TWELVE CASES WHERE THE DEAD ARE STILL NAMELESS

A guilty verdict settles who is to answer for a killing. It does not always settle who was killed. In each of the cases that follow, a prosecutor stood before a court and named a defendant, and in each, some of the people at the center of the case had no name that anyone could give. A few waited more than forty years for one. Some are still waiting.

The methods of naming them changed with the decades. In 1928 it meant deputies knocking on doors in the Mexican neighborhoods east of Los Angeles. By the 2000s it meant police departments posting old photographs on the internet and asking strangers for help. By the 2020s it meant DNA extracted from material that had sat in a coroner’s storage for forty years, and volunteer genealogists building family trees until a cousin’s name came up. What did not change was the reason the work was needed. In most of these cases, nobody had come forward to say that someone was missing.

Dennis Nilsen: London, 1978 to 1983

When Dennis Nilsen went on trial at the Old Bailey in October 1983, the Crown’s case rested on a gap it could not close. Opening for the prosecution, Allan Green told the jury that the defendant said he had killed 15 or 16 people, and that the police had been able to identify seven of them. Six of the seven featured in the charges, United Press International reported. Nilsen, a former Army cook and civil servant, pleaded not guilty to six counts of murder and two of attempted murder on the ground of diminished responsibility. The jury rejected the defense, and in November 1983 he was convicted on every count.

The men he had described to detectives but who could not be traced were never part of any indictment. The Scotsman, looking back on the case in 2009, put the total at an estimated 15 victims, some of whom had never been identified. NationalWorld, writing about the case years later, said that Nilsen claimed not to remember most of the men he had killed and gave police only vague profiles of them. In the years after the trial, detectives put a name to one more of them, Stephen Holmes, the boy Nilsen came to describe as his first. His death was not among the six murders charged. Nilsen died in custody in May 2018, aged 72, and the names of the others went with him.

William Bradford: Los Angeles County, 1984

One of the two young women William Bradford was convicted of killing was herself, for a month, a woman without a name. Shari Miller, 21, died in Los Angeles County in early July 1984, and with nothing to identify her she was recorded as Jane Doe No. 60. When Bradford, a freelance photographer, was arrested on July 31 in the disappearance of his 15-year-old neighbor, Tracey Campbell, officers seized photographs from him. At the station a detective saw a resemblance between the young woman in the pictures and Jane Doe No. 60, and a fingerprint comparison gave her back her name, according to the California Supreme Court. A jury convicted Bradford of both murders and returned a verdict of death, and the court affirmed the judgment in its entirety on July 14, 1997.

The rest of his photographs stayed in the case file until 2006. In June 2006 a cold case investigator came across them again, and on July 25 the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department posted numbered pictures of about fifty women and asked the public to identify them, CBS News and the Associated Press reported. Investigators said they feared that some of the women had been harmed between 1975 and 1984. Within three days, 31 had been tentatively identified, 28 of them believed to be alive. By November 2006, CBS’s 48 Hours reported, 39 women had been identified, and dozens were still unknown. Bradford was then on death row at San Quentin, seeking a new trial.

Lonnie Franklin Jr.: South Los Angeles, 1985 to 2007

The case of the man the press called the Grim Sleeper was solved by DNA in July 2010, after California’s familial search program pointed state analysts to a relative of Lonnie Franklin Jr. On May 5, 2016, a Los Angeles County jury convicted him of ten counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted murder. He was sentenced to death and died at San Quentin on March 28, 2020, with his automatic appeal still pending, UPI reported.

The verdict did not account for the photographs. Detectives had seized a large collection of pictures of women from his home, and on December 16, 2010, the Los Angeles Police Department posted more than 100 of them on its website under the heading "Public’s Help Needed to Put Names to Faces." Detective Kilcoyne said the department had a duty to identify the women, many of whom might well be alive. By early January 2011, CBS News reported, more than 50 had been identified and at least 79 photographs taken down after friends, relatives or the women themselves came forward. The tips opened four new missing persons cases, believed to date from the early 1990s. The collection held about 180 photographs of women whom police could not name. Chief Charlie Beck said releasing them had been a hard decision.

Rodney Alcala: California, New York and Wyoming, 1971 to 1979

Rodney Alcala, a photographer, was convicted by an Orange County jury on February 25, 2010, of five murders committed between 1977 and 1979, among them that of 12-year-old Robin Samsoe of Huntington Beach. He was sentenced to death that March. In 2012 he pleaded guilty in Manhattan to two more murders from the 1970s. He died on July 24, 2021.

Like Bradford and Franklin, he left behind photographs. After the 2010 verdict, Huntington Beach police and the Orange County District Attorney’s Office released more than 100 of them and asked the public to help identify the people in them. Within days, CBS News reported, nine women had come forward to say they were in the pictures and alive, and three families had called believing a missing relative appeared in them. In April 2010 the New York Police Department released more than 200 further images that appeared to have been taken in New York.

One of the released pictures gave a name back to a woman who had gone without one for more than thirty years. Christine Ruth Thornton, 28, of San Antonio, Texas, was killed in Sweetwater County, Wyoming, in the summer of 1977, and from 1982 she was an unidentified homicide victim. In 2013 a relative who had been searching for her recognized her in one of Alcala’s photographs. Her siblings gave DNA to the national database for missing and unidentified persons, and in 2015 it matched, CBS News and the Associated Press reported. Wyoming charged Alcala with her murder in 2016. He was never tried, and the charge was dismissed after his death, the Rawlins Times reported in August 2021.

Larry Eyler: Indiana and Illinois, 1982 to 1984

No case in this group shows the long arc of the work more clearly. Larry Eyler was convicted by a Cook County jury in July 1986 of the murder of Danny Bridges, 15, of Chicago, and sentenced to death. On the night of that verdict Detective Sergeant Ted Knorr of the Indiana State Police told UPI that Indiana investigators had linked Eyler to the deaths of four young men in 1983, two of whom had never been identified, and that he hoped the conviction would lead Eyler to say what he knew. In December 1990 Eyler pleaded guilty in Indiana to the 1982 murder of Steven Agan, 23. He died in prison in March 1994, and his lawyer then made public his confession to 21 killings, UPI reported. None of the others was tried.

In 2015 Reveal, the outlet of the Center for Investigative Reporting, counted as many as six of the men attributed to Eyler as still unidentified, four of them in Indiana: two held by the Newton County coroner, Scott McCord, and one each in Jasper and Hendricks counties. Samples had gone to a University of North Texas laboratory that works with NamUs, the national missing and unidentified persons system, and to the FBI’s CODIS database. McCord called the unnamed young men "my kids." "There has to be a mother, a father, a brother, a sister," he said, "somebody out there looking for these kids."

Genetic genealogy began to answer him. In April 2021 the Newton County coroner, working with the nonprofit DNA Doe Project, identified the man known since 1983 as Brad Doe as John Brandenburg Jr., 19, of Chicago, WISH-TV reported. In December 2021 the young man held by the Jasper County coroner was named as William Joseph Lewis, 19, after a student intern at the forensic genealogy firm Redgrave Research volunteered on the case and matches on a genealogy website pointed to his relatives, the Banner Graphic reported. The last of the Newton County men, Adam Doe, was identified in July 2023 as Keith Lavell Bibbs, a 16-year-old from Chicago, the Associated Press reported. As of the Banner Graphic’s December 2021 list, one young man whose death in Hendricks County in December 1983 was linked to Eyler had still not been named.

William Mansfield Jr.: Hernando County, Florida, 1975 to 1980

In 1982 William Mansfield Jr. pleaded guilty in Hernando County, Florida, to the murders of four women and girls, and he was also serving a life term in California for a murder in Santa Cruz County. Two of the Florida victims, Elaine Zeigler and Sandra Graham, were identified early. The other two were held as unidentified for more than forty years.

The Hernando County Sheriff’s Office set out what it took to name one of them. Several laboratories tried and failed to develop a DNA profile. In 2020 the University of North Texas produced a complete one, but a search of the national database produced no match. Investigators then turned to Parabon NanoLabs, whose Snapshot service predicts ancestry and physical traits from DNA. Its chief genetic genealogist, CeCe Moore, told Bay News 9 that she spent about ten hours building family trees. On July 20, 2022, the sheriff’s office announced that the victim was Theresa Caroline Fillingim of Tampa, whose sister had reported her missing on May 16, 1980. The office thanked a long list of partners, among them the University of North Texas, the forensic anthropologist Erin Kimmerle of the University of South Florida, NamUs, the district medical examiner, police departments in Tampa, Cape Coral and Longmont, Colorado, and Parabon. The fourth victim, a woman in her twenties, had not been identified when the announcement was made.

Stewart Wilken: Port Elizabeth, South Africa, 1990 to 1997

Stewart Wilken, a Port Elizabeth fisherman known as Boetie Boer, was arrested on January 31, 1997, and in police custody confessed to ten killings, most of which police had not connected to him, IOL reported in 2023. In February 1998 the Port Elizabeth High Court convicted him of seven murders, with other charges, and he received seven life terms. Agence France-Presse, as quoted by the Cape Argus, reported at the time that the seven were four women and three children, one of them his own daughter, Wuane. IOL named the boy whose disappearance brought about the arrest as Henry Bakkers, 10. Beyond those two, the dead have been described largely by age and circumstance rather than by name, and the identities of the rest have not been publicly reported.

Douglas Clark: Los Angeles County, 1980

Douglas Clark was convicted by a Los Angeles County jury of six counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to death in March 1983. Five of the women named in the verdict were Gina Marano, Cynthia Chandler, Karen Jones, Exxie Wilson and Marnette Comer. The sixth was a young woman killed in Los Angeles County in the summer of 1980, around late July or early August by the trial testimony, whom no one has named. The coroner put her death at one to two months before late August 1980. When the California Supreme Court affirmed the six murder convictions on July 30, 1992, it still knew her only as Jane Doe 18. He died of natural causes at San Quentin on October 11, 2023, the Associated Press reported.

Dayton Leroy Rogers: Clackamas County, Oregon, 1987

Dayton Leroy Rogers was convicted in 1988 of the aggravated murder of Jennifer Lisa Smith and in May 1989 of thirteen counts of aggravated murder covering six more women killed in Clackamas County in 1987: Lisa Marie Mock, Maureen Ann Hodges, Christine Lotus Adams, Cynthia DeVore, Nondace Cervantes and Riatha Gyles. The Oregon Supreme Court upheld those convictions in 1992 and noted that a seventh woman in the Molalla Forest case had not been identified.

She went without a name until 2013. On November 18 of that year, the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office announced that DNA had identified her as Tawnia Jarie Johnston, who was 18 when she was killed, KATU and the Associated Press reported. No charge against Rogers in her death has been reported. His sentences followed a separate road: four death sentences were vacated in turn, the last in November 2021, when the Oregon Supreme Court held that his crimes were no longer punishable by death under a changed state law, Oregon Public Broadcasting reported. In July 2023, KPTV reported, he was facing a fifth sentencing.

Gordon Northcott: Los Angeles and Riverside Counties, 1928

The oldest case in this group shows how the work was done in the 1920s. On February 2, 1928, Los Angeles County sheriff’s deputies opened an investigation into the killing of a youth near Puente, east of Los Angeles. The papers described him as Mexican and put his age at somewhere between 15 and 18. Paul R. Spitzzeri, writing for the Homestead Museum in 2026, traced what followed in the press of the day. Two deputies, Abel Mendoza and Jose Sepúlveda, worked through the Mexican communities of Puente, Belvedere and Temple City. Others checked missing persons reports. Residents who had sons of that age missing came forward, and none of them could say the boy was theirs. Police put out an appeal in a Spanish-language paper and followed rumors that went nowhere. The coverage faded without a name.

That autumn the youth became part of the Wineville case. In September 1928, Spitzzeri wrote, Gordon Northcott’s father told the Riverside County grand jury that his son had killed the unidentified teenager, and an indictment for that killing waited on Northcott’s return to Riverside from Canada. William Bright of the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department said he expected the boy to be identified. By February 1929 Northcott was on trial at Riverside for the murders of four boys, Time reported. When the 1928 coverage ends, the youth is still unnamed.

Lazarus Mazingane: Johannesburg, 1995 to 1998

The indictment against Lazarus Tshidiso Mazingane ran to 75 counts, 17 of them murder, and listed more than 300 potential witnesses, IOL reported as the trial opened in 2002. Most of the murder counts named the women killed in and around Nasrec, in Johannesburg, and in parts of Soweto. The third did not. It charged him with the death of a woman killed near Nasrec on March 7, 1995, and called her only "an unidentified woman." Superintendent Piet Byleveld of the Serious and Violent Crimes Unit had linked the deaths, and DNA tied Mazingane to them; by the time the investigation pointed to him, he was already serving a sentence for another crime.

In November 2002 Judge Joop Labuschagne of the Johannesburg High Court convicted him on 74 of the 75 counts, including 16 of murder, and acquitted him on the first murder count, a 1993 death in Sebokeng. He was sentenced to 17 life terms and 781 years, to run concurrently. As of March 2023, the Mail & Guardian reported, his applications for parole had been refused twice.

Mohan Kumar: Karnataka, India, 2005 to 2009

In coastal Karnataka the failure to name the dead was not a laboratory problem but a clerical one. Mohan Kumar, a schoolteacher, was arrested on October 21, 2009, and police said at once that he had been linked to the deaths of 18 young women, the Deccan Herald reported. Many had died far from home, in towns where no one knew them. Open magazine reported in 2014 that police at the time recorded such deaths as suicides or as the deaths of destitute women, that one of the women was never properly identified, and that officers made no attempt to compare the missing persons reports from the coast with the unexplained deaths inland. In one case, a woman from Bantwal taluk who died in Bengaluru in October 2005 was recorded as an unidentified person; Kumar was sentenced to death for her murder in October 2019, the Press Trust of India reported.

Prosecutors brought about twenty separate cases, and sessions courts in Mangaluru tried them one at a time between 2013 and 2020. The record is more mixed than the common claim of twenty convictions in twenty cases. In 2017 the Karnataka High Court confirmed one death sentence, commuted another to imprisonment for the rest of his life without remission, and set aside a third murder conviction for want of proof. A trial court acquitted him in a Kollur case in January 2019, and on August 17, 2026, the High Court dismissed the state’s appeal against that acquittal, recording that he was in custody.

What the cases share

Set side by side, the twelve cases point to the same weakness. In Indiana a coroner kept asking how young men could die and no one claim them. In Karnataka police filed the dead under no name while families a few hours away reported daughters missing. In Los Angeles County a sheriff’s department kept a photographer’s pictures of women in a case file from 1984 until 2006 before asking the public who they were. Reveal reported in 2015 that more than 10,000 bodies in the United States were still unidentified, with NamUs, housed at the Center for Human Identification in Fort Worth, Texas, holding the voluntary case data.

Where names have come back, they have come back slowly and through outside help: a relative scanning a released photograph in 2013, a laboratory in North Texas, a phenotyping company in Virginia, volunteer genealogists working for no fee. Keith Bibbs, Theresa Fillingim, Tawnia Johnston and Christine Thornton were all named decades after their deaths. The woman known as Jane Doe 18, the youth from Puente and the unnamed woman of March 7, 1995, near Nasrec are still waiting, and no court that sat in judgment on the men accused of their deaths could supply what the families needed most.

Timeline

• February 2, 1928: Los Angeles County deputies open the investigation into the killing of an unidentified youth near Puente.

• September 1928: Gordon Northcott’s father tells a Riverside County grand jury that his son killed the unidentified youth.

• February 1929: Gordon Northcott on trial at Riverside for the murders of four boys.

• 1977: Christine Ruth Thornton is killed in Sweetwater County, Wyoming; from 1982 she is an unidentified homicide victim.

• May 16, 1980: Theresa Fillingim is reported missing in Tampa.

• 1982: William Mansfield Jr. pleads guilty in Hernando County to four murders; two of the Florida victims are still unidentified.

• March 1983: Douglas Clark sentenced to death; one of his six victims is known only as Jane Doe 18.

• October and November 1983: Dennis Nilsen tried at the Old Bailey; police have identified seven of the 15 or 16 people he says he killed. He is convicted of six murders and two attempted murders.

• July 1984: Shari Miller is recorded as Jane Doe No. 60 until a fingerprint comparison after William Bradford’s arrest gives her name back.

• July 1986: Larry Eyler convicted of the murder of Danny Bridges; Indiana police say two of four young men linked to him are unidentified.

• May 1989: Dayton Leroy Rogers convicted of aggravated murder in six cases; a seventh woman in the Molalla Forest case is unidentified.

• March 7, 1995: an unidentified woman is killed near Nasrec, Johannesburg; her death becomes the third count against Lazarus Mazingane.

• July 14, 1997: the California Supreme Court affirms Bradford’s judgment.

• February 1998: Stewart Wilken convicted in Port Elizabeth of seven murders, with other charges.

• November 2002: Mazingane convicted in Johannesburg of 16 murders among 74 counts.

• July 25, 2006: the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department posts photographs of about fifty women from Bradford’s collection.

• October 21, 2009: Mohan Kumar arrested in Karnataka; police link him to 18 deaths.

• March 10, 2010: Huntington Beach police and the Orange County District Attorney release more than 100 of Alcala’s photographs; the NYPD releases more than 200 in April.

• December 16, 2010: the LAPD posts more than 100 photographs from Lonnie Franklin Jr.'s home.

• November 18, 2013: Tawnia Jarie Johnston identified by DNA in the Rogers case.

• 2015: a DNA match confirms Christine Thornton’s identity.

• May 5, 2016: Franklin convicted of ten murders and one attempted murder.

• 2017: the Karnataka High Court confirms one of Kumar’s death sentences, commutes another and sets aside a third murder conviction.

• April 2021: John Brandenburg Jr. identified as Brad Doe in Newton County, Indiana.

• December 2021: William Joseph Lewis identified in Jasper County, Indiana.

• July 20, 2022: the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office identifies Theresa Caroline Fillingim.

• July 2023: Adam Doe identified as Keith Lavell Bibbs, 16, of Chicago.

• October 11, 2023: Douglas Clark dies at San Quentin.

• August 17, 2026: the Karnataka High Court upholds Kumar’s acquittal in the Kollur case; he is in custody.