THIRTEEN CASES WHERE THE SUSPECT WAS RELEASED

In September 1984 two police officers at the bus station in Rostov-on-Don grew suspicious of a man in the crowd and followed him across the city to the central market before they stopped him. He was a factory supply agent named Andrei Chikatilo. When he walked out of custody early in 1985, the investigators hunting the killer of children and young women along the region’s railway lines had crossed him off their list. He killed for almost six more years.

A release that later proves costly is rarely an act of carelessness that can be pinned on one person. More often it is an ordinary decision made for ordinary reasons: a laboratory result, a polygraph chart, a psychiatric opinion, a witness the prosecutor did not trust, a plea bargain, a parole order signed by a judge who had seen the prisoner come back on time before. The thirteen cases that follow, from Montana to Kerala, turn on decisions of that kind. In each the investigation, or the court, had the man in hand, and in each he left.

Andrei Chikatilo: the blood test

What saved Chikatilo in 1984 was serology. The laboratory work in the Rostov investigation had assigned the killer to blood group IV, AB in Western notation; Chikatilo’s blood was recorded as group II. Issa Kostoyev, the investigator who later led the case, told Lenta.ru in 2022 that the first expert had recorded Chikatilo’s group as II and that later testing established group IV. In 1984, with no direct evidence against him and a blood group that did not fit, he was ruled out as a murder suspect. He was prosecuted instead on an old theft complaint from a former employer, and he was released early in 1985, Peter Conradi reported in The Moscow Times in 1992.

Police arrested him again in Novocherkassk on November 20, 1990. In October 1992 the Rostov Regional Court convicted him of 52 murders and sentenced him to death, The Moscow Times reported. The Supreme Court of Russia struck nine of those murders from the verdict in 1993 for lack of proof and upheld the sentence on the remaining 43, according to an Investigative Committee of Russia project reported by Amitel in 2019. President Boris Yeltsin rejected his plea for clemency, and he was shot at the prison in Novocherkassk on February 14, 1994, United Press International reported.

His was not the only wrong turn in the case. The first killing Chikatilo confessed to, of a nine-year-old girl in Shakhty in December 1978, had already been charged to a local man, who was convicted and shot in 1983. That verdict was overturned in 1990. Amurkhan Yandiev, an investigator who later worked the Chikatilo case, told an interviewer in September 2026, as Rossiyskaya Gazeta reported, that had the right man been held responsible in 1979, more than 50 lives could have been saved.

D.M.: the polygraph

On June 25, 1973, seven-year-old Susie Jaeger was abducted near Three Forks, Montana. Investigators came to suspect D.M., a 24-year-old contractor from the nearby town of Manhattan whom the Alicia Patterson Foundation later described as a loner. He passed a polygraph examination, and he passed a test given under a so-called truth serum, Susie’s mother, Marietta Jaeger, later recounted in a talk reported by the Valley Journal of Ronan, Montana.

In February 1974 a 19-year-old woman from Manhattan, Sandra Smallegan, disappeared. On June 25, 1974, a year to the day after the abduction, a caller who said he had taken Susie telephoned the Jaeger home in Michigan in the early hours. The FBI was recording the line, and Marietta Jaeger kept him talking for more than an hour. The recording, the FBI said, confirmed the caller’s identity as D.M.

He was arrested in 1974. He confessed to the 1967 death of a 13-year-old boy, the 1968 death of a 12-year-old Boy Scout, the death of Sandra Smallegan and the death of Susie Jaeger. Hours later, on September 29, 1974, he took his own life in his cell, according to the Alicia Patterson Foundation account. He was never tried, and no court ruled on his guilt. Marietta Jaeger went on to campaign against the death penalty, and she told the Bozeman Daily Chronicle in 2008 that his death had brought her no relief.

Peter Sutcliffe: the tape

Between 1975 and 1980 the West Yorkshire inquiry into the killings of women in Leeds, Bradford, Halifax, Huddersfield and Manchester interviewed Peter Sutcliffe, a truck driver from Bradford, nine times. On the fifth occasion, in July 1979, two detectives, Andrew Laptew and Graham Greenwood, came away suspicious and wrote a report saying so. The report was filed away. Sutcliffe’s voice and handwriting did not match the letters and the cassette tape the inquiry had accepted as coming from the killer, the Yorkshire Post reported in its 2019 obituary of Laptew, and the tape carried a Wearside accent. Dialect experts had placed the voice in Sunderland, and detectives were told they could eliminate men who did not speak like it.

The tape was a hoax. Its author, John Humble, a laborer from Sunderland, was identified through DNA in 2005, pleaded guilty in 2006 to perverting the course of justice and was sentenced to eight years. The Court of Appeal, dismissing his appeal against the sentence that October, held that it could not be said his conduct caused the later deaths, but noted the sentencing judge’s view that the turn of the hunt toward a Wearside man had given Sutcliffe confidence.

Sutcliffe was arrested in Sheffield on January 2, 1981, by two officers on patrol after a check showed false number plates on his car, and two days later he confessed. On May 22, 1981, an Old Bailey jury convicted him of the murders of 13 women; he had already pleaded guilty to seven attempted murders. The review of the inquiry by Lawrence Byford, summarized for Parliament on January 19, 1982, concluded that "excessive credence" had been given to the letters and tape, that the major incident room had been overwhelmed, and that on the facts that emerged from his interviews there was little doubt he should have been arrested earlier. Sutcliffe died in custody on November 13, 2020, the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman recorded.

Gary Ridgway: the polygraph again

The task force formed in King County, Washington, to investigate the deaths of women and girls from Pacific Highway South knew Gary Ridgway’s name for most of the 1980s. He was a truck painter at the Kenworth plant who admitted picking up women on the highway, and he made the list of suspects for that reason, HistoryLink.org recorded. He took a polygraph test in the inquiry and passed, CBS News reported in 2004. In 1987 detectives collected a saliva sample from him. Investigators still could not tie him to any of the deaths, apart from one eyewitness account of a woman getting into his vehicle, and he was not charged.

The 48 murders he would later admit ran from 1982 to 1998. The sample sat in storage until 2001, when the Washington State Patrol crime laboratory could test it with newer methods, and the profile matched evidence from early cases in the series. Ridgway was arrested on November 30, 2001. On November 5, 2003, he pleaded guilty to 48 counts of aggravated first-degree murder under an agreement that took the death penalty off the table in exchange for a full accounting, HistoryLink.org reported, and in December 2003 he was sentenced to life without parole, the Associated Press reported. He pleaded guilty to a 49th murder, of Rebecca Marrero, in February 2011, KNKX Public Radio reported.

Charles Hatcher: the wrong man released, the right man free

Eric Christgen was four years old when he was abducted from a shopping mall in St. Joseph, Missouri, on May 26, 1978, and killed. An anonymous caller put a 24-year-old house painter, M.L.R., near the mall that day, according to the National Registry of Exonerations. He did not match the witnesses' description of a gray-haired older man. Police brought him in nine times over eight months; he took a polygraph, was hypnotized and was questioned under sodium amytal, the law professor Samuel R. Gross wrote in 1998. After a final interrogation in February 1979 that the Registry puts at 12 to 13 hours, he confessed. He was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in October 1979, on a case that rested largely on that confession.

The man the witnesses had described stayed at large. Charles Hatcher, a drifter whose trail of violence ran, federal officials told UPI, from San Francisco to Rock Island, Illinois, was arrested in August 1982 in the death of 11-year-old Michelle Steele of St. Joseph. In July 1983 he wrote to the FBI admitting the Christgen killing. In October 1983 he pleaded guilty to that murder and was sentenced to life with no parole for 50 years, and a Buchanan County circuit judge ordered M.L.R.'s immediate release; the prosecutor who had convicted him called the imprisonment "a terrible tragedy." His conviction was reversed and the charge dismissed on November 21, 1983. On September 22, 1984, a jury convicted Hatcher of capital murder in the Steele case, and that December he died in his cell at the Missouri State Penitentiary, UPI reported.

Mahanand Naik: the drivers' protest

On September 11, 1995, Vasanti Gaude was killed at Bethora village in Ponda, Goa, the Herald of Goa reported. Mahanand Naik, an auto-rickshaw driver from Shiroda, was picked up that year on suspicion of kidnapping her. According to the writer Mukesh Kumar, whose book on the case was launched in Panaji in October 2025, as The Goan reported, he was let go after a protest by drivers, a release Kumar called a serious failure. Arab News reported in 2009 that his arrest in 1995 and release without charge had raised questions in Goa about how he went unnoticed for so long afterward.

Ponda police arrested him again in April 2009 on a woman’s complaint of sexual assault and blackmail, and within weeks, according to reports at the time, he was said to have confessed to the deaths of 16 young women over 15 years. Police registered 16 murder cases. The courts did not follow the confession. He was convicted of Vasanti Gaude’s murder in July 2011 and sentenced to life, and the Supreme Court of India dismissed his appeal, the Herald reported. He was convicted in at least one more murder case, while in May 2017 The Goan counted his ninth acquittal in 16 murder cases, most of them on the benefit of the doubt. In June 2023 he was granted a 21-day furlough, his first release in 14 years, and in December 2024 the High Court of Bombay at Goa told the state’s Sentence Review Board to reconsider his plea for premature release, The Goan reported.

Billy Mansfield Jr.: the bargain in Michigan

Billy Mansfield Jr., whose family lived on rural land in Hernando County, Florida, faced a case in Kent County, Michigan, at the end of the 1970s that involved two teenage girls. He agreed to testify against a cellmate in a murder case; the arrangement cut his term to about a year behind bars, and he was released in February 1980, according to a 2020 Cox Media Group account published by WFTV. In June 1980 he was accused in Hernando County of false imprisonment and battery against a woman, and he left for California with a younger brother, with a warrant outstanding, WFTV reported.

That spring Sandra Jean Graham, 21, and Theresa Fillingim, 16, both of Tampa, vanished, and in December 1980 Rene Saling, 29, a mother of three from Watsonville, California, was killed in Santa Cruz County. A California jury convicted him of Saling’s murder in 1982, at a second trial, and that year he pleaded guilty in Hernando County to four murders, including those of Graham, Fillingim and Elaine Zeigler, 15, who had disappeared in 1975, and received four life terms, the Associated Press reported in 2022. Fillingim was identified only in 2022, through genetic genealogy, the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office announced; the fourth Florida victim has not been named. In 2022 he confessed to the 1980 killing of Carol Ann Barrett, 18, a student from Ohio on spring break, but he was not charged in her death, WKMG News 6 reported in 2024. California prison records showed he had been denied parole multiple times, the Associated Press reported in July 2022.

Morris Solomon Jr: a false name

On June 18, 1986, the death of Yolanda Johnson, 22, came to light in the Oak Park neighborhood of Sacramento. Police questioned Morris Solomon Jr, a carpenter and handyman well known in Oak Park, the same day. He first gave his brother’s name and said he did not recognize the dead woman, and his accounts of their last meeting shifted through the day. That evening he gave his real name, explaining that he had used his brother’s because of outstanding warrants, and sat for a taped interview, according to the California Supreme Court’s 2010 opinion in his case. Over the following days he gave fingerprints and a blood sample. No cause of death could be determined, and he was not arrested.

He stayed free until April 22, 1987. In the months between, the deaths of more women came to light in Sacramento. He had a record of violent crimes against women in Oakland, Berkeley, San Jose and Sacramento going back to 1969, much of it unknown in Oak Park, the Sacramento News and Review later wrote. A jury convicted him of the murders of six women: Yolanda Johnson, Maria Apodaca, Cherie Washington, Linda Vitela, Sheila Jacox and Sharon Massey. A second penalty jury returned a death verdict, and he was taken into state prison in September 1992. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on July 15, 2010. He died in custody at the California Health Care Facility in Stockton on August 1, 2024, still under sentence of death, Stocktonia News reported.

Robert Pickton: the stayed charges

In March 1997 Robert Pickton, a pig farmer in Port Coquitlam, east of Vancouver, was charged with attempted murder, assault with a weapon and forcible confinement over an incident involving a woman at his farm. On January 26, 1998, Crown counsel stayed the charges. The Missing Women Commission of Inquiry, led by the former judge Wally Oppal, reported in 2012 that police had interviewed the woman only once and taken no formal statement from her; The Canadian Encyclopedia records that prosecutors did not consider her a competent witness. Oppal identified serious limitations in the Coquitlam RCMP’s initial investigation and called it "patently unreasonable" that the case was not pursued further.

Women continued to disappear from Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. Doug LePard, a Vancouver deputy chief who reviewed his own department’s handling of the case, concluded in a report released in August 2010 that police had received information pointing to Pickton in 1998 and 1999 that should have led to a more vigorous investigation, and that the delays likely cost the lives of more than a dozen women, CBC News reported. Pickton was charged with murder in February 2002. On December 9, 2007, a jury in New Westminster convicted him of the second-degree murders of Sereena Abotsway, Mona Wilson, Andrea Joesbury, Brenda Ann Wolfe, Georgina Faith Papin and Marnie Frey, and he was sentenced to life with no parole for 25 years. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the convictions on July 30, 2010, and on August 4, 2010, the Crown stayed 20 further first-degree murder charges, saying more convictions could not lengthen his sentence. He died in custody on May 31, 2024, Correctional Service Canada announced. Oppal called the police investigations a "blatant failure."

D.V.: the psychiatric discharge

In 1995 D.V., a homeless man in Táchira state, Venezuela, was accused in the death of Cruz Baltazar Moreno, another homeless man who slept under the same bridge, Infobae and Agencia Reforma reported. He was not tried. He was sent instead to the Instituto de Rehabilitación Psiquiátrica de Peribeca for about two years, and then he was let go. Agencia Reforma, in a feature printed by NVI Noticias in 2023, wrote that he was released without medical follow-up because he had behaved quietly in the institute; Infobae wrote in 2017 that the authorities judged him fit for a "normal" life on the street and then lost track of him.

In February 1999 the deaths of several men came to light at Táriba, the town where he was living, and on February 12, 1999, he was arrested. Police said he admitted the killings. Psychiatrists diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia, and he was declared inimputable, not criminally responsible under Venezuelan law. Jesús Alberto Berro, a former Táchira judge, told La Nación of San Cristóbal in 2020 that there was a ruling in the case "but not a conviction," and that the judge had ordered confinement in a mental health institution, not a police building. He was placed provisionally in the jail of the Táchira state police in San Cristóbal. In late October 2024 the detention monitor Una Ventana a la Libertad reported that he had spent 25 years there without trial, conviction or sentence, as Notas de Hoy reported.

Chandrakant Jha: lack of evidence, then parole

Delhi Police say Chandrakant Jha, a vegetable hawker from Madhepura district in Bihar, killed a man named Mangal, also called Aurangzeb, in Adarsh Nagar in 1998. Jha was arrested that year, held for about four years and released in 2002, the Press Trust of India reported in 2025; WION reported that he was freed for lack of evidence. The Delhi High Court recorded in 2016 that he had earlier been tried and acquitted in a murder case, without naming it.

Between October 2006 and May 2007 the deaths of three young men came to light in Delhi, most of them in the west of the city, with handwritten letters taunting the police. Jha was arrested in Alipur on May 20, 2007, on an informer’s tip. In January 2013 a sessions court at Rohini convicted him of all three murders and sentenced him to death in two cases and to life for the rest of his life in the third. On January 27, 2016, the Delhi High Court upheld all three convictions and replaced both death sentences with imprisonment for the rest of his natural life without remission. One of the three victims was never identified.

Then came a second release. On August 16, 2023, Justice Rajnish Bhatnagar of the High Court granted him 90 days' parole to arrange a daughter’s marriage, noting five earlier paroles and seven furloughs without misuse. He was let out in October 2023 and did not return. The Delhi Police Crime Branch rearrested him at Old Delhi Railway Station on January 17, 2025, as he tried to leave for Bihar, The Tribune reported. "Jha was on the run after jumping parole in October 2023," an additional commissioner of police, Sanjay Kumar Sain, said.

N.: the hospital that let him go

In 2012 the deaths of men who slept in the open began to come to light in Kollam, Kerala. After the second death that year the police detained a local man, N., Reporter TV reported in 2024. In custody he behaved like a man with a mental illness, and the police had him admitted to a mental health centre in Thiruvananthapuram. Doctors there put him through a series of tests, saw no sign of illness and discharged him. Deaths that followed his discharge, by the police account, were what brought investigators back to him.

He was arrested on November 2, 2012, and accused of the deaths of five men. He had been arrested twice before over deaths in the city, in 1996 and in 2007; in the first case a court acquitted him for want of eyewitnesses, and in the second he was released. He spent more than six years as an undertrial prisoner in the central jail at Poojappura, and in March 2019 the court acquitted him for lack of evidence. Critics, including some within the police, said errors in the investigation and gaps in the chargesheet had led to the acquittal, Reporter TV reported. No appeal was reported. In October 2024 the channel said no one knew where he was.

Bruce McArthur: a witness, then a complaint

In November 2012 Toronto police formed Project Houston to investigate the disappearances of three men with ties to the city’s Gay Village: Skandaraj Navaratnam, Abdulbasir Faizi and Majeed Kayhan. On November 11, 2013, officers interviewed Bruce McArthur, a self-employed landscaper, as a witness; they had come across his username and phone number among Navaratnam’s email contacts and his username in a notepad that belonged to Faizi, CP24 reported from court documents unsealed in 2019. He was not treated as a person of interest, and Project Houston was shut down in April 2014.

On June 20, 2016, a man McArthur knew went to the police with a complaint against him. McArthur went to the police himself, said the encounter had been consensual and was released without charges; officers judged his account credible, and his record check came back clean, CBC News reported. A Toronto police sergeant was later charged under the Police Services Act over the handling of the complaint and was acquitted on all counts in August 2021, CP24 reported. A second task force, Project Prism, formed in August 2017 after the disappearances of Selim Esen and Andrew Kinsman, arrested McArthur on January 18, 2018. He pleaded guilty on January 29, 2019, to eight counts of first-degree murder, of Navaratnam, Faizi, Kayhan, Soroush Mahmudi, Kirushna Kumar Kanagaratnam, Dean Lisowick, Esen and Kinsman, and on February 8, 2019, Justice John McMahon sentenced him to life with no chance of parole for 25 years. The independent review led by the retired judge Gloria Epstein, released on April 13, 2021, identified serious flaws in the police handling of the missing men’s cases and concluded that systemic discrimination had contributed to them, Global News reported.

What the releases had in common

None of these men slipped away through a hole in a fence. They left by the front door, with the paperwork in order: a blood group that did not match, a polygraph chart that read clean, a voice on a tape from the wrong city, a psychiatrist’s discharge, a stayed charge, a parole order granted to a prisoner who had always come back. Most of those decisions could be defended on the day they were made, and several were defended for years afterward. St. Joseph ran the other way. There the state held an innocent man for four years and let him go only because the killer it had never looked for wrote to the FBI.

Timeline

• June 25, 1973: Susie Jaeger is abducted in Montana; D.M. later passes a polygraph and a truth serum test.

• September 29, 1974: D.M. takes his own life in custody, hours after confessing to four killings.

• May 26, 1978: Eric Christgen is killed in St. Joseph, Missouri; a local house painter is convicted of the killing in October 1979.

• July 1979: two West Yorkshire detectives report their suspicions of Peter Sutcliffe; the report is filed away.

• February 1980: Billy Mansfield Jr. is released from custody in Michigan after agreeing to testify in another case.

• January 2, 1981: Sutcliffe is arrested in Sheffield; he is convicted of 13 murders on May 22, 1981.

• January 19, 1982: Lawrence Byford’s findings on the Sutcliffe inquiry are reported to Parliament.

• 1982: Mansfield is convicted of murder in California and pleads guilty to four murders in Florida.

• October 1983: Charles Hatcher pleads guilty to the Christgen murder, and the man wrongly convicted of it is freed.

• September 1984: Andrei Chikatilo is detained in Rostov-on-Don and ruled out as a murder suspect; he is released early in 1985.

• 1995: Mahanand Naik is detained in Goa over the disappearance of Vasanti Gaude and let go. D.V. is accused in a death in Táchira and sent to a psychiatric institute.

• June 18, 1986: Morris Solomon Jr is questioned in Sacramento and released.

• April 1987: Solomon is arrested on April 22. Ridgway gives a saliva sample the same year.

• November 20, 1990: Chikatilo is arrested in Novocherkassk; he is convicted of 52 murders in October 1992 and shot on February 14, 1994.

• January 26, 1998: charges against Robert Pickton from 1997 are stayed.

• 1998 to 2002: Chandrakant Jha is held in Delhi and released.

• February 12, 1999: D.V. is arrested at Táriba, Venezuela.

• November 30, 2001: Ridgway is arrested; he pleads guilty to 48 murders on November 5, 2003.

• February 2002: Pickton is charged with murder; he is convicted of six second-degree murders on December 9, 2007.

• May 20, 2007: Jha is arrested in Alipur; he is convicted of three murders in January 2013.

• April 2009: Naik is arrested in Ponda.

• 2012: N. is detained in Kollam, discharged from a mental health centre and arrested on November 2.

• November 11, 2013: Toronto police interview Bruce McArthur as a witness.

• June 20, 2016: McArthur is released without charges after a complaint.

• January 18, 2018: McArthur is arrested; he pleads guilty to eight murders on January 29, 2019.

• March 2019: N. is acquitted for lack of evidence.

• October 2023: Jha is released on parole and does not return; he is rearrested on January 17, 2025.

• October 2024: D.V. is reported to have spent 25 years in a Táchira police jail without trial.