The Murder of Samia Shahid

Victims
1 murder alleged: Samia Shahid; no conviction. Her first husband was charged with murder and rape; her father was charged with murder.
Years active
July 20, 2016
Location
Pandori, Jhelum District, Punjab, Pakistan (killing); Jhelum, Punjab, Pakistan (trial); Bradford, England, United Kingdom (residence); Dubai, United Arab Emirates (residence)
Method
Strangled (post-mortem finding and police case; no court has tested it).
Status
No verdict. Father bailed by the Lahore High Court, Rawalpindi Bench, December 2016; died untried, January 2018. First husband bailed 2018; untried and on bail as of July 2019.

Samia Shahid died on July 20, 2016, in Pandori, a village near the Mangla Dam in Jhelum District, in Pakistan's Punjab province. She had come from Dubai, where she lived with her second husband, to stay with relatives in the village her family came from. Her relatives told her husband that she had died of natural causes. By early September a police inquiry commissioned by the provincial government had concluded that she was murdered, that the killing was premeditated, and that the motive was the family's "honor." Her first husband, who was also her first cousin, was charged with murder and rape. Her father was charged with murder. Police alleged that her mother and sister had abetted the crime and had left for England.

No court has decided any of it. Her father was bailed for lack of evidence in December 2016 and died in January 2018 without having been tried. Her first husband spent about two years in custody, was released on bail because the trial had made so little progress, and was still on bail, untried, in July 2019. The case was raised in the House of Commons and pressed with two successive Pakistani prime ministers, yet the murder charge has gone without a verdict.

She was a dual British and Pakistani citizen who grew up in Manningham, an inner-city district of Bradford in West Yorkshire. Her family came from Pandori.

Her first marriage was arranged within the family. On February 27, 2012, she married her first cousin in Jhelum. She did not stay in Pakistan for long afterward, and she returned to Britain. The following year she met the man who would become her second husband. Her family did not approve.

On May 1, 2014, she obtained an Islamic divorce from her first husband through a cleric. The document gave Luton as its place of issue, though the divorce was in fact handled in Bradford, and it had no standing in English law. She had, by her second husband's account, already adopted his Shia faith. On August 14, 2014, the couple married in an Islamic ceremony in Manchester, and on September 24, 2014, they registered the marriage at the Leeds register office. In registering it, she declared herself single and did not mention the earlier marriage.

The couple then settled in Dubai. By the summer of 2016 they had been married about two years. The police report later prepared in Punjab stated that her family had opposed the second marriage because her husband was a Shia Muslim and not a relative. Her first husband took a different line. In July 2016 he told police that she was still his wife, since in his view she had remarried without a valid divorce from him.

In July 2016 she traveled from Dubai to Pakistan to stay with her family in Pandori. On July 20 her parents told police that she had died there, and the family's account was that the death was natural. Her second husband learned of it by telephone from a cousin of hers, who told him that she had suffered a heart attack.

He did not accept the explanation and went to the police in Punjab. His complaint named her father, her sister, her first husband and a cousin, and stated that she had been killed for "honor." The Mangla police registered a murder case on it. Her father denied the allegation in a written statement, said she had died of natural causes, and said he did not want the matter investigated. The cousin made the same denial in writing. Her first husband applied for interim bail before arrest and gave the police no statement.

In late July the MP for Bradford West, whose constituency took in the district where she grew up, wrote to the prime minister of Pakistan asking for a proper investigation. Pakistan's interior minister ordered one at once. Senior police officers from Rawalpindi and Jhelum visited the village and the Mangla police station, her father and the cousin were taken into custody, and the chief minister of Punjab set up a high-level investigation committee headed by a deputy inspector general of police. On July 28 her second husband made public a copy of the post-mortem report, which contradicted the family's account of a natural death. The next day the provincial committee took over the case record from the Jhelum police. Her mother and sister had come back to Pakistan from England after her death, but they did not join the investigation.

In mid-August her first husband missed a hearing on his application for bail before arrest, and a sessions judge in Jhelum cancelled his interim bail. He and her father were formally arrested and remanded to the custody of the Mangla police. An official report released in the same period found that the death was not natural.

By the start of September the inquiry had turned on the local police as well as the family. On September 2 the investigation team had the station house officer of Mangla police station arrested for negligence in handling the case. On September 3 the deputy inspector general announced the findings: her former husband and her father were involved in the killing. Both men were charged with murder, and the former husband was also charged with rape. The 43-page police report found that her mother and sister had abetted the crime and proposed that they be extradited from Britain to answer abetment charges. Her father denied every charge. Neither woman was ever arrested, and the case went forward against the two men alone.

A court in Jhelum refused her father bail on September 10, 2016. On September 23 the police submitted their investigation report, and the case was sent to the Jhelum additional sessions judge, where the trial opened on September 27 with charge sheets served on both men. Both said they would contest it. In November the two men were still held on judicial remand, and her second husband had asked the Lahore High Court to move the trial from Jhelum to Lahore, saying her family had threatened his life.

In December 2016 the Lahore High Court's Rawalpindi Bench granted her father bail, on the ground that the prosecution's evidence was insufficient. The first husband stayed in custody, and a court refused him bail in January 2017. On February 1, 2017, the MP for Bradford West raised the case at Prime Minister's Questions in the House of Commons.

Her father died in Lahore in January 2018. He had been charged, bailed and never tried, and his death ended the case against him without a finding of any kind.

Later in 2018 the first husband was released on bail, the reason given being the lack of progress in the trial. He denied the murder. The MP for Bradford West wrote to Pakistan's new prime minister that September, and again in July 2019, asking that the state prosecute the case with care. As of July 2019 the man charged with her murder had been held about two years before his bail, was free on bail, and had not been tried.

No court has found that she was murdered, or by whom. The conclusion that she was killed, that the killing was premeditated and that the motive was "honor" belongs to the Punjab police investigation of September 2016. The charges of murder and rape remain allegations against a man who denies them, and the charge of murder against her father was never tried.

In August 2016 police sources said her first husband had confessed in custody, and in their version he said her father had no part in the killing, which is at odds with the police case against both men. He later denied the murder.

The roles of her mother and sister rest entirely on the police finding that they abetted the crime. Neither woman was arrested, charged in court or tried.

The record of the trial is unsettled in two places: one wire report placed the trial before a court in Islamabad, while the Jhelum police filing and other reports put it in Jhelum, and although charge sheets were served on September 27, 2016, a November 2016 report said the two men had not yet been charged.

Timeline

February 27, 2012: She marries her first cousin in Jhelum.

May 1, 2014: She obtains an Islamic divorce through a cleric in Bradford.

August 14, 2014: She marries her second husband in an Islamic ceremony in Manchester; the couple later settle in Dubai.

September 24, 2014: The second marriage is registered at the Leeds register office.

July 20, 2016: She dies in Pandori, Jhelum District; her family says the death was natural.

Late July 2016: Her second husband's complaint leads the Mangla police to register a murder case; the interior minister orders an investigation.

July 28, 2016: Her second husband makes public the post-mortem report.

July 29, 2016: A provincial investigation committee takes over the case record.

Mid-August 2016: A Jhelum court cancels the first husband's interim bail; he and her father are arrested and remanded.

September 3, 2016: Police announce murder charges against her first husband and her father, and a rape charge against her first husband.

September 10, 2016: A Jhelum court refuses the father bail.

September 27, 2016: The trial opens before the Jhelum additional sessions judge.

December 2016: The Lahore High Court's Rawalpindi Bench grants the father bail for insufficient evidence.

January 2017: A court refuses the first husband bail.

February 1, 2017: The case is raised at Prime Minister's Questions in the House of Commons.

January 2018: Her father dies in Lahore, untried.

2018: The first husband is released on bail.

July 2019: The first husband remains on bail and no trial has taken place.