The Solingen Arson Attack

Victims
5 women and girls killed in Solingen, 1993. Four men convicted of murder of 5, attempted murder of 14 and arson, October 13, 1995
Years active
May 29, 1993
Location
Solingen, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany (killings); Düsseldorf, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany (trial).
Method
Arson: a fire set deliberately (court finding: particularly serious arson).
Status
15 years' imprisonment for the oldest; 10 years' juvenile detention, the maximum, for the other three; upheld by the Federal Court of Justice. All four released from prison by 2005.

In the early hours of Pentecost Saturday, May 29, 1993, a fire set deliberately swept through a family's home in Solingen, North Rhine-Westphalia. Five women and girls of Turkish origin died: Gürsün İnce, Hatice Genç and three girls of the family. Fourteen more people inside survived, several of them gravely injured. Within a week four young men from the same city were in custody. On October 13, 1995, after a trial of eighteen months before the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf, all four were convicted of murder of five people in combination with attempted murder of 14 people and particularly serious arson. The court found that the killings had been committed from base, racist motives.

The oldest received fifteen years in prison. The other three, sentenced under juvenile law, received ten years each, the most that law allowed. All four were free by 2005. Three of them denied their guilt from the beginning, and in June 2026, thirty-three years after the fire, one of them asked the same court to reopen the case.

The fire came three days after the Bundestag, on May 26, 1993, passed the asylum compromise, an amendment to the Basic Law that sharply restricted the right to asylum.

The Federal Prosecutor General in Karlsruhe took charge of the investigation. On May 30, 1993, the day after the fire, a sixteen-year-old from Solingen was taken into custody. He at first named other young men as his accomplices, and a public appeal for them went out, but the federal prosecutors withdrew it within days, saying there were well-founded indications that his description of the others was false. For a short time the case looked like the act of one young man.

That account did not hold. On June 3, 1993, three more young men from Solingen were taken into custody: a second sixteen-year-old, a twenty-year-old and a twenty-three-year-old. All four lived in the neighborhood, and all four had come to notice before for far-right statements.

The oldest of the four confessed to the police in 1993. He repeated the confession to his own lawyer and to the investigating judge of the Federal Court of Justice. The other three denied any part in the crime, and they went on denying it. The federal prosecutors charged all four together, and because the case was brought as a state security matter, it went for trial at first instance to the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf rather than to a regional court.

The trial opened in April 1994 and drew attention well beyond Germany. It ran for eighteen months and 127 days of hearings, with more than 130 witnesses and fourteen expert witnesses. By early May 1994 the court had finished questioning the defendants. The oldest stood by his confession; the other three said they had not been there. A young man who had first given three of them an alibi later withdrew it.

Three of the four had trained at a martial arts school in Solingen. When its founder appeared as a witness, he disclosed that he had worked as an informant for the North Rhine-Westphalia Office for the Protection of the Constitution, the state's domestic intelligence service. He was never charged with any part in the fire.

The physical evidence gave the court trouble of its own. In December 1994 it heard that the burned site had been largely cleared before a fire expert of the Federal Criminal Police Office arrived, and that debris had been moved in the meantime. The court could not obtain conclusive physical proof of how the fire had begun and spread, and had to weigh competing expert opinions instead.

Then the backbone of the prosecution came under strain. In the spring of 1995 the oldest defendant withdrew his confession, saying he had been put under pressure in police questioning. On April 3, 1995, the Protestant chaplain of the prison in Wuppertal, released from his duty of confidentiality, testified that the defendant had told him as early as 1993 that the confession was false. The police officers concerned denied that any such methods had been used.

On October 13, 1995, the court convicted all four defendants as co-perpetrators of murder of five people in combination with attempted murder of 14 people and particularly serious arson, finding that they had acted from base, racist motives. The oldest, twenty-three at the time of the fire, was sentenced as an adult to fifteen years' imprisonment, and the court counted his confession in his favor. The other three, aged sixteen, sixteen and twenty at the time of the fire, were sentenced under juvenile law to ten years' juvenile detention each, the maximum the law then allowed.

The defendants appealed on points of law to the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe, which upheld the judgment. The convictions became final.

On December 15, 2000, the Higher Regional Court suspended the rest of one of the ten-year juvenile sentences on probation, holding that the gravity of the guilt had to be weighed in such a decision. All four men had been released by 2005, three of them before the end of their terms.

In June 2026 one of the men sentenced under juvenile law, who had been sixteen at the time of the fire, applied to the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf for a reopening of the case. The application argued that the 1995 judgment had rested centrally on the confessions of two of the convicted men, confessions adjusted many times and later withdrawn, and it offered new evidence said to show that three of the four were innocent. The court confirmed that the application had arrived and asked the Federal Prosecutor General for a statement. As of late June 2026 no decision had been announced, and no later ruling has been reported.

The core of the dispute is who set the fire. The court convicted all four men as co-perpetrators, and the Federal Court of Justice upheld the judgment. Three of the four never admitted the crime, and the oldest, who did admit it, withdrew his confession in the spring of 1995 and said it had been the product of pressure in police questioning; the officers concerned denied that. The 2026 application rests on that history and on new evidence that no court has yet assessed. Until the Higher Regional Court rules, the 1995 judgment stands as final.

Because the site was largely cleared before federal investigators arrived, the court decided between competing expert opinions about how the fire began and spread, not on conclusive physical proof. The informant who ran the martial arts school where three of the defendants trained was never charged, and his place in the case has never been fully settled.

Timeline

May 26, 1993: The Bundestag passes the asylum compromise, amending the Basic Law.

May 29, 1993: Fire at a family's home in Solingen; five women and girls die and fourteen others survive.

May 30, 1993: A sixteen-year-old from Solingen is taken into custody.

June 3, 1993: Three more young men from Solingen, aged sixteen, twenty and twenty-three, are taken into custody.

April 1994: Trial opens before the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf.

December 1994: The court hears that the burned site was largely cleared before the federal fire expert arrived.

April 3, 1995: The prison chaplain testifies after the oldest defendant withdraws his confession.

October 13, 1995: All four are convicted of murder of five people in combination with attempted murder of 14 people and particularly serious arson; fifteen years for the oldest, ten years' juvenile detention for the other three.

After 1995: The Federal Court of Justice upholds the judgment.

December 15, 2000: The Higher Regional Court suspends the rest of one ten-year juvenile sentence on probation.

2005: All four convicted men are out of prison.

June 2026: One of the men convicted as juveniles applies to the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf to reopen the case.