TWELVE DEATH SENTENCES THE STATE NEVER CARRIED OUT

A death sentence is the most exact order an American court can give. It names the prisoner, the crime and the penalty, and in the years when judges still did so it named the day. What it cannot do is make the state keep the appointment. The twelve cases that follow come from state courts across the country and from the federal system. In each one a judge or jury chose death, the higher courts let the choice stand or kept it under review for decades, and no executioner ever went to work. Most of the condemned died in prison of cancer, heart disease or old age. Two had their sentences thrown out by federal judges. Two more were last reported still waiting.

Lawrence Bittaker: from Torrance to San Quentin

On February 17, 1981, a Los Angeles County jury sitting in Torrance convicted Lawrence Bittaker, a paroled machinist from Burbank, on all 26 counts against him, among them five counts of murder with special circumstances and five of kidnapping. The victims were five teenage girls abducted in the South Bay and the San Fernando Valley between June and October 1979: Lucinda Schaefer, Andrea Hall, Jacqueline Gilliam, Jacqueline Leah Lamp and Shirley Ledford. His partner, Roy Norris, a younger man he had met in prison, pleaded guilty and testified against him. The jury returned a death verdict a week after the guilty verdicts, and United Press International reported the formal sentence of death on March 24, 1981. Bittaker was 40.

The California Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and the sentence on June 22, 1989. After that the case moved into the slower currents of state and federal habeas corpus, where it was still being argued in the Ninth Circuit in 2003. In March 2019 Governor Gavin Newsom signed an executive order halting executions in California and reprieving every prisoner on the state’s death row, 737 people in all, and Bittaker was among them. He died of natural causes on San Quentin’s death row on December 13, 2019. He was 79. The Associated Press, reporting his death, recalled the name the press had given the pair decades earlier: the "Tool Box Killers."

Richard Ramirez: the gas chamber that sat idle

The man Los Angeles called the Night Stalker was caught on August 31, 1985, in East Los Angeles, by residents who recognized his face from the morning papers and held him for police. In September 1989 a Los Angeles jury convicted Richard Ramirez on all 43 counts tried: 12 counts of first degree murder, one of second degree murder, and 30 other felonies, among them attempted murder and burglary, committed in homes across Los Angeles County between June 1984 and August 1985. On November 7, 1989, Judge Michael Tynan sentenced him to die in the gas chamber. At the time California had 265 people under sentence of death and had not used the gas chamber at San Quentin since 1967.

The automatic appeal was not decided until 2006. On August 7 of that year, the California Supreme Court unanimously affirmed the convictions and the sentence, and in 2007 the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case, which made the judgment final. When he died, the Associated Press reported, other appeals were still pending. On June 7, 2013, he died at Marin General Hospital, where he had been taken from death row for treatment. He was 53. The Marin County coroner later gave the cause as complications of B-cell lymphoma, with chronic substance abuse and hepatitis C as contributing factors, CBS San Francisco reported. In 2009 San Francisco police had linked him by DNA to the 1984 killing of Mei Leung, a nine-year-old girl. He was never charged with it.

William Richard Bradford: the date he asked for

William Richard Bradford was a freelance photographer in West Los Angeles. In July 1984 Shari Miller, 21, and Tracey Campbell, 15, who had come to Los Angeles from Montana that spring, were killed. Bradford had photographed Miller and told detectives he had known her for two years. A Los Angeles County jury convicted him of both first degree murders, with a multiple-murder special circumstance. The Associated Press later put the verdict in 1987; a 1998 newsletter of Amnesty International’s Pasadena group put it in 1988. Bradford represented himself at the penalty phase, offered no evidence, and told the jurors, "Think of how many you don’t even know about." They chose death. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in its entirety on July 14, 1997.

Then Bradford gave up his appeals. The state set his execution for August 18, 1998, at San Quentin, and Amnesty’s Pasadena group asked Governor Pete Wilson to commute the sentence and planned a vigil for the night before. The execution did not take place. He was back in the news for another reason in July 2006, when the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department released dozens of photographs of women from his seized collection and asked the public to help identify them, saying it was convinced he had committed at least one other killing, from 1978, which he denied. In November 2006 CBS News reported that he remained on death row at San Quentin and that his lawyers were seeking a new trial.

Robert Rubane Diaz: the nurse on every shift

In March and April 1981, patients began dying at night in the small intensive care unit of a community hospital in Perris, in Riverside County. Robert Rubane Diaz, a registered nurse, worked the night shifts there. He was charged with the deaths of twelve patients from lidocaine poisoning, waived a jury, and was tried before Judge John H. Barnard of the Riverside County Superior Court, who convicted him of 12 counts of first degree murder and sentenced him to death. The trial was over by the end of 1984.

On August 31, 1992, the California Supreme Court affirmed. Only one nurse, the court noted, had been on duty on all the nights the fatal doses were given; no other nurse had been there on more than five of them. The evidence, it said, pointed "unerringly" to Diaz. He did not accept the verdict. In 1993 he was in the New York courts, seeking access to the records of a medical research study he hoped would help him, and on November 16 of that year the New York Court of Appeals ruled that he had a substantial interest in at least some of them. As of that ruling he remained under sentence of death in California and still maintained that the deaths were not murders.

Rodney Alcala: three trials, one sentence

On June 20, 1979, twelve-year-old Robin Samsoe disappeared in Huntington Beach. Rodney Alcala, a UCLA-trained photographer who the year before had appeared on The Dating Game and won, was tried for her murder in Orange County and sentenced to death in 1980. The California Supreme Court reversed that conviction in 1984. A second jury convicted him and sentenced him to death in 1986; the state supreme court affirmed in 1992, but the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals set the conviction aside in 2003.

The third trial joined the Samsoe case to the killings of four women in Los Angeles County: Jill Barcomb, 18; Georgia Wixted, 27; Charlotte Lamb, 32; and Jill Parenteau, 21. On February 25, 2010, an Orange County jury convicted Alcala of all five murders and of kidnapping, and on March 30, 2010, Judge Francisco Briseño sentenced him to death for the third time. In 2012 he was extradited to New York, where in December 2012 he pleaded guilty to the murders of Cornelia Crilley and Ellen Hover, both 23, killed in Manhattan in 1971 and 1977; he received 25 years to life. In 2016 Wyoming charged him with the murder of Christine Ruth Thornton, 28.

He was never tried there. Alcala died of natural causes on July 24, 2021, at a hospital in Kings County, California, near the Corcoran prison where he had been moved for constant medical care. He was 77. The appeal of his 2010 judgment had last been reported pending, and the Wyoming charge was dismissed after his death.

The California pattern

Five of the twelve were condemned in California. When Governor Newsom signed his order on March 13, 2019, UPI counted 737 prisoners on the state’s death row and reported that the last execution there had been that of Clarence Ray Allen, 76, on January 17, 2006. The order closed the execution chamber at San Quentin, withdrew the state’s lethal injection protocol and granted reprieves to everyone waiting. Bittaker and Alcala both died after it was signed. Ramirez died during the long pause that preceded it.

Howard A. Allen Jr.: a sentence undone

Indiana condemned Howard A. Allen Jr. on August 30, 1988. A Marion County jury had convicted him of the murder and robbery of Ernestine Griffin, 74, who was killed in her Indianapolis home on July 14, 1987. He already had a conviction for the voluntary manslaughter of an 85-year-old woman, named by the Indiana Supreme Court as Olga Cooper. The court affirmed the conviction and the death sentence in 1997.

The longest fight in Allen’s case was over his childhood. School records showed IQ scores of 70 and 68 and years in special education classes; a prison test given when he was an adult showed 104. After the United States Supreme Court barred the execution of people with mental retardation in 2002, those scores stopped being a plea for mercy and became a possible bar to execution. The Indiana courts held that the question had already been decided against him. In 2009 the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago disagreed and sent the case back for a hearing. A federal district court then found him mentally retarded under Indiana law and vacated the death sentence, the state dropped its appeal under a sentencing agreement, and on May 28, 2013, he was resentenced to 60 years for the murder. He did not die on death row. As of October 2026 the Indiana Department of Correction listed him as deceased.

John Paul Phillips: the cases that closed after him

On the night of November 10, 1981, Joan Weatherall, a waitress at a hotel lounge in Carbondale, Illinois, was killed; her death came to light the next day near Elkville. A Jackson County grand jury indicted John Paul Phillips, a Carbondale native, on April 8, 1986. At his request the trial was moved to Massac County, where a jury convicted him of murder. It acquitted him of the two felony murder counts tied to sexual offenses. He waived a jury for sentencing, and the judge sentenced him to death. On March 29, 1989, the Illinois Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and the sentence and set September 13, 1989, as the date of execution.

Phillips was still on death row at Menard Correctional Center when he died of a heart attack in 1993, the Associated Press reported. At his sentencing a former cellmate had testified that Phillips bragged about two earlier killings of Southern Illinois University students, Theresa Clark, 22, a graduate student killed in January 1975, and Kathleen McSharry, 24, killed in July 1976. He was never tried for either. In 2001 a judge allowed investigators to exhume his body for DNA testing. On September 18, 2008, Carbondale police announced that a newer form of DNA analysis at the Illinois State Police laboratory had matched him to the McSharry case, and that they had also concluded he was responsible for Clark’s death, relying on the cellmate’s account and the similarities between the two cases. Neither killing was ever tested in a courtroom.

Daniel Lee Siebert: waiting on Baze

On the night of February 19, 1986, in Talladega, Alabama, Sherri Weathers, 24, her sons Chad, 5, and Joey, 4, and her neighbor Linda Jarman were killed. The man who had been seen with the women that evening was a newcomer who called himself Danial Spence and had come to town to build theater sets for the state institute for deaf and blind students. Six months later he was arrested in Tennessee and identified as Daniel Lee Siebert, a freelance artist with an earlier conviction for voluntary manslaughter. A Talladega County jury convicted him of the capital murder of Linda Jarman on March 19, 1987, and he was sentenced to death on April 17. A Lee County jury convicted him in June 1987 of the capital murder of Sherri Weathers and her two sons, and he was sentenced to death a second time on August 19.

Twenty years of appeals later, Alabama set his execution for October 25, 2007. By then Siebert was dying of pancreatic cancer, and he argued in federal court that his illness made it likely the lethal injection would cause him severe pain. A district judge refused a stay. On October 24, the day before the execution, a panel of the Eleventh Circuit stopped it pending the Supreme Court’s decision in Baze v. Rees, the Kentucky lethal injection case. The Supreme Court upheld Kentucky’s method on April 16, 2008. On April 22, Siebert was pronounced dead on Alabama’s death row. He was 53, and his death appeared to be related to the cancer, a Department of Corrections spokesman told the Associated Press.

Gerald Patrick Lewis: two states, two sentences

Gerald Patrick Lewis was arrested in Mobile County, Alabama, in April 1998 for the murder of Kathleen Bracken, and went on to confess to more. A Baldwin County jury convicted him in February 2000 of the capital murder of Misty McGugin, and he was sentenced to death. He received life without parole for Bracken’s murder. Georgia wanted him too. In the summer of 1993 Peggy Lynn Grimes, 22 and close to giving birth, had gone missing from Atlanta; Lewis confessed to killing her. On November 19, 2001, in Douglas County, Georgia, he pleaded guilty to malice murder, felony murder, feticide, aggravated battery and kidnapping with bodily injury, and in March 2003 a Georgia jury sentenced him to death. The Supreme Court of Georgia affirmed on September 19, 2005.

Neither state executed him. Lewis died on Alabama’s death row in July 2009; the Douglas County Sentinel later reported the cause as cancer. The Douglas County district attorney said he had admitted killing five young women; Lewis claimed more than twenty. One more killing he confessed to, of a woman near Atlanta in 1993 who has not been identified, did not reach a court.

Derrick Todd Lee: the end of the appeals

From the fall of 2001 into the spring of 2003, investigators in Baton Rouge and Lafayette tied the killings of several women to the DNA of one unknown man. In May 2003 a court-ordered cheek swab from Derrick Todd Lee, a laborer from St. Francisville, matched that profile. In August 2004 a West Baton Rouge Parish jury convicted him of the second degree murder of Geralyn Barr DeSoto, 21, and he was sentenced to life. In October 2004 an East Baton Rouge Parish jury convicted him of the first degree murder of Charlotte Murray Pace, 22, and recommended death; the sentence was imposed on December 10, 2004. Five more killings linked to him by DNA, those of Gina Wilson Green, Pam Kinamore, Trineisha Dené Colomb, Carrie Lynn Yoder and Randi Mebruer, were put before courts as evidence or charging papers but never tried.

The Louisiana Supreme Court affirmed the Pace conviction and sentence in January 2008. A district court denied post-conviction relief in August 2014, and the Louisiana Supreme Court refused it in September 2015. On January 16, 2016, Lee was taken from the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola to a hospital for emergency care. He died there on January 21, the Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections said, and the West Feliciana Parish coroner’s office later gave the cause as heart disease. He was 47. "Condemned serial killer dies in hospital, not death chamber," ran the Associated Press headline.

Joseph Edward Duncan III: thirteen executions without him

In May 2005, near Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, Brenda Groene, 40, her son Slade Groene, 13, and her fiancé Mark McKenzie, 37, were killed, and her two youngest children were taken. Her son Dylan, 9, was killed in Montana weeks later; his sister survived. Joseph Edward Duncan III, a registered sex offender from Fargo, North Dakota, pleaded guilty in Idaho state court in October 2006 to the three murders and three kidnappings, and in December 2007 to ten federal counts arising from Dylan’s death, three of them capital. A federal jury returned three death sentences on August 27, 2008. In 2011 he pleaded guilty in Riverside County, California, to the 1997 murder of Anthony Martinez, 10, and received life. Federal prosecutors also attributed to him the 1996 deaths of two girls in Seattle, Sammiejo White, 11, and Carmen Cubias, 9; he was never charged with them.

Duncan tried to give up his appeals, and the question of whether he was competent to do so took years. In December 2013 a federal judge found that he was. The Ninth Circuit dismissed his appeal in 2015, and in March 2016 the United States Supreme Court refused to hear the matter. Then the federal government resumed executions. Beginning in July 2020, after a 17-year pause, it put thirteen people to death in about six months, the last of them on January 16, 2021, the Associated Press reported; no president in more than 120 years had overseen as many. Duncan was not among them, and no execution date was ever set for him. He died on March 28, 2021, at a hospital near the federal prison in Terre Haute, where he had been held on death row. He was 58 and had been diagnosed with glioblastoma, an aggressive brain cancer, The Spokesman-Review reported.

Faye and Ray Copeland: two sentences, two endings

The last case is two cases. In the late 1980s Ray Copeland, a farmer near Mooresville in Livingston County, Missouri, hired homeless men from missions in Springfield and Joplin, used them to buy cattle at auction with bad checks, and then, prosecutors said, shot them before the checks could bring anyone looking. Five were found dead in the fall of 1989: Paul Cowart, John Freeman, Jimmie Harvey, Wayne Warner and Dennis Murphy. His wife, Faye, kept records and helped with the paperwork of the fraud. There was no evidence she fired a shot. A jury in Chillicothe convicted her on November 10, 1990, of five counts of first degree murder as an accomplice, and recommended death on four of them. She was 69, and she came to be described as the oldest woman on death row in the United States.

Ray Copeland was convicted of the same five murders on March 20, 1991, and sentenced to death on each count. An attorney general’s spokesman said he had apparently become the oldest inmate on death row in the nation. Ray suffered from a degenerative brain disease, and he died at the Potosi Correctional Center in 1993, at 78, still awaiting execution, the Associated Press reported.

Faye Copeland’s sentences followed a different path. The Supreme Court of Missouri affirmed them in 1996. On August 4, 1999, a federal district court left her convictions in place but vacated the death sentences, finding that the prosecutor’s penalty-phase argument had been improper and that her lawyers had failed to object; the case for death, the court wrote, had been "rather weak." The Eighth Circuit affirmed in November 2000, and in May 2001 she was sentenced to life without parole. After a stroke she was released on medical parole in 2002, and she died in a nursing home in Chillicothe in December 2003, aged 82.

What the courts ordered

Lawrence Bittaker, Richard Ramirez, Rodney Alcala, John Paul Phillips, Daniel Siebert, Gerald Lewis, Derrick Todd Lee, Joseph Duncan and Ray Copeland died while the sentence still stood. Faye Copeland and Howard Allen won their way off death row in federal court. William Bradford was last reported waiting at San Quentin in 2006, Robert Diaz in 1993. A death sentence records what a court decided. What became of the people under it was settled by appellate calendars, by governors and by illness.

Timeline

• February 17, 1981: Lawrence Bittaker convicted in Torrance; sentenced to death in March 1981.

• November 10, 1981: Joan Weatherall is killed in Carbondale, Illinois.

• By December 31, 1984: Robert Diaz convicted of 12 murders and sentenced to death in Riverside County.

• April 8, 1986: John Paul Phillips indicted in Jackson County, Illinois; later convicted in Massac County and sentenced to death.

• March 19 and April 17, 1987: Daniel Siebert convicted in Talladega County and sentenced to death; second death sentence, Lee County, August 19, 1987.

• August 30, 1988: Howard A. Allen Jr. sentenced to death in Indianapolis.

• March 29, 1989: Illinois Supreme Court affirms Phillips’s sentence and sets an execution date of September 13, 1989.

• November 7, 1989: Richard Ramirez sentenced to death in Los Angeles.

• November 10, 1990: Faye Copeland convicted in Chillicothe, Missouri; Ray Copeland convicted March 20, 1991.

• August 31, 1992: California Supreme Court affirms Diaz’s convictions and sentence.

• 1993: John Paul Phillips dies of a heart attack on Illinois’s death row; Ray Copeland dies at the Potosi Correctional Center.

• November 16, 1993: New York Court of Appeals rules in Diaz’s favor on research records; he remains under sentence of death.

• July 14, 1997: California Supreme Court affirms William Bradford’s death judgment.

• August 18, 1998: Execution date set for Bradford; it does not go ahead.

• August 4, 1999: Federal court vacates Faye Copeland’s death sentences; life without parole follows in May 2001.

• February 2000: Gerald Patrick Lewis convicted of capital murder in Baldwin County, Alabama; Georgia death sentence follows in March 2003.

• 2002: Faye Copeland released on medical parole; she dies in December 2003.

• December 10, 2004: Derrick Todd Lee sentenced to death in Baton Rouge.

• January 17, 2006: California executes Clarence Ray Allen; in March 2019 it was still the state’s most recent execution.

• August 7, 2006: California Supreme Court affirms Ramirez’s convictions and sentence.

• October 24, 2007: Eleventh Circuit stays Siebert’s execution, set for the next day.

• April 22, 2008: Siebert dies on Alabama’s death row.

• August 27, 2008: Federal jury returns three death sentences against Joseph Edward Duncan III.

• September 18, 2008: Carbondale police announce that DNA ties Phillips to the McSharry case and that they hold him responsible for Clark’s death.

• July 2009: Lewis dies on Alabama’s death row.

• March 30, 2010: Rodney Alcala sentenced to death in Orange County for the third time.

• May 28, 2013: Allen resentenced to 60 years after a federal court vacates his death sentence.

• June 7, 2013: Ramirez dies at Marin General Hospital.

• January 21, 2016: Lee dies after being taken from Angola for emergency care.

• March 13, 2019: Governor Gavin Newsom halts executions in California and reprieves 737 condemned prisoners.

• December 13, 2019: Bittaker dies on San Quentin’s death row.

• July 2020 to January 16, 2021: The federal government carries out thirteen executions.

• March 28, 2021: Duncan dies near the federal prison in Terre Haute, Indiana.

• July 24, 2021: Alcala dies in Kings County, California.