In April 2003, in Seattle, three of Gary Ridgway’s lawyers brought King County Prosecuting Attorney Norm Maleng a proposal he had promised never to accept. When Ridgway was charged in 2001, Maleng had pledged that his office would not trade away the death penalty; prosecutors, he held, should not bargain over a man’s life, because the pressure can push an innocent suspect into pleading guilty. Ridgway was then charged with seven killings. His lawyers offered a confession to dozens more, in exchange for his life. Maleng rejected it outright, then said he would think about it. He spent several weeks weighing it, consulting friends and detectives. Then he said yes.
Most plea bargains are priced by the strength of the evidence. A weak case buys a defendant a lighter charge; a strong one buys him very little. The thirteen sentences that follow were priced by a different measure. In some, the state paid for what a killer knew about his victims, knowledge no witness, laboratory or search warrant could supply. In others, it paid one partner to testify against another. The discounts ran from a few years off a term to complete immunity, and in every case the families of the dead lived with the terms.
Maleng told Sheriff Dave Reichert, who agreed, as did the Green River Task Force. The bargain was simple in its outline: the death penalty was off the table, and in exchange Ridgway would give a complete accounting of the murders and provide information about the locations of victims, and serve life without parole. Maleng insisted that the money a trial would cost the county had played no part in his thinking.
On November 5, 2003, Ridgway pleaded guilty to 48 counts of aggravated first-degree murder: 42 of the deaths attributed to the Green River case and six that police had not connected to it. A lengthy confession in his name was read into the record. Maleng told the Associated Press afterward that he was "at peace with it." The deal, he said, was meant to bring answers and peace of mind to the families and the community, and the need to know the truth was a principle of justice. He spoke of the death of his own daughter in 1989. His office received about 120 letters and emails, most of them supportive; some supporters of capital punishment warned that the bargain would make death sentences harder to win in smaller cases.
On December 18, 2003, Judge Richard Jones of King County Superior Court called for 48 seconds of silence, one for each victim, and imposed 48 consecutive life terms and 480,000 dollars in fines. A victim’s mother told the court there should have been no plea bargain. Robert Rule, whose daughter was among the dead, told Ridgway, "I pity you, sir," and forgave him; it was the only moment in the hearing when Ridgway broke down. In December 2010 the death of Rebecca "Becky" Marrero, who had disappeared in 1982 at 20, came to light in Auburn. Prosecutors charged Ridgway in February 2011, and under the 2003 agreement no death sentence was possible. On February 18, 2011, he pleaded guilty and received a 49th life term. "It makes me sick to my stomach that he beat the system," her sister said.
In 2013 Ridgway told a KOMO Newsradio reporter that his total was 75 to 80. Investigators treated the claim with skepticism; Dave Reichert, the former sheriff, put his own estimate at 65 to 70. In December 2025 the state Department of Corrections called reports that Ridgway was dying "inaccurate rumors." He was then held at the Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla.
White was arrested in September 2003 in the shooting death of Jason Reichardt, 27, an Aurora man who had been his friend. Questioned about Reichardt, he began to talk about women. Within days the deaths of two women came to light in Denver, and a Denver grand jury later returned a 53-count indictment charging murder, kidnapping and other violent crimes against five women, two of whom had been killed.
He was eligible for the death penalty. On September 7, 2004, in Arapahoe County Court in Centennial, he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murder of Reichardt. The following week, in Denver, he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murders of Victoria Lyn Turpin and Annaletia Maria Gonzales. Prosecutors did not seek death. In exchange, according to the Denver District Attorney’s office, he agreed to help investigators with the cases of three other women he said he had killed in Colorado since 1998. District Judge Gerald Rafferty, sentencing him for Reichardt’s death, told him a great deal of mercy had been shown to him and that he would be behind bars for the rest of his natural life.
By April 2005, the Associated Press reported, White was serving life without parole for the three killings and had not been charged in the cases of the other women he had described. That spring his father began selling DVD copies of his son’s videotaped statement to police. Annaletia Gonzales’s father said the family was profiting from the crimes.
In 1984 a Maine jury convicted Hicks of killing his first wife, Jennie Cyr Hicks, 23, who had disappeared in 1977. The Bangor Daily News has described the offense as fourth-degree murder. He served six years of a ten-year sentence and was released in July 1990. He was also the main suspect in the disappearances of Jerilyn Towers of Newport in 1982 and of Lynn Willette, a former partner, in 1996, but without more evidence police could not charge him.
The leverage came from Texas. In April 2000 Hicks robbed an older woman who employed him as a handyman, and with his Maine record he faced 55 years in a Texas prison. Maine investigators made him an offer. He would confess to the three Maine killings and provide information about the locations of victims; in return he would serve any Maine sentence before any Texas time. With a life term in Maine all but certain, he would in practice never serve the Texas sentence at all. His recorded confession ran nine hours.
He pleaded guilty in Penobscot County Superior Court in Bangor to the murders of Jerilyn Towers and Lynn Willette. William Stokes, who had prosecuted the 1984 case, recommended life and told the court he was "not very impressed" by the cooperation, which in his view was self-interest. Chief Superior Court Justice Andrew Mead imposed two concurrent life sentences. Maine has no parole. In Lubbock, Judge Cecil Puryear sentenced Hicks to 55 years for the aggravated robbery, a term he was expected never to begin.
For nearly two decades Anthony Cook was in prison for one killing, the September 1981 murder of Peter Sawicki in Toledo, while the others went unsolved. In 1998 DNA from the 1980 case in which Tom Gordon was killed matched Anthony and his younger brother Nathaniel. It tied them to that case and nothing else. Lucas County Prosecutor Julia Bates was not certain evidence nearly 20 years old would hold up at trial.
The terms were simple. If both brothers confessed fully to every crime they had committed in Lucas County and passed polygraph examinations, Nathaniel would be released after 20 years; any lie would void the deal. Bates put the choice to the victims' families, and they agreed because they wanted answers. Ohio law at the time of the killings allowed neither a death sentence nor life without parole. The brothers gave videotaped confessions in April 2000 describing nine killings between 1973 and 1981. Nathaniel admitted taking part in three, those of Tom Gordon, Connie Sue Thompson and Dawn Rene Backes, who was 12. Anthony pleaded guilty in the Gordon killing and received a second life term; prosecutors agreed not to pursue charges for the others.
Nathaniel pleaded guilty to attempted murder and kidnapping, as the Associated Press and WNWO reported, and holds no murder conviction. His 20 years ended in 2018. "We made a deal he would do 20 years, and be set free," Bates told WTVG. Her office would not oppose his release, she said, because otherwise "nobody is ever going to trust the prosecutor in the future ever again." On August 9, 2018, Judge Linda Jennings ordered him released. She told him she had looked for a legal reason to keep him in prison and had none. He was required to register his address every 90 days. "We’ve dreaded it, but we agreed to it," Scott Moulton’s sister said. Anthony was denied parole in February 2015. A hearing set for December 5, 2024, was moved to March 2025 after he refused to meet the board; as of that December he was still in prison.
Harris County could prove an attack on two women in Houston on May 23, 1982. It could not prove a single murder. District Attorney John Holmes said his office had "not a stitch of evidence" in the killings. On August 9, 1982, the day trial was set to begin, the assistant district attorney Ira Jones asked Watts whether, as the father of a daughter, he would want to know what had happened to her if she went missing. Watts said yes.
The agreement gave him immunity from murder prosecution for the killings he confessed to, in exchange for a guilty plea to burglary with intent to commit murder and a 60-year sentence. He confessed to a Houston homicide detective, Tom Ladd, and the Associated Press counted twelve confessed killings in Texas and one in Michigan. Judge Doug Shaver accepted the bargain because there was no evidence to convict Watts of murder and police needed his help. Sixty years, he said, was the most the evidence allowed. Michigan refused to offer the same immunity.
The price grew over time. Shaver had entered a finding that a deadly weapon was used, which limited good-time credit. In 1989 the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals deleted it, and under a mandatory supervision law of the period Watts was due for release in 2006. Families who had backed the 1982 deal because they wanted to know what had happened to their daughters, sisters and wives now lobbied Governor Rick Perry to keep him in. "You do not rehabilitate a serial killer," said Andy Kahan of the Houston mayor’s crime victims office.
Michigan supplied the answer. After a public appeal by Attorney General Mike Cox in January 2004, a witness, Joseph Foy, came forward about the 1979 death of Helen Dutcher in Ferndale, a killing Watts had never confessed. Judge Richard Kuhn allowed the 1982 Texas confessions in as evidence of a pattern. On November 17, 2004, an Oakland County jury convicted Watts of first-degree murder, and Michigan law made the sentence life without parole. In 2007 a Kalamazoo jury convicted him of the 1974 murder of Gloria Steele. He died of prostate cancer in a secure hospital area in Jackson, Michigan, in September 2007, still in custody.
Blair had already served one long sentence. In 1982 he killed Angela Monroe, his former girlfriend and the mother of two of his children, and he served 21 years of a 25-year term before he was paroled, about seven months before his arrest in September 2004. That summer six women died in Kansas City: Sheliah McKinzie, 38; Anna Ewing, 42; Patricia Wilson Butler, 45; Carmen Hunt, 40; Claudette Juniel, 31; and Darci I. Williams, 25.
Blair had nothing to sell. At trial the State’s case rested on DNA linking him to Sheliah McKinzie and on a series of anonymous 911 calls in which a man claimed responsibility for the deaths; the judge concluded that Blair was the caller. He made no confession and denied the killings throughout. In December 2004 a Jackson County grand jury indicted him on eight counts of first-degree murder and further counts involving women who survived.
The bargain he did make concerned procedure, not knowledge. Under a pretrial agreement the State dropped the death penalty and dismissed two murder counts, for Nellia Harris, 33, and Sandra Reed, 47, along with the other counts. In return Blair gave up his right to a jury and agreed that a witness’s earlier statement could be admitted if she was unavailable to testify. He was never tried for the Harris and Reed deaths.
On March 27, 2008, Jackson County Circuit Judge John R. O’Malley convicted him of all six murders after a bench trial, while criticizing the police for letting television cameras accompany detectives. On April 24, 2008, he imposed six consecutive terms of life without parole. The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed in 2009, holding that neither constitution requires police to record interrogations. Blair died in custody at Potosi Correctional Center on May 11, 2024, at 62.
Shermantine and Herzog grew up together in Linden, a farm town east of Stockton. In 2001, after a trial moved to Santa Clara County because of publicity, a jury convicted Shermantine of the first-degree murders of Howard King III and Paul Cavanaugh (1984), Chevelle "Chevy" Wheeler, 16 (1985), and Cyndi Vanderheiden, 25 (1998). The prosecutor, Dave Testa, told the jury there were "no fingerprints, no eyewitnesses, no smoking gun."
During the trial Shermantine tried to sell what he knew. He offered information about the locations of victims if his two sons received $20,000 in reward money. Prosecutors refused. Testa then offered to ask the judge for life without parole instead of death if Shermantine disclosed what he knew; Shermantine declined. In March 2001 the jury returned a death verdict.
Herzog was tried separately and convicted of three murders, but in August 2004 the Court of Appeal overturned the verdicts, ruling that investigators had coerced his statements by ignoring his requests for a lawyer. Without the confession, prosecutors offered a plea. Herzog pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in Vanderheiden’s death, to three counts of being an accessory to a felony and to a drug count, and received 14 years with credit for time served. He was paroled on September 18, 2010, to a trailer on the grounds of High Desert State Prison near Susanville. "There is no bigger injustice," Vanderheiden’s father said.
Shermantine sold to a private buyer. A Sacramento bail bondsman and bounty hunter, Leonard Padilla, offered him money for information about the locations of victims. In January 2012 Padilla telephoned Herzog to warn him that Shermantine was about to talk. On January 16, Herzog died at his trailer; the Lassen County sheriff said the evidence pointed to suicide. Shermantine’s disclosures came in the weeks after. In May 2012 he told a CBS13 reporter, "I had an active role." He was still on death row, his automatic appeal pending, when he died at California State Prison, Sacramento, on September 17, 2026, at 60.
The oldest of these bargains was struck in Edinburgh in the winter of 1828. William Burke, William Hare, Helen McDougal and Margaret Hare were held after the death of a woman named Margery Campbell or Docherty. The Crown had one body and little evidence of how she had died. The University of Edinburgh’s medical college says there was not enough to convict.
The Lord Advocate, Sir William Rae, decided that one of the four had to give evidence against the others. According to the National Library of Scotland, he chose Hare, who was to turn King’s evidence and was offered immunity from prosecution if his testimony led to the prosecution of Burke and McDougal. The trial before the High Court of Justiciary began on December 24, 1828, and ran through the night. Hare described the killing of Mrs. Docherty and said he had taken no hand in it. On Christmas morning the jury convicted Burke; the charge against McDougal was returned not proven.
Burke later confessed to sixteen killings in 1828, naming Hare as his only accomplice, and said Hare had perjured himself about the Docherty killing. Burke was hanged in the Lawnmarket on January 28, 1829. A private prosecution of Hare for the murder of James Wilson failed, and he was released from prison on February 5, 1829. A crowd threatened his life at Dumfries days later, and he was taken out of the town under guard. The last reliable sighting placed him on the road to Carlisle on February 7, 1829. Nothing certain is known of him after that.
In early 1993, a federal Justice Department paper later wrote, the Ontario authorities had no admissible evidence tying Paul Bernardo to the deaths of Leslie Mahaffy, 14, and Kristen French, 15, and without his wife’s cooperation a murder prosecution was unlikely. Karla Homolka sought blanket immunity and was refused. The agreement finalized on May 14, 1993, set a term of 12 years on guilty pleas to two counts of manslaughter. It required her to give a full and truthful account of the deaths of the two girls and of her sister Tammy, 15, who had died in December 1990, and of any other crimes she had taken part in. She was never charged in her sister’s death.
On July 6, 1993, Justice Francis Kovacs sentenced her to two concurrent 12-year terms. By the fall of 1994 the bargain looked very different. Six videotapes held by Bernardo’s former lawyer reached police on September 22, 1994, and they showed Homolka as a participant rather than a coerced witness. The Justice Department paper states that had the authorities possessed the tapes on May 14, 1993, the prosecutor would never have entered into the agreement.
She testified at Bernardo’s trial. On September 1, 1995, a jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree murder, with other charges, and he was later declared a dangerous offender. A review by Patrick Galligan in 1996 concluded that the Crown had had no alternative but to deal with her and that she could not now be charged with murder: the agreement barred it, and under the Criminal Code a manslaughter conviction bars a later murder indictment for the same death. Homolka served the full 12 years and was released on July 4, 2005. A Quebec judge imposed conditions on her that June; a Superior Court judge lifted them that December.
Charlene Gallego pleaded guilty in two states. In California she pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder for the November 1980 deaths of Craig Miller and Mary Beth Sowers, students at Sacramento State College, under an agreement that set her term at 16 years and 8 months. The California Supreme Court noted that she "enjoyed no immunity for perjury." In Nevada she pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder for the April 1980 deaths of Stacey Redican and Karen Twiggs, both 17.
The price was her testimony against her partner, Gerald Gallego. A California jury convicted him on April 11, 1983, of two counts of first-degree murder and two of kidnapping, and he was sentenced to death. A Nevada jury convicted him in 1984 of two counts of first-degree murder and two of first-degree kidnapping, and again chose death. Under Nevada law an accomplice’s testimony alone cannot convict; the state supplied corroboration, and the Nevada Supreme Court affirmed in 1985. By her own account to investigators, ten people died in all. The other six deaths were never charged against either of them.
Gerald Gallego died of colon cancer at the prison medical center in Carson City on July 18, 2002, never executed. When the Nevada Supreme Court affirmed his second death sentence in May 2001, it noted that Charlene was no longer serving prison time.
In 1979 five teenage girls died in Los Angeles County: Lucinda Lynn Schaefer, 16; Andrea Joy Hall, 18; Jacqueline Doris Gilliam, 15; Jacqueline Leah Lamp, 13; and Shirley Lynette Ledford. Roy Norris and Lawrence Bittaker were arrested that fall.
Norris bargained first. Under his plea agreement, as the California Supreme Court described it, he would not face the death penalty or life without the possibility of parole. In exchange he agreed to give information about the victims, to testify at Bittaker’s trial, and to plead guilty to five counts of murder without special circumstances, with other charges. He was required "to give a complete and truthful account of both his and Larry Bittaker’s participation in the murders." He was sentenced to 45 years to life.
He was the prosecution’s chief witness in 1981. On February 17, 1981, a jury convicted Bittaker of five counts of murder with special circumstances, and he was sentenced to death that March. In 1989 the California Supreme Court affirmed. It held that "nothing in the bargain requires or permits Norris to testify falsely," but it criticized the clause leaving it to the district attorney to judge whether Norris had told the truth, saying that decision belonged to a court. Bittaker died on death row at San Quentin on December 13, 2019. Norris died of natural causes at the California Medical Facility in Vacaville on February 24, 2020, at 72.
In early 1987 five elderly women died at the Alpine Manor Nursing Home in Walker, near Grand Rapids. The investigation began when Catherine Wood’s former husband went to police with what she had told him. By January 1989 she had been ordered to stand trial on two counts of open murder, and her co-worker and former partner, Gwendolyn Graham, had been brought back from Texas.
Wood pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit second-degree murder and was sentenced to 20 to 40 years. She was the key witness at Graham’s trial. In September 1989 a Kent County jury convicted Graham of five counts of first-degree murder and one of conspiracy, which carried mandatory life without parole.
The Michigan Parole Board turned Wood down eight times, most recently in 2016, and voted to release her on the ninth review, in 2018. The families appealed. Attorney General Dana Nessel told the court that Wood had confessed to helping kill at least five patients. In October 2019 Kent County Judge Joe Rossi ruled that the board had not abused its discretion, and WGVU reported that investigators had called her cooperation crucial to the case against Graham. The ruling cleared the way for her release; by then she had served about 30 years. Graham is serving life.
Each of these agreements was written by prosecutors who believed the alternative was worse. Maleng thought a seven-count trial would leave dozens of families without an answer. Rae thought the Docherty case would fail without Hare. Galligan concluded that Ontario had no choice. Bates kept her word to Nathaniel Cook because, she said, no future witness would trust a prosecutor who broke it.
The bargains did not age evenly. Ridgway’s still held in 2011, when a 49th guilty plea came with no possibility of death. Watts’s nearly set him free in 2006. Homolka’s was signed before the tapes reached police. Hicks traded away a 55-year Texas term he was expected never to begin. And Blair, who sold nothing, still bargained his way out of a death sentence by giving up a jury.
• 1828, winter: Margery Campbell or Docherty dies in Edinburgh; William Hare is offered immunity to give evidence for the Crown.
• December 24 to 25, 1828: Burke and McDougal tried; Burke convicted, the charge against McDougal returned not proven.
• January 28, 1829: William Burke hanged in Edinburgh. February 5, 1829: Hare released.
• 1977: Jennie Cyr Hicks disappears in Maine.
• 1979: five teenage girls die in Los Angeles County; Norris and Bittaker arrested that fall.
• February 17, 1981: Lawrence Bittaker convicted; Roy Norris later sentenced to 45 years to life under his plea agreement.
• March 1982: Anthony Cook convicted by a Lucas County jury of the murder of Peter Sawicki.
• August 9, 1982: Coral Eugene Watts agrees to plead guilty to burglary with intent to commit murder in exchange for immunity for the killings he confesses; sentenced to 60 years on September 3.
• April 11, 1983: Gerald Gallego convicted in California, with Charlene Gallego as the central witness.
• 1984: Hicks convicted in his wife’s death; Gerald Gallego convicted in Nevada.
• 1987: five women die at the Alpine Manor Nursing Home in Walker, Michigan.
• 1989: Catherine Wood pleads guilty to second-degree murder and conspiracy; Gwendolyn Graham convicted of five first-degree murders in September. The deadly weapon finding in Watts’s Texas case is deleted.
• May 14, 1993: Karla Homolka’s resolution agreement finalized; sentenced July 6, 1993, to 12 years.
• September 22, 1994: the Bernardo videotapes reach police.
• September 1, 1995: Paul Bernardo convicted of two counts of first-degree murder, with other charges.
• 1996: the Galligan review upholds the Homolka agreement.
• 2000: Anthony and Nathaniel Cook confess under the Lucas County plea agreement; Hicks pleads guilty in Bangor to the murders of Jerilyn Towers and Lynn Willette.
• February 14, 2001: Wesley Shermantine convicted of four first-degree murders; death verdict in March.
• April 2003: Ridgway’s lawyers propose the plea bargain to Norm Maleng. November 5, 2003: Ridgway pleads guilty to 48 counts; sentenced December 18.
• August 2004: the Court of Appeal overturns Loren Herzog’s murder convictions; he later pleads guilty to voluntary manslaughter and accessory counts.
• September 2004: Richard Paul White pleads guilty to three first-degree murders; Terry Blair arrested in Kansas City.
• November 17, 2004: Watts convicted in Michigan of the murder of Helen Dutcher.
• July 4, 2005: Homolka released at the end of her sentence.
• September 2007: Watts dies in custody in Jackson, Michigan, after a second Michigan murder conviction.
• March 27, 2008: Blair convicted of six first-degree murders after a bench trial.
• September 18, 2010: Herzog paroled to a trailer near Susanville.
• February 18, 2011: Ridgway pleads guilty to a 49th count.
• January 16, 2012: Herzog dies at his trailer; Shermantine’s disclosures follow in the weeks after.
• August 9, 2018: Judge Linda Jennings orders Nathaniel Cook released under the 2000 agreement.
• October 2019: Judge Joe Rossi upholds Wood’s parole.
• February 24, 2020: Norris dies in custody in Vacaville.
• May 11, 2024: Blair dies at Potosi Correctional Center.
• December 2024: Anthony Cook’s parole hearing moved to March 2025.
• December 2025: Washington corrections officials call reports of Ridgway’s decline "inaccurate rumors."
• September 17, 2026: Shermantine dies on death row at California State Prison, Sacramento.