THIRTEEN DEATHS FILED AS SOMETHING ELSE

Every death begins with a form. A pathologist, a coroner, a fire officer or a family doctor writes down a cause and a manner, and in the great majority of cases the first answer is the right one. Old people die in nursing homes. Infants die of illnesses no one saw coming. Houses burn. A man who has been drinking dies in his sleep. Thirteen cases, from Cincinnati in the 1930s to Saitama in 2009, are the exceptions: deaths that were filed as accidents, suicides or natural events and that later came back before a court, a police inquiry or a confession as something else. In some the first finding was corrected within weeks. In others it stood for years, and in a few it was never fully overturned.

The accident files

Carroll Edward Cole is the oldest example by the date of the death in question, and the thinnest on the record. A Dallas jury convicted him of murdering three women, Sally Thompson, Dorothy King and Wanda Faye Roberts, and he pleaded guilty in Nevada to the murders of Kathlyn J. Blum and Marie Cushman. At his Nevada sentencing he acted as his own lawyer, asked the three-judge panel for death and filed no appeal. When the Supreme Court of Nevada considered the case in October 1985, it wrote that, on his own admissions, he had killed at least 13 people, and that apart from "an eight or nine-year-old childhood companion," all of them were women. The court said nothing more about that child: no name, no year, no place, no word on how the death had been recorded. No charge was ever brought over it. Cole was executed by lethal injection at Nevada State Prison in Carson City on December 6, 1985.

Tammy Lyn Homolka was 15 when she died in St. Catharines, Ontario, early on December 24, 1990. Her older sister Karla and Karla’s fiance, Paul Bernardo, had drugged her. She was pronounced dead in hospital that morning, and police accepted the couple’s account. Doctors concluded that she had choked after drinking heavily, and her death was not treated as a crime. Justice Archie Campbell’s 1996 review of the police investigation called it "a secret homicide thought by the coroner and the police to be a death from natural causes." Karla Homolka was never charged in her sister’s death; the resolution agreement under which she pleaded guilty in 1993 to two counts of manslaughter, for the deaths of Leslie Mahaffy, 14, and Kristen French, 15, also covered her part in Tammy’s death. Bernardo was convicted in 1995 of the first-degree murders of both schoolgirls, and The Canadian Press has reported that he was convicted of manslaughter in Tammy’s death as well.

In South Korea, fire took the lives of Kang Ho-sun’s fourth wife and her mother in Ansan on October 30, 2005, while they were asleep. Kang got out with his son. At the time the fire was not treated as a crime. Weeks earlier he had taken out several life insurance policies on his wife, and in 2007, the Korea JoongAng Daily reported, he received 480 million won. Kang said the fire had started from mosquito coils he had lit. That account held until January 2009, when police arrested him over the disappearance of a university student in Gunpo and he confessed to killing seven women in southwestern Gyeonggi Province and, the following month, an eighth in Gangwon Province. Prosecutors at the Suwon District Prosecutors' Office reopened the fire. They noted that mosquito coils were not needed at the end of October, and fire experts concluded that flammable material, not the coils, had caused the fire. Kang admitted the eight killings and denied the fire to the end. On April 22, 2009, the Ansan Branch of the Suwon District Court found him guilty of all ten murders, including his wife and her mother, and sentenced him to death. The Seoul High Court upheld the sentence that July, and it became final when he did not appeal to the Supreme Court. As of October 2026 he remained on death row in Uiwang; South Korea has carried out no execution since December 1997.

Sharon Kinne’s first case turned on a story about a toddler. In March 1960 her husband, James Kinne, 25, was shot dead in Independence, Missouri. She told police that their two-year-old daughter had fired her husband’s pistol, and that the girl had asked, "How does this thing work, Daddy?" The first officer at the scene, William Morton, recalled decades later: "We bought it at that time." The death was ruled accidental, and she collected about $29,000 in life insurance. Two months later Patricia Jones, 23, the wife of a car salesman with whom Kinne was having an affair, was found shot dead after a meeting with Kinne. The Jackson County Sheriff’s Office arrested Kinne on May 31, 1960; she was charged with Jones’s murder, and a grand jury indicted her in her husband’s death. A jury acquitted her of the Jones murder in June 1961. A second jury convicted her of her husband’s murder in January 1962, but the Missouri Supreme Court reversed that verdict in 1963, and the retrials ended in a mistrial and a hung jury. Free on bond, she went to Mexico City, where in September 1964 a man named Francisco Paredes Ordoñez was shot dead. A Mexican court convicted her of his killing, and ballistics tests showed that a gun found among her things was the weapon used to kill Patricia Jones. She escaped from a Mexico City women’s prison in December 1969 and lived for decades in Taber, Alberta, under another name. She died in Alberta on January 21, 2022. In January 2025, after her identity was confirmed, the Jackson County prosecutor dismissed the charges still pending, and Kansas City police and the sheriff’s office announced that they attributed all three deaths to her.

The drowned women of Austria

Max Gufler, a traveling salesman of washing machines and vacuum cleaners from St. Pölten, courted women who had savings. Most of the women died by drowning, the Austrian broadcaster ORF reported, and the deaths were made to look like suicide. The pattern broke in October 1958, when the former husband of Maria Robas received a letter, apparently from a doctor in Munich, telling him she had been killed in a car accident. Police could find no record of any such accident. The registration papers for a green DKW, left as security for a loan at a butcher’s shop, led them to Gufler, and he was arrested on November 2, 1958. Investigators seized more than 3,500 objects from his rooms and garage, so many that they had to be sorted in a police gymnasium, the St. Pölten magazine MFG reported. The forensic chemist Gottfried Machata examined seven of the dead women and found the same substance in every one of them.

Gufler confessed and withdrew his confessions again and again. In 1961 a jury at the Vienna regional criminal court, trying him on seven counts of murder, convicted him of four murders, those of Maria Robas, Juliana Nass, Josefine Kammleitner and Emilie Meystrzik, and of two attempted murders, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a dark cell on each anniversary of the killings. The Argentine paper La Capital reported that investigators suspected him of 18 deaths, among them that of Auguste Lindebner, 47, who died in Schwaz, Tyrol, on April 16, 1952, and whose death the medical report at the time recorded as natural. Those further deaths were never tried. Gufler died of stomach cancer in Stein prison in 1966.

The charcoal deaths in Japan

Burning charcoal is a method widely used in suicides in Japan. Kanae Kijima met men through marriage-hunting websites in 2008 and 2009, took money from them on the promise of marriage and, a Saitama court later found, killed three of them. Takao Terada, 53, a company employee, died in Ome, in western Tokyo, in January 2009, of carbon monoxide from burning charcoal. Kenzo Ando, 80, a pensioner in Noda, Chiba Prefecture, died in May 2009 when his house burned down a few hours after Kijima had left it. Yoshiyuki Oide, 41, an office worker who built plastic models and kept a blog about his coming marriage, was found dead in Fujimi, Saitama Prefecture, on August 6, 2009, of carbon monoxide poisoning.

The journalist Philip Brasor, analyzing the trial in The Asia-Pacific Journal in 2012, wrote that two of the deaths took place in near identical charcoal settings and were first ruled suicides, and that the fire at Ando’s house was first treated as an accident. What reopened them was Oide’s death. An autopsy found a high concentration of a sleeping drug in his blood, and his own blog posts about the marriage and a planned trip with his fiancee argued against suicide. Saitama police arrested Kijima on fraud charges in 2009 and re-arrested her for Oide’s murder on February 1, 2010.

Her trial ran for 100 days, the longest in Japan’s lay judge system at the time. There was no confession and no witness to any death. The prosecution relied on her purchases of sleeping pills and charcoal, the money that moved from the men to her, and her presence with each man shortly before he died; Brasor noted the prosecution’s point that one man had no charcoal on his hands. Her lawyers argued that the men might have died by suicide or accident. On April 13, 2012, the Saitama District Court convicted her of all three murders and of a series of fraud and theft counts and sentenced her to death. The Tokyo High Court upheld the sentence in March 2014, and the Supreme Court rejected her final appeal on April 14, 2017. She has always denied the killings. As of November 2024 she was held at the Tokyo Detention House.

Fires in Hull

Between 1973 and 1979, eleven fires in and around Hull, in the north of England, killed 26 people. At the time, investigations and inquests treated every one of them except the last as accidental. The first, on June 24, 1973, killed Richard Ellerington, aged 6; the inquest recorded death by misadventure. In January 1977 eleven elderly residents died in a fire at a home for elderly men in Hessle, a fire that a public inquiry found to be accidental. Fire officers and a Home Office forensic officer put an April 1977 house fire that killed Deborah Gould, 13, and Mark Jordan, 7, down to accidental causes.

The one fire that was plainly set on purpose, in December 1979, killed three brothers, Charles, Paul and Peter Hastie. In 1980 a 19-year-old man with a physical disability and epilepsy, born Peter Dinsdale and calling himself Bruce Lee, confessed to it and then, over the following weeks, to ten more. On January 20, 1981, at Leeds Crown Court, he pleaded guilty to 26 counts of manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility and 11 counts of arson; the Crown did not proceed on the murder counts, and he was ordered detained without limit of time at Park Lane Hospital in Liverpool.

The convictions rested on his confessions, with no identification or forensic evidence tying him to any fire, according to the Criminal Cases Review Commission. In December 1983 the Court of Appeal quashed the eleven manslaughter convictions and one arson conviction for the Hessle fire. It accepted that the senior detective had obtained and recorded the statements properly but found weaknesses in the scientific evidence about the fire; it upheld the conviction for a 1979 fire in which no one died. After a review that ran for years, the commission referred the remaining convictions back to the court in October 2019. On February 8, 2022, the Court of Appeal found that he could not have set two more of the fires, the June 1976 fire that killed 13-month-old Andrew Edwards and the April 1977 Gould and Jordan fire, and quashed those convictions. It upheld the rest. Twelve manslaughter convictions and eight arson convictions stand, among them those for Richard Ellerington, Katrina Thacker, five months old, Christine Dickson and her three young sons, and the Hastie brothers. For those eight fires the 2022 court did not find that he had set them; it found that he had not shown that he could not have. He was 61 at the time of that ruling and held at Rampton Secure Hospital, ITV News reported. How many of the fires he set remains disputed.

Natural causes in a Michigan nursing home

Gwendolyn Graham and Catherine Wood met at Alpine Manor Nursing Home in Walker, a suburb of Grand Rapids, where Graham was a nurse’s aide and Wood supervised the aides. In early 1987 five elderly women died there. All had Alzheimer’s disease or dementia. Edith Cook was 98; Marguerite Chambers was 60. Everyone believed the women had died of natural causes, the Associated Press later reported. No autopsies were done, and three of the women were cremated.

The case began more than a year later, when Wood’s former husband told Walker police that she had confessed to him that patients had been killed. Late in 1988 investigators had the bodies of Edith Cook and Marguerite Chambers exhumed, and the autopsies were inconclusive. Wood pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the death of Marguerite Chambers and to conspiracy, and testified that she had kept watch while Graham smothered patients. Graham, brought back from Texas after fighting extradition, told the jury that no one had been killed and that the two of them had invented the story. The medical examiner testified that his autopsies neither confirmed nor ruled out smothering. In September 1989 a Kent County jury convicted Graham of five counts of first-degree murder and one count of conspiracy to commit murder, and she received the mandatory sentence of life without parole. Wood was sentenced in October 1989 to 20 to 40 years. Over the objections of the Michigan Attorney General and of relatives of the victims, she was paroled in January 2020.

Exhumations in Cincinnati

Anna Marie Hahn, a Bavarian immigrant in Cincinnati, befriended elderly German-American men and, Time reported, took about $50,000 from them over eight years, much of it to bet on horses. The case against her began in August 1937, when a hotel in Colorado Springs reported $305 worth of diamond rings stolen. Hahn had visited it with George Obendoerfer, an aging Cincinnati cobbler, who died the next day of arsenic and croton oil poisoning. Back in Cincinnati, Time reported, the bodies of several of her elderly friends were exhumed and found to contain the same poisons. By August 19 she was indicted for first-degree murder in two deaths, and an Associated Press report printed in The Michigan Daily said the inquiry had reached at least eleven. She was tried only for the death of Jacob Wagner, 78. In November 1937 a jury of eleven women and one man found her guilty of first-degree murder without a recommendation of mercy, the first such verdict in Hamilton County, according to the Supreme Court of Ohio. The court’s history of the trial judge, Charles S. Bell, adds that the evidence showed she had killed three more men and disabled another the same way. She was electrocuted at the Ohio Penitentiary on December 7, 1938.

The Houston rulings

Claudette Kibble’s three sons died in Houston between 1986 and 1990. Joshua was 17 months old when an ambulance crew found him unconscious on August 4, 1986; his mother, then 14, said he was epileptic and had suffered a seizure. Edward died in 1988 at eight months, and Quinten in 1990 at nine months. In each case she said the child had been having seizures. The Harris County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Joshua’s death natural, from epilepsy, ruled Edward’s natural as well, and listed the cause of Quinten’s death as undetermined, the Houston Press reported.

Investigators suspected foul play for years. The district attorney’s office, the Houston Police Department and Children’s Protective Services all pressed the medical examiner’s office to change its rulings, and it would not. In 1990 prosecutors asked Dr. Vincent Di Maio, the chief medical examiner of Bexar County, to review the autopsies; he believed the third death should have been called a homicide. District Attorney Johnny Holmes told the Houston Press that prosecutors were bound by the medical examiner’s findings unless they could persuade the office to reconsider. The deadlock broke in September 1995, when Kibble confessed to her mother, who went to the authorities. The Associated Press reported that she then admitted to investigators that she had killed all three boys, and the medical examiner’s office ruled all three deaths homicides. She was charged with murder in Quinten’s death; authorities said she was not charged in the two earlier deaths because she had been a minor. In January 1996 her lawyer said she would plead not guilty. How the case ended has not been reported.

Seven children in West Texas and Kansas

Diana Lumbrera’s children and a cousin’s infant died one after another in West Texas between 1976 and 1984, and the causes written down at the time pointed away from a crime: a convulsive disorder for her daughter Joanna, "multiple natural causes" on the death certificate of her son Jose Lionel Garza in 1978, aspiration for her daughter Melissa, heart failure and viral infection for her daughter Melinda Garza in 1982, and septicemia for her son Daniel. The death that was not filed that way was the last. On May 1, 1990, in Garden City, Kansas, her four-year-old son Jose Antonio was pronounced dead, and a surgeon became suspicious; the pathologist concluded that he had been smothered and recorded "asphyxia due to smothering."

A Finney County jury convicted her of first-degree murder. That verdict was reversed in 1992, and a second jury convicted her again in April 1993; the Kansas Supreme Court affirmed on March 10, 1995. Its opinion records two earlier Texas convictions, on pleas of no contest, for the murders of Jose Lionel and Melinda Garza. At the Kansas trial a Texas forensic pathologist, Dr. Robert Bux, examined the earlier children’s records and testified that he believed they were "asphyxial deaths of one type or another." A defense pathologist, Dr. Harry Wilson, said that, taken one at a time, each of those two deaths was unexpected and unexplained and that he could not call either a homicide on its own. The view that the deaths formed one pattern came later, and it rested on the pattern itself rather than on the medical findings in any single case.

A finding that set a man free

In January 2002 police in Camden, north London, linked the death of Sally White to Anthony John Hardy, a former engineer then in the care of local mental health services. The pathologist, Dr. Freddy Patel, found no positive evidence of how she had died but concluded that she had suffered a heart attack. At an inquest the coroner recorded natural causes, and the matter was classed as "No Crime." Hardy pleaded guilty in March 2002 only to racially aggravated criminal damage and was detained in hospital under the Mental Health Act. He was discharged early that November. By the end of December two more women, Elizabeth Valad and Bridgette MacLennan, were dead.

He was charged with all three murders, including Sally White’s, and on November 25, 2003, the day his trial was due to begin at the Central Criminal Court, he pleaded guilty to all three. In May 2010 the trial judge, Mr. Justice Keith, made a whole life order, so that he would never be released, giving weight to the fact that Hardy had killed again at a time when he must have believed he had got away with the first death. Patel was later found guilty of incompetence by a medical tribunal, Channel 4 News reported, and was struck off in 2012. Hardy died in hospital on November 25, 2020, aged 69, while a prisoner of HMP Frankland in County Durham.

The secret agent of Odessa

David Albert Dowler, a salesman in West Texas, told friends he was an undercover government agent. On August 16, 1983, Lisa Blythe Krieg, whom he knew through business, was found dead with no sign of violence. On February 12, 1986, his business partner, Tony Casillas, was found dead, again with no sign of violence. Both deaths, the Texas Court of Appeals later wrote, were believed at the time to be natural. On June 28, 1987, a schoolteacher in her late twenties named Leza, Casillas’s former wife, was found dead in Odessa; investigators determined that she had died of chloroform.

In roughly nine and a half hours of conversation that a friend of Leza’s recorded, Dowler described the deaths as a series of murders by another man. Investigators went back to the tissue and fluid samples preserved from the first two deaths, and the re-examination showed "massive doses of cyanide." A search of his home found chloroform, chemicals and laboratory equipment with traces of cyanide. In January 1988 a jury convicted him of Leza’s murder and assessed life in prison, and the trial court let the jury hear evidence of the two cyanide deaths. On August 23, 1989, the Court of Appeals in El Paso affirmed, holding that the earlier deaths were relevant to identity and intent and showed "a propensity to commit a particular crime." His conviction concerns Leza’s death alone. In March 2023 the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles denied him parole and set his next review for March 2028.

What reopened the files

Across the thirteen cases, the first findings gave way in a few recurring ways. A later death made earlier ones look different: Yoshiyuki Oide’s in Saitama, Jose Antonio’s in Garden City, the Hastie brothers' in Hull, the two women’s in Camden in December 2002. Someone talked: Catherine Wood to her former husband, Claudette Kibble to her mother, David Dowler to a friend who was recording him. A false story failed a simple check, as when the police found no trace of the car accident described in the letter about Maria Robas. Money moved where it should not have, in Kang Ho-sun’s insurance claims and in the rings missing from a Colorado hotel. And in Hull the correction has run partly the other way: two appeals quashed the convictions for three fires that had first been recorded as accidents, while the convictions for eight others stand. The cases differ in almost everything else. What they share is a first form, filled in by someone with no evident reason to suspect anything, and a long wait before anyone read it again.

Timeline

• August 1937: George Obendoerfer dies in Colorado Springs of arsenic and croton oil poisoning; exhumations follow in Cincinnati, and Anna Marie Hahn is indicted in two deaths.

• November 1937: Hahn is convicted of the first-degree murder of Jacob Wagner; she is executed on December 7, 1938.

• April 16, 1952: Auguste Lindebner dies in Schwaz, Tyrol; the medical report records a natural death. Max Gufler is later suspected in her death but never tried for it.

• October to November 1958: a forged letter about Maria Robas leads police to Gufler; he is arrested on November 2, 1958.

• March 1960: James Kinne is shot dead in Independence, Missouri; his death is ruled accidental.

• 1961: a Vienna jury convicts Gufler of four murders and two attempted murders. In June, a Jackson County jury acquits Sharon Kinne of the murder of Patricia Jones.

• 1963: the Missouri Supreme Court reverses Kinne’s 1962 conviction for her husband’s murder.

• June 24, 1973: Richard Ellerington, 6, dies in a fire in Hull; the inquest records misadventure.

• 1976 to 1984: six young children die in Diana Lumbrera’s care or family in West Texas; the causes recorded are natural or medical.

• January 5, 1977: eleven residents die in a fire at a home for elderly men in Hessle; a public inquiry finds it accidental.

• December 1979: the Hastie brothers die in a deliberately set fire in Hull.

• January 20, 1981: Bruce Lee pleads guilty at Leeds Crown Court to 26 counts of manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility and 11 of arson.

• August 16, 1983: Lisa Blythe Krieg is found dead; her death is believed at the time to be natural.

• December 1983: the Court of Appeal quashes the Hessle convictions.

• October 22, 1985: the Supreme Court of Nevada affirms Carroll Edward Cole’s death sentence; he is executed on December 6, 1985.

• February 12, 1986: Tony Casillas is found dead; his death is believed at the time to be natural.

• August 4, 1986: Joshua, 17 months, dies in Houston; his death is ruled natural. His brothers Edward (1988) and Quinten (1990) also die; one death is ruled natural and the other undetermined.

• Early 1987: five elderly women die at Alpine Manor Nursing Home in Walker, Michigan; the deaths are treated as natural.

• June 28, 1987: a schoolteacher named Leza dies of chloroform in Odessa, Texas.

• January 1988: David Dowler is convicted of her murder and given life; the conviction is affirmed on August 23, 1989.

• Late 1988: two Alpine Manor patients are exhumed.

• September 1989: Gwendolyn Graham is convicted of five counts of first-degree murder.

• May 1, 1990: Jose Antonio, 4, dies in Garden City, Kansas; the pathologist rules asphyxia due to smothering.

• December 24, 1990: Tammy Homolka, 15, dies in St. Catharines; her death is not treated as a crime.

• April 1993: Lumbrera is convicted again in Kansas; the Kansas Supreme Court affirms on March 10, 1995.

• July 1993: Karla Homolka is sentenced to 12 years for two counts of manslaughter.

• September 1995: Claudette Kibble confesses; the Harris County Medical Examiner’s Office rules all three of her sons' deaths homicides, and she is charged with murder.

• January 2002: Sally White’s death in Camden is recorded at inquest as natural causes.

• December 2002: Elizabeth Valad and Bridgette MacLennan are killed in Camden.

• November 25, 2003: Anthony Hardy pleads guilty to three murders.

• October 30, 2005: Kang Ho-sun’s fourth wife and her mother die in a house fire in Ansan; it is not treated as a crime.

• January to August 2009: Takao Terada, Kenzo Ando and Yoshiyuki Oide die; two deaths are first ruled suicides and the fire at Ando’s house is first treated as an accident.

• April 22, 2009: Kang is sentenced to death for ten murders, including the two fire deaths.

• May 14, 2010: Hardy is given a whole life order.

• April 13, 2012: Kanae Kijima is convicted of three murders and sentenced to death; her final appeal is rejected on April 14, 2017.

• October 24, 2019: the Criminal Cases Review Commission refers Lee’s remaining convictions to the Court of Appeal.

• January 2020: Catherine Wood is paroled in Michigan.

• November 25, 2020: Hardy dies in hospital while a prisoner of HMP Frankland.

• January 21, 2022: Kinne dies in Alberta.

• February 8, 2022: the Court of Appeal quashes Lee’s convictions for two more fires and upholds the rest.

• March 13, 2023: Dowler is denied parole; next review March 2028.

• January 2025: Missouri charges against Kinne are dismissed and police attribute three deaths to her.