Huang Yong is arrested in Pingyu County after a youth escapes and goes to the police.

• December 9 and 26, 2003: Huang is sentenced to death and executed.

• June 2004: Monique Olivier begins to describe Fourniret’s past to Belgian police.

• September 28, 2005: Matsunaga is sentenced to death in Kokura.

• December 9, 2007: Pickton is convicted of six counts of second-degree murder.

• May 28, 2008: Fourniret is convicted of seven murders at Charleville-Mézières.

• December 8, 2008: a woman escapes from Anthony Sowell’s house in Cleveland; he is arrested and released without charges.

• September 22, 2009: a second woman escapes and reports to police; Sowell is arrested on October 31.

• March 2010: Simmons’s six death sentences are changed to life without parole.

• March 31, 2010: Cleveland’s special commission issues 26 recommendations.

• August 4, 2010: the Crown stays twenty further murder charges against Pickton.

• July 22, 2011: Sowell is convicted on 81 counts, including eleven aggravated murders.

• December 12, 2011: Japan’s Supreme Court makes Matsunaga’s death sentence final.

• December 2012: the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry releases Forsaken.

• September 2018: Cleveland agrees to pay 1 million dollars to the families of six of Sowell’s victims.

• November 16, 2018: Fourniret receives a further life sentence at Versailles.

• February 8, 2021: Sowell dies in custody.

• May 10, 2021: Fourniret dies in Paris.

• December 2023: Olivier is convicted of complicity in three more killings.

• May 31, 2024: Pickton dies after an assault in prison.