The Murder of Sanaa Dafani

Victims
1 murder: his own daughter, Sanaa Dafani; also convicted of serious personal injury to her partner, who survived.
Years active
September 15, 2009
Location
Montereale Valcellina, Pordenone, Italy (killing); Azzano Decimo, Pordenone, Italy (residence and arrest); Pordenone, Italy (trial)
Method
Stabbed; her partner was also stabbed and survived.
Status
Life imprisonment, June 14, 2010, Pordenone; reduced on appeal to 30 years; confirmed by the Court of Cassation, April 23, 2012. Imprisoned in Italy; custody not on record after April 2012.

On the evening of Tuesday, September 15, 2009, in Grizzo, a district of Montereale Valcellina in the province of Pordenone in northeastern Italy, El Ketawi Dafani killed his daughter, Sanaa Dafani. The man she lived with tried to protect her and was injured; he survived. Dafani, a Moroccan-born cook of 45 who had lived near Pordenone for more than a decade, had spent months trying to end the relationship. A few weeks before her death she had left her parents to live with the man and his family. Investigators placed the killing squarely in that conflict. He regarded the relationship as a shame on the family, and the case is remembered in Italy as a killing over family "honor."

The courts dealt with him in under three years. In June 2010 a preliminary hearing judge in Pordenone, trying the case under the abbreviated procedure, convicted him of voluntary homicide aggravated by family ties and of serious personal injury to his daughter's partner, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. On appeal the sentence was reduced to thirty years. On April 23, 2012, the Court of Cassation rejected his last appeal, which had attacked the finding that the killing was planned, and the thirty-year sentence became final.

The Dafani family came to Italy from Morocco about eleven years before 2009 and settled near Pordenone, in the Friuli Venezia Giulia region. By 2009 they lived in Azzano Decimo, a town in the farm country between Friuli and the Veneto. Dafani worked in restaurant kitchens; at the time of the killing he was a cook at a restaurant in Pordenone. He and his wife had other daughters, and in 2009 he wanted the family to go back to Morocco.

His daughter had other plans. About a year before her death she had to leave school because the family was short of money, and she took a job in Montereale Valcellina. It was there that she met the man who would become her partner. He was Italian, older than she was, and a partner in the business where they met. The relationship began five or six months before her death, and by every account the feeling was mutual.

Dafani objected from the start. The reasons he gave, as the couple's friends and investigators later set them out, were the difference in age, the difference in religion and the different cultures the two came from. He pressed his daughter again and again to stop seeing the man. Arguments within the family grew more frequent, and over the following months he repeatedly threatened both his daughter and her partner.

About five weeks before her death she made her choice. She moved in with her partner and his family, who welcomed her as a future daughter-in-law, and the couple spoke of marrying. Witnesses told investigators that the move made matters far worse. The tension that had been building for months now had nowhere to go.

On the evening of September 15, Dafani confronted the couple in Grizzo. He killed his daughter there and injured her partner, who had tried to stand between them. The partner raised the alarm, and officers of the Sacile company of the Carabinieri arrested Dafani in Azzano Decimo that same evening.

The inquiry belonged to the Carabinieri of the Sacile company, under the provincial command in Pordenone. Officers spoke briefly with the injured partner during the night. What he told them, investigators said, fit the account already given by the couple's friends and acquaintances, who described the father's long opposition and his threats.

Dafani was held under a fermo, the Italian order for emergency detention of a suspect, and was questioned overnight. He said nothing at first; by the next morning his answers had placed him at the scene. He was initially held on suspicion of homicide and of attempted homicide with multiple aggravating circumstances. Asked by a Carabinieri officer whether he understood what he had done, he answered that he had been trying for a week. A few days later the judge for preliminary investigations in Pordenone validated the arrest, kept him in custody and added two aggravating circumstances to the provisional charge: cruelty ("sevizie e crudeltà") and futile and abject motives.

The case came before the preliminary hearing judge of the Pordenone court on June 14, 2010, under the abbreviated procedure, the rito abbreviato, which the defense had chosen. The judge returned a verdict the same day. Dafani was convicted of voluntary homicide aggravated by his family relationship to the victim and of serious personal injury to her partner, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. Even under a procedure that normally brings a reduction, the court imposed the maximum penalty.

On appeal the life sentence was reduced to thirty years of imprisonment. The conviction itself stood. The defense still disputed that the killing had been premeditated, and it took that point to Italy's highest court. On April 23, 2012, the Court of Cassation rejected the appeal, confirmed the thirty-year sentence and ordered Dafani to pay the costs of the proceedings.

The thirty-year sentence has been final since April 23, 2012. His custody is not on record after April 2012.

The place of the killing is reported two ways. The Carabinieri reconstruction of September 2009 and most later reports place it in Grizzo, Montereale Valcellina; several reports of the June 2010 sentencing place it in Azzano Decimo, the family's home town.

Premeditation was the central legal dispute. The defense maintained through every stage that Dafani had acted on impulse and not to a plan. The Court of Cassation rejected that argument in April 2012, and the courts' finding stands. His words to the Carabinieri officer, that he had been trying for a week, were never given a settled public meaning: they could refer to the killing or to his efforts to bring his daughter back to the family.

The aggravating circumstances changed over the life of the case. The judge who validated the arrest in September 2009 added cruelty and futile and abject motives to the provisional charge. The conviction of June 2010 is for voluntary homicide aggravated by the family relationship, together with serious personal injury, and the appeal court's written reasons for reducing the sentence to thirty years are not on record.

The motive was described in several ways: the age difference, the difference in religion and culture, the father's sense that the relationship brought shame on the family, and his wish for the family to return to Morocco. The courts' own written findings on motive are not on record. A defense request for a psychiatric assessment was refused in 2010, and no finding about his mental state was ever made.

Timeline

2009: Months of threats against the couple follow the father's opposition to the relationship; a few weeks before September 15 the daughter moves in with her partner and his family.

September 15, 2009: El Ketawi Dafani kills his daughter in Grizzo, Montereale Valcellina, and injures her partner; Carabinieri of the Sacile company arrest him the same evening in Azzano Decimo.

September 16, 2009: After a night of questioning his answers place him at the scene.

September 2009: The Pordenone judge for preliminary investigations validates the arrest and adds the aggravating circumstances of cruelty and futile and abject motives.

June 14, 2010: The Pordenone preliminary hearing judge, under the abbreviated procedure, convicts him of voluntary homicide aggravated by family ties and serious personal injury and sentences him to life imprisonment.

2010 to 2012: On appeal the sentence is reduced to thirty years.

April 23, 2012: The Court of Cassation rejects his appeal on premeditation and confirms the thirty-year sentence.