Serial murder has a plain meaning. It is more than one killing, by the same offender, in separate events, with time between them. The definition is narrow on purpose, and it excludes a great deal that the public instinctively files beside it: the man who kills a houseful of strangers in one night, the couple who kill their way across two states in a week, the political cell that turns on its own members in the mountains, the woman whose legend outruns any record of her.
The thirteen cases that follow sit on the wrong side of that line, some by a matter of hours, some by a mile. Each is regularly shelved with serial murder. Each, examined closely, turns out to be something else: a massacre, a rampage, a purge, a myth, a man who killed nobody, a fatal fraud, a wrongful conviction, or a single proven killing surrounded by suspicion that no court has turned into a verdict.
Richard Benjamin Speck was born on December 6, 1941, in Kirkwood, Illinois, the seventh of eight children in a poor family, and grew up mostly in the suburbs of Dallas, Texas. By 1966 he was 24 and already had a criminal record that included a prison sentence in 1963, according to the Chicago History Museum.
On the night of July 13, 1966, in Chicago, he killed eight student nurses, all in their early twenties: Gloria Davy, Patricia Matusek, Nina Jo Schmale, Pamela Wilkening, Suzanne Farris, Mary Ann Jordan, Merlita Gargullo and Valentina Pasion. He was arrested about two days later, after a physician at Cook County Hospital, treating a patient who had tried to take his own life, alerted police that the man might be Speck.
The trial was moved to the Peoria County Courthouse and began in early April 1967. The jury deliberated for less than an hour and returned a guilty verdict on April 15, recommending death, and in June a judge sentenced him to the electric chair. The Supreme Court’s decision in Furman v. Georgia on June 29, 1972, ended that sentence; in November 1972 he was resentenced to consecutive terms of 400 to 1,200 years, later reduced to 100 to 300 years. He was refused parole about seven times. In his only interview, given to a Chicago Tribune columnist in 1978, he claimed an accomplice, a claim for which no proof was produced. He died in a Joliet hospital on December 5, 1991, a day before his fiftieth birthday, of what was largely believed to be a heart attack.
Eight people died at his hands, but they died in a single event. The Chicago History Museum’s own account of the case calls him the city’s first mass murderer, which is the accurate term.
The deaths of five people came to light outside Soquel, in Santa Cruz County, California, on October 19, 1970. They were Dr. Victor Ohta, an eye surgeon prominent in the county; his wife, Virginia; their sons, Derrick and Taggart, aged 11 and 12; and Dorothy Cadwallader, the doctor’s medical secretary. The couple’s two daughters, then 18 and 15, were away at school.
John Linley Frazier was 25. He had grown up in Soquel and worked as a mechanic in Santa Cruz garages, the historian Geoffrey Dunn wrote in Good Times in 2022.
A grand jury indicted Frazier on five counts of murder on October 28, 1970. Publicity in the county was intense, and so was local hostility toward the counterculture with which he was identified. On July 7, 1971, the Supreme Court of California, in Frazier v. Superior Court, ruled that there was a "reasonable likelihood" he could not receive a fair trial in Santa Cruz and ordered the superior court to grant a change of venue. He was convicted of the five murders. District Attorney Peter Chang, who prosecuted Frazier and, soon afterward, Herbert Mullin and Edmund Kemper, called Santa Cruz "the Murder Capital of the World," a label that reached Time magazine.
Frazier killed five people at one address on one day. That makes the case a mass murder, however often it is filed beside the two series that followed it in the same county.
In August 2009 a fire swept through a wedding tent in the tribal district of Al-Jahra, about 40 kilometers west of Kuwait City. The tent had been raised for the celebration of a man’s second marriage. Fifty-seven women and children died. Kuwait afterward banned wedding tents.
The man’s first wife, Nasra al-Enezi, was arrested on August 16. Prosecutors said she had set the fire to wreck the wedding, and press reports at the time spoke of revenge for her husband’s treatment of her. On March 30, 2010, a Kuwaiti court of first instance, with Judge Adel al-Sager reading the verdict, convicted her in her absence of premeditated murder and of starting a fire with intent to kill, and sentenced her to death. She was 23 and the mother of two. Her lawyer said she had confessed to police but denied the crime in court, where she said she had been at home; a domestic worker testified for the prosecution. The lawyer called the verdict "very harsh" and said it had been shaped by public opinion.
The sentence stood. On January 25, 2017, al-Enezi was hanged with six other prisoners, among them a member of the ruling family, Sheikh Faisal Abdullah al-Sabah, in Kuwait’s first executions since 2013. Fifty-seven deaths make hers one of the deadliest crimes in the country’s history, but they came from a single act.
In August 1985 five members of one family were shot dead at White House Farm, in Tolleshunt D’Arcy, Essex: Nevill and June Bamber; their adopted daughter, Sheila Caffell; and her six-year-old twin sons, Daniel and Nicholas. Police first treated the deaths as a murder and suicide by Sheila, ITV News Anglia recorded in its timeline of the case.
Her adoptive brother, Jeremy Bamber, was charged with the murders. At Chelmsford Crown Court in October 1986 he was convicted of all five and sentenced to life imprisonment. The prosecution’s case was that he had killed his family; the defense argued that Sheila had killed the others and then herself. The Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd, called for an inquiry into the police handling of the case, which produced 18 recommendations.
Bamber lost his first appeal in March 1989. In December 1994 his minimum term was replaced by a whole-life tariff. The Criminal Cases Review Commission, which inherited his application from the Home Office in March 1997, referred the conviction back to the Court of Appeal in March 2001, after new DNA evidence undermined a strand of the prosecution case that the trial judge had stressed in his summing up. In December 2002 the Court of Appeal upheld the conviction. He lost challenges to the whole-life term in 2008 and 2009, and in February 2011 the Commission declined to refer the case again. In July 2013 the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights, in a case brought by Bamber and two other prisoners, ruled that whole-life sentences as then structured amounted to inhuman and degrading treatment, while stressing that the ruling gave the men no prospect of imminent release. A later application to the Commission was also turned down: it concluded that the fresh material could not have affected the jury’s decision, Gepp Solicitors reported.
Bamber has always maintained that he is innocent. His conviction stands, for five killings committed on a single night.
The case of Charles Starkweather is the closest call of the thirteen. On December 1, 1957, Robert Colvert, a 21-year-old Lincoln service station attendant, was killed in Lancaster County. On January 21, 1958, Marion Bartlett, 57, his wife Velda, 36, and their daughter Betty Jean, two and a half, the family of Starkweather’s 14-year-old girlfriend, Caril Ann Fugate, were killed.
On January 27, August Meyer, 70, was killed near Bennet, and Robert Jensen, 17, and Carol King, 16, were killed near the same town. On January 28, in Lincoln, the businessman C. Lauer Ward, 48, his wife Clara, 46, and their maid, Lillian Fencl, 51, were killed. On January 29 Merle Collison, 37, a shoe salesman from Great Falls, Montana, was killed near Douglas, Wyoming. Starkweather and Fugate were captured near Douglas the same day, according to the Lincoln Evening Journal’s account of June 25, 1959.
Starkweather was tried for one killing only. A Lancaster County jury convicted him on May 23, 1958, of the first-degree murder of Robert Jensen and fixed the penalty at death. The Nebraska Supreme Court denied his appeal that December, the pardon board refused clemency in April 1959, and the federal courts refused to intervene. Four execution dates were stayed. He was executed on June 25, 1959.
Fugate was tried separately and convicted on November 21, 1958, of the same Jensen murder; the jury fixed a life sentence. In October 1973 the pardon board commuted it to 30 to 50 years, she was paroled on June 8, 1976, and her parole was discharged on September 28, 1981.
The Colvert killing stood apart from the rest by weeks, and the case has been argued over for that reason. But the January killings came in one continuous run, ending only with the arrest in Wyoming, and the case is ordinarily described as a spree. In law it is a single murder conviction, with the other deaths never tried.
On February 14, 1981, a gang of dacoits killed 20 villagers in Behmai, in what is now Kanpur Dehat district of Uttar Pradesh; 17 of the dead were Thakurs, an upper caste, according to the Press Trust of India. The gang was led by Phoolan Devi, who had grown up an illiterate villager and who said the killings avenged abuse she had suffered at the hands of upper-caste men. Other agency reports gave the toll as 22.
She surrendered to the authorities in 1983 and was released from jail in 1994. In 1996 she was elected to parliament, and the same year the film Bandit Queen retold her life. In 2001, at 38, she was shot dead in New Delhi. Sher Singh Rana was convicted of her murder in August 2014 and sentenced to life imprisonment by Judge Bharat Parashar; ten other defendants were acquitted.
She was never tried for Behmai. Thirty-five people, including her, were accused in the case, and the trial dragged on for more than four decades while the accused died one after another. On February 14, 2024, the anniversary of the killings, Judge Amit Malviya of the anti-dacoity court in Kanpur Dehat convicted Shyam Babu, a member of her gang, and sentenced him to life; the only other living defendant was acquitted for lack of evidence. The case is a single massacre, rooted in caste conflict, and it has one conviction.
Hiroko Nagata was born in Tokyo on February 8, 1945. By 1971 she chaired the Revolutionary Left, one of two militant groups on the Japanese far left that merged on July 15 of that year as the United Red Army; the other was the Red Army faction led by Tsuneo Mori. In August 1971, before the merger, the Revolutionary Left killed two of its own members who had tried to leave its first base.
From late November 1971 the combined group gathered at a base on Mount Haruna, in Gunma Prefecture, and later moved to another on Mount Myōgi. There, under Mori and Nagata, members were subjected to what the group called sōkatsu, or self-criticism, a regime that turned into a series of killings. The Associated Press, summing up the prosecution case in 1993, described the victims as having been condemned in "revolutionary kangaroo trials" for failing to follow the group’s ideology or for trying to quit. Nippon.com puts the total number of purged members, counting the two killed in August, at 14. Mori and Nagata were arrested on Mount Myōgi. Five other members fled across to Karuizawa and on February 19, 1972, seized a lodge at Asama-Sansō, holding a woman hostage for ten days; when police stormed the building on February 28, two officers were killed, and a civilian also died.
The Tokyo District Court sentenced Nagata to death on June 18, 1982. The Tokyo High Court upheld the sentence on September 26, 1986, and on February 19, 1993, the Supreme Court of Japan upheld the death sentences of Nagata and of Hiroshi Sakaguchi, one of the Asama-Sansō five. She was never executed. She died in custody on February 6, 2011, at the age of 65, according to the Japan Innocence and Death Penalty Information Center.
The deaths were killings of comrades by a political cell, decided collectively and carried out by a group under its leaders over a few months in the mountains. The case is a political purge, and Nagata’s conviction is for her part in it.
The tale of Vera Renczi is told the same way almost everywhere. A wealthy woman of the Banat, in the town then called Bečkerek and now Zrenjanin, in Serbia, is said to have killed two husbands, a son and dozens of lovers. The figure of 35 recurs.
What the tale lacks is a record. Reviewing the story in May 2026, the Serbian daily Kurir reported that there were no reliable court records of any trial, and no precise information on how or when she died; that some historians regard her as an urban legend that took on the form of a real person; and that the story first appeared in print in the United States in May 1925. The same report added that archival traces show a woman of that name lived in the town, and it noted that many local documents were lost in the wars of the twentieth century. A claim that she was entered in the Guinness Book of Records in 1972 appears there only as hearsay.
A woman of that name may have lived in Bečkerek. A trial, a conviction and a list of victims have not been reported. Without them the case is a story, not a criminal record, and the count of 35 rests on nothing a court established.
Carl Tanzler killed no one and was never accused of killing anyone. His real name was Karl Tanzler; in Key West, where he arrived in the 1920s and worked as a radiologist at the local hospital, he called himself Count Carl von Cosel, though he was not a count, Nancy Klingener reported for WLRN in 2018.
At the hospital he met Elena Milagro Hoyos, a young Cuban-American woman who was ill with tuberculosis. After her death he kept her body. When this came to light in 1940 he was charged with the wanton and willful destruction of her burial place, and a three-person board that included two doctors declared him sane. The charge was dropped because the two-year statute of limitations had run out. Public opinion in Key West that year was, by WLRN’s account, largely sympathetic to him.
He left Key West for Zephyrhills, Florida, where his wife and daughters had been living. In 1947 the pulp magazine Fantastic Adventures published his account of the affair under the title "The Secret of Elena’s Tomb." He died about ten years later. Whatever else his case is, it is not murder of any kind.
Dean Faiello ran a profitable skin and laser clinic in New York City without a license to practice medicine. Charged with three counts of practicing medicine without a license and ordered to stop treating patients, he carried on seeing them from a friend’s apartment in lower Manhattan, ABC News reported in 2022.
One of those patients was Maria Cruz, 35, a finance professional who had emigrated from the Philippines, earned an MBA at Fordham University and was a devout Catholic. She died in April 2003 during a laser treatment he was giving her. Faiello, who had already missed court dates on the licensing charges, fled to Costa Rica. He was extradited to the United States and pleaded guilty to first-degree assault in her death. He was sentenced to 20 years, served 17 and was released on parole in 2022.
Interviewed by ABC News after his release, he said he could offer no logical explanation for what he had done, and apologized to Cruz’s family: "Not a day passes that I do not think of Maria or think of her family and why I acted like such a coward." His crime caused one death, and his conviction is for assault.
For most of the 1990s Sture Bergwall, a patient at the forensic psychiatric hospital at Säter, in central Sweden, who had taken the name Thomas Quick, was presented to the Swedish public as a multiple murderer. He had been sentenced to closed psychiatric care in 1991 for theft, aggravated theft and aggravated robbery. At Säter, first in therapy and then in police interviews, he claimed responsibility for killings in Sweden, Norway and Finland; counts of his confessions range from more than 20 to 39. Between 1994 and 2001 six Swedish district courts convicted him of eight murders: Charles Zelmanovits, 15; Marinus and Janny Stegehuis, a Dutch couple camping in Lapland; Yenon Levi, an Israeli visitor; Therese Johannessen, 9; Trine Jensen, 17; Gry Storvik, 23; and Johan Asplund, 11. The evidence consisted largely of his own statements, and none of the convictions was examined by a higher court.
In November 2001 he announced a "time out" from the investigations, and the next year he ended therapy and took back his birth name. In December 2008, in two documentaries by the journalist Hannes Råstam on Sveriges Television, he withdrew every confession. Råstam’s later work, summarized by Bernard Porter and Kajsa Ohrlander in the London Review of Books blog, showed that Bergwall’s information came from newspapers, from hints during police contacts and from cues given while he was driven to sites, and that much of it was wrong.
Retrials were granted in all eight cases between 2009 and 2013. In each, the prosecutor dropped the charge and the district court entered an acquittal; the last became final on November 26, 2013. The government commission under Daniel Tarschys reported in June 2015 that a mentally ill person’s confession is not enough, by itself, for a murder conviction, and set out failures by the prosecutor, the courts and the hospital that treated him. He left Säter in March 2014, and his forensic psychiatric care ended in April 2015. In June 2018 the Chancellor of Justice refused his claim for compensation. No conviction against him for any killing stands.
Lowell Edwin Amos, known as Ed, was a General Motors executive in Anderson, Indiana, who in January 1979 announced a bid for the Republican nomination for mayor. A former family friend remembered him playing the part of a playboy, The Herald Bulletin of Anderson reported in 2006.
In 1996 a court in Detroit convicted him of the murder of his third wife, Roberta "Bobbe" Amos, who had died of a cocaine overdose in Detroit. He was sentenced to life imprisonment and was held at Muskegon Correctional Facility in Michigan, where the parole board refused him in November 2005.
Around that single conviction sit three other deaths. His first wife, Saundra Heard Amos, died in Anderson in 1979, and Anderson police investigated; the cause of death was not determined. His second wife, Carolyn Amos, died in Henry County, Indiana, in April 1989; that cause, too, was not determined. Local investigators also believed he might have been responsible for the death of his mother. A neighbor told the paper that Saundra had said he took out a life insurance policy of a million dollars on her. No charge was brought in Indiana in either wife’s death. In law Amos is a man convicted of one murder, suspected in others.
Eli Stutzman grew up in the Swartzentruber Amish community at Dalton, Ohio, where he and his wife, Ida, farmed south of the village. In 1977 Ida died in a barn fire; she was eight months pregnant. The fire was attributed at the time to lightning, and Stutzman was not treated as a suspect. In 1979 he left the Amish church, was shunned, and moved away with their son, Danny.
Danny’s death came to light in Nebraska, and in December 1987 the boy was identified as Daniel Stutzman, aged 9. In 1985 he had been placed with a foster family in Wyoming, and that December his father collected him for what was described as a visit to his grandparents in Wayne County, Ohio; afterward Stutzman told friends and family that the boy had died in a car accident in Utah, but Utah authorities had no record of such a death. Nebraska officials did not disclose a cause of death. On December 21, 1987, authorities in Texas arrested Stutzman on a felony child abuse charge, and he was extradited to Nebraska on a charge that carried up to five years in prison. Texas investigators also wanted to question him about the 1985 shooting death of a roommate, and Ohio investigators reopened the 1977 fire, the Mennonite Weekly Review reported on December 31, 1987.
He was later convicted of murdering a roommate, according to the review of Gregg Olsen’s 2024 book The Amish Wife published by Bookreporter, which argues that Ida was killed before the fire. No court has tied him to Ida’s death or ruled on how Danny died. His record holds one murder conviction.
Set side by side, the thirteen cases fall into a handful of kinds. Speck, Frazier, al-Enezi and Bamber were convicted of killings committed in a single event, whatever the toll. Starkweather’s January killings ran together without a break. The Behmai massacre and the United Red Army purge were group killings with political or caste roots. Vera Renczi’s case has no reported trial at all, and Tanzler’s has no killing. Faiello’s patient died at the hands of a man with no license to treat her, and Bergwall’s eight convictions were all set aside. Amos and Stutzman each stand convicted of one murder, with other deaths around them that no court has charged to them. None of the thirteen meets the test of separate killings, proven against one offender, divided by time.
• December 1, 1957: Robert Colvert is killed in Lancaster County, Nebraska.
• January 21 to 29, 1958: the Bartlett family, August Meyer, Robert Jensen, Carol King, Lauer and Clara Ward, Lillian Fencl and Merle Collison are killed in Lincoln, near Bennet and near Douglas, Wyoming; Charles Starkweather and Caril Ann Fugate are captured near Douglas on January 29.
• May 23, 1958: Starkweather is convicted of the first-degree murder of Robert Jensen; Fugate is convicted of the same murder on November 21.
• June 25, 1959: Starkweather is executed.
• July 13, 1966: Richard Speck kills eight student nurses in Chicago.
• April 15, 1967: Speck is convicted in Peoria and the jury recommends death.
• October 19, 1970: the deaths of the Ohta family and Dorothy Cadwallader come to light outside Soquel, California; John Linley Frazier is indicted on October 28.
• July 7, 1971: the Supreme Court of California orders a change of venue for Frazier’s trial.
• July 15, 1971: the United Red Army is formed.
• Late 1971 to February 1972: the purge at the group’s mountain bases; the Asama-Sansō siege runs from February 19 to 28, 1972.
• November 1972: Speck is resentenced after Furman v. Georgia.
• February 14, 1981: twenty villagers are killed at Behmai, Uttar Pradesh.
• June 18, 1982: Hiroko Nagata is sentenced to death by the Tokyo District Court.
• 1983: Phoolan Devi surrenders.
• August 1985: five members of the Bamber family are shot dead at White House Farm, Essex.
• October 1986: Jeremy Bamber is convicted of five murders at Chelmsford Crown Court.
• December 21, 1987: Eli Stutzman is arrested in Texas.
• December 5, 1991: Speck dies in Joliet, Illinois.
• February 19, 1993: Japan’s Supreme Court upholds Nagata’s death sentence.
• 1994 to 2001: Sture Bergwall, as Thomas Quick, is convicted of eight murders in six trials.
• 1996: Ed Amos is convicted in Detroit of the murder of his third wife; Phoolan Devi is elected to parliament.
• March 2001 and December 2002: the Bamber conviction is referred back to the Court of Appeal and upheld.
• 2001: Phoolan Devi is shot dead in New Delhi.
• April 2003: Maria Cruz dies during a laser treatment given by Dean Faiello in New York.
• December 2008: Bergwall withdraws his confessions.
• August 2009: fifty-seven women and children die in the wedding tent fire at Al-Jahra, Kuwait.
• March 30, 2010: Nasra al-Enezi is sentenced to death.
• February 6, 2011: Nagata dies in custody.
• July 2013: the European Court of Human Rights rules on whole-life sentences in a case brought by Bamber and two other prisoners.
• November 26, 2013: Bergwall’s last acquittal becomes final.
• August 2014: Sher Singh Rana is sentenced to life for the murder of Phoolan Devi.
• January 25, 2017: al-Enezi is hanged.
• 2022: Faiello is released on parole.
• February 14, 2024: Shyam Babu is convicted in the Behmai case and sentenced to life.