A conviction is supposed to be the end of a story. In each of the twelve cases that follow, it was not. Some of the verdicts were torn up by the courts that had passed them, a few only after the defendant was dead. Some came apart after another man, convicted or suspected of other killings, came into the frame. In three, the conviction still stands on the books while the questions raised about it have gone unanswered in court. The cases run from Gaffney, South Carolina, in 1967 to a district court in Wakayama in 2026, and they have more in common than their geography suggests.
Kathleen Folbigg lost four children in ten years. Caleb died on February 20, 1989, at 19 days old. Patrick died on February 13, 1991, at eight months. Sarah died on August 30, 1993, at ten months, and Laura on March 1, 1999, at 18 months, according to a chronology published by the New South Wales Department of Communities and Justice. Prosecutors argued that she had killed them. On May 21, 2003, a jury in the New South Wales Supreme Court convicted Folbigg of the manslaughter of Caleb, of maliciously inflicting grievous bodily harm on Patrick, and of the murders of Patrick, Sarah and Laura. She was sentenced to 40 years, cut on appeal to 30 years with a non-parole period of 25. She maintained throughout that her children had died of natural causes.
The first serious challenge went nowhere. In 2015 the University of Newcastle Legal Centre petitioned the Governor for a review. An inquiry under the former Chief Judge of the District Court, Reginald Blanch, reported on July 19, 2019, that the evidence reinforced her guilt and that he had no reasonable doubt about it, and on March 24, 2021, the Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed her application to overturn his findings.
The science moved faster than the law. In 2018, evidence emerged that both of the Folbigg daughters carried a rare variant of the CALM2 gene that could cause sudden death, the Associated Press reported, and in March 2021 a petition signed by 90 scientists, medical practitioners and related professionals asked the Governor for a pardon. A second inquiry, under the former Chief Justice Thomas Bathurst, began in 2022. On June 5, 2023, the Executive Council met to recommend a pardon, and Governor Margaret Beazley granted Folbigg an unconditional pardon on the advice of the Attorney General, Michael Daley. She had served 20 years.
A pardon forgives; it does not quash. That came on December 14, 2023, when the Court of Criminal Appeal, Chief Justice Andrew Bell presiding with Justices Julie Ward and Ian Harrison, set aside all four convictions and entered verdicts of acquittal. Lawyers Weekly summarized the ground: the Bathurst inquiry had identified a reasonable doubt; the two daughters had an identifiable cause of death in the CALM2 variant; a neurogenetic disorder offered an explanation for what happened to Patrick; and once natural causes were possible for three children, a reasonable possibility arose that Caleb too had died naturally, which drained the coincidence evidence of much of its force. "There is now reasonable doubt as to Ms. Folbigg’s guilt," Bell said. Folbigg said she was "grateful that updated science and genetics have given me answers of how my children died." Her former husband called for a retrial, and her lawyer, Rhanee Rego, said her team would seek substantial compensation from the state.
The deaths of three American Indian women came to light in Minneapolis between July 1986 and April 1987: Kathleen Bullman, 19, on July 27, 1986; Angeline Whitebird Sweet, 26, a mother of three, on April 12, 1987; and Angela Green, 21, on April 29, 1987, MPR News reported from the case record. Billy Glaze, a drifter with a long record, became the prime suspect after authorities said he had made derogatory remarks about American Indian women. In February 1989 a Hennepin County jury convicted him of first-degree murder during a sexual assault and second-degree intentional murder, and he received three consecutive life sentences. The Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed the convictions in 1990. He denied the killings from the start.
The trial record was thin on physical proof. The state relied largely on witnesses and on jail inmates who said he had admitted the killings, and its own closing argument conceded that apart from a shoe print there was no physical evidence pointing to him. In 2007 a court granted Glaze’s motion for DNA testing, and the two sides then spent years arguing over which items would be tested. According to the defense filings reported by MPR News, a sample from Angela Green’s case excluded Glaze and in 2012 was matched through the FBI database to another man, and in 2014 a second sample, from the Whitebird Sweet case, excluded Glaze and matched the same man. That man, identified in court papers only as J.A.S., denied any part in the killings and was never charged. In June 2014 Glaze’s lawyers petitioned for a new trial.
Hennepin County never wavered. Prosecutors said Glaze had admitted the killings at least twice, and the County Attorney, Mike Freeman, called the new evidence "inconclusive and unpersuasive" and short of the clear and convincing standard a new trial required. Before any judge ruled on the evidence, Glaze died of lung cancer in a Delaware prison infirmary on December 22, 2015, at 72, the Associated Press reported. On November 2, 2016, Hennepin County District Judge Toddrick Barnette dismissed the petition as moot, writing that nothing in the record supported a finding that the conviction was wrongful. On March 21, 2018, the Minnesota Supreme Court dismissed the appeal because no appellant with standing remained after his death. The court never reached the DNA. The convictions stand.
On April 7, 1987, Adrian Newton, his son Alton, 7, and his daughter Farrah, 21 months, were shot dead outside Houston. Frances Newton, Adrian’s wife and the children’s mother, was arrested more than two weeks later, after she had filed claims on life insurance policies, and was charged with capital murder in the death of Farrah, The Austin Chronicle reported. A Harris County jury convicted her in 1988, and she was sentenced to death.
Doubts gathered around the case in the years that followed. Her court-appointed trial lawyer, Ron Mock, admitted before trial that he had not interviewed the prosecution’s witnesses or subpoenaed any for the defense; the judge removed him, then refused a continuance. Mock had come before the State Bar’s disciplinary board at least five times, and by 2005 he was suspended. The State’s chemical evidence was a trace of nitrite near the hem of her skirt, which technicians could not rule out as fertilizer from her father’s garden; none appeared on her hands. The ballistics work came from the Houston Police Department’s crime laboratory, which was under investigation for what the Chronicle called "incompetent, shoddy work." And there was the question of a second pistol. A police sergeant testified, "I believe we talked about two pistols"; the district attorney, Chuck Rosenthal, said, "One gun was recovered in the case."
On December 1, 2004, the day Newton was to die, the Board of Pardons and Paroles recommended and Governor Rick Perry granted a 120-day reprieve to allow fresh testing, though Perry said he saw no "evidence of innocence." The retesting settled nothing for the defense: the original 1987 test had consumed the nitrite particles, and a second ballistics examination was reported to confirm the match. On August 24, 2005, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed her latest appeal, with Judge Cathy Cochran calling the evidence "more than sufficient." The board then voted 7 to 0 against clemency, and the U.S. Supreme Court turned down her final appeal without comment. She was executed on September 14, 2005, at 40, according to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. The Chronicle described her as the third woman executed in Texas since executions resumed in 1982 and the first Black woman executed in the state since the Civil War. She maintained her innocence. Her conviction was never set aside.
In July 1998, at a neighborhood summer festival in the city of Wakayama, about 450 kilometers southwest of Tokyo, four people died of arsenic poisoning, two of them children, and 63 others fell ill, the Associated Press reported. Masumi Hayashi, who lived in the neighborhood, was arrested in October 1998. A district court convicted her in 2002 and sentenced her to death. On April 21, 2009, Japan’s Supreme Court rejected her final appeal, holding that circumstantial evidence proved her guilt beyond doubt. No direct evidence tied her to the poisoning, and the courts never settled on a motive; prosecutors had suggested she was angry with other women in the neighborhood.
Her case is not a mistaken identity awaiting a DNA match. Hayashi admitted that she and her husband had conspired to use arsenic in insurance frauds, and the judges treated that as evidence of what Agence France-Presse rendered as "deep-seated criminality." But she has maintained her innocence of the festival poisoning since her arrest, and since 2009 she has applied for a retrial several times, her latest bid aimed at discrediting a forensic analysis that helped convict her. In 2025 her son, speaking under a pseudonym, told AFP that he was not certain of her innocence but thought there was "a good chance," and that "a retrial is the only way" to the truth. In July 2026 she was 65 and still on death row, and a third retrial petition was before the Wakayama District Court. Her husband, who had campaigned for her, died in June 2026 at 81. Her conviction stands.
On the evening of April 9, 1996, the death of a woman surnamed Yang came to light in Hohhot, the capital of Inner Mongolia. The man who reported it was Hugjiltu, an 18-year-old ethnic Mongolian who worked at a cigarette factory. He became the suspect himself. On May 17, 1996, the Hohhot Intermediate People’s Court sentenced him to death for intentional homicide, and to five years for hooliganism, with the death sentence to be carried out at once. The Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court rejected his appeal on June 5, and he was executed on June 10, 1996. His parents spent years petitioning for the case to be reopened, Agence France-Presse reported.
In 2005 police arrested Zhao Zhihong, who confessed to more than 20 robberies, killings and other crimes, the People’s Court Daily reported. His first such killing, he told investigators, was the one in Hohhot on April 9, 1996. He repeated that confession for years. It took until November 19, 2014, for the Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court to order a retrial of the Hugjiltu case, and on December 15, 2014, the court set aside the 1996 conviction and declared him not guilty, on the ground that the facts were unclear and the evidence insufficient. The blood-type evidence used at his trial identified only a type, not a person, the court said, and his own statements were unstable and at odds with the other evidence. On December 30, 2014, the court awarded his parents 2,059,621.40 yuan in state compensation, Xinhua reported; money, they told the agency, could not bring back a life. On February 1, 2016, the regional authorities announced that 27 people from the police, the procuratorate and the courts had been held responsible; a former deputy police chief was handled under criminal law and the rest received Party or administrative discipline, Inquirer.net and Radio Free Asia reported. Hugjiltu’s mother called the handling too hasty.
Zhao was sentenced to death in February 2015. The case did not end there. When the Supreme People’s Court approved his execution on July 2, 2019, it confirmed 17 of the 21 crimes on which the lower courts had convicted him and declined to confirm four, among them the killing of Yang in 1996: his confession, the court said, contradicted the other evidence on the timing, the victim’s clothing and other points, and could not meet the standard of proof. The head of the court’s Fifth Criminal Division was careful to draw the line. Hugjiltu had been acquitted because the evidence against him was insufficient, not because Zhao claimed the crime. Zhao was executed in Hohhot on July 30, 2019. No one stands convicted of the death of the woman surnamed Yang.
In August 1994 a woman was killed in the western suburbs of Shijiazhuang, the capital of Hebei province. Nie Shubin, a young factory worker in the area, was detained on October 1, 1994, and confessed on the sixth day of questioning, according to a case study by the U.S.-Asia Law Institute at New York University. The Shijiazhuang Intermediate People’s Court convicted him of intentional homicide, with other charges, on March 15, 1995, and sentenced him to death. The Hebei High People’s Court upheld the sentence on April 25, and he was executed on April 27, 1995. He was 20 by the account of Agence France-Presse, 21 by the law institute’s. No DNA testing had been done, the South China Morning Post later reported, and the conviction rested on Nie’s own statements.
In 2005 Wang Shujin, a man from Guangping County in the south of the province, confessed to a string of killings, and to the Shijiazhuang killing among them. A newspaper report that March, under the headline "One case, two killers," turned the discrepancy into a national argument. The Hebei authorities promised a conclusion within a month and published none. Wang was convicted at Handan of killings in Guangping, but prosecutors never charged him with the Shijiazhuang case, and when he argued on appeal that his confession to it should count in his favor, the Hebei High People’s Court ruled in September 2013 that he had not committed it, citing contradictions between his account and the record. Forty lawyers signed an open letter condemning the ruling, the Morning Post reported.
The Supreme People’s Court moved the Nie case out of Hebei. On December 12, 2014, it assigned a review to the Shandong High People’s Court, Xinhua reported, and on December 2, 2016, its Second Circuit Court, sitting in Shenyang, overturned Nie’s conviction and declared him not guilty because the facts relied on were unclear and the evidence insufficient. The Christian Science Monitor, citing Xinhua, reported that the court also held that his confession might have been obtained by illegitimate means. His parents received 2.68 million yuan in state compensation in March 2017. His mother had petitioned for 21 years.
Wang was retried in 2020 on new evidence in one of the Guangping killings and sentenced to death again on November 24, 2020; the Hebei High People’s Court dismissed his last appeal on December 22, 2020, again declining to hold him responsible for the Shijiazhuang killing. He was executed at Handan on February 2, 2021, Xinhua reported. The Supreme People’s Court said that day that it had applied the principles of evidence-based judgment and of no conviction where guilt is in doubt, Beijing News reported. The death of the woman in Shijiazhuang has no conviction attached to it.
On September 5, 1979, Miami police arrested Jerry Frank Townsend, 27, a man whose IQ the National Registry of Exonerations gives as 58 and whom the Innocence Project describes as having the mental capacity of an eight-year-old. Under questioning by Miami officers and two Broward Sheriff’s detectives from September 6 to 10, with the tape stopped at times, he implicated himself in about 20 killings, many of which prosecutors never pursued because the evidence showed he could not have committed them. No physical evidence tied him to any of the crimes. In July 1980 a Broward jury convicted him of first-degree murder in the 1973 deaths of Naomi Gamble, 15, and Barbara Ann Brown, 21. In October 1982 he pleaded no contest to the murders of Cathy Moore and Terry Jean Cummings, and that December he pleaded guilty in Miami-Dade County to two more. By then he stood convicted of six murders.
A Fort Lauderdale detective, Doug Evans, had another man in mind. He had long suspected Eddie Lee Mosley, and about three weeks before Townsend’s arrest he named Mosley as the prime suspect, Florida Bulldog reported. Sheriff’s detectives did not pursue him.
The second wrong turn came in 1985. Shandra Whitehead, eight years old, died in Fort Lauderdale that April, and on April 29 police arrested Frank Lee Smith, 37, who had a long criminal record. No physical or forensic evidence linked him to the crime; three witnesses identified him. On January 31, 1986, a Broward jury convicted him of first-degree murder, with other charges, and on May 6 he was sentenced to death. In 1989 the key witness signed a sworn statement that the man she had seen was Mosley, whose photograph a defense investigator had shown her. The trial court rejected her recantation as not credible. In October 1998 a judge refused Smith’s request for DNA testing. On January 30, 2000, Smith died of pancreatic cancer on death row, at 52.
The testing he had asked for came that summer. On December 11, 2000, the FBI laboratory reported that Smith was not the source of the evidence in the Whitehead case, and on December 15 it reported that the genetic material was consistent with Mosley. Smith’s convictions were vacated and the charges dismissed that day, eleven months after his death, the Registry records. On April 27, 2001, Broward Sheriff Ken Jenne announced that DNA linked the deaths of Naomi Gamble and Terry Jean Cummings to Mosley and excluded Townsend. Townsend’s convictions were vacated in Broward that spring and in Miami-Dade on June 15, 2001, and he walked free the next day, at 49. Jenne apologized to him. The City of Miami paid $2.2 million in 2008 and the Broward Sheriff’s Office $2 million in 2009 to settle his suits, the Bulldog reported; Smith’s family settled with the Sheriff’s Office for $340,000 in 2013.
Mosley never faced a jury for any killing. Charged with murder in 1987, he was declared incompetent to stand trial and committed to a state psychiatric hospital. The Registry records that his DNA was linked to seven Fort Lauderdale murders between 1973 and 1987. He died in state custody in 2020, at 73.
Jeanine Nicarico was ten years old, a fifth-grader in Naperville, Illinois, who loved horses. She was killed in February 1983. A $10,000 reward was offered, and Rolando Cruz, a young man from Aurora, came to investigators with a story about the crime that, by the account of the National Registry of Exonerations, he invented in the hope of collecting it. His story pulled in Alejandro Hernandez, 19, and a third Aurora man. On March 9, 1984, DuPage County prosecutors obtained murder indictments against all three. The lead detective, John Sam, resigned because he believed they were innocent. On February 22, 1985, a jury convicted Cruz and Hernandez and deadlocked on the third man, and Cruz and Hernandez were sentenced to death. The case against the third man was later dropped.
That November, Brian Dugan, who was about to plead guilty to two other murders, signed a statement confessing to Jeanine’s killing and offered, through his lawyer, to confess formally if his life was spared. Prosecutors doubted him and refused to bargain. On November 19, 1985, he pleaded guilty to the murders of Melissa Ackerman and Donna Schnorr and received two life sentences, the Daily Herald reported.
The Nicarico convictions then ran a decade-long gauntlet. The Illinois Supreme Court reversed both in January 1988, ruling that the two men should have been tried separately; the Registry dates that decision to January 1989. Cruz was convicted again on February 1, 1990, and again sentenced to death. Hernandez’s second trial ended with a hung jury; a third jury convicted him on May 17, 1991, and he received 80 years. In 1992 DNA testing excluded Hernandez and the third man as the source of evidence from the crime, and an assistant attorney general assigned to the Cruz appeal, Mary Brigid Kenney, resigned in protest. On December 4, 1992, the Illinois Supreme Court affirmed Cruz’s second conviction by a vote of 4 to 3. After three justices retired, the reconstituted court granted a rehearing, and on July 14, 1994, it reversed the conviction and ordered a third trial, holding that the trial judge had wrongly excluded evidence of Dugan’s other crimes and wrongly admitted bloodhound testimony, Illinois Issues reported. An appellate court overturned Hernandez’s conviction on January 30, 1995.
At Cruz’s third trial, a sheriff’s lieutenant who had testified about a telephone call supposedly showing that Cruz had made admissions was shown to have been on vacation in Florida at the time of the call, the Registry records. On November 3, 1995, Judge Ronald Mehling acquitted Cruz. On December 8, 1995, the charges against Hernandez were dropped. A grand jury indicted seven men, three former prosecutors and four sheriff’s officers, on December 12, 1996, on charges including official misconduct and perjury; a judge freed two for lack of evidence, and the remaining defendants were acquitted on June 4, 1999. In 2000 the county settled the civil rights suits for $3.5 million, and on December 19, 2002, Governor George Ryan pardoned Cruz on the basis of innocence.
Dugan pleaded guilty to Jeanine Nicarico’s murder on July 28, 2009, without any promise to spare his life, and on November 11, 2009, a jury voted for death. The sentence was commuted when Illinois abolished the death penalty on March 9, 2011, St. Louis Public Radio reported.
In the early 1980s a series of rapes in Buffalo led the local press to write of a single attacker. In 1983 a city official noticed a man behaving strangely, followed him to a car and took down the plate number, which traced to Anthony Capozzi, a Buffalo man who had been diagnosed with schizophrenia. He was arrested on September 13, 1985. Three women picked him out of a photo lineup, one of them after first choosing someone else. His lawyers pointed out that no victim had described the scar over his left eyebrow and that his weight was well above the attacker’s described build, and the court refused to let them show similar crimes committed while he had an alibi or after he was jailed, the National Registry of Exonerations records. On April 6, 1987, a jury convicted him of first-degree rape, with other charges, in two cases from 1984 and acquitted him in a third. He received the maximum sentence, and the Appellate Division upheld the verdicts in 1989. His mother fought for his release for the next two decades.
On January 15, 2007, a task force arrested Altemio Sanchez, a factory worker from the suburb of Cheektowaga, whose DNA police said linked him to three killings and to a long run of sexual assaults around Buffalo. Investigators asked whether he had also committed the crimes for which Capozzi was serving time. Biological evidence from those cases, long thought lost, had been kept for decades at Erie County Medical Center, and in March 2007 slides from both cases were located there. The DNA excluded Capozzi and matched Sanchez, the district attorney said. On April 2, 2007, at a hearing that lasted seven minutes, Erie County Judge Shirley Troutman vacated both convictions and dismissed the charges, WBFO reported. Capozzi had spent about 22 years in custody. In June 2010 New York settled his claim for $4.25 million. "He will never get back 20 years of his life," his lawyer said. His mother had died the previous October.
Sanchez pleaded guilty on May 16, 2007, to three counts of second-degree murder, for the deaths of Linda Yalem in 1990, Majane Mazur in 1992 and Joan Diver in 2006. The sexual assaults linked to him were never charged because the statute of limitations had run. He died in state custody on September 22, 2023, the State Commission of Correction recorded.
Early on September 30, 1979, a woman nine months pregnant was assaulted in Tustin, California. She survived. Her baby daughter was delivered stillborn several hours later. Her husband, a Marine, was charged in April 1980, and the prosecution’s case rested chiefly on his wife’s testimony, according to the Innocence Project. On October 1, 1980, a jury convicted him of second degree murder for the death of the baby, with other charges, and on November 7, 1980, he was sentenced to 15 years to life, the National Registry of Exonerations records. The Registry lists mistaken identification and false or misleading forensic evidence among the causes. The California Court of Appeal upheld the conviction in 1992. He always maintained his innocence.
In the mid-1990s the Orange County Sheriff’s crime laboratory was one of three in the country able to run a newer form of DNA analysis, and detectives in Tustin and Costa Mesa sent it evidence from their unsolved killings of 1978 and 1979. In June 1996 the profiles matched Gerald Parker, a former Marine then in state prison, and so did the evidence from the 1979 Tustin assault, the Sheriff’s Department later wrote. In interviews with detectives that June, Parker admitted the crimes. On June 20, 1996, an Orange County Superior Court judge set aside the husband’s convictions and dismissed the case, and he walked out that day after 16 years in prison. St. Louis Public Radio described him in 2003 as the 35th person in the United States exonerated by DNA. California paid him $10,000 in 1997, then the most its law allowed, and in October 1999 Governor Gray Davis signed a bill granting him a further $620,000.
Parker was convicted of six counts of first degree murder with special circumstances, among them the death of the unborn child, and was sentenced to death on January 21, 1999. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on June 5, 2017. He remained on death row in September 2020, the Sheriff’s Department reported.
Carolyn Kronenberg had taught study skills at Lansing Community College for 25 years; she was a mother of two sons and a grandmother, and colleagues remembered her as kind and supportive, the college’s student newspaper recalled. She was killed in Lansing on January 23, 2005. Two days later police arrested Claude McCollum, a 26-year-old student who was homeless and who had, according to the National Registry of Exonerations, significant learning disabilities. Detectives asked him how he might, hypothetically, have killed the professor, and he talked about the possibility that he had done something while sleepwalking. Prosecutors put those answers to the jury as a confession. On the stand he said police had described the crime to him in unrecorded interviews and he had repeated their suggestions back on tape. "They did trick me," he said, The State News reported. A forensic scientist testified that the DNA evidence did not match him. On February 14, 2006, the jury convicted him of murder, with other charges, and he was sentenced to life without parole.
In August 2007 Lansing police named Matthew Macon, a parolee, as the suspect in a summer of killings in the city, and McCollum’s family asked prosecutors to look again. The Kronenberg case was reopened on September 11, 2007. A damaged campus surveillance tape placed McCollum in a different building at the time of the killing, and a state police detective had analyzed it before the trial and concluded that McCollum could not have committed the crime. Prosecutors said the report had gone to the defense; McCollum’s trial lawyer said he never saw it. That September the prosecutor joined in asking the Michigan Court of Appeals to vacate the conviction, and the court ordered a new trial. McCollum was released on October 16, 2007, and the charges were dismissed later that month. A state attorney general’s investigation determined that video evidence that could have cleared him had been kept from the defense, City Pulse reported, and Ingham County Prosecutor Stuart Dunnings III fired the lead prosecutor in the case. McCollum settled his lawsuit for $2 million in 2010.
Macon was convicted in May 2008 of the first-degree murders of Sandra Eichorn and Karen Delgado-Yates, with other charges, and was sentenced to life on June 18, 2008. He was never charged in the Kronenberg killing. On March 1, 2010, Dunnings closed it and four other unsolved killings, saying, "We have solid reason to believe that the prisoner Macon is responsible for these crimes," and that a trial could add nothing to the sentence Macon was already serving, WKAR reported.
In May 1967 the death of Annie Lucille Dedmond came to light in Union County, South Carolina. Her husband, Roger Zane Dedmond, 28, was arrested. His conviction rested largely on police testimony that he had confessed in custody, which he denied; he testified that he had been questioned for more than two days without a break, and alibi witnesses placed him in a cafe in Spindale, North Carolina, at the time she died, the National Registry of Exonerations records. On December 12, 1967, he was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 18 years.
In February 1968 a man who would not give his name twice telephoned Bill Gibbons, managing editor of a local newspaper. He said he had killed Annie Lucille Dedmond, and on the second call, on February 12, he gave details of her death that had not been made public and said her husband "should be released." The deaths of two young women, Nancy Christine Rhinehart and Nancy Carol Farris, came to light that month, and days after the second call so did the death of Opal Dianne Buckson, 15. Two men who saw a man matching a witness description took down a license plate number, and it traced to Lee Roy Martin, a 30-year-old textile worker and father of three. Martin admitted all four killings.
Dedmond was released on February 29, 1968. Martin pleaded guilty to Annie Lucille Dedmond’s murder, and on September 16, 1968, the manslaughter charge against her husband was dismissed. He had spent about ten months in prison. The Registry lists false confession and official misconduct as factors in his conviction. Martin was convicted on four counts of murder and sentenced to four life terms, FOX Carolina reported in 2023, when an exhibit in Gaffney revisited the case.
The reversals came from different directions. In Fort Lauderdale, Buffalo and Tustin it was DNA testing of evidence that had sat untested for years, and in Frank Lee Smith’s case testing a judge had refused while he was alive. In New South Wales it was genetics, and the decision to let a second inquiry weigh it. In Lansing it was a report already in the case file. In Gaffney, Hohhot, Shijiazhuang and DuPage County another man claimed the crime. In Gaffney an arrest and Dedmond’s release followed within weeks; elsewhere the claim moved slowly or not at all. Cruz and Hernandez were held until 1995, and Hugjiltu and Nie were cleared long after their executions, by courts that in the end declined to hold the men who confessed responsible for those deaths.
Several of those convicted came before the courts with plain vulnerabilities. Townsend had an IQ the Registry puts at 58, Capozzi had schizophrenia, McCollum had significant learning disabilities, and Hugjiltu was 18. In three cases no court has set the verdict aside at all. Billy Glaze died before a judge weighed the DNA, Frances Newton was executed after retesting that resolved nothing, and Masumi Hayashi was still waiting on a third retrial petition in 2026.
• May 1967: Annie Lucille Dedmond’s death comes to light in Union County, South Carolina; her husband is convicted of manslaughter on December 12, 1967.
• February 1968: Lee Roy Martin calls a Gaffney newspaper editor and is arrested; Roger Dedmond is released on February 29 and the charge dismissed on September 16, 1968.
• September 5, 1979: Jerry Frank Townsend is arrested in Miami; he is convicted of six murders between 1980 and 1982.
• September 30, 1979: The Tustin assault; the husband is convicted on October 1, 1980.
• February 1983: Jeanine Nicarico, 10, is killed in DuPage County, Illinois.
• February 22, 1985: Rolando Cruz and Alejandro Hernandez are convicted and sentenced to death.
• January 31, 1986: Frank Lee Smith is convicted in Broward County.
• April 6, 1987: Anthony Capozzi is convicted in Buffalo.
• April 7, 1987: Adrian, Alton and Farrah Newton are killed near Houston; Frances Newton is convicted in 1988.
• February 1989: Billy Glaze is convicted in Minneapolis.
• April 27, 1995: Nie Shubin is executed in Hebei.
• November 3, 1995: Cruz is acquitted at his third trial; the charges against Hernandez are dropped on December 8.
• June 10, 1996: Hugjiltu is executed in Hohhot.
• June 20, 1996: The Tustin husband’s convictions are set aside after DNA matches Gerald Parker.
• July 1998: Four people die of arsenic poisoning at a festival in Wakayama; Masumi Hayashi is arrested in October.
• January 30, 2000: Smith dies on death row; on December 15, 2000, DNA points to Eddie Lee Mosley and Smith’s convictions are vacated.
• June 15, 2001: Townsend’s last convictions are vacated; he is released the next day.
• December 19, 2002: Governor George Ryan pardons Cruz.
• May 21, 2003: Kathleen Folbigg is convicted in New South Wales.
• January 2005: Carolyn Kronenberg is killed in Lansing; Claude McCollum is convicted on February 14, 2006.
• September 14, 2005: Frances Newton is executed in Texas.
• April 2, 2007: Capozzi’s convictions are vacated after DNA matches Altemio Sanchez.
• October 2007: McCollum is released and the charges are dismissed.
• April 21, 2009: Japan’s Supreme Court makes Hayashi’s death sentence final.
• July 28, 2009: Brian Dugan pleads guilty to the Nicarico murder.
• December 15, 2014: Hugjiltu is declared not guilty on retrial.
• December 22, 2015: Glaze dies in prison with his DNA petition pending.
• December 2, 2016: The Supreme People’s Court declares Nie Shubin not guilty.
• March 21, 2018: The Minnesota Supreme Court dismisses the Glaze appeal for lack of standing.
• July 30, 2019: Zhao Zhihong is executed; the court has declined to confirm the 1996 Hohhot killing.
• 2020: Mosley dies in state custody, never tried.
• February 2, 2021: Wang Shujin is executed.
• June 5, 2023: Folbigg is pardoned and released.
• December 14, 2023: The New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal quashes Folbigg’s convictions.
• July 2026: Hayashi’s third retrial petition is before the Wakayama District Court.