The Murder of Sir Harry Oakes

Victims
1 baronet killed in Nassau, Bahamas, July 8, 1943; unsolved. His son-in-law was tried and found not guilty, 9 to 3, in November 1943
Years active
July 8, 1943 (early hours)
Location
Nassau, New Providence, Bahamas
Method
Murder (unsolved).
Status
Acquitted, November 1943 ("Not guilty, 9 to 3"), then deported by order of the governor-in-council. The case remains unsolved.

Sir Harry Oakes died in Nassau, the capital of the British colony of the Bahamas, in the early hours of July 8, 1943. He was among the richest men in the British Empire, a baronet created by King George VI four years earlier, and the owner of a large share of New Providence, the island on which Nassau stands. The next day the police arrested his son-in-law, Alfred de Marigny. In November 1943 a jury of the Supreme Court of the Bahamas found de Marigny not guilty, and the killing has never been solved.

The fortune behind the case came out of the ground. Born in Sangerville, Maine, in 1874, he spent years chasing gold from the Klondike onward before a strike at Kirkland Lake in northern Ontario in 1912, and the Lake Shore Mine he began there in 1917 grew into the most productive gold mine in the Western Hemisphere. After Canadian income tax reforms in 1934 he moved to the Bahamas, where he spent heavily on the airport, on housing and hotels and on land; by 1940 his fortune was estimated at $200 million to $300 million.

De Marigny, born in 1910 on the Indian Ocean island of Mauritius, had settled in the Bahamas in the late 1930s and made his living there as an investor. In May 1942 he eloped with the baronet's daughter.

The governor of the colony, the Duke of Windsor, took charge of the inquiry after the death and called in two detectives from the Miami police.

De Marigny was arrested on July 9 and denied that he was guilty. After a preliminary inquiry before the Chief Magistrate of Nassau that summer, he was committed for trial on the murder charge, and the trial opened before the Chief Justice of the Bahamas on October 18, 1943. He pleaded not guilty.

Much of the trial turned on a piece of physical evidence the Miami detectives had produced. The court heard the defense contend that it had not come from where the Crown said it had, and heard the detective who handled it deny that.

The jury acquitted him by nine votes to three, and the foreman gave the verdict as "Not guilty, 9 to 3." Within days the governor-in-council, acting on a recommendation the jurors had added to their verdict, ordered him deported from the colony.

No one else was ever tried, and the murder remains unsolved.

The acquittal settled only that the Crown had not proved its case against de Marigny. It did not settle who killed the baronet.

Writers since 1943 have blamed organized crime, figures in the dead man's own circle and the colonial authorities; none of these accounts has been tested in a court.

Timeline

1874: Born in Sangerville, Maine.

1912: Makes his gold strike at Kirkland Lake, Ontario.

1917: Begins the Lake Shore Mine.

1934: Moves to the Bahamas after Canadian income tax reforms.

1939: Created a baronet by King George VI.

May 1942: Alfred de Marigny elopes with his daughter.

July 8, 1943: Dies in Nassau in the early hours.

July 9, 1943: De Marigny is arrested.

Summer 1943: After a preliminary inquiry before the Chief Magistrate, de Marigny is committed for trial.

October 18, 1943: Trial opens before the Supreme Court of the Bahamas.

November 1943: The jury returns "Not guilty, 9 to 3"; the governor-in-council orders de Marigny deported.