The Murders of Barry and Honey Sherman

Victims
2 people murdered in Toronto, December 2017; no one charged or convicted. Police ruled it a double homicide, January 2018
Years active
December 2017
Location
Toronto, Ontario, Canada (killings)
Method
Ligature neck compression (post-mortem finding announced by Toronto police, January 2018).
Status
Unsolved double homicide; Toronto Police Service homicide investigation still open. No one charged as of June 2025.

On December 15, 2017, Toronto learned that Bernard Sherman, known as Barry, and Honey Sherman were dead. The two had been murdered. They were among the wealthiest people in Canada and among its most generous donors, and for more than four decades their money and their time had gone to hospitals, medical research, Jewish community causes and the United Way. Six weeks later, after an inquiry that had begun as an examination of suspicious deaths, the Toronto Police Service announced that it was investigating a double homicide and that both of them had been targeted.

No one has been charged. Police have identified a person of interest, released video of a figure they classify as a suspect, and executed a long list of judicial authorizations. A reward for information grew to 35 million dollars. As of mid-2025, the killer had not been identified.

Over forty years they gave millions of dollars to medical research, health-care institutions and community organizations, among them Baycrest, Mount Sinai Hospital, the UJA Federation of Greater Toronto and the United Way of Greater Toronto. Their gifts to the United Jewish Appeal ran to tens of millions of dollars. They sent medicine to disaster zones abroad, and together with a charitable foundation they gave more than 12 million dollars to medicine and pharmacy education and research at the University of Toronto, where she served on the executive of the Boundless fundraising campaign and he sat on the entrepreneurship leadership council.

Their wealth made the case a national story from the first hour. His net worth alone had been estimated at 4.77 billion Canadian dollars, which placed him 15th among the richest people in the country.

The deaths came to light on Friday, December 15, 2017, in the North York district of Toronto. In the first days police described them as suspicious, said they were not looking for suspects, and did not say how the two had died. Detectives spent the following weeks interviewing witnesses and reviewing security video from the district, and by late January they had taken statements from at least 127 witnesses.

On Friday, January 26, 2018, the Toronto Police Service homicide squad announced that six weeks of review had produced sufficient evidence to treat the case as a double homicide investigation, and that both victims had been targeted. Police declined to discuss motives or suspects. The inquiry was already unusually large: 20 judicial authorizations executed or being obtained, 348 further investigative actions to follow up, and a long list of people still to be interviewed. No suspect or person of interest was named.

The family, meanwhile, ran a private investigation alongside the police inquiry; on December 16, 2019, police announced that it was complete, its findings were never made public, and the police investigation stayed open. In 2018 the family offered a reward of 10 million dollars for information leading to an arrest.

On November 25, 2020, a Toronto Police Service spokeswoman confirmed that a person of interest had been identified but not arrested. She gave no further detail, and no arrest followed.

On December 14, 2021, police released a short surveillance clip of a lone figure in dark clothing and said they had decided to classify the person as a suspect. The footage was too poor to show the person's face, sex, race, age or weight; analysis put the person's height between five feet six inches and about five feet nine and a half inches. Police asked the public to study the way the figure walked, noting that the person appeared to kick up the right foot with each step.

Detectives had canvassed the district and worked through video and interviews to include or exclude everyone seen nearby, and this figure was the one person they had been unable to identify. They held more video of the same person than the clip they released. They asked anyone who recognized themselves in it to come forward so that they could be excluded. Hundreds of tips arrived after the release, but the person in the video was not identified.

In December 2022 the family added 25 million dollars to the reward, bringing the total to 35 million dollars for information leading to an arrest.

Over the years police identified dozens of people as persons of interest. None led to a charge. Until February 2025, a single homicide detective constable worked on the case full time; his supervisors then directed him to divide his time between the inquiry and administrative work on other homicide cases. As of June 2025, no arrest had been made and no charge had been laid.

The case reached the Supreme Court of Canada, though not through any criminal trial. In 2018 the trustees of the couple's estates obtained orders sealing the court files that would show who inherited the couple's assets, arguing privacy and a risk from the unknown killers. The Toronto Star challenged the orders. The Court of Appeal for Ontario set them aside on May 8, 2019, finding that the claimed danger rested on speculation rather than evidence, and on June 11, 2021, the Supreme Court of Canada unanimously dismissed the trustees' appeal in 2021 SCC 25, holding that court files, estate files included, are presumptively open and that no serious risk to privacy, dignity or safety had been shown. The files became open to the media.

The identity of the person of interest confirmed in November 2020 has not been made public, and no charge followed. Police declined to discuss motives when they announced the homicide finding and have not stated one since. The findings of the family's private investigation have not been made public.

Timeline

December 15, 2017: The two deaths come to light in the North York district of Toronto; police treat them as suspicious.

January 26, 2018: Toronto police announce a double homicide investigation in which both victims were targeted.

2018: The estate files are sealed by court order; the family offers a reward of 10 million dollars.

May 8, 2019: The Court of Appeal for Ontario sets the sealing orders aside.

December 16, 2019: Police announce that the family's private investigation is complete; the police inquiry continues.

November 25, 2020: Police confirm that a person of interest has been identified but not arrested.

June 11, 2021: The Supreme Court of Canada dismisses the trustees' appeal in 2021 SCC 25; the estate files are opened.

December 14, 2021: Police release video of an unidentified figure they classify as a suspect.

December 2022: The reward rises to 35 million dollars.

February 2025: The lone detective assigned to the case is directed to divide his time with other homicide work.

June 2025: No arrest or charge.