THE STONEMAN

For two years in the middle of the 1980s, and again through a long season at the end of the decade, people who slept on the footpaths of India’s two largest cities were killed in the night with heavy stones. In Bombay the deaths ran from 1985 to 1987. In Calcutta they began in June 1989 and continued into the following winter. The dead were among the poorest people in either city: men and women, and at least one boy, who had nowhere to sleep but the street. Neither city produced a witness or a fingerprint, and no one has been charged in any of the deaths. A Calcutta newspaper gave the unknown attacker a name, the Stoneman, and the name has outlasted every theory about who he was, or whether he was one man at all.

Bombay, 1985 to 1987

The fullest account of the Bombay deaths comes from Open magazine, which revisited the case in June 2013 with the help of Mumbai police sources. By that account, twelve pavement dwellers were found dead between 1985 and 1987, most of them in the central suburbs of Sion and Matunga. Most were rag pickers and beggars. They slept alone, on poorly lit stretches of road, and they were killed in the early hours of the morning, in their sleep, by blows to the head with heavy stones. Many had no family to come forward and identify them.

The police brought in sniffer dogs, which found nothing. There were no fingerprints and no witnesses. Investigators drew up profile after profile of the man they were looking for, and none of them led anywhere. One, Open reported, held that the killer was acting on the instructions of a tantric, a practitioner of ritual magic, in pursuit of some spiritual reward. Nothing came of it.

A Bengali news site, Inscript, retelling the case in 2021, wrote that the Bombay attacker had a local name of his own, Pathharmar, and that the police did not begin to suspect a single hand until the sixth death. By its account the killings, concentrated around Sion and King’s Circle, went on for about two years before they ended in 1987, and many of the victims went unidentified. The CSR Journal, a Kolkata news portal, gave the same two districts and a count of at least twelve in 2025. A Hyderabad news site, The South First, wrote in 2023 that the Mumbai attacker had committed 26 similar murders between 1985 and 1988; it gave no basis for that figure, which stands apart from every other count.

Then the Bombay killings stopped, as abruptly as they had begun. Open’s police sources could offer no reason.

The deaths left a mark on the city’s children. Manish Gupta, who grew up in Bombay and later made a feature film about the case, told Open that as a schoolboy he was warned by his family not to linger after school, or the Stoneman would get him.

Calcutta, the summer of 1989

In 1989 the pattern surfaced in Calcutta. The first death there came in June, according to India TV News. Homegrown, an Indian youth-culture site, dated it to June 4 and named the victim as Aleya Bibi, a homeless woman of 30, found dead in central Calcutta that morning. Inscript gave the date as around June 4 and described the victim as a woman who lived and slept on the pavement. Calcutta Television Network, a local broadcaster, put the first death a day later, on June 5. Inscript observed that the death drew little attention at first; the papers that week were full of the protests in Tiananmen Square.

The second killing, by Inscript’s account, came on July 4, when a man who begged for his living was killed in the same way on another road. Homegrown’s chronology differs: it records two deaths on July 19, a man in his forties and a teenage boy, each in a different part of the city. Over the following weeks the deaths multiplied. Inscript counted four more in the three months after the second, among them a boy of fourteen, and a seventh on September 8, a man of 35. Homegrown put seven deaths between June 4 and September 11.

By then the city had a name for the attacker. A popular English-language daily in Calcutta called him the Stoneman, India TV News reported in 2012, and Inscript also credited an English-language paper with coining the name. In the press he became a single figure, though no one could say whether he was one.

Fear moved through the city faster than the police. Inscript described neighborhood gatherings breaking up early and people hurrying home at night, and wrote that by the end of the Puja festival season, with seven dead, the fear reached from Tala to Tollygunge. Calcutta Television Network described the victims as pavement dwellers, beggars and porters, people who slept outdoors because they had no other choice.

The hunt in Calcutta

The detectives of the Calcutta Police had almost nothing to go on. Investigators concluded, according to Inscript, that the attacks were taking place between about three and five in the morning, and judged from the weight of the stones that the attacker was tall and strong. Open reported that the police profiled him as "a well-built tall person," a description that went no further for want of any forensic evidence.

What the police could do, they did in the streets. Patrols were stepped up across the city, The CSR Journal wrote, and Calcutta Television Network reported that plainclothes officers posed as pavement dwellers and slept on the footpaths in the hope of drawing the attacker out. Inscript described officers keeping watch through the night with revolvers hidden under their shawls, and patrols clearing loose stones and bricks from neighborhoods in the evenings so that no weapon would lie to hand. From October 1989, by the same account, the police began rounding up vagrants and people they judged to be mentally ill. One man held in those sweeps would give his name only as "Mera naam duniya ka malik," a Hindi phrase meaning that his name was master of the world; he was scolded and let go. The CSR Journal wrote that despite many arrests, no one was ever charged.

The Calcutta police also compared their files with those of their counterparts in Bombay. Open reported that the two forces shared investigative information but found no evidence that the same person was responsible in both cities. The only link was the method.

In February 1990 the Calcutta inquiry found what it had lacked from the start: a physical trace. Homegrown, which points its readers to the casebooks of the Kolkata Police officer and author Supratim Sarkar, wrote that footprints were recovered after the eleventh death, on February 20, 1990, three of the left foot and nine of the right. Experts who studied them concluded that they belonged to a man of medium build, neither especially tall nor broad, with an unusually long big toe on the right foot. If that reading was correct, it ran against the tall, powerful figure of the original profile. It led to no arrest.

How the Calcutta killings ended

The accounts disagree on when the Calcutta series stopped. Homegrown describes a pause of about two months after the autumn of 1989, then a tenth death on January 29, 1990, an eleventh on February 20 and a twelfth on February 26, five days later, when a boy of 15 or 16 was killed shortly after midnight. After that, by its account, the killings ceased. Inscript wrote that six more deaths followed the seventh before March 1990, for a total of 13, and that the attacks then ended. India TV News credited the Stoneman with 13 killings over about six months from June 1989, and Calcutta Television Network wrote that the deaths stopped abruptly late in 1989. Open, in 2013, counted ten deaths in Calcutta and said only that they stopped suddenly.

No one was brought to trial. India TV News wrote in November 2012 that no one had been sentenced for the crimes, and called the case one of the greatest unsolved mysteries facing the police of any modern Indian city. In July 2025 The CSR Journal described the killings as unsolved, with no one ever charged or convicted.

One attacker or several

Whether the Stoneman was one person is the oldest question in the case, and it has no answer. India TV News reported that the Calcutta police never established whether the killings were the work of one man or of a group, or whether some of them were copycat crimes. Calcutta Television Network wrote that the police could not say whether the attacker was a single person, someone suffering from mental illness, or part of a gang. Homegrown listed the theories that circulated at the time: that the Bombay attacker had moved east, that imitators were at work, and that a cult was carrying out sacrifices. Some, it added, suggested that the attacker came into the city by train.

The link between the two cities rests on resemblance. Both series struck people asleep and alone on the pavement, in the small hours, with heavy stones. Both ended without an arrest. The CSR Journal wrote in 2025 that some people believed the same person or group was behind both, and that this was never confirmed. The two police forces, comparing what they had, found nothing more than the method to connect them.

The victims

The people who died in both cities were, almost by definition, people whose absence went unremarked. Open wrote that in Bombay many of the dead had no family to identify them. Inscript reported that many in Bombay went unidentified. Of the Calcutta dead, only Aleya Bibi, the first victim in Homegrown’s account, has been named. The others are recorded, where they are recorded at all, by age and circumstance: a man in his forties, a man of 35, a boy of fourteen, a boy of 15 or 16. Their killings were investigated, and patrolled against, and argued over for decades, and still most of their names have not been reported.

Before the Stoneman

Bombay had seen pavement sleepers attacked before. Open recalled that in 1965 and 1966 about 19 people sleeping on pavements and in shanties in the city’s eastern suburbs were struck with a blunt object, and nine of them died. The police arrested a homeless man, Raman Raghav, after finding him loitering. He served five years for robbery, but was released on the killings for lack of evidence. When a new run of attacks began in 1968, the police went looking for him again, and this time he confessed to 23 killings in 1965 and 1966 and about a dozen more in 1968. He died in prison in 1987, the year the Bombay Stoneman killings ended. Open set the two cases side by side; nothing reported connects Raghav to the deaths of the 1980s.

The name returns

The Stoneman was never found, but the name kept finding new owners. In 2009, Open reported, nine beggars were found dead in a similar manner in Guwahati, in Assam, and the deaths stopped within a few months; The South First dated those incidents to February 2009.

In 2013 the name came back in Kolhapur, in Maharashtra, and it was the Kolhapur deaths that prompted Open’s retrospective. Ten beggars sleeping on poorly lit pavements near the railway station had been found dead over four months, killed in the early morning. The police set out a mannequin dressed as a beggar as bait. After the state’s deputy home minister demanded results, they arrested a man from Chhattisgarh who was alleged to have confessed to two of the deaths. A local right-to-information activist told the magazine he believed the police had the wrong man, and that other deaths had been registered as accidents. Shops near the station lost trade, and residents stayed off the streets after seven in the evening.

The pattern has recurred since, each time under the same name. In October 2021, Vice reported, a man in Mumbai was arrested and accused of killing two men asleep on separate streets with a heavy rock, after another killing outside a fruit market; Vice recalled Kolkata’s Stoneman as the precedent. In 2022, IANS reported through Outlook, a man arrested in Bhopal, accused of killing six people, among them security guards asleep on duty, was also called the Stoneman. In June 2023 The South First reported that a man accused of killing three pavement dwellers in Hyderabad had been remanded to judicial custody, and the press there called him the Stoneman too. In July 2025 The CSR Journal asked in a headline whether the Stoneman was back in Kolkata, after a young man who lived on a footpath was found dead; the police traced the death to a dispute with another worker and said the man they arrested had confessed. None of these cases has been tied by any report to the killings of the 1980s.

On screen

Manish Gupta turned the Bombay case into his first feature film, The Stoneman Murders, starring Kay Kay Menon and Arbaaz Khan. Its producer, Bobby Bedi, chose Friday the 13th of February 2009 for the release, Gupta told Bollywood Hungama in 2025. He said the idea came from an article about the 1980s killings, and that because the killer was never caught he had little to work from beyond old newspaper clippings, some of which appear in the film’s opening titles; the rest was imagination. The film follows a suspended police sub-inspector, played by Menon, who hunts the killer on his own in the hope of winning back his badge. Reviewing it on its release, Taran Adarsh called it true to life and engrossing, and wrote that it blended fact with fiction; his review placed the real killings in 1983, a date no other account supports. Outlook, carrying an IANS report, described the film as weaving fiction and reality.

Calcutta’s version reached the screen later. The CSR Journal lists the Bengali film Baishe Srabon, released in 2011, among the works the case inspired. In July 2019 Sangbad Pratidin reported on the trailer of a Bengali web series, also titled The Stoneman Murders, set in Kolkata and announced for streaming on Hoichoi from August 2. Directed by Ejaz Syed from a story by Amitabha Bhattacharya, with Swastika Mukherjee, Rajatava Dutta and Rupankar Bagchi in the leading roles, it imagined the Stoneman returning to the city some thirty years after he first frightened it.

In Kolhapur in 2013, Open found, parents had begun telling their children to come straight home after school, or the Stoneman would get them. It was the same warning Manish Gupta had heard as a schoolboy in Bombay. The man it described has not been identified, and the people he was said to have killed are, for the most part, still without names.

Timeline

• 1965 to 1966: About 19 people sleeping on pavements and in shanties in Bombay’s eastern suburbs are attacked and nine die; Raman Raghav is arrested and later released on the killings for lack of evidence (Open).

• 1968: After new attacks, Raghav confesses to the killings of 1965 and 1966 and about a dozen more (Open).

• 1985 to 1987: Twelve pavement dwellers are killed with heavy stones in Bombay, mainly in Sion, Matunga and King’s Circle; there are no witnesses and no fingerprints (Open; Inscript; The CSR Journal).

• 1987: The Bombay killings stop. Raman Raghav dies in prison the same year (Open).

• June 4 or 5, 1989: The first death in the Calcutta series (Homegrown; Inscript; Calcutta Television Network).

• July 1989: Further deaths, dated July 4 by Inscript and July 19 by Homegrown.

• September 1989: The seventh Calcutta death, dated September 8 by Inscript; Homegrown counts seven by September 11. An English-language daily names the attacker the Stoneman (India TV News; Inscript).

• October 1989: Police begin rounding up vagrants and others for questioning; those held are released (Inscript; The CSR Journal).

• January 29, 1990: The tenth death in Homegrown’s chronology.

• February 20, 1990: The eleventh death; footprints are recovered (Homegrown).

• February 26, 1990: A boy of 15 or 16 is killed, the last death in Homegrown’s account; Inscript says the killings ended by March 1990 after 13 deaths.

• February 2009: Nine beggars are found dead in Guwahati in a similar manner (Open; The South First).

• February 13, 2009: The Stoneman Murders, directed by Manish Gupta, is released (Bollywood Hungama; Filmibeat).

• 2011: The Bengali film Baishe Srabon is released (The CSR Journal).

• November 30, 2012: India TV News reports that no one has been sentenced for the Calcutta killings.

• 2013: Ten beggars are found dead in Kolhapur; a man is arrested and alleged to have confessed to two deaths (Open).

• July 22, 2019: Sangbad Pratidin reports the trailer of the Bengali web series The Stoneman Murders, announced for Hoichoi from August 2.

• October 2021: A man is arrested in Mumbai, accused of killing men asleep on the street (Vice).

• June 2023: A man accused of killing three pavement dwellers in Hyderabad is remanded to judicial custody (The South First).

• July 24, 2025: The CSR Journal describes the 1989 Calcutta killings as unsolved, with no one ever charged or convicted.