In the autumn of 1615 a death that the court of King James I had treated as natural for two years was reopened as a murder. The dead man was Sir Thomas Overbury, the closest friend and political adviser of the king's favorite, Robert Carr, Earl of Somerset. He had died in September 1613 as a royal prisoner in the Tower of London, held there for contempt after refusing a post abroad. Within weeks of the inquiry's start his keeper had confessed, and the case ran upward through the officers of the Tower to the favorite and his wife, Frances Howard, Countess of Somerset, whose marriage the dead man had fought to prevent.
Between October and early December 1615 four people were tried in London, convicted and executed: the keeper, Richard Weston, as the principal; and Anne Turner, Sir Gervase Elwes, Lieutenant of the Tower, and James Franklin as accessories. In late May 1616 the Countess pleaded guilty before a court of peers and was sentenced to death. The Earl denied the charge, was found guilty by his peers and was sentenced to death. The king spared them both. They remained prisoners in the Tower until early 1622. The Countess died in 1632 and the Earl in 1645.
Robert Carr came to the English court from Scotland as a page. In 1607 he broke his leg in a jousting contest, the king took a personal interest in his recovery, and his rise from then on was fast. James knighted him that year, made him Viscount Rochester in 1611 and, in November 1613, Earl of Somerset. By 1607 he was the most favored man at the court.
The man who died in 1613 had met Carr in the early years of the decade, and through him gained influence of his own. He was Carr's friend, his mentor and his political counselor. The partnership held for years. It broke over Frances Howard.
Frances Howard had been married young to Robert Devereux, 3rd Earl of Essex, and the couple were kept apart in the first years of the marriage. Essex came back to England in 1609. By then, and by 1611 at the latest, she and Carr were in love.
Carr's adviser opposed the relationship openly, and in March 1613 he told Carr he would leave him unless the affair ended. The quarrel was not only personal. A marriage to Frances Howard would bind Carr to the Howards and give that faction a far larger hold on royal policy.
On May 17, 1613, Frances Howard petitioned a specially assembled commission of churchmen and lawyers to annul her marriage to Essex, on the ground that it had never been consummated. Neither party disputed that point. Several commissioners, led by George Abbot, Archbishop of Canterbury, opposed the petition, and the hearings threatened to stall. In late July the king postponed the case and added bishops to the commission, who would break the deadlock in her favor.
By then the man who stood in the way was a prisoner. In the spring of 1613 he was offered a diplomatic posting abroad, put forward by a senior Howard privy councillor. He refused it. The refusal displeased the king, and on April 21, 1613, he was committed to the Tower of London for contempt of royal authority.
On May 6, 1613, a new Lieutenant of the Tower took office: Sir Gervase Elwes. The prisoner's keeper in the months that followed was Richard Weston. The prisoner was held in the Tower for the last months of his life, from April into September.
He died there on September 15, 1613. At the time the death was put down to natural causes or disease, and only a few whispers of foul play went around.
Ten days after the death, on September 25, 1613, the commission granted the nullity. In November Carr was raised to Earl of Somerset, in preparation for the wedding, and on December 26, 1613, he married Frances Howard at court in a spectacular and enormously expensive ceremony.
After the Parliament of 1614, Somerset became lord chamberlain. His position looked secure. It was not. A new favorite, George Villiers, was rising in the king's regard, and as Somerset's standing fell, rumors about the death in the Tower found a readier hearing.
The first official to hear the truth was Sir Ralph Winwood, the Secretary of State. In 1615 he learned of it from a noblewoman at court and from Elwes himself, who admitted that he had been told of a plot against the prisoner in his charge. It was the Lieutenant's own first testimony that set the inquiry going. Winwood waited several weeks before he took what he knew to the king.
In September 1615 James received information that the death had not been natural, and he ordered a full investigation. Toward the end of October the king appointed a commission to inquire into the matter, overseen by the Lord Chief Justice and the Attorney General. The inquiry, and the trials that followed, found that the prisoner had been murdered by poison.
The interrogations quickly fixed on the keeper. Weston's confessions made him the principal actor and led to the arrest and committal of others: Elwes, the Lieutenant of the Tower; the master of the Tower armoury; and Anne Turner, the Countess's confidante. The evidence then reached the Earl and Countess of Somerset themselves. James Franklin, a London apothecary, was examined in October and gave further statements through November.
Somerset could not stop the inquiry. His influence had already ebbed, and by mid-October 1615 he and his wife were under arrest. Before his arrest he had sought a general pardon from the king under the great seal; the seal was never applied. In November Somerset gave up his seals of office and his lord chamberlain's staff on the king's order and was examined before four judges, and he was later committed to the Tower. The Countess was first held under house arrest before she too was sent to the Tower.
Weston was tried first, at the Guildhall in the City of London, in October 1615, for the murder of the prisoner in his keeping. He was convicted as the principal and executed in London within days.
Anne Turner was arraigned on November 9, 1615, indicted as an accessory before the fact. She pleaded not guilty. The court heard Weston's confession and admissions from the officers of the Tower. The jury found her guilty, and she was condemned to death and executed in London.
Elwes was tried and convicted as an accessory. He was executed in London on November 20, 1615, and at his execution he made a speech of repentance.
Franklin was arraigned on November 27, 1615, as an accessory. He pleaded not guilty. The jury found him guilty, and he was executed in London in early December 1615.
By early December all four were dead. The master of the Tower armoury, charged as an accessory, never came to trial and was never convicted.
The Earl and Countess of Somerset were tried in late May 1616 before a court of peers. The Countess was tried first. She confessed her guilt and submitted to justice, and she was sentenced to death. She was the only one of the accused to confess at trial.
The Earl was tried the following day. He denied the charge. His peers found him guilty. The sentence stripped him of his titles, his earldom and baronies, the Order of the Garter and the goods the king had given him, and condemned him to death. No charge other than the murder was tried.
By the first days of July 1616 it was known that the Earl and Countess would not lose their lives, and by mid-July James had decided to pardon the Countess.
The Somersets remained prisoners in the Tower, together, until they were released early in 1622. The Earl held to his innocence. Frances Howard, Countess of Somerset, died in 1632. Robert Carr, Earl of Somerset, died in 1645.
The Earl of Somerset never admitted any part in the murder. How much he knew, and when, was argued at his trial and has not been settled since; his peers convicted him on the evidence presented, and he held to his innocence.
The senior Howard privy councillor who had proposed the posting abroad died in 1614, before the inquiry began, and was never charged. The master of the Tower armoury, charged as an accessory, was never tried, and no court found him guilty of anything.
1607: Robert Carr knighted; already the leading favorite of James I.
1611: Carr made Viscount Rochester.
March 1613: The adviser threatens to leave Carr unless he ends the affair with Frances Howard.
April 21, 1613: Committed to the Tower of London for contempt after refusing a diplomatic posting.
May 6, 1613: Sir Gervase Elwes appointed Lieutenant of the Tower.
May 17, 1613: Frances Howard petitions the nullity commission.
September 15, 1613: The prisoner dies in the Tower; the death is treated as natural.
September 25, 1613: Nullity granted.
November 1613: Carr made Earl of Somerset.
December 26, 1613: The Earl of Somerset marries Frances Howard.
September 1615: The king receives information of murder and orders an investigation.
Mid-October 1615: The Earl and Countess under arrest.
October 1615: Richard Weston tried at the Guildhall; convicted and executed days later.
November 9, 1615: Anne Turner arraigned; convicted and executed.
November 20, 1615: Elwes executed in London.
November 27, 1615: James Franklin arraigned; convicted; executed in early December.
Late May 1616: The Countess pleads guilty and is sentenced to death; the Earl is found guilty by his peers and sentenced to death.
July 1616: The king decides to spare the Countess; both Somersets are spared execution.
Early 1622: The Earl and Countess released from the Tower.
1632: The Countess dies.
1645: The Earl dies.